1.Comparison of efficacy of different biological scaffolds for pulp regeneration therapy in immature permanent teeth:a Bayesian network meta-analysis
Kaigang WANG ; Dongsheng HAO ; Pei MA ; Shuo ZHOU ; Ruimin LI
Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research 2025;29(34):7447-7460
OBJECTIVE:There are many kinds of biological scaffolds used for pulp revascularization in clinical practice,and the difference of efficacy between different scaffolds is controversial.The efficacy of nine kinds of biological scaffolds in endodontic revascularization was evaluated by Bayesian network meta-analysis.METHODS:The computer was used to search the literature in CNKI,VIP,WanFang,China Biomedical Literature Service System,PubMed,Cochrane Library,Web of Science,Embase,and Scopus databases.Randomized controlled trials of different biological scaffolds for the treatment of pulp revascularization in young permanent teeth meeting inclusion criteria were collected from each database up to April 1,2024.Two researchers sifted through the literature,data collection,sorting and extraction were completed independently,and the quality of the included literature was assessed for risk of bias.A network meta-analysis was performed using BUGSnet1.1.1 package of R4.2.0 software.RESULTS:A total of 22 studies with 926 affected teeth and 9 different interventions were included in this study.The results of network meta-analysis showed that:(1)Clinical success rate(primary goal):platelet-rich fibrin was superior to blood clot[OR=1.45,95%CI(0.32,2.69)],and the top three ranking results were:concentrated growth factor(82.77%)>platelet-rich fibrin(75.38%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(62.39%).(2)Increased root length(secondary goal):There was no difference among the 7 biological scaffolds at 1-6 months of follow-up(P>0.05),the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(86.25%)>platelet-rich plasma(53.76%)>platelet-rich fibrin(51.11%).When followed up for>6 months and<12 months,concentrated growth factor was superior to blood clot[MD=9.59,95%CI(0.52,18.40)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(92.42%)>platelet-rich plasma(56.03%)>platelet-rich fibrin(55.76%).When followed up for more than 12 months,concentrated growth factor was superior to modified platelet-rich fibrin[MD=11.01,95%CI(0.02,22.72)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(86.95%)>platelet-rich fibrin(68.61%)>blood clot combined with collagen(52.5%).(3)Increased root wall thickness(secondary goal):at 1-6 months of follow-up,platelet-rich fibrin was superior to blood clot[MD=11.37,95%CI(4.74,17.71)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:platelet-rich fibrin(93.66%)>concentrated growth factor(63.11%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(50.48%).At>6 months and<12 months of follow-up,there was no difference among the 6 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:modified platelet-rich fibrin(73.63%)>platelet-rich fibrin(62.36%)>concentrated growth factor(56.25%).When followed up for more than 12 months,there was no difference among the 9 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),and the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:blood clot combined with collagen(81.9%)>platelet-rich plasma(62.67%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(59.49%).(4)Pulp vitality(third-level goal):there was no difference among the 6 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),and the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:blood clot combined with collagen(84.22%)>concentrated growth factor(67.71%)>platelet-rich fibrin(48.79%).CONCLUSION:Existing evidence shows that the clinical success rate of different scaffolds is higher in pulp revascularization,among which platelet-rich fibrin is better than blood clots.In terms of comprehensive comparison of root length and root wall thickness increase,concentrated growth factor performs best in the follow-up period of 1-6 months and>6 months and<12 months,while blood clot combined with collagen performs best after follow-up of more than 12 months;concentrated growth factor performs outstandingly in all levels of goals,and may be more conducive to the continued development of the tooth root than other scaffolds,and has great potential in pulp regeneration treatment.Limited by the quality and quantity of literature,the above conclusions still need to be verified by more high-quality studies.
2.Comparison of efficacy of different biological scaffolds for pulp regeneration therapy in immature permanent teeth:a Bayesian network meta-analysis
Kaigang WANG ; Dongsheng HAO ; Pei MA ; Shuo ZHOU ; Ruimin LI
Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research 2025;29(34):7447-7460
OBJECTIVE:There are many kinds of biological scaffolds used for pulp revascularization in clinical practice,and the difference of efficacy between different scaffolds is controversial.The efficacy of nine kinds of biological scaffolds in endodontic revascularization was evaluated by Bayesian network meta-analysis.METHODS:The computer was used to search the literature in CNKI,VIP,WanFang,China Biomedical Literature Service System,PubMed,Cochrane Library,Web of Science,Embase,and Scopus databases.Randomized controlled trials of different biological scaffolds for the treatment of pulp revascularization in young permanent teeth meeting inclusion criteria were collected from each database up to April 1,2024.Two researchers sifted through the literature,data collection,sorting and extraction were completed independently,and the quality of the included literature was assessed for risk of bias.A network meta-analysis was performed using BUGSnet1.1.1 package of R4.2.0 software.RESULTS:A total of 22 studies with 926 affected teeth and 9 different interventions were included in this study.The results of network meta-analysis showed that:(1)Clinical success rate(primary goal):platelet-rich fibrin was superior to blood clot[OR=1.45,95%CI(0.32,2.69)],and the top three ranking results were:concentrated growth factor(82.77%)>platelet-rich fibrin(75.38%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(62.39%).(2)Increased root length(secondary goal):There was no difference among the 7 biological scaffolds at 1-6 months of follow-up(P>0.05),the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(86.25%)>platelet-rich plasma(53.76%)>platelet-rich fibrin(51.11%).When followed up for>6 months and<12 months,concentrated growth factor was superior to blood clot[MD=9.59,95%CI(0.52,18.40)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(92.42%)>platelet-rich plasma(56.03%)>platelet-rich fibrin(55.76%).When followed up for more than 12 months,concentrated growth factor was superior to modified platelet-rich fibrin[MD=11.01,95%CI(0.02,22.72)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:concentrated growth factor(86.95%)>platelet-rich fibrin(68.61%)>blood clot combined with collagen(52.5%).(3)Increased root wall thickness(secondary goal):at 1-6 months of follow-up,platelet-rich fibrin was superior to blood clot[MD=11.37,95%CI(4.74,17.71)],the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:platelet-rich fibrin(93.66%)>concentrated growth factor(63.11%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(50.48%).At>6 months and<12 months of follow-up,there was no difference among the 6 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:modified platelet-rich fibrin(73.63%)>platelet-rich fibrin(62.36%)>concentrated growth factor(56.25%).When followed up for more than 12 months,there was no difference among the 9 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),and the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:blood clot combined with collagen(81.9%)>platelet-rich plasma(62.67%)>modified platelet-rich fibrin(59.49%).(4)Pulp vitality(third-level goal):there was no difference among the 6 biological scaffolds(P>0.05),and the top 3 ranking results of rank probability were:blood clot combined with collagen(84.22%)>concentrated growth factor(67.71%)>platelet-rich fibrin(48.79%).CONCLUSION:Existing evidence shows that the clinical success rate of different scaffolds is higher in pulp revascularization,among which platelet-rich fibrin is better than blood clots.In terms of comprehensive comparison of root length and root wall thickness increase,concentrated growth factor performs best in the follow-up period of 1-6 months and>6 months and<12 months,while blood clot combined with collagen performs best after follow-up of more than 12 months;concentrated growth factor performs outstandingly in all levels of goals,and may be more conducive to the continued development of the tooth root than other scaffolds,and has great potential in pulp regeneration treatment.Limited by the quality and quantity of literature,the above conclusions still need to be verified by more high-quality studies.
3. Instrumentation with 3D printed patient-specific guides versus conventional techniques in supramalleolar osteotomy for varus ankle osteoarthritis
Zhongmin SHI ; Xiaokang WANG ; Jiantao JIANG ; Zhendong LI ; Wenqi GU ; Guohua MEI ; Jianfeng XUE ; Jian ZOU ; Qi WANG ; Kaigang ZHANG ; Min ZHANG ; Yan SU
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma 2019;21(11):978-985
Objective:
To compare instrumentation with 3D-printed patient-specific guides versus conventional techniques in supramalleolar osteotomy for varus ankle osteoarthritis.
Methods:
A retrospective analysis was done of the 21 patients with varus ankle osteoarthritis who had been treated at Department of Orthopaedics, Shanghai JiaoTong University Affiliated Sixth People's Hospital from January 2017 to December 2018. They were divided into 2 groups by their treatment methods. In the 9 patients treated by instrumentation with 3D-printed patient-specific guides, there were 6 males and 3 females with an age of 54.6±8.6 years, 4 left and 5 right sides involved, and one case of Takakura stage 1, 3 cases of Takakura stage 2 and 5 cases of Takakura stage 3a. In the 12 patients treated by conventional techniques, there were 7 males and 5 females with an age of 53.0±6.5 years, 7 left and 5 right sides involved, and one case of Takakura stage 1, 5 cases of Takakura stage 2 and 6 cases of Takakura stage 3a. The 3D printed guide group and the conventional group were compared in terms of operation time, intraoperative blood loss and frequency of intraoperative fluoroscopy, tibial anterior surface angle (TAS), talar tilt angle (TT), and tibial lateral surface angle (TLS). The differences in TAS, TT and TLS between pre- and post-operation in the 3D printed guide group were also evaluated.
Results:
There were no significant differences in the preoperative general data between the 2 groups (
4.Inhibition of RPMI-8226 myeloma cell xenografted tumor angiogenesis by down-regulation of Notch1
Chunpu LI ; Jing WANG ; Yan LIU ; Ling WANG ; Banban LI ; Kaigang ZHANG ; Dongmei GUO
Journal of International Oncology 2015;42(9):661-665
Objective To investigate the effects of Notch1 siRNA on VEGF and angiogenesis of myeloma cell line RPMI-8226 in vitro and in vivo.Methods In vitro,Notch siRNA was transfected into RPMI-8226 cells,and then cell supernatant VEGF secretion was detected using ELISA method.Expression levels of Notch1 and VEGF proteins were assayed by Western blotting.RPMI-8226 cells were subcutaneously transplanted in NOD/SCID mice,and then the tumor mice were divided into three groups randomly:NS group (Notch1 siRNA-transfected group),CS group (Control siRNA-transfected group) and UN group (Untransfected group),and the changes of tumor volume were observed.Immunohistochemical staining was used to detect the changes in expression levels of Notch1,VEGF and CD34.Results Notch1 and VEGF proteins expressions of RPMI-8226 cells were significantly decreased by Notch1 siRNA.At 48 h and 72 h,VEGF secretion level in NS group was significantly different with CS group [(120 ± 25) ng/L ∶ (175 ± 15) ng/L,t =3.27,P < 0.05;(145 ± 24)ng/L ∶ (295 ± 17)ng/L,t =8.83,P<0.01].At 13 d,17 d and 21 d,tumor volume in NS group was significantly reduced,that was significantly different with CS group [(1 548 ± 218) mm3 ∶ (1 820 ± 64) mm3,t =2.68,P <0.05;(1 200 ±75)mm3 ∶ (2 180 ±84)mm3,t =19.46,P<0.01;(1 150 ±88)mm3 ∶ (2 250 ± 145)mm3,t =14.50,P <0.01].The expression levels of Notch1 and VEGF protein were decreased by Notch1 siRNA.The expression levels of Notchl and VEGF in NS group were different with CS group [(16.33 ±2.52)%∶ (75.33 ±2.52)%,t=28.71,P<0.01;(5.00±1.00)%∶29.67±2.08 %,t=18.50,P < 0.01].Notch1 siRNA reduced the number of transplanted tumor neovascularization in NS group.Microvascular density in NS group was significantly less than that in CS group [(14.67 ± 2.52) ∶ (30.00 ± 5.00),t =4.74,P < 0.01].Conclusion In vitro,Notch siRNA reduces human myeloma cell RPMI-8226 cell supernatant VEGF secretion.In vivo,Notch siRNA can reduce tumor volume and the number of new blood vessels in transplanted-multiple myeloma mice.Thus,Notchl is an effective molecular target for anti-angiogenesis in myeloma.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail