2.Factors Influencing the Initiation Time of Forensic Psychiatric Assessment of Criminal Cases in Hunan Province.
Hui Jun GUO ; Jun WANG ; Qi Guang LI ; Shao Ling ZHONG ; Si Mei ZHANG ; Jian Song ZHOU ; Xiao Ping WANG
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2019;35(5):586-591
Objective To discuss the related factors influencing the initiation time of forensic psychiatric assessment by analysis of the initiation time of forensic psychiatric assessment of criminal cases in Hunan Province. Methods Related data in assessment files of criminal cases accepted by 8 forensic psychiatric assessment institutions in Hunan Province from January 1, 2011 to December 31, 2016 were extracted. The Logistic regression analysis was used to explore the factors influencing the initiation time of forensic psychiatric assessment. After using property score matching (PSM) to control the influence of confounding factors, the efficiency of public security organs to initiate assessments of suspects with (without) mental disorders and with (without) responsibilities were compared. Results A total of 4 346 cases were included. The Logistic regression analysis suggested that the factors independently related to the initiation time of assessment include: cause of assessment, nationality of the assessed, history of diagnosis and treatment of mental illnesses, history of crimes, history of drug abuse, and status of alcohol consumption before the crime (all P<0.05). The initiation time of assessment of suspects diagnosed with mental disorder was shorter than those with none (P<0.05); the initiation time of assessment of suspects without criminal responsibility was shorter than those with responsibility (P<0.05). After using PSM to control confounding factors, the differences above still existed. Conclusion The cause of assessment, nationality of the assessed, history of diagnosis and treatment of mental illnesses, history of crimes, history of drug abuse, and status of alcohol consumption before the crime are factors that influence the efficiency of public security organs to initiate forensic psychiatric assessments. Under the current assessment initiation mode, forensic psychiatric assessment of suspects who have mental disorders, especially those with no responsibility may be given priority to initiate.
Crime
;
Criminals
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Psychiatric Status Rating Scales
3.Concept Analysis of Female Sexual Subjectivity based on Walker and Avant's Method.
Korean Journal of Women Health Nursing 2017;23(4):243-255
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to clarify attributes, antecedents, and consequences of female sexual subjectivity. METHODS: Walker and Avant's concept analysis process was used to analyze 27 studies from the current literature that relates to female sexual subjectivity. A systematic literature review of women's study in sociology, psychology, theology, law, health science, and nursing was reviewed. RESULTS: The defining attributes of female sexual subjectivity were sexual self-awareness, sexual decision making, sexual desire, and good sexual communication with partner. The antecedents of female sexual subjectivity were social environment, sexual education, sexual experience, and interpersonal relationship. The consequences of female sexual subjectivity were safe sex, prevention of sexual victimization, and sexual satisfaction. CONCLUSION: Female sexual subjectivity is defined as sexual self-awareness, sexual decision making, sexual desire to seek sexual pleasure and safety, and effective communication with partner in terms of sexual behavior, sexual experience and sexual health. Based on these results, a scale measuring female sexual subjectivity is needed.
Crime Victims
;
Decision Making
;
Education
;
Female*
;
Humans
;
Jurisprudence
;
Methods*
;
Nursing
;
Orgasm
;
Pleasure
;
Psychology
;
Reproductive Health
;
Safe Sex
;
Sexual Behavior
;
Social Environment
;
Sociology
;
Theology
;
Walkers*
4.Characteristics of Schizophrenia Patients' Homicide Behaviors and Their Correlations with Criminal Capacity.
Zhi Wei SUN ; Tian Tao SHI ; Pei Xin FU
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2017;33(1):32-35
OBJECTIVES:
To explore the characteristics of schizophrenia patients' homicide behaviors and the influences of the assessments of criminal capacity.
METHODS:
Indicators such as demographic and clinical data, characteristics of criminal behaviors and criminal capacity from the suspects whom were diagnosed by forensic psychiatry as schizophrenia (n=110) and normal mental (n=70) with homicide behavior, were collected by self-made investigation form and compared. The influences of the assessments of criminal capacity on the suspects diagnosed as schizophrenia were also analyzed using logistic regression analysis.
RESULTS:
There were no significant statistical differences between the schizophrenic group and the normal mental group concerning age, gender, education and marital status (P>0.05). There were significant statistical differences between the two groups concerning thought disorder, emotion state and social function before crime (P<0.05) and there were significant statistical differences in some characteristics of the case such as aggressive history (P<0.05), cue, trigger, plan, criminal incentives, object of crime, circumstance cognition and self-protection (P<0.05). Multivariate logistic regression analysis suggested that thought disorder, emotion state, social function, criminal incentives, plan and self-protection before crime of the schizophrenic group were positively correlated with the criminal capacity (P<0.05).
CONCLUSIONS
The relevant influences of psychopathology and crime characteristics should be considered comprehensively for improving the accuracy of the criminal capacity evaluation on the suspects diagnosed as schizophrenia with homicide behavior.
Aggression/psychology*
;
Crime
;
Criminals
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Homicide/psychology*
;
Humans
;
Motivation
;
Schizophrenia/diagnosis*
;
Schizophrenic Psychology
5.Kleptomania: a case series.
Bharat SALUJA ; Lai Gwen CHAN ; Dani DHAVAL
Singapore medical journal 2014;55(12):e207-9
Kleptomania is an enigmatic condition and is among the very few psychiatric disorders in which crime is medicalised and used as a legal defence. The scientific literature on kleptomania is scarce. Early literature and recent studies have shown a female preponderance, with an early age of onset of stealing in people with comorbid personality disorder(s). In a retrospective review of the case notes of theft offenders who had forensic psychiatric evaluations performed in a one-year period in 2010 at the Institute of Mental Health, Singapore, we found three patients who were diagnosed with kleptomania. In this report, we describe the pertinent clinical and sociodemographic characteristics, as well as the diagnostic issues of kleptomania in relation to the three cases.
Alcoholism
;
complications
;
China
;
ethnology
;
Comorbidity
;
Crime
;
Depressive Disorder
;
complications
;
Disruptive, Impulse Control, and Conduct Disorders
;
complications
;
diagnosis
;
psychology
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
India
;
ethnology
;
Male
;
Middle Aged
;
Retrospective Studies
;
Singapore
6.Assessment on the criminal responsibility of drug-induced mental disorders: a questionnaire survey.
Sheng-yu ZHANG ; Hai ZHAO ; Tao TANG ; Wei GUAN
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2014;30(6):431-433
OBJECTIVE:
To understand the assessment on the criminal responsibility of drug-induced mental disorders and judicial experts' opinions.
METHODS:
The judicial experts from institutes of forensic psychiatry in Shanghai were selected. They were asked to finish a self-made questionnaire of assessment on the criminal responsibility of drug-induced mental disorders by letters and visits.
RESULTS:
Most of experts knew the special regulation, "not suitable for evaluation" towards the criminal responsibility of drug-induced mental disorders of the guideline promulgated by Ministry of Justice. Before and after the guideline was issued, no expert made a no-responsibility opinion in such cases. After the guideline was issued, some experts made a full-responsibility or limited-responsibility opinion in such cases. There was a little disagreement among the experts in the case that the crime was unrelated with mental symptoms or the criminals used drugs even though he knew it could induced insanity. But there were still many obvious disagreements among experts in the case that crime was related to such symptoms and person was no ability to debate. Most experts agreed to settle the disagreements with improved legislative perfection.
CONCLUSION
Most experts are not strictly complying with the assessment guidelines during their practice, and there is still an obvious disagreement towards the criminal responsibility of drug-induced mental disorders.
China
;
Crime/psychology*
;
Criminals/psychology*
;
Data Collection
;
Expert Testimony
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Liability, Legal
;
Male
;
Mental Competency
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Psychotic Disorders
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
7.Pattern of psychiatric morbidity among theft offenders remanded or referred for psychiatric evaluation and factors associated with reoffence.
Lai Gwen CHAN ; Saluja BHARAT ; Dhaval Kirti DANI
Singapore medical journal 2013;54(6):339-342
INTRODUCTIONIn Singapore, theft and related crimes constitute more than 50% of all reported crime, and are the most common offences committed by accused persons remanded to the Institute of Mental Health (IMH), Singapore. There is a need for better understanding of the forensic psychiatric aspects of such offenders. This study aimed to determine the prevalence of psychiatric disorders among theft offenders remanded or referred for forensic assessment in 2010, compare the differences between first-time and repeat theft offenders, and identify the factors associated with reoffence.
METHODSForensic evaluations of inpatient and outpatient theft offenders that were conducted at IMH in the year 2010 were retrieved and reviewed. The sociodemographic and clinical data of first-time and repeat theft offenders were collected and compared using Student's t-test and chi-square test for continuous and categorical variables, respectively. Multivariate regression was used to identify the factors that were predictive of repeat offence.
RESULTSOverall, 10% of offenders had no mental illness. Substance use disorders, mood disorders and psychotic disorders were the most common diagnoses. Psychotic disorders were significantly less common in repeat offenders. Repeat offenders also tended to have a history of conduct problems in childhood. Noncompliance with psychiatric treatment was positively associated with repeat offence, while psychotic disorders were negatively associated.
CONCLUSIONThe pattern of psychiatric morbidity among theft offenders in Singapore has changed over the last ten years. Kleptomania remains rare. Significant differences between first-time and repeat offenders have implications on the treatment, follow-up and rehabilitation of theft offenders in Singapore.
Adult ; Crime ; Criminals ; Female ; Humans ; Male ; Mental Disorders ; epidemiology ; psychology ; Middle Aged ; Prevalence ; Psychiatry ; methods ; Singapore ; Substance-Related Disorders ; epidemiology ; psychology ; Theft
8.Retrospective forensic analysis of 483 solved homicide cases in Suzhou city.
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2013;29(1):31-36
OBJECTIVE:
To summarize the solved homicide cases taking place in Suzhou city and to find out the characteristics and commonness of them in order to analyze the key points of investigation at the scene.
METHODS:
The data of 483 solved homicide cases occurring from January 2006 to March 2010 in the city were analyzed.
RESULTS:
Most cases involved 1 victim and 1 suspect, with young male adults dominated. Most of them were non-local residents. The majority of suspects were intentional by passion due to quarrel and dispute. The most common weapons were sharp instruments generally carried by the suspects. Mechanical asphyxia and mechanical injury were the two most common causes of death in these cases.
CONCLUSION
The social characteristics of suspects, criminal motivation, injury instruments, distribution of injuries, cause of death, and manner of death in Suzhou showed similar general characteristics as the experience for detecting homicide cases in the future.
Adult
;
Age Distribution
;
Asphyxia/mortality*
;
Cause of Death
;
Crime Victims/statistics & numerical data*
;
Criminal Psychology
;
Female
;
Forensic Pathology
;
Homicide/statistics & numerical data*
;
Humans
;
Male
;
Retrospective Studies
;
Sex Distribution
;
Shock, Hemorrhagic/mortality*
;
Socioeconomic Factors
;
Weapons/statistics & numerical data*
;
Wounds and Injuries/pathology*
9.Difference between the cognitive and control ability and the responsibility in forensic psychiatry evaluation.
Xue-Wu LI ; Bei-Ling GAO ; Feng HU ; Chao WU ; Hua ZHANG ; Ya-Jun GUAN ; Wu LAI ; Yi LI ; Yi WANG ; Dong-Ling WU ; Xiao-Lan CAO
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2013;29(4):263-267
OBJECTIVE:
To analyze the difference between the cognitive and control ability and the responsibility in forensic psychiatry evaluation.
METHODS:
To compare the results of the responsibility evaluation from 2001.1 to 2006.10 (the first period) with that of the cognitive and control ability evaluation from 2006.11 to 2010.10 (the second period). The admissibility opinions on court judgment and evaluation were investigated by return visit. The legal professions' opinions on forensic psychiatric issues from the police office, the procuratorate, the court, and the judiciary were investigated.
RESULTS:
There was no significant difference of the criminal types between two periods (P > 0.05). There was significant difference of the diagnostic types between two periods (P < 0.05). The proportion of normal range and part loss of the cognitive and control ability in the second period were higher than that in the first period, but the proportion of complete loss of the cognitive and control ability in the second period was lower than that in the first period (P < 0.05). Among the legal professions, 70.5% of them thought that "the evaluation of cognitive and control ability" was different from "the evaluation of criminal responsibility" and 94.9% of them thought that "to confirm the influence of the forensic psychiatric evaluation of mental disorder on the crime behavior" or "to assess of cognitive and control ability" met requirements of normative judicial expertise.
CONCLUSION
The evaluation of cognitive and control ability is more aligned with legal requirements and behavioral norms of own subject than the evaluation of responsibility.
Crime/psychology*
;
Expert Testimony
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Insanity Defense
;
Mental Competency
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
10.Characteristics of recidivism in patients with mental disorders: 156 cases analysis.
Jian-Mei LIU ; Pan LÜ ; Jun-Mei HU
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2013;29(4):278-281
OBJECTIVE:
To analyze the characteristics of recidivism in patients with mental disorders, including criminology, clinic and guardianship, in order to provide references for preventing recidivism.
METHODS:
Using the self-designed questionnaire, 156 psychotic patients who had repeated crimes were appraised by West China Forensic Science Center of Sichuan University from 2007 to 2011 and the data were collected and analyzed.
RESULTS:
In the majority of these cases, patients were male, 26-45 years old, junior high school or below diploma, unmarried, and farmers or jobless. Each patient broke law 3.26 times on average. The main crimes were intentional injury (34.6%) and murder (15.7%). Within 5 years after diagnosis with mental disorder, 56.4% of the patients committed first crime. Within 1 year after the first time breaking the law, 55.8% of them repeated crimes. The diagnoses of schizophrenia (63.5%) were in the majority. The assessment results were mostly irresponsibility (61.5%). Among the patients, 44.9% of them didn't receive treatment while 34.6% of them were out of supervision. After the first crime, 66.1% of them didn't receive criminal prosecution while only 7.1% of them went through the appraisement of forensic psychiatry.
CONCLUSION
Most of the patients had low education and low income. Meanwhile, low outpatient rate and pool supervision occurred in this special crowd. A good system for care and treatment of these mental patients should be built to prevent them from recidivism.
Adolescent
;
Adult
;
China/epidemiology*
;
Crime/statistics & numerical data*
;
Criminals
;
Educational Status
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Homicide/statistics & numerical data*
;
Humans
;
Liability, Legal
;
Male
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Middle Aged
;
Personality Disorders/psychology*
;
Recurrence
;
Schizophrenia/epidemiology*
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
;
Violence/statistics & numerical data*
;
Young Adult

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail