1.Research on the robustness of Ethos cervical cancer online fully automatic generation of adaptive plans
Bo YANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Xiangyin MENG ; Yongguang LIANG ; Tingtian PANG ; Xingliu WANG ; Xiaoshen WANG ; Hongying LUO ; Jiawei CHEN ; Fuqiang CHEN ; Zongkai ZHOU ; Zhen ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2024;33(2):145-151
Objective:To evaluate the robustness of fully automated adaptive planning for Ethos online adaptive radiotherapy (ART) based on the intelligent optimization engine (IOE).Methods:Clinical data of 11 stage ⅠB cervical cancer patients admitted to Peking Union Medical College Hospital between June 2021 and June 2022 were retrospectively analyzed. Original planning images and iterative cone-beam computed tomography (iCBCT) images of each radiotherapy treatment were acquired, and all patient data were imported into the Ethos simulator. IOE-based 9-field automatic plan generation was performed for 11 patients using Ethos, and the generated plans were sent to online adaptive radiotherapy simulation to obtain each online adaptive radiotherapy plan (273 fractions in total) and complete the simulated treatment. For comparison, manual plan design was performed based on the images and contoured structures used for online adaptive radiotherapy planning, and the manually plans created with evenly divided 9 fields. Dosimetric parameters, plan complexity parameters, and Mobius quality assurance (QA) pass rates were collected to compare and evaluate the robustness of the online adaptive radiotherapy plan in terms of organs at risk (OAR), target volume dosimetric parameters, and plan complexity by using paired t-test or rank sum test. Results:The online adaptive plan of cervical cancer had comparable planning target volume (PTV) coverage compared to the manual plan. For the clinical target volume (CTV) D 99%, online adaptive plan was significantly higher than the manual plan [(45.93±0.36) vs. (45.32±0.31) Gy, P<0.001]. For hot dose area, the maximum point dose (PTV D max) of adaptive plan was significantly higher than the manual plan [(49.89±1.25) vs. (48.48±0.77) Gy, P<0.001], but the PTV D 1% of adaptive plan was significantly lower than the manual plan [(47.22±0.29) vs. (47.59±0.48) Gy, P<0.001]. There was no statistical difference in the conformal index ( P=0.967). And there was significant difference in the homogeneity index, with same medians and less dispersion in adaptive plan ( P<0.001). For OAR dose, bladder D mean, rectal V 40 Gy, small intestine D mean of adaptive plan was slightly higher than that of the manual plan; the rectal D mean, small intestine D 2 cm3 of the adaptive plan was slightly lower than that of manual plan; dosimetric parameters of right and left femoral heads, spinal cord and bone marrow of the adaptive plan were better than those of manual plan. The adaptive plan had more monitor units (MU) than the manual plan, but the complexity of the adaptive plan was significantly lower than that of the manual plan (0.135±0.012 vs. 0.151±0.015, P<0.001). For Mobius γ pass rate (5%/3 mm), both adaptive and manual plans met clinical requirements. Conclusion:Ethos cervical cancer online adaptive plan, which is based on the IOE engine, demonstrates good robustness and ensures the quality of online adaptive plans generated for each treatment fraction.
2.Performance evaluation of Ethos intelligent optimization engine in automatic plan generation
Zhiqun WANG ; Bo YANG ; Xiangyin MENG ; Yongguang LIANG ; Tingtian PANG ; Xingliu WANG ; Xiaoshen WANG ; Hongying LUO ; Jiawei CHEN ; Fuqiang CHEN ; Zongkai ZHOU ; Zhen ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2024;33(4):339-345
Objective:To evaluate the automatic optimization performance and clinical feasibility of the intelligent optimization engine (IOE) in the Ethos online adaptive radiotherapy platform.Methods:Clinical data of 11 patients with postoperative cervical cancer treated with Halcyon accelerator were retrospectively analyzed. Manual planning was performed for all patients using the 4 full arc volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) (Manual-4Arc) in Eclipse, with a prescription dose of 45 Gy/25F. Patient images and structures were imported into the Ethos simulator, and appropriate clinical goals were added based on clinical requirements. The target coverage was normalized to 95%. Automatic plan generation was conducted using IOE, resulting in 7, 9, and 12 field intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) plans (IMRT-7F、IMRT-9F、IMRT-12F), as well as 2 and 3 arc VMAT plans (VMAT-2Arc、VMAT-3Arc). Dosimetric index comparisons were made between the Manual-4Arc plans and the 5 groups of IOE-generated plans through one-way analysis of variance. Based on the analysis results, Turky post hoc multiple comparisons were performed to evaluate the automatic optimization performance of IOE.Results:In terms of the high dose area, the IMRT-12F plans showed the lowest D 1% for the planning target volume (PTV), and there were significant differences compared to the Manual-4Arc plans ( P=0.004). Regarding target coverage, all groups produced clinical target volume (CTV) plans that met the clinical requirements. Although the Ethos online adaptive plans were normalized during planning, the PTV coverage was slightly insufficient. For organs at risk (OAR) close to the target, such as the bladder, there were significant differences in V 30 Gy, V 40 Gy, and D mean among the 6 groups of plans. The dose ranking for the bladder was generally as follows: IMRT-12F
3.Study on the establishment of quality control system of TaiChi accelerator on the basis of AAPM TG119 reporter
Tingtian PANG ; Tao WANG ; Qiqi LEI ; Bo YANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Jie ZHANG ; Yinzhu CHEN ; Shihao LI ; Peng ZAN ; Jie QIU
China Medical Equipment 2024;21(6):1-5,11
Objective:The purpose of this study is to test and assess the model of modeling data of TaiChi accelerator in the Raystation Treatment Planning System(RayStation system)according to the test method and item of TG119 report of American Association Physicians Medicine(AAPM).Methods:The intensity-modulated radiation therapy(IMRT)and volumetric-modulated arc therapy(VMAT)plans of the test cases of different clinical situations,which included the simulated multi target region,prostate target region,head and neck target region,easy type C-shape target region plan and difficult type C-shape target region plan,were designed according to the AAPM TG119 report in the treatment planning system.The deviations of the doses of point and area of the two kinds of plans were measured,and the measured results were compared and analyzed with the recommended standards of AAPM TG119 report.The IBA CC13 ionization chamber and the ArcCHECK matrix ionization chamber were used respectively to verify the point dose and area dose,and the assessment standard was γ passing rate under 3%3mm.The confidence interval was adopted to judge the consistency between the measured dose and the calculated dose.Results:The accuracies of plan dose target,point dose deviation and area dose distribution of tested cases could meet the requirement of the TGl19 report.The deviations of mean doses for the high-dose points of IMRT plan and VMAT plan of tested cases were respectively(0.39±1.02)%and(1.27±0.64)%,and the confidence intervals of them were respectively 2.39%and 2.52%.The average dose deviations of low doses of organ at risk(OAR)of IMRT plan and VMAT plan were respectively(0.53±1.73)%and(0.88±1.11)%,and the confidence intervals were respectively 3.92%and 3.06%.The average γ passing rate under 3%/3mm of IMRT plan and VMAT plan were respectively(99.52±0.366)%and(99.86±0.136)%,and the confidence intervals of them were respectively 1.196%and 0.406%.Conclusion:The TaiChi accelerator performance and the accuracy of Raystation system 6MV FFF model fitting can meet the standard of TG119 report,and the subsequent standards of the quality control of equipment and patients were established according to these tested results,which would provide reference for the improvement of the performance of subsequent accelerator.
4.Comprehensive comparison between Halcyon 2.0 and Truebeam VMAT plans for different treatment sites: dosimetric quality and plan complexity
Qizhen ZHU ; Bo YANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Yongguang LIANG ; Wenjun ZHANG ; Yuan GAO ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2023;32(3):241-247
Objective:To analyze the differences in dosimetric quality and plan complexity of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) plans based on Halcyon 2.0 and Truebeam for different treatment sites of the patients.Methods:Halcyon 2.0 VMAT plans in head & neck, chest, abdomen, and pelvis treatment sites of 49 cases were retrospectively selected and the VMAT plans were re-designed based on Truebeam with the same optimization parameters. The differences in dosimetric metrics and plan complexity between the two types of plans were compared and analyzed. P<0.05 was considered as statistically significant. Results:In terms of PTV, Halcyon 2.0 plans showed better homogeneity index (HI), conformal index (CI) in the head & neck and chest. Besides, Halcyon 2.0 plans yielded better D 98% and CI in the abdomen and better D 2% in the pelvis. For organs at risk (OAR), the D 20% and D mean of bilateral lungs, and D meanof heart for Halcyon 2.0 plans in the chest were lower than those for Truebeam plans (all P<0.05). For the complexity metrics, the median average aperture area variability (AAV) of Halcyon 2.0 plans in the head & neck, abdomen and pelvis were 0.414, 0.425 and 0.432, which were better than 0.385, 0.368 and 0.361 of Truebeam plans in the corresponding sites, respectively. In the abdomen and pelvis, Halcyon 2.0 plans showed better median modulation complexity score (MCS) than Truebeam plans (0.320 vs. 0.268, 0.303 vs. 0.282; both P<0.05). The median small aperture score (SAS) for all plans of Halcyon 2.0 were better than that of Truebeam plans (all P<0.05), and the median plan average beam area (PA) of all plans of Halcyon 2.0 were larger than that of Truebeam plans (all P<0.05). Conclusions:Compared with conventional fractionated VMAT plans based on Halcyon 2.0 and Truebeam, Halcyon 2.0 plans have similar or even better dosimetric quality. However, Halcyon 2.0 plans have lower plan complexity, which makes it an advantage in clinical application.
5.The application of the RapidPlan module based on O-ring accelerator in volumetric modulated arc therapy for cervical cancer
Zhen ZHOU ; Bo YANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Heling ZHU ; Xiangyin MENG ; Tingting DONG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiological Medicine and Protection 2022;42(9):691-696
Objective:To study the clinical feasibility and advantages of the RapidPlan module based on Halcyon 2.0 ring medical linear accelerator in the design of volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) plans after cervical cancer surgery.Methods:The data of 98 clinical cervical cancer cases were selected from the database, and VMAT artificial radiotherapy plans were designed based on Halcyon 2.0. Then, the designed plans were imported into the RapidPlan module to train the module for a prediction model with high goodness of fit. Another 20 patients after cervical cancer surgery were selected as the validation set to compare the differences in dosimetry, plan consistency, and plan execution efficiency between the manual plans and RapidPlan automatic plans.Results:The RapidPlan automatic plans could obtain dose distribution of target volume and organs at risk with the same quality as the manual plans. The RapidPlan automatic plans provided slightly inferior protection of the femoral head but superior protection of the spinal cord compared to the manual plans, and the difference was statistically significant ( t = 4.71, P<0.001). The average MU of the RapidPlan automatic plans was 687.46, which was lower than that of the manual plan (815.34), and the difference was statistically significant ( t = 6.09, P < 0.05). The portal dosimetry (PD) verification revealed that the average γ passing rate (1 mm/1%) of the RapidPlan automatic plans was 89.48%and that of the manual plans was 88.22%, and the difference was statistically significant ( t = 3.35, P < 0.05). Conclusion:RapidPlan automatic plans based on the Halcyon 2.0 platform can meet the clinical needs of the VMAT program for cervical cancer and has certain advantages.
6.Dosimetric feasibility of iterative kV CBCT for radiation therapy planning for pelvis
Bo YANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Wenbo LI ; Qizhen ZHU ; Rui LI ; Xin ZHANG ; Junsheng PAN ; Ke HU ; Fuquan ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiological Medicine and Protection 2021;41(11):851-855
Objective:To study the feasibility of using pelvic iterative cone beam CT images for dose calculation of radiation therapy planning, so as to provide support for adaptive radiotherapy.Methods:The CIRS 062 M phantom was scanned by Varian Halcyon v2.0 o-ring accelerator, and the average CT number under different scattering conditions was calculated, and then the ICBCT-ED conversion curve was established. CT images of CIRS 002PRA pelvic IMRT phantom and ICBCT images at different positions were collected. Treatment plan using VMAT technique based on CT image was designed and transplanted into ICBCT image with dose recalculated. The differences of gamma passing rate among target volume, organs at risk and 3-dimensional dose were compared. Based on the actual treatment plan of patients, the differences of 3-dimensional dose gamma passing rate in 10 pelvic patients were analyzed retrospectively.Results:There was a large CT value deviation at central position between the isolated no-scattering condition and the full-scattering condition, and the maximum deviation was 144 HU. The CT values of other positions in full-scattering condition were similar to those of the central position, and the maximum deviation was less than 50 HU. Based on the calculated result of ICBCT images at different positions of the pelvic phantom, the dose deviation of the target volume or organs at risk was less than 1 Gy. Compared with the plan based on CT images, the average 3-dimensional dose gamma passing rate under the criteria of 1% dose difference (DD)/1 mm distance-to-agreement (DTA) and 2% DD/2 mm DTA in plan based on ICBCT images were (88.86 ±1.18)% and (98.38±0.89)%, respectively. The ranges of average 3-dimensional dose gamma passing rate under the criteria of 2% DD/2 mm DTA and 3% DD/3 mm DTA in 10 patients with pelvic tumors were 90.03%-95.43% and 93.58%-97.78%, respectively, and the worst result was only 85.90% and 92.90%, respectively. The main reason of the worst result was the dose difference caused by large variation of bladder contour due to over-filling.Conclusions:Under comprehensive scattering conditions, the ICBCT-ED conversion curve is reconstructed and the treatment plan can be designed by using the ICBCT image of Halcyon v2.0 linear accelerator. The accuracy meets the standards of clinical application, which provides assurance for adaptive radiotherapy in the future.
7.Comparison between HyperArc and conventional VMAT approach for brain metastases
Bo YANG ; Lang YU ; Zhiqun WANG ; Bei WANG ; Wenbo LI ; Jie ZHANG ; Xingliu WANG ; Hao ZHU ; Xiaoshen WANG ; Maoying LAN ; Feng ZHU ; Zhen ZHANG ; Ke HU ; Fuquan ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2021;30(9):876-881
Objective:To compare the dosimetric parameters and plan complexity between newly-delicated HyperArc (HA) and conventional volumetric-modulated arc therapy (VMAT) in the treatment of brain metastases.Methods:For 26 patients with brain metastases, HA, conventional coplanar (Cop) and non-coplanar (Non-cop) VMAT plans with a prescription dose of 9 Gy 3fx or 6 Gy 5fx were generated. The dosimetric parameters for planning target volume (PTV), RTOG conformity index (RTOG CI), Paddick CI, homogeneity index (HI), gradient index (GI), maximum dose (D max) of brainstem and dose-volume parameters of brain-PTV(V 2Gy-V 26Gy) were statisticaly compared among these three approaches. In addition, the monitor unit (MU) and the plan complexity parameters (including MCSv and AlPO) were statistically compared. Results:To prevent missed targets during treatment, all plans were established with RTOG CI of greater than 1.1. For Paddick CI, HA provided significantly higher conformity (0.89±0.019) than Non-cop (0.87±0.036, P=0.001) and Cop (0.88±0.017, P=0.003) VMAT. For GI, the fastest dose fall-off was noted in HA (3.35±0.64), followed by conventional Non-cop VMAT of (3.70±0.80), and conventional Cop VMAT of (4.90±1.85)(all P<0.05). For the brainstem sparing, HA plan performed better than Non-cop plan[(604.14±531.61) cGy vs.(682.75±558.22) cGy, P<0.05)]. For normal brain tissue sparing, HA approach showed significant reduction than conventional Cop and Non-cop VMAT (both P<0.05). For MU, HA approach (2 872.60 ± 566.93) was significantly lower than those of Non-cop VMAT (3 771.28 ± 1 022.38, P<0.05) and Cop VMAT (4 494.08 ± 1 323.09, P<0.05). In terms of plan complexity, the MCSv of Cop plan was the lowest, indicating that the complexity was the highest ( P<0.05). The AlPO of HA was significantly higher than that of Non-cop VMAT ( P<0.05), suggesting that the complexity of HA plan was lower ( P<0.05). Conclusion:For the treatment of brain metastases, HA provides better conformity, more rapid dose fall-off, better sparing of brainstem and normal brain tissues and less plan complexity compared with conventional VMAT.
8.Implementation and assessment of software based on ESAPI compilation structure
Zhiqun WANG ; Bo YANG ; Jie ZHANG ; Lang YU ; Bei WANG ; Wenbo LI ; Gao ZHU ; Xiaoshen WANG ; Maoying LAN ; Xingliu WANG ; Zongkai ZHOU ; Weihua ZHU ; Zhen ZHANG ; Ke HU ; Fuquan ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2021;30(11):1173-1177
Objective:To help clinicians simplify the post-processing operations of structures by developing rapid processing software for target area and organs at risk structures based on ESAPI.Methods:SmartStructure script software was developed based on ESAPI, verified and evaluated in clinical work. 10 cases of rectal cancer receiving neoadjuvant radiotherapy, 10 breast cancer treated with postoperative radiotherapy, 10 cervical cancer receiving postoperative radiotherapy, 10 nasopharyngeal carcinoma receiving radical radiotherapy and 10 lung stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) were selected, and different types of tumors had different post-processing operations of structures. In each case, three methods were used for post-processing of structures. In the control group (manual group), normal manual processing was employed. In the experimental group 1(SmaStru-N group), scripts without templates were utilized. In the experimental group 2(SmaStru-P group). scripts combined with templates were adopted. The processing time of the three methods was compared. Clinicians scored the scripting software from multiple aspects and compared the feeling scores of scripting software and manual operation.Results:All three methods can be normally applied in clinical settings. The error rate in the manual group was 7.0%, 3.0% in the SmaStru-N group 0% in the SmaStru-P group, respectively. Compared with the manual method, SmaStru-N shortened the processing time of target area and organs at risk by 60.9% and 93.3% for SmaStru-P. In addition, SmartStructure was superior to manual method in terms of using feeling scores. Clinicians gave lower score for the" applicability" and" simplicity" , and higher score on the" accuracy" and" efficiency" .Conclusions:Compared with conventional manual structure processing method, SmartStructure software can rapidly and accurately process all structures of the target area and organs at risk, and its advantages become more obvious with the increasing number of structures that need to be processed. SmartStructure software can meet clinical requirements, reduce the error rate, elevate processing speed, improve the working efficiency of clinicians, providing basis for the development of adaptive radiotherapy.
9.Protection design of Halcyon accelerator room
Lang YU ; Bo YANG ; Xiansong SUN ; Yue ZHANG ; Bei WANG ; Zhiqun WANG ; Jie ZHANG ; Jie QIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2020;29(12):1086-1090
Objective:To discuss the design details of accelerator room for a novel enclosed O-ring linac Halcyon, and to optimize its protection and layout.Methods:According to the optimization principle of radiation protection and the requirements of national radiation protection standards, and the structural characteristics of Halcyon accelerator, the differences between conventional and this novel accelerator rooms were analyzed by discussing the space layout of the machine room, shielding calculation, electrical facilities, purifying ventilation, temperature and humidity control and other factors.Results:The Halcyon machine had a compact structure, a closed ring frame design and a main beam shielding device, which could greatly reduce the radiation protection pressure while improving the space utilization rate of the machine room. The optimized design layout of the machine room could eliminate hidden dangers, avoid design defects, and prevent adverse consequences caused by design errors.Conclusions:The overall structure of Halcyon accelerator is different from that of conventional accelerators. The design details should be taken into full consideration to ensure the optimization of radiation protection, lay a good foundation for subsequent installation, debugging and operation of the equipment and create a good treatment environment for patients and medical staff.
10. The blood lead level and its relationship with behavior in school-age children from rural areas of Chongqing
Hui ZENG ; Lingqiao WANG ; Menglong XIANG ; Yao TAN ; Jia WANG ; Ji'an CHEN ; Ziyuan ZHOU ; Jiaohua LUO ; Yujing HUANG ; Chen LYU ; Honghui RONG ; Weiqun SHU ; Zhiqun QIU
Chinese Journal of Preventive Medicine 2019;53(9):907-912
Objective:
To explore the blood lead level and its relationship with behavior in school-age children from rural areas of Chongqing.
Methods:
A total of 697 students from grades 3 to 6 in the fall semester of 2014 from 14 rural townships in one district of Chongqing was selected by using the random cluster sampling method. Blood were sampled to analyze the lead level. Neurobehavioral tests were performed to determine their personal cognitive and memory ability. Questionnaires and physical examinations were administered to obtain the information of confounding factors. All students were divided into

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail