1.Standardization Challenges in Outcome Evaluation Systems of Animal Experiments and Considerations for Core Outcome Set Construction Strategies
Qingyong ZHENG ; Yongjia ZHOU ; Tengfei LI ; Jianguo XU ; Chen TIAN ; Hui LIU ; Min TIAN ; Ziyu ZHOU ; Caihua XU ; Yating CUI ; Junfei WANG ; Jinhui TIAN
Laboratory Animal and Comparative Medicine 2026;46(1):138-148
Animal experimentation constitutes a critical link between basic research and clinical application, making its research quality and translational efficiency paramount. Although considerable progress has been made in standardizing operational procedures and ethical guidelines, the standardization of outcome evaluation systems has significantly lagged, creating a key bottleneck that constrains the quality of biomedical research and evidence synthesis. This deficiency is manifested by pronounced heterogeneity in outcome selection across similar studies, incomplete methodological reporting, and disparate criteria for result interpretation, which severely impairs the comparability of findings and the evidence integration. To cope with this challenge, this paper systematically introduces a mature methodological tool from clinical research–the core outcome set (COS)–and explores its construction strategies and application potential in the field of animal experimentation. Given the extensive diversity of animal experiments, a pragmatic strategy of "focusing on key areas, implementing phased pilots, and promoting gradual expansion" should be adopted. This approach prioritizes the development of domain-specific COS for disease areas characterized by high research volume, urgent translational needs, and well-established animal models. A multi-source integration pathway for COS development is detailed, comprising systematic literature searches, methodological appraisals, and expert consensus, with the feasibility of leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) to enhance efficiency also being examined. The development and promotion of such COS are not intended to restrict scientific exploration; rather, they aim to establish a new, tiered evaluation paradigm consisting of "core outcomes" (mandatory), "recommended outcomes" (encouraged), and "exploratory outcomes" (optional). This framework is expected not only to enhance research quality through standardization and to adhere to the "3R" principles but also to accelerate the accumulation of high-quality evidence. This, in turn, provides a solid foundation for higher-level evidence synthesis, ultimately facilitating the effective translation of basic research findings into clinical practice and providing an essential methodological framework for scientific advancement in relevant disciplines.
2.Construction and Evaluation of Maternal Mortality Prediction Model in Yunnan Province
Shan ZHAO ; Sai GAO ; Tangchun LI ; Zhongming ZHAO ; Yating WU ; Min ZHENG
Journal of Kunming Medical University 2025;46(2):110-117
Objective To construct and evaluate the prediction model of maternal mortality in Yunnan Province,and predict the maternal mortality rate in Yunnan Province from 2024 to 2030.Methods Based on the maternal mortality rates in Yunnan Province from 1994 to 2023,a grey prediction model and a autoregressive integrated moving average model were constructed,The models were compared using mean absolute error,mean square error and root mean square error to assess their fitting performance,and the optimal model was used to predict the maternal mortality rate in Yunnan Province from 2024 to 2030.Resuls The maternal mortality rate in Yunnan Province showed a continuous decline from 1994 to 2023(χ2=50 170.0,P<0.05).The mean absolute error,mean-square error and root mean-square error for the grey prediction model were 2.424,12.389,3.519,respectively,while for the differential autoregressive moving average model,they were 3.966,27.651,5.258,respectively.The prediction effect of the grey prediction model is superior to that of the autoregressive integrated moving average model,with a posterior difference ratio C=0.079 and a low probability error P=1,indicating a prediction accuracy of level 1.Using the grey prediction model,the maternal mortality rates for Yunnan Province from 2024 to 2030 are 10.05/100 000,9.16/100 000,8.34/100 000,7.59/100 000,691/100 000,6.30/100 000 and 5.73/100 000,respectively.Conclusion The grey prediction model has a good prediction effect on maternal mortality in Yunnan Province.It is predicted that the maternal mortality rate in Yunnan Province in 2030 can meet the control targets outlined in the"Healthy China 2030 Plan",the"Outline of Chinese Women's Development(2021-2030)"and the"Yunnan Women's Development Plan(2021-2030)".
3.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
4.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
5.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
6.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
7.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
8.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
9.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.
10.Qualitative Research on Influencing Factors of Hospital Administrators' Job Meaning
Huilan ZHU ; Shuaihe ZHU ; Chunyang LU ; Bin ZHENG ; Yuxuan ZHU ; Yating CHENG ; Tingshan DUAN ; Tao SUN
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(6):51-55
Objective It conducted a grounded theory on the factors influencing the sense of job significance of hospital administrators to provide suggestions and references for the promotion of high-quality development of hospital management work.Methods From April to September 2023,it interviewed 23 administrators from various departments across Provinces/Cities,including Zhejiang,Heilongjiang,Guangdong,Shanghai,Henan,Jilin,Sichuan and others,using a theoretical sampling method.Employing Grounded Theory,it encoded over transcriptional information at three levels.Results Three-level coding process yielded 66 free nodes,19 initial concepts,7 main categories,and 3 dimensions,leading to the development of a theoretical model encompassing existence,relatedness,and growth.Conclusion The job meaning for hospital administrators is shaped by existence,relatedness,and growth.It recommend revising performance assessments,fostering an empowering culture,enhancing informal communication,providing professional growth pathways,and offering diverse career development options to deepen administrators'job meaning.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail