1.The development of a local sexual assault investigation kit: The Philippine experience
Maria Corazon A. De Ungria ; Miriam Ruth M. Dalet ; Minerva S. Sagum ; Merle P. Tan ; Bernadette J. Madrid
Acta Medica Philippina 2022;56(15):32-41
Objectives:
This paper presents the development of a local sexual assault investigation kit (SAK) that doctors in the Philippines could use to collect biological samples from victims of sexual abuse, including child patients, that would be used for DNA testing. The study also reports on a management system via courier service to protect the integrity of the samples that could be eventually used as evidence in court from the collection site to the laboratory with sufficient backup measures.
Methods:
Women and Child Protection Units (WCPU) from Manila, Baguio, Cebu, and Davao partnered with the DNA Analysis Laboratory, Natural Sciences Research Institute of UP Diliman (NSRI-UPD) DNA Analysis Laboratory in testing the utility of a prototype SAK for the collection of biological samples from child patients. From January 2002 to March 2006, samples were collected from patients who went to WCPU within 72 hours post-contact and consented to participate in the study. WCPU doctors collected biological samples guided by the patient’s narratives and packaged the samples while following detailed documentation and chain of custody procedures. SAKs were then sent via a designated courier service from WCPU to the NSRI-UPD DNA Analysis Laboratory for DNA testing. The WCPU kept half of the samples collected, following recommendations made during sectoral consultations that included members of the Research Group of the Philippine Judicial Academy, prosecutors, and defense counsels. Case samples were packed well by the WCPU and received at the NSRI-UPD DNA Analysis Laboratory. Due to budget limitations, only the internal genitalia and patients’ reference buccal swabs were subjected to DNA tests as reported by Maiquilla et al.1 The remaining SAK components and case records were kept in a dedicated and secure storage facility. DNA testing reports were sent to the WCPU, which released them to the child patients and their legal guardians.
Results:
One hundred fifty-four female children aged 2-18 years old and their legal guardians agreed to participate in the study. Based on the initial interviews of the social workers who conducted the evaluation, all the participants came from families with very low socioeconomic status. The WCPU doctors then complied with prescribed procedures. To date, NSRI-UPD DNA Analysis Laboratory records show that a subpoena for expert testimony had been issued in only one case out of the 63 cases (1.6%) that were positive for male DNA. No further information was available on the final decision in this case due to the absence of any order from the judge granting the laboratory access to court records. Likewise, WCPUs did not have any information on the remaining 62 cases that could have used the DNA test results as evidence if a case had been filed in court.
Conclusion
This study is the first to report the development and validation of a sexual assault investigation kit in the Philippines aimed at helping medical doctors in collecting and preserving critical biological samples for DNA testing. Using a dedicated courier service to send SAK from collecting agencies to the laboratory for DNA testing was successfully tested and resulted in faster delivery and significantly reduced overall cost. While DNA testing remains the most powerful tool for human identification and the technology has been available in the Philippines since 1997, certain factors have prevented it from being used routinely in sexual assault investigations, including those involving children.
Women and child protection units
;
Sex Offenses
2.Prevalence and risk factors of suicidal ideation among victims of child sexual abuse seen at the Philippine General Hospital Child Protection Unit
Pia Angelica G. Vega ; Riza C. Lorenzana
Acta Medica Philippina 2022;56(15):52-58
Objectives:
Suicidal ideation is a serious concern even among the pediatric population. This study aimed to determine its prevalence among victims of child sexual abuse and the factors that may contribute to its occurrence.
Methods:
A cross-sectional analytic study was done using medical records of 393 victims of child sexual abuse seen at the PGH CPU from 2017–2019. A logistic regression analysis was performed to assess the associations of age, sex, closest relation to perpetrator, mode, and chronicity of sexual abuse to the presence of suicidal ideation.
Results:
The prevalence of suicidal ideation among victims of child sexual abuse is 28%. The factors that were found to have a statistically significant association with suicidal ideation were age and closest relation to perpetrator. For each additional year from 6 to 17 years of age, the odds of having suicidal ideation increased by a factor of 1.33 (95% CI 1.19, 1.49; p<0.001). Victims who were abused by an immediate family member had increased odds of suicidal ideation by a factor of 2.12 (95% CI 1.12, 4.03; p=0.021).
Conclusion
Suicide is prevalent among victims of child sexual abuse. A high index of suspicion should be given to older adolescents and those whose perpetrators are immediate family members.
Suicidal Ideation
;
Child Abuse
;
Sex Offenses
;
Mental Health
3.The demographics of minor perpetrators of sexually assaulted pediatric patients from the Philippine General Hospital - Child Protection Unit (PGH-CPU) from January 2013 to December 2018
Patricia Carla N. Asuncion ; Merle P. Tan ; Kathylnne Anne Abat-Senen
Acta Medica Philippina 2022;56(15):69-77
Background:
Child sexual assault has been underreported, more so, those who minor perpetrators have assaulted. Surveillance for these children, victims and perpetrators alike, must be established.
Objective:
The objective was to describe the characteristic profile of the minor perpetrators who committed child sexual abuse seen in Philippine General Hospital - Child Protection Unit (PGH-CPU) from January 2013 to December 2018.
Methodology:
This retrospective cohort study was conducted using chart review and data retrieval from the Child Protection Management Information System (CPMIS) of the PGH-CPU.
Results:
There were 931 minor perpetrators. 55.9% were 15-19 years old and were predominantly male. 12.7% came from Cavite and 9.5% from Manila. Most were neighbors, acquaintances, and cousins of the victims. 39.4% were still students. 14.4% engaged in alcohol consumption. 7.7% have repeatedly abused children. 6.1% already had police blotter records. 7.3% were exposed to pornography. 7.5% are currently in jail, and 4.1% are in the same household as the victim.
Conclusion
A child’s environment is potentially contributory to their actions. The minor perpetrators reported were observed to have adverse childhood experiences like violence in their families. Although sexual abuse cases focus on the victims, it is equally vital that authorities give attention to minor perpetrators because they are also children. Programs and interventions should be provided for them to grow up to be better individuals in society.
Sex Offenses
;
Child
4.A retrospective look on the use of DNA evidence in a sexual assault investigation in the Philippines
Gayvelline C. Calacal ; Frederick C. Delfin ; Maria Corazon A. De Ungria
Acta Medica Philippina 2022;56(15):121-126
In 1998, biological samples were collected from the body of a 17-year old female rape-homicide victim within 24 hours post-contact. In the absence of a sexual assault investigation kit, locally available medical supplies were used to collect biological samples. The victim’s family filed a case naming the victim’s uncle as the assailant. More than a year into the trial, samples from the victim and the accused were tested for DNA. The vaginal smears yielded DNA profiles originating from at least two persons, with one DNA source being male. Upon discovery, the victim’s age, the state of her body, and medicolegal examination results supported the allegation of sexual assault rather than consensual sex. This paper described the DNA testing conducted for this rape with homicide case. The prosecution used the DNA test results to support the charges against the accused, who was eventually convicted and sentenced to death in 2001. Upon automatic review in 2004, the Philippine Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and dismissed the defense’s claim that DNA testing violated the defendant’s right against self-incrimination. The defendant’s death conviction was commuted to life imprisonment when the Death Penalty was suspended via Republic Act No. 9346 in 2006. The case described here is considered one of the DNA landmark cases cited in the Philippine Rule on DNA Evidence of 2007.
Sex Offenses
;
Microsatellite Repeats
5.Application Value and Research Progress of Human Microbiome in Sexual Assault Cases.
Yang LIU ; Min-Min XU ; Ya ZHANG ; Shi-Quan LIU ; Mei-Qing YUAN ; Zhen-Jun JIA
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2022;38(6):774-782
In recent years, sexual assault cases have been on the rise, seriously infringing the legitimate rights and interests of women and children, causing widespread concern in society. DNA evidence has become the key evidence to prove the facts in sexual assault cases, but lack of DNA evidence or only DNA evidence in some sexual assault cases leads to unclear facts and insufficient evidence. With the emergence of high-throughput sequencing technology and the development of bioinformatics and artificial intelligence, new progress has been made in the study of human microbiome. Researchers have begun to use human microbiome for difficult sexual assault cases indentification. This paper reviews the characteristics of human microbiome, and its application value in the inferences of the body fluid stain origin, the sexual assault method, the crime time, etc. In addition, the challenges faced by the application of the human microbiome in practical case handling, the solutions and future development potential are analyzed and prospected.
Child
;
Humans
;
Female
;
Artificial Intelligence
;
Forensic Medicine/methods*
;
Sex Offenses
;
DNA
;
Microbiota
;
Crime Victims
6.Development of a program to prevent sexual violence among teens in Japan: education using DVD video teaching materials and web-based learning.
Miyuki NAGAMATSU ; Narumi OOSHIGE ; Nozomi SONODA ; Mika NIINA ; Ken-Ichi HARA
Environmental Health and Preventive Medicine 2021;26(1):41-41
BACKGROUND:
This study aimed to develop an education system using DVD video-based teaching materials or web-based learning to reduce sexual violence among teens in Japan.
METHODS:
During the first stage, June 2018 to March 2019, an education program using DVD video teaching materials was carried out at three high schools and four universities with research consent from the director of the facility. From 1337 high school students and first- and second-year university students, subjects in their teen years were targeted for analysis. A survey was conducted at baseline and after the DVD video teaching. During the second stage, November 2019 to March 2020, web-based learning using improved video teaching materials was developed and carried out. From the adolescents who participated in the web-based learning, subjects in their teen years were targeted for analysis. A survey was conducted at baseline and after the web-based learning.
RESULTS:
In the first stage, 876 students consented to and participated in the education using DVD video teaching materials and baseline and after surveys (collection rate 65.5%). Among these, the number of respondents in their teens both baseline and after education was 705 persons (valid response rate 80.4%). In the second stage, the number of respondents in their teens both baseline and after education was 250 respondents in their teens who received web-based learning using the improved video teaching materials (valid response rate 87.1%). The improvement effect of the two programs was observed in attitudes that lead to physical violence, attitudes that lead to mental violence, attitudes that promote healthy conflict resolution, and dangerous attitudes that lead to sexual violence from persons in the community or through the Internet. The web-based learning program achieved an improvement of preventive attitudes toward sexual violence.
CONCLUSIONS
The education program using DVD video teaching materials or web-based learning may help prevent sexual violence among teens in Japan.
Adolescent
;
Compact Disks
;
Female
;
Humans
;
Internet
;
Japan
;
Male
;
Sex Offenses/statistics & numerical data*
;
Students
;
Teaching Materials
;
Video Recording
7.Descriptive analysis of the adherence to the acute care protocol for adult female sexual abuse patients seen at the OB admitting section in a tertiary public hospital in the Philippines
Pamela Grace V. Valera ; Joanne Karen S. Aguinaldo
Philippine Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2020;44(2):25-33
Background:
There has been an increasing trend in reported sexual abuse patients in the Philippines in the past 20 years. Patient evaluation is critical from health care providers and it is imperative to have an acute care protocol that heath care providers can use in managing these patients.
Objective:
To assess the adherence to the acute care protocol as applied to adult female sexual abuse patients who consulted at the Philippine General Hospital OB Admitting Section from March to August 2019
Methods:
The study design used was an observational, cross-sectional study via descriptive analysis using a designed questionnaire. Relevant data regarding compliance to the acute care protocol was assessed from patient experience via the questionnaire after undergoing the standard services of the hospital. Data was then documented, tabulated and processed via Microsoft Excel data sheets.
Results:
In terms of patient perspective, 96.2 % of all cases (n=27) were provided service by OBGYNs and psychiatrists and 100% were assessed by social workers. Although stated in the protocol, legal and/or police assistance was not provided by the hospital during patient consult.
Conclusion
The institution was able to adhere to the acute care protocol services of patients in terms of obstetric and gynecologic, psychiatric and social worker services but not legal and/or police assistance.
Humans
;
Sex Offenses
;
Patient Compliance
8.Research Status and Limitations of Sadomasochism.
Wan Ying LIANG ; Yu Qing ZHANG
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2020;36(6):828-830
Sadomasochism is the sexual interest, psychosexual deviance or sexual crimes that are sexually aroused by suffering or causing others to suffer. This study summarizes the concept, assessment and diagnosis, categories and symptoms, psychological and biological mechanisms, judicial disposition and clinical intervention strategies of sadomasochism from the perspectives of clinical medicine, law, criminology and psychology, suggests that further research should take local people with sadomasochism preference and local patients as research objects, pay attention to different types of sadomasochists, conduct bottom-up research, explore the core elements and manifestations of sadomasochism, and accurately define and classify sadomasochism, construct an effective scale, a erectile measurement sexual stimulation system and a diagnostic criteria; discuss evaluation methods combined with crime scene data; discuss the validity of masochists' consent combined with diagnosis; establish targeted criminal correction programs and a treatment and rehabilitation system to provide reference for the improvement of medical, judicial and mental health services.
Criminals
;
Humans
;
Male
;
Masochism
;
Sadism
;
Sex Offenses
;
Sexual Behavior
9.Experiencing Coercive Control in Female Victims of Dating Violence
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing 2019;49(1):46-58
BACKGROUND: Dating violence refers to violence occurring between people in an intimate relationship. Forms of dating violence are often categorized into physical, psychological, and sexual violence, and most existing literature has followed this frame. However, few studies have focused on the phenomenon of living under the perpetrator's coercive control in victims of dating violence, although those experiences are known to be signs of severe forms of violence later on. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to explore the experiences of being coercively controlled in female victims who had experienced dating violence. METHODS: For this study, in-depth interviews were conducted with a total of 14 female victims, and all interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. The data were analyzed using the phenomenological analysis method suggested by Colaizzi. RESULTS: Three themes were derived in chronological order: idealizing the relationship (period of potential control), facing severer tyranny (period of coercive control), and escaping from the unending trap (period of post-control). The results showed that the victims experienced perpetrators' control with specific patterns. The perpetrators' controlling behaviors were invisible, literally benevolent, at the beginning; however, severe forms of violence seemed to appear as their relationship deepened and the perpetrators failed to control the victims. CONCLUSION: Findings from this study presented vivid experiences of female victims who needed help and care. Hopefully, the results can benefit in terms of developing evidence-based prevention strategies for victims as well as assessing the risks of severe forms of dating violence, such as physical attack or murder.
Crime Victims
;
Female
;
Homicide
;
Humans
;
Intimate Partner Violence
;
Methods
;
Physical Abuse
;
Qualitative Research
;
Sex Offenses
;
United Nations
;
Violence
10.A Cohort Study of Children and Adolescents Victims with Sexual Abuse in Korea and Their Initial Assessment Results
Kyung Yoon KIM ; Na Hyun LEE ; Keun Ah CHEON ; Dong Ho SONG
Korean Journal of Psychosomatic Medicine 2019;27(1):13-24
OBJECTIVES: The goals of the study are how to establish the cohort systems for the children and adolescents victims with sexual abuse in Korea and to identify the risk and protective factors that influence mental health in child sexual abuse (CSA). This is initial assessment data based on the analysis of cohort variables for baseline evaluation of subjects. METHODS: We constructed the cohort systems for CSA victims recruited by Seoul Sunflower Children Center, CSA victims protection center. The initial assessment data which consisted of demographic and psychological inventories of CSA victims and their parents/families, psychiatric diagnoses were the results of statistical analysis of 65 subjects under 19 years old for 3 years 7 months. RESULTS: The initial data were followings : female participants, N=56; mean age, 11.6 (SD=4.5); the most sexual assault, molestation 71.8%; victims, family and acquaintance 87.1%; 61.5% of the subjects diagnosed with psychiatric disorder; 29.2% diagnosed with PTSD and 23.1% diagnosed with depression. Mean duration for abuse to report is 1.5 years. Mean score of IES-R-K, TSCYC-avoidant and CBCL-problematic behavior were increased above clinical cut-off. CONCLUSIONS: CSA victims tend to have high risks in mental health problem. The cohort study could provide the risk and protective factors of CSA in mental health, and construct the predictive model for mental illness in Korea.
Adolescent
;
Child Abuse, Sexual
;
Child
;
Cohort Studies
;
Depression
;
Diagnosis
;
Equipment and Supplies
;
Female
;
Helianthus
;
Humans
;
Korea
;
Mental Health
;
Protective Factors
;
Seoul
;
Sex Offenses
;
Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic


Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail