1.UPLC-QTOF mass spectrometry detection of four endocrine disrupting chemicals (Methyl Paraben, 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, Monobutyl Phthalate, and Bisphenol A) in urine of Filipino women
Francisco M. Heralde III ; Zaidy T. Martin ; Maria Stephanie Fay S. Cagayan ; Ma. Esterlita V. Uy ; Paulyn Jean R. Ubial ; Michael C. Velarde ; Erlidia F. Llamas-clark
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(3):70-79
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE
Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals (EDCs) are ubiquitously found as low-level contaminants and pose serious threat to women’s health. EDCs may result in various reproductive disorders, fetal birth and developmental abnormalities, and endocrine and metabolic disorders. EDCs can be detected in body fluids of exposed individuals including blood and urine. This study aimed to detect four EDCs — Methyl Paraben (MP), 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), Monobutyl Phthalate (MBP), and Bisphenol A (BPA) in urine samples of women using Ultra-Performance Liquid Chromatography – Quadrupole Time-of-Flight (UPLC-QTOF) mass spectrometry.
METHODSSequential steps of enzymatic deconjugation, liquid-liquid extraction, solid phase extraction, and liquid chromatography separation and mass spectrometry detection were optimized in urine samples. The method was used to analyze 70 urine samples from women of reproductive age.
RESULTSThe sample preparation method showed a recovery ranging from 86.6% (MBP) to 100 % (2,4-D). The method demonstrated limits of quantitation ranging from 1.52 ng/m(MP) to 6.46 ng/mL(2,4D). Intra-day precisions expressed as relative standard deviation were all below 15% while accuracy was shown to range from 67.10% (2,4-D) to 102.39% (MBP). MP was detected in nine samples (12.86%) with a geometric mean value of 10.15 ng/ml (range: 3.62-52.39 ng/ml). MBP was detected in 68 samples (97.14%) with a geometric mean value of 97.62 ng/ml (range: 15.32-698.18 ng/ml). BPA was detected only once (9.58 ng/ml) while 2, 4-D was not detected in all samples.
CONCLUSIONA UPLC-QTOF mass spectrometry method to detect four EDCs at parts per billion level (ng/ml) was adapted and applied for analysis of urine samples. This method can find applicability in routine testing of clinical specimens as well as surveillance and other epidemiological studies.
Endocrine Disruptors ; 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic Acid ; Bisphenol A
2.Are Filipinos ready for long-term care? A qualitative study on awareness, perspectives, and challenges of relevant organizations, community leaders, carers, and older persons in select sites in the Philippines
Angely P. Garcia ; Shelley Ann F. De la vega ; Ayra Mae S. Balingbing ; Ma. Anna Carmina D. Orlino ; Jan Michael M. Herber ; Angelita L. Viloria-larin
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(3):21-38
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
With the global population aging, there is an emerging need for access to quality longterm care (LTC) services. Many countries have developed LTC systems while others are at the infancy stage. This paper aimed to provide an overview of the country’s readiness for LTC based on the perspectives of relevant stakeholders. Specifically, it described the roles, initiatives, and challenges of relevant organizations and community leaders for LTC provision. It also described the older persons (OPs) and carers’ perspectives towards LTC including their awareness, capacity, and preferences.
METHODSThe study utilized a descriptive design using qualitative methods of data collection namely key informant interviews (KIIs) and focus group discussions (FGDs). Participating institutions and their designated representatives were purposively sampled as key informants. OPs and carers from select barangays in NCR and Region IVA participated in the FGDs. Guided by the interpretivism approach, thematic analysis was performed. A trained research assistant coded the FGD and KII transcripts through the Nvivo PRO plus software and verified by the first author. Themes were reviewed and validated by the multidisciplinary team.
RESULTSA total of 15 KIIs and two FGDs were conducted. The participating institutions and organizations were found to have varied roles and initiatives relevant to LTC; from strategic planning, development of policies and standards of care, training and capacity-building, and up to the actual implementation of LTC services. Identified challenges include implementation issues, financial issues, lack of political and stakeholder support, OPs and familial issues, and lack of knowledge on LTC.
Participants shared their description on what LTC is, an LTC facility, and the conditions of those in LTC facility. OPs expressed their willingness to utilize LTC services and identified several factors related to their preferred LTC arrangements. Carers identified various topics related to taking care of OPs that they would like to learn.
CONCLUSIONThe roles, initiatives, and awareness of relevant stakeholders, older persons, and carers towards LTC were found to greatly vary. Policy makers, health workforce, families, communities, and the older persons themselves should have a better understanding of longterm care before they can provide or utilize the system. With the current landscape of LTC provision, the country still has a long way to go in achieving the integrated continuum of LTC appropriate to promote healthy aging. Promoting awareness, integrating LTC in the current programs and services for older persons in the country, capacitating the formal and non-formal caregivers, and strengthening collaborations are recommended.
Further research on quantitative measures of readiness for long-term care with focus on the health system and in-depth studies on the varieties or models of long-term care are recommended.
Home Care Services ; Long-term Care ; Nursing Homes ; Philippines
3.Effect of COVID-19, vaccination ratio, and human population on the reported canine rabies cases in Davao City, Philippines: A panel regression analysis
Feby Kirstine A. Evangelio ; Sherelyn A. Evangelio ; John Raven C. Macanan ; Zython Paul T. Lachica ; Arlene P. Lagare ; Ma. Noreen J. Eng ; Maria Corazon B. Sepulveda ; Emmanuel S. Baja ; May Anne E. Mata
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(4):56-64
OBJECTIVE
Given that rabies remains endemic in the Philippines despite government interventions and the pandemicrelated restrictions have hampered its surveillance, this study aimed to estimate the effect of human population, anti-rabies vaccination efforts, and COVID-19 situation on the spread of rabies cases in the districts of Davao City, Philippines.
METHODSA retrospective study of the canine records at Davao City Veterinarians’ Office was done from January 2018 to June 2021. Monthly rabies cases were ascertained, and the effect of the human population, COVID-19 season, and vaccination ratio on rabies cases was estimated using panel regression models adjusting for confounding factors.
RESULTSThe reporting of rabies cases was lower during COVID-19 than during the non-COVID-19 season, with an IRR of 0.52 [95% confidence interval (CI): 0.33–0.82]. Furthermore, rabies cases increased by 2.23% (95% CI: 0.60–3.89) per 1% increase in vaccination ratio. Additionally, high-population districts recorded more rabies cases than low-population districts.
CONCLUSIONConsistency in monitoring rabies cases during the pandemic is suggested as a roadmap for future program initiatives. Vaccination efforts should be reinforced to increase rabies awareness and ensure early response to emerging diseases. Moreover, highpopulated districts should be prioritized in implementing rabies control interventions to gain optimal development.
Human ; Animals ; Rabies ; Covid-19 ; Vaccination
4.Optimal control theory applied to rabies epidemiological model with time-dependent vaccination in Davao City, Mindanao Island, Philippines
Dejell Anne M. Satur ; Zython Paul T. Lachica ; Pamela Grace J. Roxas ; Eliezer O. Diamante ; El Veena Grace A. Rosero ; John Raven C. Macanan ; Arlene P. Lagare ; Ma. Noreen J. Eng ; Maria Corazon B. Sepulveda ; Giovanna Fae R. Ogius ; May Anne E. Mata
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(4):90-102
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE
Rabies continues to be a challenge in Davao City despite the efforts of the city’s local government to vaccinate primarily the non-stray dog population. Meanwhile, studies have shown that time-dependent vaccination strategy is considered a prime factor for a cost-effective rabies control strategy. Hence, this study aims to provide information that will determine the optimal vaccination strategy targeted to the stray dog population that minimizes the rabies-infected dog population and vaccination costs using optimal control theory (OCT).
METHODSOCT is used to identify the optimal level of key rabies control, i.e., vaccination. Here, OCT was applied to a modified Susceptible-Exposed-Infectious-Vaccinated (SEIV) compartmental model. The study's key parameters were derived from published articles on rabies in Davao City and similar regions, along with the city's rabies reports.
RESULTSThe findings revealed that while rabies remains endemic in the city, it is possible to reduce the number of cases through consistent implementation of vaccination programs to the exposed and susceptible dog populations. Nevertheless, the feasibility of these findings relies to the effective targeting of vaccine coverage for the dog population. From the simulations performed, the exposed dog population (i.e., pre-rabid dogs) was able to reach zero observation when the transmission rate (?) is 0.001 for all values of anti-rabies vaccine coverages for exposed (?) and susceptible (b) dog populations and ? = 0.01 only when ? = 0.7 and b = 0.7, ? = 0.7 and b = 0.5, and ? = 0.5 and b = 0.7. Consequently, the number of infectious dogs will thereby decrease. Moreover, a nonlinear correspondence was also observed in all scenarios between the vaccination rate and the number of rabies-exposed dogs such that the reduction in the incidence of rabies cases becomes apparent only when the vaccination rate is at least 0.9995.
CONCLUSIONIn high rabies transmissibility scenarios, a time-dependent vaccination strategy demonstrated a reduction in the number of rabies-infected dogs. However, this approach involves a trade-off, limiting the period during which monthly vaccinations can be relaxed. Consequently, a robust and timely vaccination program for dogs is crucial to manage high rabies transmission rates. Lastly, the model simulation underscores the importance of initiating monthly vaccinations.
Animals ; Rabies
5.Right ventricular-pulmonary artery connection for palliative treatment of pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect in children: A single-center retrospective study
Shuai ZHANG ; Jianrui MA ; Hailong QIU ; Xinjian YAN ; Wen XIE ; Qiushi REN ; Juemin YU ; Tianyu CHEN ; Yong ZHANG ; Xiaohua LI ; Furong LIU ; Shusheng WEN ; Jian ZHUANG ; Qiang GAO ; Jianzheng CEN
Chinese Journal of Clinical Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery 2025;32(03):366-371
Objective To compare the benefits and drawbacks of primary patch expansion versus pericardial tube right ventricular-pulmonary artery connection in patients diagnosed with pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect (PA/VSD). Methods A retrospective study was conducted on patients diagnosed with PA/VSD who underwent primary right ventricular-pulmonary artery connection surgery at our center between 2010 and 2020. Patients were categorized into two groups based on the type of right ventricular-pulmonary artery connection: a pericardial tube group and a patch expansion group. Clinical data and imaging findings were compared between the two groups. Results A total of 51 patients were included in the study, comprising 31 males and 20 females, with a median age of 12.57 (4.57, 49.67) months. The pericardial tube group included 19 patients with a median age of 17.17 (7.33, 49.67) months, while the patch expansion group consisted of 32 patients with a median age of 8.58 (3.57, 52.72) months. In both groups, the diameter of pulmonary artery, McGoon index, and Nakata index significantly increased after treatment (P<0.001). However, the pericardial tube group exhibited a longer extracorporeal circulation time (P<0.001). The reoperation rate was notably high, with 74.51% of patients requiring further surgical intervention, including 26 (81.25%) patients in the patch expansion group and 12 (63.16%) patients in the pericardial tube group. No statistical differences were observed in long-term cure rates or mortality between the two groups (P>0.005). Conclusion In patients with PA/VSD, both patch expansion and pericardial tube right ventricular-pulmonary artery connection serve as effective initial palliative treatment strategies that promote pulmonary vessel development and provide a favorable foundation for subsequent radical operations. However, compared to the pericardial tube approach, the patch expansion technique is simpler to perform and preserves some intrinsic potential for pulmonary artery development, making it the preferred procedure.
6.Homeobox protein C4 regulates the proliferation, migration and invasion of gastric cancer cells by integrin β1
YUAN Bo1 ; MA Lei2 ; CHEN Xiaobing3 ; CHANG Zhanguo1
Chinese Journal of Cancer Biotherapy 2025;32(4):364-370
[摘 要] 目的:探讨同源框蛋白C4(HOXC4)在胃癌组织和细胞中的表达及其对胃癌细胞增殖、迁移与侵袭的作用及其机制。方法:收集2020年5月至2021年4月期间在南阳市第一人民医院肿瘤科手术切除的16例进展期胃癌患者的癌及癌旁组织标本,以及人胃正常上皮细胞GES-1和胃癌细胞AGS、SGC-790和MGC-803,采用WB法检测胃癌组织和细胞中HOXC4的表达。通过RNA干扰技术对SGC-790及AGS细胞中HOXC4进行敲低或过表达,实验分为sh-HOXC4#1组、sh-HOXC4#2组、sh-Con组、sh-HOXC4 + pc-integrin β1组、pc-HOXC4组、pc-Con组、pc-HOXC4 + pc-integrin β1组。利用EdU、CCK-8、Transwell实验分别检测敲低或过表达HOXC4对各组细胞活力、增殖、侵袭、迁移和integrin β1表达的影响。用敲低HOXC4的胃癌AGS细胞构建荷瘤小鼠模型,观察敲低HOXC4对移植瘤体积及组织中Ki67和integrin β1蛋白表达的影响。结果:胃癌组织和细胞中HOXC4的表达均显著上调(均P < 0.01)。与sh-Con组相比,sh-HOXC4#1组和sh-HOXC4#2组SGC-790及AGS细胞中HOXC4、integrin β1蛋白表达水平,以及细胞的活力、增殖、迁移及侵袭能力均显著降低(均P < 0.01)。与sh-HOXC4组相比,sh-HOXC4 + pc-integrin β1组细胞活力、增殖、迁移及侵袭能力均显著增加(均P < 0.01);与pc-Con组相比,pc-HOXC4组细胞活力、侵袭及迁移能力均显著增加(均P < 0.01);与pc-HOXC4组相比,pc-HOXC4 + pc-integrin β1组细胞活力、迁移及侵袭能力均显著降低(均P < 0.01)。与sh-Con组相比,sh-HOXC4#1组和sh-HOXC4#2组小鼠移植瘤生长缓慢、体积变小,组织中Ki67和integrin β1表达均显著降低(均P < 0.01)。结论:HOXC4在胃癌组织与细胞中表达上调,其通过激活integrin β1信号促进胃癌细胞的增殖、迁移与侵袭。
7.Predictive value of prognostic nutritional index for treatment efficacy and prognosis in locally advanced esophageal squamous cell carcinoma patients treated with chemotherapy combined with immune sequential radiotherapy
WANG Yu1,2 ; WEI Zhuojun2 ; WANG Lin3 ; WANG Ruiqi4 ; CHEN Huan2 ; CHENG Qi2 ; LIN Xiao2 ; MA Honglian2 ; XU Yujin2
Chinese Journal of Cancer Biotherapy 2025;32(4):405-412
[摘 要] 目的:探索预后营养指数(PNI)在接受诱导化疗联合免疫(化免)序贯放疗的局部晚期食管鳞状细胞癌(ESCC)中的疗效预测价值及预后影响。方法: 回顾性分析浙江省肿瘤医院2019年5月至2023年8月期间收治的126例行诱导化免序贯放疗的局部晚期ESCC患者的临床资料。绘制受试者工作特征曲线(ROC曲线),确定患者诱导化免前1周内、放疗前1周内、放疗开始后4 ± 1周的PNI最佳临界值并对患者进行分组。采用Kaplan-Meier法绘制生存曲线,并用Log-Rank法比较组间患者的总生存期(OS)及无进展生存期(PFS),采用Cox回归分析探讨诱导化免序贯放疗的局部晚期ESCC患者的预后影响因素。结果: 共纳入126例局部晚期ESCC患者,男性118例,女性8例,中位年龄65岁(44~78岁)。运用ROC曲线确认的患者诱导化免前、放疗前和放疗中PNI最佳临界值为46.2、48.3和37.9。放疗前PNI ≥ 48.3组中位OS、PFS分别为47.3、28.2个月,放疗前PNI < 48.3组中位OS、PFS分别为18.7、15.2个月(P < 0.01,P < 0.05)。放疗中PNI ≥ 37.9组中位OS未达到,中位PFS为25.7个月,放疗中PNI < 37.9组中位OS、PFS分别为17.0、12.5个月(P < 0.01,P < 0.05)。诱导化免后PNI升高组中位OS未达到,中位PFS为28.4个月;PNI降低组中位OS、PFS分别为20.4、16.0个月(P < 0.01,P < 0.05)。多因素分析显示,放疗中PNI[HR = 2.292,95% CI(1.264,4.159),P < 0.05]、诱导化免后PNI变化[HR = 2.120, 95% CI(1.007, 4.463),P < 0.05]为影响OS因素。结论: 放疗中PNI、诱导化免后PNI变化与患者治疗疗效及预后有一定相关性,可作为预测ESCC化免序贯放疗获益的重要指标。
8.ST6GAL1 promotes glycolysis, migration and invasion of colorectal cancer HCT116 cells by activating the Notch1/PI3K/AKT/mTORC1 pathway
HUO Yishan1 ; WU Huili1 ; DUAN Xiangbing1 ; MA Xiumin1 ; LI Tao2
Chinese Journal of Cancer Biotherapy 2025;32(5):469-475
[摘 要] 目的:探究β-半乳糖苷α-2-6唾液酸转移酶1(ST6GAL1)对结直肠癌(CRC)HCT116细胞糖酵解和迁移、侵袭的作用及可能的分子机制。方法:通过检索GEPIA2数据库,分析ST6GAL1在CRC患者和健康人群中的表达差异;WB法检测ST6GAL1在CRC细胞HCT116、SW480、Caco-2、HT29、LoVo和人正常结肠上皮细胞NCM460细胞中的表达差异;免疫组织化学法分析ST6GAL1在CRC组织和对应癌旁组织中的表达差异。通过慢病毒转染细胞的方法构建稳定敲低或过表达ST6GAL1的HCT116细胞,通过划痕愈合实验检测细胞迁移能力,Transwell实验检测细胞侵袭能力,WB法检测细胞糖酵解相关蛋白、Notch1受体胞内段(Notch1 ICD)以及PI3K/AKT/mTOR通路磷酸化水平,细胞免疫荧光实验观察Notch1 ICD表达水平和进入细胞核情况;加入Notch1受体激动剂Jagged1处理HCT116细胞,通过WB法检测糖酵解相关蛋白、Notch1 ICD表达水平以及PI3K/AKT/mTOR通路磷酸化水平。结果:ST6GAL1在CRC组织和细胞中均表达上调(均P < 0.05)。与对照组和过表达组相比,敲低ST6GAL1导致HCT116细胞内Notch1 ICD表达水平和PI3K/AKT/mTORC1磷酸化水平显著降低,细胞糖酵解相关蛋白表达水平降低,细胞迁移和侵袭能力减弱(均P < 0.05);过表达ST6GAL1增加了HCT116细胞内Notch1 ICD表达水平并促进其进入细胞核,细胞糖酵解相关蛋白表达水平升高,细胞迁移和侵袭能力增强(均P < 0.05)。结论:ST6GAL1通过活化Notch1受体进而磷酸化激活PI3K/AKT/mTORC1通路,并增强CRC细胞糖酵解水平和迁移、侵袭能力。
9.Trends in knowledge, attitude and perceptions about HIV among Filipinos during and after the COVID-19 pandemic: Responses from a digital survey.
Glyzelle Anne A. Lagason ; Judith Anne Rose Y. Ganaden ; Martin Xavier D. Peñ ; aflor ; Ericson P. Acapulco ; Kristine T. Donarye ; John Alexander L. Fellizar ; Ma. Tarcela S. Gler
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(Early Access 2025):1-6
BACKGROUND
The Philippines has been significantly affected by the HIV epidemic in the Asia-Pacific region, with a notable increase in new cases over the past decade. Despite efforts to promote HIV testing, access to treatment, and awareness campaigns, progress has been slow, particularly among youths. Tangere, a market research application, conducted surveys during and after the COVID-19 pandemic to assess HIV knowledge among Filipinos.
OBJECTIVESThis study aimed to evaluate changes in HIV awareness among young Filipinos during and after the COVID-19 pandemic using data collected via Tangere’s surveys. Specifically, it sought to analyze demographic characteristics, sources of HIV information, and knowledge regarding HIV transmission, prevention, and stigma.
METHODSTangere collaborated with the investigators to develop a questionnaire assessing HIV knowledge among young Filipinos. Surveys were conducted during and after the COVID-19 pandemic, targeting subscribers aged 18-35 years, primarily from the National Capital Region and Luzon area. Data analysis involved calculating frequencies and percentages to summarize demographic characteristics and HIV knowledge. An Independent-Samples Proportions procedure was used to compare HIV knowledge during and after the pandemic.
RESULTSThe survey revealed that while respondents generally possessed reasonable knowledge about HIV, there were notable changes in the awareness during and after the pandemic. Social media and television were identified as primary sources of HIV information. Knowledge regarding HIV transmission and prevention increased postpandemic, particularly concerning preventive measures such as pre-exposure prophylaxis (PREP) and motherto-child transmission (MTCT). However, persistent misconceptions and stigma surrounding HIV remained, indicating the need for continued education and advocacy efforts.
CONCLUSIONThe study underscores the importance of utilizing social media platforms for HIV awareness campaigns, especially among youths who are disproportionately affected by the epidemic. Despite improvements in knowledge, the Philippines has yet to achieve global HIV prevention goals. Continued efforts to enhance awareness, particularly regarding recent advancements in HIV prevention and treatment, are essential for curbing the epidemic and improving public health outcomes nationwide.
Human ; Knowledge ; Attitude ; Hiv ; Covid-19 ; Pandemics
10.Psychometric properties of self-report questionnaires in evaluating blended learning in health science university students: A systematic review
Valentin C. Dones III ; Maria Teresita B. Dalusong ; Donald G. Manlapaz ; Juan Alfonso S. Rojas ; Ma. Bianca Beatriz P. Ballesteros ; Ron Kevin S. Flores ; Kaela Celine C. Hor ; Jose Angelo D. Monreal ; Audrey Marie A. Narselles ; Jose Joaquin R. Reyes ; Lianna Andrea B. Sangatanan
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(Early Access 2025):1-14
BACKGROUND
Due to the COVID-19 outbreak, schools had to switch online. The sudden transition to blended teaching and learning (BTL) poses challenges for students and teachers, especially for health science programs that require hands-on practical experience. The validity, reliability, and responsiveness of these self-report questionnaires (SRQs) should be established to ensure the accuracy of the results as intended by the SRQ.
OBJECTIVESThis study critically appraised, compared, and summarized the psychometric properties of SRQ evaluating BTL among health science university students. This review determined the SRQ’s reliability, internal consistency, various forms of validity (content, criterion, construct), and responsiveness.
METHODSFollowing a 10-step procedure based on COSMIN guidelines, we conducted a systematic review of SRQs used by health science university students to evaluate blended teaching and learning. Studies were eligible if they reported psychometric properties of SRQs related to blended learning among university health science students; exclusions included studies focusing on perceptions, attitudes, self-efficacy, and satisfaction, as well as articles such as biographies, editorials, and conference materials. Searches covered multiple electronic databases until April 26, 2023, including PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, MEDLINE (OVID), PsycInfo, CINAHL, EBSCOHOST, ERIC, Scopus, Science Direct, Google Scholar, JSTOR, Acta Medica Philippina, Philippine Journal of Health Research and Development, and HERDIN, managed through Zotero. Two independent reviewers performed database searches, title and abstract screening, and full-text evaluations, with a third reviewer resolving any disputes. The COSMIN Risk of Bias Checklist was employed to evaluate included studies on the development and various measurement properties of SRQs. The reviewers assessed SRQ standards, including validity, reliability, internal consistency, measurement error, responsiveness, interpretability, and feasibility. Data extraction and result tabulation were independently completed, with content comparison by two health education experts. This evaluation categorized the SRQs into three quality and validity levels.
RESULTSThe study examined five articles; four were rated as 'doubtful' and one as 'inadequate' in the overall development of SRQ. All four 'doubtful' studies demonstrated questionable content validity when university students were asked about the questionnaire's relevance, comprehensiveness, and comprehensibility. Only half of these studies achieved an 'adequate' rating for content validity based on expert opinions on relevance and comprehensiveness. All but one study scored from 'very good' to 'adequate' in structural validity. Three out of the four studies scored a very good rating for internal consistency, while one was deemed 'inadequate' in internal consistency, cross-cultural validity, and reliability. Three out of four studies scored 'very good' on construct validity, but all overlooked criterion validity and responsiveness. Conducted in various locations, including Australia, Romania, Turkey, and Taiwan, these studies highlighted both common characteristics and limitations in questionnaire development according to the COSMIN guidelines. Four studies were deemed reliable and valid for BTL constructs (Category A); Wu et al. requires further validation (Category B). Study limitations included heterogeneity in populations, settings, and questionnaire versions, potential subjective bias in SRQ content comparison, and the evolving nature of SRQs in blended learning contexts.
CONCLUSIONThe systematic review reports the development and evaluation of SRQs for BTL while identifying gaps in their applicability to health science programs. The Blended Learning Scale (BLS) of Lazar et al. and the Blended Learning Questionnaire (BLQ) of Ballouk et al. showed an ‘adequate' rating for content validity. BLS revealed very good structural validity, internal consistency, and adequate content validation. Although the BLQ lacked Confirmatory Factor Analysis, it yielded valuable constructs for evaluating health sciences students' experiences in BTL. Both tools require improvements on recall period, completion time, interpretability, and feasibility. The review underscores the necessity for cont inuous assessment and enhancement of such instruments in BTL, advocating a rigorous scale development process. Furthermore, it encourages the customization of teaching and learning evaluation tools to suit specific institutional contexts while promoting further validation of these questionnaires across different populations in future research.
Human ; Psychometrics ; Checklist ; Self Report ; Universities ; Health Education


Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail