1.Development and validation of a quality appraisal tool for case reports in traditional Chinese medicine using the Delphi method
Duoting TAN ; Hao LIANG ; Yipin YU ; Jin GUO ; Liqin ZHONG ; Zhixi HU
Digital Chinese Medicine 2025;8(2):137-146
Objective:
To develop a quality appraisal tool for case reports in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) based on their characteristics.
[Methods]:
An extensive literature search was conducted in Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM), China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), and China Science and Technology Journal Database (CSTJ), focusing on expert consensus statements and checklists for TCM case reports. Relevant items were extracted, and a Delphi method involving 34 experts was used in two rounds to rate each item on a 5-point Likert scale. Items were screened based on measures of central tendency and coordination (including total score, mean score, percentage of items rated as unimportant, and coefficient of variation). The weighted average method was used to determine item weights and construct the appraisal tool. Internal consistency was assessed using Cronbach’s α coefficient. The finalized tool was pilot-tested by two reviewers independently appraising 20 case reports, with an additional four reviewers evaluating 5 of these cases to compare inter-rater consistency.
Results:
A total of 9 513 articles were retrieved, and 96 items from 25 articles were extracted. After two rounds of the Delphi method, 27 items across 10 domains were retained. The Cronbach’s α coefficient was 0.72 in the first round (acceptable range), and 0.96 in the second round, indicating strong internal consistency. The tool was piloted by six reviewers, achieving a kappa value of 0.663 and a Kendall’s coefficient of concordance of 0.845, demonstrating high consistency among reviewers.
Conclusion
The developed TCM case report quality appraisal tool, consisting of 27 items in 10 domains, offers a scientific and reliable means of assessing the quality of TCM case reports. The tool showed high consistency and practical utility, and its application is expected to enhance the standardization, scientific rigor, and evidence quality of TCM case reports, facilitating the integration of traditional medical knowledge with modern evidence-based standards.
2.In Vitro and Animal Studies of Human Natural Killer Cell-Derived Exosomes for the Treatment of Otitis Media.
Zirui ZHAO ; Liqin WANG ; Zhen GUO ; Kanglun JIANG ; Jianghong XU ; Yilai SHU ; Christina Y XU ; Jianning ZHANG ; Yunfeng WANG ; Geng-Lin LI
Neuroscience Bulletin 2025;41(10):1792-1804
Otitis media is an infection of the middle ear mainly caused by bacteria, and current treatments rely heavily on antibiotics. However, the emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains seriously affects their efficacy. In our study, we found that extracellular vesicles (EVs) derived from human natural killer cells (NKs) inhibit the proliferation of both standard and levofloxacin (LVX)-resistant strains of Staphylococcus aureus in a dose-dependent manner. Moreover, compared to LVX, EVs were more effective at reducing effusion and rescuing hearing thresholds in animal models. For LVX-sensitive strains, EVs were significantly more effective in terms of curative time but not curative rate. For LVX-resistant strains, EVs were significantly more effective in terms of both curative rate and curative time when applied alone or applied jointly with LVX. In summary, we found that NK EVs are highly effective in treating otitis media, providing an alternative approach for treating this common disease.
Killer Cells, Natural/metabolism*
;
Exosomes/metabolism*
;
Animals
;
Humans
;
Otitis Media/therapy*
;
Staphylococcus aureus/drug effects*
;
Disease Models, Animal
;
Anti-Bacterial Agents/pharmacology*
;
Levofloxacin/pharmacology*
3.Guideline for Adult Weight Management in China
Weiqing WANG ; Qin WAN ; Jianhua MA ; Guang WANG ; Yufan WANG ; Guixia WANG ; Yongquan SHI ; Tingjun YE ; Xiaoguang SHI ; Jian KUANG ; Bo FENG ; Xiuyan FENG ; Guang NING ; Yiming MU ; Hongyu KUANG ; Xiaoping XING ; Chunli PIAO ; Xingbo CHENG ; Zhifeng CHENG ; Yufang BI ; Yan BI ; Wenshan LYU ; Dalong ZHU ; Cuiyan ZHU ; Wei ZHU ; Fei HUA ; Fei XIANG ; Shuang YAN ; Zilin SUN ; Yadong SUN ; Liqin SUN ; Luying SUN ; Li YAN ; Yanbing LI ; Hong LI ; Shu LI ; Ling LI ; Yiming LI ; Chenzhong LI ; Hua YANG ; Jinkui YANG ; Ling YANG ; Ying YANG ; Tao YANG ; Xiao YANG ; Xinhua XIAO ; Dan WU ; Jinsong KUANG ; Lanjie HE ; Wei GU ; Jie SHEN ; Yongfeng SONG ; Qiao ZHANG ; Hong ZHANG ; Yuwei ZHANG ; Junqing ZHANG ; Xianfeng ZHANG ; Miao ZHANG ; Yifei ZHANG ; Yingli LU ; Hong CHEN ; Li CHEN ; Bing CHEN ; Shihong CHEN ; Guiyan CHEN ; Haibing CHEN ; Lei CHEN ; Yanyan CHEN ; Genben CHEN ; Yikun ZHOU ; Xianghai ZHOU ; Qiang ZHOU ; Jiaqiang ZHOU ; Hongting ZHENG ; Zhongyan SHAN ; Jiajun ZHAO ; Dong ZHAO ; Ji HU ; Jiang HU ; Xinguo HOU ; Bimin SHI ; Tianpei HONG ; Mingxia YUAN ; Weibo XIA ; Xuejiang GU ; Yong XU ; Shuguang PANG ; Tianshu GAO ; Zuhua GAO ; Xiaohui GUO ; Hongyi CAO ; Mingfeng CAO ; Xiaopei CAO ; Jing MA ; Bin LU ; Zhen LIANG ; Jun LIANG ; Min LONG ; Yongde PENG ; Jin LU ; Hongyun LU ; Yan LU ; Chunping ZENG ; Binhong WEN ; Xueyong LOU ; Qingbo GUAN ; Lin LIAO ; Xin LIAO ; Ping XIONG ; Yaoming XUE
Chinese Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism 2025;41(11):891-907
Body weight abnormalities, including overweight, obesity, and underweight, have become a dual public health challenge in Chinese adults: overweight and obesity lead to a variety of chronic complications, while underweight increases the risks of malnutrition, sarcopenia, and organ dysfunction. To systematically address these issues, multidisciplinary experts in endocrinology, sports science, nutrition, and psychiatry from various regions have held multiple weight management seminars. Based on the latest epidemiological data and clinical evidence, they expanded the guideline to include assessment and intervention strategies for underweight, in addition to the core content of obesity management. This guideline outlines the etiological mechanisms, evaluation methods, and multidimensional management strategies for overweight and obesity, covering key areas such as diagnosis and assessment, medical nutrition therapy, exercise prescription, pharmacological intervention, and psychological support. It is intended to provide a scientific and standardized approach to weight management across the adult population, aiming to curb the rising prevalence of obesity, mitigate complications associated with abnormal body weight, and improve nutritional status and overall quality of life.
4.Significance of serum BAFF and complement lytic factor Bb expression in patients with idiopathic membra-nous nephropathy and their correlation with UACR
Liqin GUO ; Xiaojing HAN ; Huan WANG ; Guobin HE
The Journal of Practical Medicine 2025;41(21):3330-3337
Objective To investigate the clinical significance of serum B cell activating factor(BAFF)and complement lytic factor Bb in patients with idiopathic membranous nephropathy(IMN),as well as their correlation with the urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio(UACR).Methods A total of 204 IMN patients were enrolled as the study group,and 100 healthy individuals undergoing physical examinations during the same period served as the control group.Serum levels of BAFF,Bb,and UACR were measured and compared between the two groups.Pearson correlation analysis was performed to assess the associations among serum BAFF,Bb,and UACR.The patients in the study group were followed up for 12 months and stratified into a favorable prognosis group and a poor prognosis group(defined as no remission)based on disease remission status.Demographic and clinical characteristics,as well as serum BAFF and Bb levels,were compared between the two outcome groups.Multivariate logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify independent predictors of poor prognosis in IMN patients.Receiver operating char-acteristic(ROC)curve analysis was employed to evaluate the predictive value of these indicators for poor prognosis.Results The levels of BAFF,Bb,and UACR in the research group were significantly higher than those in the con-trol group(P<0.05).Pearson correlation analysis revealed that both BAFF and Bb were positively correlated with UACR(r=0.716 and 0.543,respectively;P<0.05).After one year of follow-up,a total of 200 patients completed the study,among whom 46 experienced poor prognosis.Based on the follow-up outcomes,patients were categorized into a poor prognosis group(n=46)and a good prognosis group(n=154).The poor prognosis group exhibited significantly higher levels of serum creatinine,24-hour urinary protein,BAFF,and Bb,as well as lower eGFR values,compared to the good prognosis group(P<0.05).Multivariate regression analysis identified 24-hour urinary protein,BAFF,and Bb as independent risk factors for poor prognosis in patients with IMN,whereas eGFR was identified as a protective factor(P<0.05).ROC curve analysis demonstrated that the combined assessment of 24-hour urinary protein,eGFR,BAFF,and Bb yielded a higher AUC value for predicting poor prognosis in IMN patients than any single indicator alone(Z=4.145,3.908,4.308,3.864;P<0.05).Conclusions The serum levels of BAFF and Bb in patients with IMN are significantly elevated and positively correlated with the UACR.The combi-nation of 24-hour urinary protein excretion and eGFR demonstrates high predictive value for poor prognosis in these patients.These findings suggest that BAFF and Bb may serve as potential biomarkers for prognostic assessment in IMN,and the integrated measurement of multiple parameters could provide a more comprehensive clinical basis for disease management.
5.Significance of serum BAFF and complement lytic factor Bb expression in patients with idiopathic membra-nous nephropathy and their correlation with UACR
Liqin GUO ; Xiaojing HAN ; Huan WANG ; Guobin HE
The Journal of Practical Medicine 2025;41(21):3330-3337
Objective To investigate the clinical significance of serum B cell activating factor(BAFF)and complement lytic factor Bb in patients with idiopathic membranous nephropathy(IMN),as well as their correlation with the urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratio(UACR).Methods A total of 204 IMN patients were enrolled as the study group,and 100 healthy individuals undergoing physical examinations during the same period served as the control group.Serum levels of BAFF,Bb,and UACR were measured and compared between the two groups.Pearson correlation analysis was performed to assess the associations among serum BAFF,Bb,and UACR.The patients in the study group were followed up for 12 months and stratified into a favorable prognosis group and a poor prognosis group(defined as no remission)based on disease remission status.Demographic and clinical characteristics,as well as serum BAFF and Bb levels,were compared between the two outcome groups.Multivariate logistic regression analysis was conducted to identify independent predictors of poor prognosis in IMN patients.Receiver operating char-acteristic(ROC)curve analysis was employed to evaluate the predictive value of these indicators for poor prognosis.Results The levels of BAFF,Bb,and UACR in the research group were significantly higher than those in the con-trol group(P<0.05).Pearson correlation analysis revealed that both BAFF and Bb were positively correlated with UACR(r=0.716 and 0.543,respectively;P<0.05).After one year of follow-up,a total of 200 patients completed the study,among whom 46 experienced poor prognosis.Based on the follow-up outcomes,patients were categorized into a poor prognosis group(n=46)and a good prognosis group(n=154).The poor prognosis group exhibited significantly higher levels of serum creatinine,24-hour urinary protein,BAFF,and Bb,as well as lower eGFR values,compared to the good prognosis group(P<0.05).Multivariate regression analysis identified 24-hour urinary protein,BAFF,and Bb as independent risk factors for poor prognosis in patients with IMN,whereas eGFR was identified as a protective factor(P<0.05).ROC curve analysis demonstrated that the combined assessment of 24-hour urinary protein,eGFR,BAFF,and Bb yielded a higher AUC value for predicting poor prognosis in IMN patients than any single indicator alone(Z=4.145,3.908,4.308,3.864;P<0.05).Conclusions The serum levels of BAFF and Bb in patients with IMN are significantly elevated and positively correlated with the UACR.The combi-nation of 24-hour urinary protein excretion and eGFR demonstrates high predictive value for poor prognosis in these patients.These findings suggest that BAFF and Bb may serve as potential biomarkers for prognostic assessment in IMN,and the integrated measurement of multiple parameters could provide a more comprehensive clinical basis for disease management.
6.Guideline for Adult Weight Management in China
Weiqing WANG ; Qin WAN ; Jianhua MA ; Guang WANG ; Yufan WANG ; Guixia WANG ; Yongquan SHI ; Tingjun YE ; Xiaoguang SHI ; Jian KUANG ; Bo FENG ; Xiuyan FENG ; Guang NING ; Yiming MU ; Hongyu KUANG ; Xiaoping XING ; Chunli PIAO ; Xingbo CHENG ; Zhifeng CHENG ; Yufang BI ; Yan BI ; Wenshan LYU ; Dalong ZHU ; Cuiyan ZHU ; Wei ZHU ; Fei HUA ; Fei XIANG ; Shuang YAN ; Zilin SUN ; Yadong SUN ; Liqin SUN ; Luying SUN ; Li YAN ; Yanbing LI ; Hong LI ; Shu LI ; Ling LI ; Yiming LI ; Chenzhong LI ; Hua YANG ; Jinkui YANG ; Ling YANG ; Ying YANG ; Tao YANG ; Xiao YANG ; Xinhua XIAO ; Dan WU ; Jinsong KUANG ; Lanjie HE ; Wei GU ; Jie SHEN ; Yongfeng SONG ; Qiao ZHANG ; Hong ZHANG ; Yuwei ZHANG ; Junqing ZHANG ; Xianfeng ZHANG ; Miao ZHANG ; Yifei ZHANG ; Yingli LU ; Hong CHEN ; Li CHEN ; Bing CHEN ; Shihong CHEN ; Guiyan CHEN ; Haibing CHEN ; Lei CHEN ; Yanyan CHEN ; Genben CHEN ; Yikun ZHOU ; Xianghai ZHOU ; Qiang ZHOU ; Jiaqiang ZHOU ; Hongting ZHENG ; Zhongyan SHAN ; Jiajun ZHAO ; Dong ZHAO ; Ji HU ; Jiang HU ; Xinguo HOU ; Bimin SHI ; Tianpei HONG ; Mingxia YUAN ; Weibo XIA ; Xuejiang GU ; Yong XU ; Shuguang PANG ; Tianshu GAO ; Zuhua GAO ; Xiaohui GUO ; Hongyi CAO ; Mingfeng CAO ; Xiaopei CAO ; Jing MA ; Bin LU ; Zhen LIANG ; Jun LIANG ; Min LONG ; Yongde PENG ; Jin LU ; Hongyun LU ; Yan LU ; Chunping ZENG ; Binhong WEN ; Xueyong LOU ; Qingbo GUAN ; Lin LIAO ; Xin LIAO ; Ping XIONG ; Yaoming XUE
Chinese Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism 2025;41(11):891-907
Body weight abnormalities, including overweight, obesity, and underweight, have become a dual public health challenge in Chinese adults: overweight and obesity lead to a variety of chronic complications, while underweight increases the risks of malnutrition, sarcopenia, and organ dysfunction. To systematically address these issues, multidisciplinary experts in endocrinology, sports science, nutrition, and psychiatry from various regions have held multiple weight management seminars. Based on the latest epidemiological data and clinical evidence, they expanded the guideline to include assessment and intervention strategies for underweight, in addition to the core content of obesity management. This guideline outlines the etiological mechanisms, evaluation methods, and multidimensional management strategies for overweight and obesity, covering key areas such as diagnosis and assessment, medical nutrition therapy, exercise prescription, pharmacological intervention, and psychological support. It is intended to provide a scientific and standardized approach to weight management across the adult population, aiming to curb the rising prevalence of obesity, mitigate complications associated with abnormal body weight, and improve nutritional status and overall quality of life.
7.Peripheral blood levels of receptor-interacting protein kinase 3, neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin, and β2-microglobulin in elderly patients with chronic kidney disease and their predictive efficacy for acute kidney injury
Liqin GUO ; Haixia BU ; Huan WANG
Chinese Journal of Geriatrics 2024;43(11):1463-1467
Objective:To investigate the changes in peripheral blood levels of receptor interacting protein kinase 3(RIP3), neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin(NGAL), and β2-microglobulin(β2M)in older patients with chronic kidney disease, as well as their predictive efficacy for acute kidney injury.Methods:A retrospective analysis was conducted involving 119 older patients diagnosed with chronic kidney disease at Xinxiang Central Hospital from June 2022 to June 2024.The patients were categorized into an acute kidney injury(AKI)group(n=58)and a non-AKI group(n=61)based on the presence of acute kidney injury.General clinical data were compared between the two groups; levels of RIP3, NGAL, and β2M were quantified using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay(ELISA).Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify multifactorial factors influencing the occurrence of acute kidney injury in older patients with chronic kidney disease.Furthermore, receiver operating characteristic(ROC)curve analysis and the area under the curve(AUC)were utilized to assess the predictive value of RIP3, NGAL, and β2M for acute kidney injury in this patient population.Results:In comparison to the non-AKI group, patients in the AKI group exhibited significantly elevated levels of serum creatinine(Scr), RIP3, NGAL, and β2M( t=2.008, 7.729, 7.680, 7.447, all P<0.05).Logistic regression analysis identified RIP3( OR=1.760, 95% CI: 1.164-2.664), NGAL( OR=1.856, 95% CI: 1.215-2.834), and β2M( OR=1.454, 95% CI: 1.118-1.891)as risk factors for acute kidney injury in older patients with chronic kidney disease(all P<0.05).Furthermore, ROC curve analysis demonstrated that RIP3, NGAL, β2M, and their combination had sensitivities of 65.52%, 94.83%, 65.52%, and 87.93%, specificities of 91.80%, 70.49%, 93.44%, and 95.08%, and AUCs of 0.833, 0.901, 0.806, and 0.975, respectively.The predictive value of RIP3, NGAL, β2M, and their combination surpassed that of individual predictors( Z=4.143, 3.305, 4.218, all P<0.001). Conclusions:The combined assessment of peripheral blood RIP3, NGAL, and β2M demonstrates superior predictive efficacy for acute kidney injury in older patients with chronic kidney disease.
8.A nested-PCR for detection and identification of Brucella vaccine A19 strain
Guozhong TIAN ; Bo LIU ; Yuanyuan GUO ; Liqin SU ; Bike ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Endemiology 2023;42(3):196-199
Objective:A nested-PCR assay is developed to detect and identify the genomic DNA of Brucella vaccine A19 strain. Methods:The whole genomic sequences of Brucella vaccine A19 strain and other Brucella spp. strains were compared and analyzed. The primers were designed by nucleotide difference sites. The nested-PCR assay was established to detect and identify Brucella vaccine A19 strain. The genomic DNA of Brucella vaccine A19 strain was extracted and diluted. The diluted template DNA was tested for sensitivity of using nested-PCR assay. And the specificity of nested-PCR assay was tested for the genomic DNA of other Brucella spp. strains and non- Brucella spp. strains. Results:The minimum detection limit of the nested-PCR assay was 3.43 fg. The nested-PCR assay established for amplification of Brucella vaccine A19 strain showed 246 bp electrophoresis bands, while other Brucella spp. strains showed 314 bp electrophoresis bands, and non- Brucella spp. strains did not produce electrophoresis bands. Conclusions:The nested-PCR assay established has the characteristics of high sensitivity and specificity. It can be detected when there is one copy of Brucella vaccine A19 strain genomic DNA in the reaction system. This method is particularly suitable for the detection and identification of trace genomic DNA of Brucella vaccine A19 strain in sample.
9.Establishment and application of a quantitative real-time PCR detection system for Brucella S2 vaccine strain
Guozhong TIAN ; Bo LIU ; Yuanyuan GUO ; Liqin SU ; Bike ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Endemiology 2023;42(4):328-331
Objective:To establish a quantitative real-time PCR detection system for Brucella S2 vaccine strain. Methods:Based on the differences in the entire genome sequence between Brucella S2 vaccine strain and other reference strains of Brucella, primers and probes were designed to establish a quantitative real-time PCR detection system for Brucella S2 vaccine strain. The DNA of 22 reference strains of Brucella and 8 non- Brucella control strains were obtained from the National Institute for Infectious Disease Control and Prevention of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention. At the same time, environmental samples were obtained from the brucellosis vaccine manufacturers, and bacterial DNA from environmental samples was extracted using a blood/tissue genomic DNA extraction kit. The obtained DNA was pre-amplified by conventional PCR, and then subjected to quantitative real-time PCR secondary amplification (nested fluorescence quantitative PCR) using the amplified PCR product as a template. The specific fluorescence curve and corresponding number of cycles (Ct value) were observed, and the sensitivity was tested. Results:The quantitative real-time PCR detection system established did not detect specific fluorescence curves (without Ct values) for 21 reference strains of Brucella and 8 non- Brucella control strains, except for S2 vaccine strains. The established detection system had a minimum detection limit of 4.34 fg (genomic DNA) for detecting the DNA of Brucella S2 vaccine strain; DNA of Brucella S2 vaccine strain was detected in 3 of the 14 environmental samples collected. Conclusion:The quantitative real-time PCR detection system established can detect Brucella S2 vaccine strain in samples, with good sensitivity and specificity.
10.Expressions of peripheral blood lymphocytes in high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions of the cervix and early cervical cancer and their significances
Jia ZHANG ; Liqin LINGHU ; Ruixia ZHAO ; Lijun WEI ; Yongfeng GUO ; Jie WANG ; Na LU ; Haixia JIA
Cancer Research and Clinic 2023;35(7):505-509
Objective:To investigate the expression levels of peripheral blood lymphocytes in patients with high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL) of the cervix and early cervical cancer, and to analyze their correlation with the clinicopathological characteristics of cervical cancer.Methods:The clinical data of 65 patients with HSIL and 78 patients with early cervical cancer (2018 International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics stage ≤ stage Ⅱ A) treated in Shanxi Province Cancer Hospital from October 2020 to November 2021 were retrospectively analyzed, and 31 healthy people undergoing physical examination during the same period were treated as the healthy control group. The expressions of CD3 + T cells, CD4 + T cells, CD8 + T cells, NK cells, NK/T cells and other immune cells in fasting peripheral blood of the patients were detected by using flow cytometry. Results:The expression levels of CD3 + T cells, CD4 + T cells, CD4 +/CD8 + and NK cells were 71±8, 39±7, 1.5±0.5, 16±7, respectively in HSIL group, and 73±9, 41±9, 1.5±0.6, 16±9, respectively in early cervical cancer group, which were lower than those in the healthy control group (76±9, 45±10, 2.0±1.3, 20±7) (all P < 0.05). The expression levels of CD8 + T cells was 28±7, 29±8, respectively in HSIL group and early cervical cancer group, which were higher than those in the healthy control group (24±7) (all P < 0.05). The expression level of total B cells in early cervical cancer group was lower than that in healthy control group (10±4 vs.12±3, P < 0.05). The expression level of CD3 + T cells in peripheral blood of early cervical cancer patients with tumor diameter >4 cm and nerve/vascular invasion was 71±10 and 72±8, which was lower than that of patients with tumor diameter 2-4 cm, ≤2 cm and without nerve/vascular invasion (72±8, 75±8, 78±7); the expression level of CD8 + T cell was 32±8 and 35±4, which was higher than that of patients with tumor diameter 2-4 cm, ≤2 cm, and without nerve/vascular invasion (28±8, 28±7, 29±8) (all P < 0.05). The levels of CD3 + T cells and total B cells were negatively correlated with the tumor diameter (all P < 0.05), while the level of CD8 + T cells was positively correlated with tumor diameter ( P < 0.05); the levels of CD3 + T cells and NK cells were negatively correlated with nerve/vascular invasion (all P < 0.05). Conclusions:The immune function of the body starts to change in the early progression of cervical cancer, and is related to the tumor diameter and nerve/vascular invasion of cervical cancer.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail