1.Expert consensus on the positioning of the "Three-in-One" Registration and Evaluation Evidence System and the value of orientation of the "personal experience"
Qi WANG ; Yongyan WANG ; Wei XIAO ; Jinzhou TIAN ; Shilin CHEN ; Liguo ZHU ; Guangrong SUN ; Daning ZHANG ; Daihan ZHOU ; Guoqiang MEI ; Baofan SHEN ; Qingguo WANG ; Xixing WANG ; Zheng NAN ; Mingxiang HAN ; Yue GAO ; Xiaohe XIAO ; Xiaobo SUN ; Kaiwen HU ; Liqun JIA ; Li FENG ; Chengyu WU ; Xia DING
Journal of Beijing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025;48(4):445-450
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), as a treasure of the Chinese nation, plays a significant role in maintaining public health. In 2019, the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China and the State Council proposed for the first time the establishment of a TCM registration and evaluation evidence system that integrates TCM theory, "personal experience" and clinical trials (referred to as the "Three-in-One" System) to promote the inheritance and innovation of TCM. Subsequently, the National Medical Products Administration issued several guiding principles to advance the improvement and implementation of this system. Owing to the complexity of its implementation, there are still differing understandings within the TCM industry regarding the positioning of the "Three-in-One" Registration and Evaluation Evidence System, as well as the connotation and value orientation of the "personal experience." To address this, Academician WANG Qi, President of the TCM Association, China International Exchange and Promotion Association for Medical and Healthcare and TCM master, led a group of academicians, TCM masters, TCM pharmacology experts and clinical TCM experts to convene a "Seminar on Promoting the Implementation of the ′Three-in-One′ Registration and Evaluation Evidence System for Chinese Medicinals." Through extensive discussions, an expert consensus was formed, clarifying the different roles of the TCM theory, "personal experience" and clinical trials within the system. It was further emphasized that the "personal experience" is the core of this system, and its data should be derived from clinical practice scenarios. In the future, the improvement of this system will require collaborative efforts across multiple fields to promote the high-quality development of the Chinese medicinal industry.
2.Integrated evidence chain-based effectiveness evaluation of traditional Chinese medicines (Eff-iEC): A demonstration study.
Ye LUO ; Xu ZHAO ; Ruilin WANG ; Xiaoyan ZHAN ; Tianyi ZHANG ; Tingting HE ; Jing JING ; Jianyu LI ; Fengyi LI ; Ping ZHANG ; Junling CAO ; Jinfa TANG ; Zhijie MA ; Tingming SHEN ; Shuanglin QIN ; Ming YANG ; Jun ZHAO ; Zhaofang BAI ; Jiabo WANG ; Aiguo DAI ; Xiangmei CHEN ; Xiaohe XIAO
Acta Pharmaceutica Sinica B 2025;15(2):909-918
Addressing the enduring challenge of evaluating traditional Chinese medicines (TCMs), the integrated evidence chain-based effectiveness evaluation of TCMs (Eff-iEC) has emerged. This paper explored its capacity through a demonstration study that evaluated the effectiveness evidence of six commonly used anti-hepatic fibrosis Chinese patent medicines (CPMs), including Biejiajian Pill (BP), Dahuang Zhechong Pill (DZP), Biejia Ruangan Compound (BRC), Fuzheng Huayu Capsule (FHC), Anluo Huaxian Pill (AHP), and Heluo Shugan Capsule (HSC), using both Eff-iEC and the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) system. The recognition of these CPMs within the TCM academic community was also assessed through their inclusion in relevant medical documents. Results showed that the evidence of BRC and FHC received higher assessments in both Eff-iEC and GRADE system, while the assessments for others varied. Analysis of community recognition revealed that Eff-iEC more accurately reflects the clinical value of these CPMs, exhibiting superior evaluative capabilities. By breaking through the conventional pattern of TCMs effectiveness evaluation, Eff-iEC offers a novel epistemology that better aligns with the clinical realities and reasoning of TCMs, providing a coherent methodology for clinical decision-making, new drug evaluations, and health policy formulation.
3.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
4.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
5.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
6.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
7.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
8.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
9.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.
10.Quantitative Evaluation Study of Chinese Medical and Preventive Integration Policy Text based on the PMC Index Model
Chen JIN ; Xiaohe WANG ; Zhongyi ZHANG
Chinese Hospital Management 2024;44(7):26-30
Objective It aims to introduce the Policy Modeling Consistency(PMC)index model for the quantitative assessment of medical and preventive integration policies,with the goal of providing reference for optimizing the poli-cies in China.Methods Using"medical and preventive integration"as the keyword,it retrieved 30 policy texts from the official websites of the central government and relevant departments.Based on the ROST CM 6.0 software and the PMC index model,it conducted a quantitative assessment of Chinese medical and preventive integration policy texts.Results The mean PMC index of the medical and preventive integration policy text is 4.552,with 8 policies clas-sified as an acceptable level.Conclusion It is necessary to strengthen the top-level design of medical and preventive integration policies,optimize the combined application of policy tools,and effectively utilize the advantages of Tradi-tional Chinese Medicine and the integration between traditional Chinese and Western medicine in medical and preven-tive integration services.


Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail