1.Evaluation of the quality of Jingangteng capsules based on UPLC fingerprinting combined with multi-component content determination
Li SHEN ; Yue SHEN ; Yuying YANG ; Dandan ZHANG ; Yuxi WU ; Xuxiang ZHOU ; Jingyu YANG ; Peng HU ; Lei WANG ; Heming WU ; Dan LIU ; Xiaochuan YE
China Pharmacy 2026;37(10):1290-1294
OBJECTIVE To establish the UPLC fingerprint and the method for multi-component content determination in Jingangteng capsules, and to evaluate its quality by combining chemical pattern recognition analysis. METHODS An UPLC method was established. Separation was performed on a Zorbax SB-C 18 Rapid Resolution HD column, with acetonitrile-0.1% formic acid as the mobile phase for gradient elution.Using the Similarity Evaluation System for Chromatographic Fingerprints of Traditional Chinese Medicines (2012 edition), UPLC fi ngerprints were established for 10 batches of Jingangteng capsules, and similarity was evaluated. SPSS 22.0 and SIMCA 14.1 software were used to perform hierarchial-cluster analysis and orthogonal partial least squares discriminant analysis (OPLS-DA), respectively. The same UPLC method was employed to determine the contents of chlorogenic acid, 3,5-dihydroxy-2-methylbenzoic acid-3- O -glucoside (M1), caffeic acid, astilbin, oxyresveratrol, quercitrin and resveratrol in the 10 batches of samples. RESULTS A total of 17 common peaks were identified in UPLC fingerprints of the 10 batches of samples, of which 7 were identified as chlorogenic acid, M1, caffeic acid, astilbin, oxyresveratrol, quercitrin, and resveratrol. The similarities of 10 batches of samples ranged from 0.820 to 0.985. The results of hierarchial-cluster analysis showed that 10 batches of samples were grouped into four categories: S1-S4 formed one group, S5 and S6 formed another, S7, S8 and S10 formed a third, and S9 formed a fourth, consistent with the OPLS-DA results; the variable importance projection values for peaks 7, 10, 2, 16 (resveratrol), 13 (oxyresveratrol), 11, 6 (caffeic acid), 5 (M1) and 15 (quercitrin) were >1. Quantitative analysis results showed that the contents of chlorogenic acid, M1, caffeic acid, astilbin, oxyresveratrol, quercitrin, and resveratrol were 1.650 8-4.213 7, 0.636 2-2.161 7, 0.031 0-0.086 5, 0.239 1-1.069 3, 0.211 9-1.104 0, 0.488 8-2.399 2, and 0.164 0-0.699 8 mg/g, respectively. CONCLUSIONS UPLC fingerprint and content determination methods established in this study are simple to operate, accurate, reliable and reproducible; when combined with chemical pattern recognition analysis, they can be used to evaluate the quality of Jingangteng capsules. Nine components, such as resveratrol, oxyresveratrol, caffeic acid, M1 and quercitrin, may serve as markers of quality variation.
2.Hyperlipidemia Animal Models Based on Disease-syndrome Clinical Characteristics of Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine
Furong XU ; Liran XU ; Yujie LI ; Xiaohan SHEN ; Qingquan MENG ; Cancan SHAO ; Bowen LI ; Jingyu YUE
Chinese Journal of Experimental Traditional Medical Formulae 2026;32(17):248-255
ObjectiveHyperlipidemia (HLP) is a chronic metabolic disease characterized by abnormal lipid metabolism and is one of the important risk factors for the occurrence of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases. Its incidence has increased year by year, showing a trend toward younger onset. The overall prevalence of HLP among adults in China is as high as 40.40%. Although existing animal models provide important tools for research on the mechanisms of HLP, they generally show insufficient clinical concordance and lack the combined disease-syndrome characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and Western medicine. This article systematically reviews the research progress of HLP animal models, integrates the clinicopathological characteristics of TCM and Western medicine, and proposes new model construction strategies, aiming to provide an experimental basis for accurately analyzing the pathogenesis of HLP and developing integrated TCM-Western medicine therapies. MethodsBased on literature included in PubMed, CNKI, and Wanfang databases over the past 30 years, the construction methods and evaluation systems of HLP animal models were systematically retrieved and summarized. The concordance of existing animal models was calculated according to the new animal model evaluation method proposed by Professor MIAO Mingsan. ResultsAmong existing Western medicine modeling approaches, genetically modified models showed the highest concordance (72%), followed by dietary induction (66%) and chemical drug induction (60%). The dietary induction method is the most widely used in practice because of its simple operation and mature technology. Existing TCM modeling approaches are classified into three types, i.e., spleen deficiency type, phlegm syndrome type, and liver-kidney yin deficiency type. Among them, the phlegm syndrome type shows a high degree of concordance. However, all three types have the problem of non-objective evaluation indicators and insufficient application of tongue and pulse assessment. ConclusionThe construction of existing HLP disease-syndrome combined animal models is still mainly based on Western medicine modeling methods and lacks adequate reflection of TCM syndromes. In the future, HLP animal models that conform to the clinical disease-syndrome characteristics of both TCM and Western medicine may be constructed through multifactor composite modeling strategies, intelligent tongue image analysis via robot learning, objective pulse detection, the establishment of objective evaluation systems for TCM syndromes through big data computing, and the application of cutting-edge technologies.
4.Impact of repeated sevoflurane anesthesia on hippocampal dendritic spine development in neonatal mice and the mechanism of microtubule polyglutamylation mediated by TTLL6
Yang YU ; Yue ZHAO ; Jingyu FENG ; Yue YANG ; Yanan LI ; Jiafeng YU ; Yonghao YU
Chinese Journal of Behavioral Medicine and Brain Science 2025;34(3):193-200
Objective:To evaluate the role of tubulin tyrosin ligase like-6 (TTLL6)-mediated microtubule polyglutamylation and Spastin(a microtubule cleaving protein)-induced excessive microtubule cleavage in the developmental impairment of dendritic spines in neonatal mice following repeated sevoflurane anesthesia, by utilizing TTLL6 conditional knockout mice.Methods:Fifty SPF female TTLL6 brain tissue-specific knockout (TTLL6 CKO: Camk2-Cre + ; TTLL6 f/f) and fifty control (TTLL6 CON: TTLL6 f/f) mice with C57BL/6J background, aged 6 days old were selected.TTLL6 CKO mice were divided into TTLL6 CON control group and TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group, and TTLL6 CKO mice were divided into TTLL6 CKO control group and TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group, with 25 mice in each group by random block method.Mice in the sevoflurane groups were exposed to 3% sevoflurane with 60% O 2 for 2 hours daily on postnatal days 6, 8, and 10.The mice in control groups received only 60% O 2 under the same condition.The polyGlu-Tubulin and postsynaptic density 95(PSD95) protein expression were detected using Western blot. The expressions of TTLL6, Spastin, and α-Tubulin were assessed via immunofluorescence.Golgi staining and electron microscopy were employed to observe the density of hippocampal dendritic spines and synaptic conditions. The Morris water maze test was used to evaluate spatial memory capabilities. Statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 8.0 software. Results:(1) Behavioral results showed significant time and group interactions among the four groups in terms of latency to find the platform ( F=8.22, P<0.001).Mice in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had a significantly longer escape latency on days 3-7 compared with the TTLL6 CON control group (all P<0.05), while there was no significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group (all P>0.05). The number of platform crossings differed significantly among the four groups ( H=11.95, P=0.007).The TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had significantly fewer crossing times than the TTLL6 CON control group ( P<0.05), but no significant difference was observed between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). (2) Golgi staining and electron microscopy results revealed significant differences in dendritic spine density and synapse number among the four groups( F=29.00, 41.94, both P<0.001). The dendritic spine density ((5.83±0.40)/10 μm) and the number of synapses ((3.67±0.58)/10 μm) in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group were both significantly lower than those in the TTLL6 CON control group ((12.87±1.70)/10 μm, (9.33±0.57)/10 μm)(both P<0.05). In contrast, there was no statistically significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and TTLL6 CKO control group (both P>0.05). (3) Immunofluorescence results showed significant differences in the percentage of TTLL6 and Spastin and α-Tubulin co-expressed positive cells in the CA3 region of the hippocampus among the four groups of mice ( F=215.20, 26.08, both P<0.001). The percentage of TTLL6 and Spastin and α-Tubulin co-expressed positive cells in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group ((16.75±1.81) %, (47.98±8.42) %) were significantly higher than those in the TTLL6 CON control group ((2.44±0.58) %, (20.07±4.54) %)(both P<0.05), while there was no statistically significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). (4) Western blot results indicated significant differences in the expression of polyGlu-Tubulin and PSD95 proteins in the hippocampal tissue among the four groups of mice ( F=19.66, 8.57, both P<0.001). The TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had higher polyGlu-Tubulin expression (0.86±0.19) and lower PSD95 expression (0.61±0.13) compared to the TTLL6 CON control group (0.51±0.11, 1.01±0.07) (both P<0.05).However, there was no significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). Conclusion:The mechanism underlying long-term cognitive impairment in developing brain of neonatal mice caused by repeated sevoflurane anesthesia may relate to the upregulation of TTLL6-induced microtubule polyglutamylation and accelerated Spastin-mediated microtubule severing, which ultimately leads to abnormal dendritic spine development.
5.Accuracy and quality of answer reasoning of Chinese large language model in Chinese middle level professional qualification examination of radiology
Jingyu ZHONG ; Yue XING ; Yangfan HU ; Qinghua MIN ; Caisong ZHU ; Dandan SHI ; Xiaoyu FAN ; Jingshen CHU ; Huan ZHANG ; Weiwu YAO
Chinese Journal of Medical Education Research 2025;24(2):145-149
Objective:To compare the accuracy of a Chinese large language model (LLM) and radiologists in Chinese middle level professional qualification examination of radiology, and evaluate the quality of answer reasoning provided by the Chinese LLM.Methods:In this study, 100 high-quality questions were selected using stratified random sampling to form a test set. We asked the ERNIE Bot by dialogues on the website to provide the correct answers and answer reasoning for these questions. These questions were also answered by 15 radiologists with different levels of experience. The accuracy of Chinese LLM and that of radiologists were compared. Two radiologists evaluated the quality of answer reasoning using a 5-point semi-quantitative scale.Results:The accuracy of ERNIE Bot was 60.00%, which was lower than the median (interquartile) accuracy of 67.00% (64.00%, 73.00%) for radiologists, and the difference was statistically significant ( W=2.47, P=0.013). The word count of the reasoning provided by Ernie Bot was (196.44±99.25) words, with no significant difference in word count between correct and incorrect answer reasoning, which were (211.03±107.53) words and (174.55±81.84) words, respectively ( t=1.82, P=0.072). Among the correct answers, the quality of reasoning was scored as follows: 1 point for 3 questions, 2 points for 9 questions, 3 points for 12 questions, and 4 points for 36 questions. No reasoning received a score of 5. Conclusions:Chinese LLM demonstrates a certain level of medical knowledge and clinical reasoning ability, which can assist clinical teachers in educational activities. However, it is not yet able to independently tutor residents and lacks the ability of invitational and heuristic teaching.
6.An investigation of the current status of Chinese-foreign cooperative education programs for medical majors
Jingyu ZHONG ; Yue XING ; Qinghua MIN ; Zhengguang XIAO ; Caisong ZHU ; Dandan SHI ; Xiaoyu FAN ; Jingshen CHU ; Huan ZHANG ; Yi JIANG ; Weiwu YAO
Chinese Journal of Medical Education Research 2025;24(5):577-582
Objective:To investigate the current status of Chinese-foreign cooperative education programs for medical majors, and to discuss the potential problems and development trends of this field.Methods:Related data were collected from the information platform of Chinese-Foreign Cooperation in Running Schools by Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China, and the characteristics of Chinese-foreign cooperative education programs for medical majors were extracted for analysis. Categorical data were expressed as frequency (percentage), and continuous data were expressed as mean±standard deviation.Results:A total of 83 Chinese-foreign cooperative education programs for medical majors were included in the study, accounting for only 3.45% (83/2 406) of all programs. Chinese partners in these cooperative programs were mainly from East China (41 programs, 49.40%), while foreign partners were mainly from Europe (39 programs, 46.99%). The mean duration of these programs was (3.61±0.88) years, with an enrollment of (87.08±35.52) students. Most of the students were included in National General Higher Education Enrollment Plan (79 programs, 95.18%), and the main majors included nursing (39 programs, 46.99%), medical technology (19 programs, 22.89%), and clinical medicine (11 programs, 13.25%), with the main enrollment level of junior college (45 programs, 54.22%). Chinese partners in the cooperative programs mainly issued academic certificate (45 programs, 54.22%) or academic certificate plus degree certificate (36 programs, 43.37%), while most foreign partners did not issue such certificates (44 programs, 53.01%).Conclusions:There are several problems in Chinese-foreign cooperative education programs for medical majors, such as a limited number of programs, a significant regional difference, an imbalanced distribution of specialties, a low level of education, and inconsistency in issuance of certificates, which still requires further improvement and standardization. However, there are also high-level and high-quality programs for reference.
7.Application of wearable devices in monitoring acute exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in primary care
Mi YAO ; Yonghao LU ; Guanning JING ; Qiaoli SU ; Jiapei XU ; Yujing SU ; Jiao XU ; Yue CHEN ; Jingyi YE ; Jingyu HAO ; Yadong HUANG ; Chunhua CHI
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2025;24(12):1503-1509
Objective:To explore the correlation between abnormal vital signs (e.g., heart rate, oxygen saturation, and body temperature) and acute exacerbations in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), as well as to evaluate the clinical value of continuous monitoring via wearable devices for the early warning and intervention.Methods:A multicenter cross-sectional study enrolled 335 patients with stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) from 12 community health centers in Beijing and Chengdu between June 2023 and May 2024. General demographic and clinical data were collected, and each participant underwent continuous monitoring of resting heart rate, oxygen saturation, and body temperature using wearable devices for 21 days. Based on whether participants had experienced acute exacerbations requiring outpatient, emergency, or inpatient treatment within the previous year, they were categorized into the acute exacerbation group and the non-exacerbation group. Differences in physiological parameters between the acute exacerbation group and non-exacerbation group were analyzed, and contributing factors were assessed using logistic regression analysis.Results:A total of 335 patients with stable COPD were enrolled, including 252 cases (75.22%) in the acute exacerbation group and 83 cases (24.78%) in the non-acute exacerbation group. There were no statistically significant differences in age, sex distribution, comorbidities, or baseline lung function between the two groups (all P>0.05). Compared with the non-acute exacerbation group, patients in the acute exacerbation group had a faster resting heart rate((76.01 ± 7.78) beats/min vs. (72.72 ± 7.35) beats/min, t=3.126, P=0.002), a higher proportion of patients with decreased oxygen saturation (1.75% (0.97%, 3.03%) vs. 0.86% (0.44%, 1.65%), Z=11.086, P=0.001), and a higher proportion of patients with elevated body temperature (0.60% (0.39%, 1.03%) vs. 0.31% (0.17%, 0.54%), Z=7.314, P=0.007). Logistic regression analysis showed that advanced age ( OR=1.051, 95% CI: 1.023-1.080), increased heart rate ( OR=1.055, 95% CI:1.013-1.098), decreased oxygen saturation ( OR=1.197, 95% CI:1.023-1.400), and elevated body temperature ( OR=1.777, 95% CI:1.148-2.752) were positively associated factors for acute exacerbation of COPD. Conclusions:Abnormalities in physiological indicators such as heart rate, oxygen saturation, and body temperature are associated with acute exacerbations in COPD patients. Continuous monitoring using wearable devices may provide a new method for early warning and timely intervention in COPD exacerbations.
8.Research status and progress of third-line treatment for metastatic colorectal cancer
Jingyu LIU ; Tong YIN ; Yue WU ; Xiaobo PENG ; Xianbao ZHAN
China Oncology 2025;35(11):1056-1066
Third-line treatment for metastatic colorectal cancer(mCRC)refers to subsequent therapeutic interventions following the failure or intolerance of first-and second-line treatments.This represents a critical challenge in clinical practice and a core focus of translational medicine research in recent years.With advancements in molecular typing technologies and the emergence of novel therapies,the third-line treatment strategy has evolved from traditional chemotherapy toward precision targeting and immunotherapy.A comprehensive literature search was conducted across PubMed,ClinicalTrials.gov database and American Society of Clinical Oncology(ASCO),European Society for Medical Oncology(ESMO)conference abstracts.Phase Ⅲ randomized controlled trials,phase Ⅰ/Ⅱ frontier clinical studies,and authoritative reviews were included,with an emphasis on data related to survival benefits,drug resistance mechanisms,and biomarkers.This review provided an in-depth analysis of significant progress in third-line treatment strategies for mCRC,encompassing standard therapies[regorafenib,fruquintinib,trifluridine/tipiracil,anti-epidermal growth factor receptor(EGFR)rechallenge therapy],targeted therapies(e.g.,BRAF V600E inhibitors,ERBB2 amplification inhibitors,KRAS G12C inhibitors)and immunotherapies[microsatellite instability-high(MSI-H)/deficient mismatch repair(dMMR),microsatellite stable(MSS)/proficient mismatch repair(pMMR)and target-immune combination therapies].Notable breakthroughs have been achieved in targeted therapies.Anti-EGFR rechallenge therapy extended the median overall survival(OS)to 17.3 months in RAS/BRAF wild-type patients identified through dynamic circulating tumor DNA(ctDNA)monitoring.However,drug resistance remains complex,with high secondary mutation rates necessitating further optimization of dynamic monitoring systems.For BRAF V600E mutations,triple therapy(encorafenib+binimetinib+cetuximab)demonstrated a median OS of 9.3 months[hazard ratio(HR)=0.52],surpassing conventional treatments.The combination of KRAS G12C inhibitor adagrasib with cetuximab achieved an objective response rate(ORR)of 34%and a median OS of 15.9 months,though tumor resistance continued to pose challenges.In the realm of immunotherapy,dual immunotherapy(nivolumab+ipilimumab)yielded a 4-year OS rate of 71%in MSI-H/dMMR patients.For MSS patients,immune-targeted combination strategies(e.g.,cabozantinib+atezolizumab)increased the ORR to 27.6%.Emerging therapies include artificial intelligence platforms for precision medicine,gut microbiota-based biomarkers and fecal microbiota transplantation,as well as advancements in chimeric antigen receptor-T(CAR-T)cell therapy.By summarizing the current status and progress of third-line treatment for mCRC,this review aims to inform clinical decision-making and guide future research directions.
9.Impact of repeated sevoflurane anesthesia on hippocampal dendritic spine development in neonatal mice and the mechanism of microtubule polyglutamylation mediated by TTLL6
Yang YU ; Yue ZHAO ; Jingyu FENG ; Yue YANG ; Yanan LI ; Jiafeng YU ; Yonghao YU
Chinese Journal of Behavioral Medicine and Brain Science 2025;34(3):193-200
Objective:To evaluate the role of tubulin tyrosin ligase like-6 (TTLL6)-mediated microtubule polyglutamylation and Spastin(a microtubule cleaving protein)-induced excessive microtubule cleavage in the developmental impairment of dendritic spines in neonatal mice following repeated sevoflurane anesthesia, by utilizing TTLL6 conditional knockout mice.Methods:Fifty SPF female TTLL6 brain tissue-specific knockout (TTLL6 CKO: Camk2-Cre + ; TTLL6 f/f) and fifty control (TTLL6 CON: TTLL6 f/f) mice with C57BL/6J background, aged 6 days old were selected.TTLL6 CKO mice were divided into TTLL6 CON control group and TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group, and TTLL6 CKO mice were divided into TTLL6 CKO control group and TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group, with 25 mice in each group by random block method.Mice in the sevoflurane groups were exposed to 3% sevoflurane with 60% O 2 for 2 hours daily on postnatal days 6, 8, and 10.The mice in control groups received only 60% O 2 under the same condition.The polyGlu-Tubulin and postsynaptic density 95(PSD95) protein expression were detected using Western blot. The expressions of TTLL6, Spastin, and α-Tubulin were assessed via immunofluorescence.Golgi staining and electron microscopy were employed to observe the density of hippocampal dendritic spines and synaptic conditions. The Morris water maze test was used to evaluate spatial memory capabilities. Statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 8.0 software. Results:(1) Behavioral results showed significant time and group interactions among the four groups in terms of latency to find the platform ( F=8.22, P<0.001).Mice in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had a significantly longer escape latency on days 3-7 compared with the TTLL6 CON control group (all P<0.05), while there was no significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group (all P>0.05). The number of platform crossings differed significantly among the four groups ( H=11.95, P=0.007).The TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had significantly fewer crossing times than the TTLL6 CON control group ( P<0.05), but no significant difference was observed between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). (2) Golgi staining and electron microscopy results revealed significant differences in dendritic spine density and synapse number among the four groups( F=29.00, 41.94, both P<0.001). The dendritic spine density ((5.83±0.40)/10 μm) and the number of synapses ((3.67±0.58)/10 μm) in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group were both significantly lower than those in the TTLL6 CON control group ((12.87±1.70)/10 μm, (9.33±0.57)/10 μm)(both P<0.05). In contrast, there was no statistically significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and TTLL6 CKO control group (both P>0.05). (3) Immunofluorescence results showed significant differences in the percentage of TTLL6 and Spastin and α-Tubulin co-expressed positive cells in the CA3 region of the hippocampus among the four groups of mice ( F=215.20, 26.08, both P<0.001). The percentage of TTLL6 and Spastin and α-Tubulin co-expressed positive cells in the TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group ((16.75±1.81) %, (47.98±8.42) %) were significantly higher than those in the TTLL6 CON control group ((2.44±0.58) %, (20.07±4.54) %)(both P<0.05), while there was no statistically significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). (4) Western blot results indicated significant differences in the expression of polyGlu-Tubulin and PSD95 proteins in the hippocampal tissue among the four groups of mice ( F=19.66, 8.57, both P<0.001). The TTLL6 CON sevoflurane group had higher polyGlu-Tubulin expression (0.86±0.19) and lower PSD95 expression (0.61±0.13) compared to the TTLL6 CON control group (0.51±0.11, 1.01±0.07) (both P<0.05).However, there was no significant difference between the TTLL6 CKO sevoflurane group and the TTLL6 CKO control group ( P>0.05). Conclusion:The mechanism underlying long-term cognitive impairment in developing brain of neonatal mice caused by repeated sevoflurane anesthesia may relate to the upregulation of TTLL6-induced microtubule polyglutamylation and accelerated Spastin-mediated microtubule severing, which ultimately leads to abnormal dendritic spine development.
10.Research on the development of entrustable professional activity indicators for residents in China: a systematic review
Jingyu ZHONG ; Yue XING ; Liangjing LÜ ; Qinghua MIN ; Zhengguang XIAO ; Caisong ZHU ; Dandan SHI ; Xiaoyu FAN ; Jingshen CHU ; Huan ZHANG ; Yi JIANG ; Weiwu YAO
Chinese Journal of Medical Education Research 2025;24(6):728-735
Objective:To systematically evaluate the current status of research on the development of indicators for entrustable professional activities (EPAs) of residents in China.Methods:We searched the China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang Data, Airiti Library, PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science databases for literature on the development of EPA indicators for residents in China published between January 1, 2005 and February 28, 2025. Two researchers independently screened the literature and extracted data, followed by descriptive analysis. The quality of the studies was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal tool for expert opinion. Quantitative data were presented as medians (ranges) and qualitative data were presented as frequencies (percentages).Results:A total of eight articles were included, in which two general EPA indicator systems and six specialty-specific EPA indicator systems were developed for residents. The overall quality of the research was high, with the main shortcomings related to the methods used in the process of constructing the consensus indicators. The number of experts recruited ranged from 22 to 45, with 100.00% response rate, high authority coefficients (0.820-0.914), and high coordination coefficients (0.157-0.741). Most of the studies used literature reviews as one source for the indicator pool (8 studies, 100.00%), employed the Delphi method to reach consensus (6 studies, 75.00%), and provided inclusion criteria for the indicators (7 studies, 87.50%). However, only one study (12.50%) explored the practical application of the developed indicators, and none of the studies set indicator weights or conducted quality assessments. The number of EPA indicators developed ranged from 10 to 38 per study. The reporting of EPA indicators was included in most studies regarding titles (8 studies, 100.00%) and the expected levels of entrustment at various stages of training (6 studies, 75.00%), but the reporting on other aspects was lacking. Among the specialty-specific EPA indicators, 38.39% overlapped with the general EPAs indicators.Conclusions:The research on the development of EPA indicators for residents in China is still in its early stages, and there is room for improvement in methodological quality and reporting coverage. There is partial overlap between specialty-specific and general EPA indicators, failing to fully reflect the unique characteristics of different specialties.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail