1.A call for re-visioning participation: Realist review of participation in community-based rehabilitation for the inclusion of children with disabilities in low-income and low-middle-income countries.
Karen S. SAGUN ; Maria Eliza R. AGUILA
Acta Medica Philippina 2025;59(14):106-117
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE
Community-based rehabilitation (CBR) represents a multifaceted social intervention designed to tackle issues related to access, equity, and service quality. Within the framework of CBR, participation stands as a pivotal principle, albeit one that frequently goes unnoticed, particularly concerning children with disabilities. Consequently, this realist synthesis embarks on an exploration of the present landscape, participation mechanisms, and resulting outcomes within CBR initiatives tailored for children with disabilities in low and low-middle-income countries.
METHODSThe realist approach is utilized to explain the causal mechanisms and explore the context, mechanism, and outcome of participation in CBR programs. A systematic search was conducted across ten databases up to April 2021. Studies were included if they involved children with disabilities aged 17 years and below, were implemented in World Bank-classified low-income or low-middle-income countries, discussed implementation mechanisms and community participation, and described outcomes. No language restrictions or publication type limitations were applied. The search process employed double screening of title, abstract, and full-text levels, followed by a snowballing technique. Quality assessment followed the RAMESES standards for realist reviews. Data extraction and analysis yielded context-mechanism-outcome configurations.
RESULTSThirteen articles were included in the synthesis, from which three context-mechanism-outcome configurations were identified: (1) family-facilitated intervention through training in the immediate environment of children with disabilities leads to knowledge translation of caregivers, (2) inaccessible healthcare services require establishing a referral system and augmenting human resource to ensure the system’s capacity to accommodate the magnified need, and (3) established collaboration of researcher, professionals, and community with stakeholder involvement in the CBR management leads to program adoption and documented effectiveness. Both training and establishing referral systems as implementation mechanisms pose sustainability challenges due to dependency on funding. Overall, participation as a form of agency is more often an implied concept. Training is a common mechanism of implementation, where women play a critical role as proxies of children with disabilities, being their caregivers and advocates. Positive and negative outcomes focus on the condition of children with disabilities and the trainees’ knowledge and awareness.
CONCLUSIONA critical analysis of children's and community's participation in the context, mechanism, and outcome unravels the non-participation of children with disabilities and tokenism of the community stakeholders in the CBR programs. Maximizing the contribution of children with disabilities and community stakeholders is called for, aligned with the ladder of participation, toward their democratic participation. Study limitations include the paucity of published CBR programs reporting participation mechanisms in low and low-middle-income countries and the exclusion of studies from economically disadvantaged communities in high-income countries.
Human ; Community Participation ; Developing Countries ; Disabled Children ; Community Health Services
2.A web-based survey on the telerehabilitation knowledge, attitude, and practice of physical therapists in a developing country during the COVID-19 pandemic: An analytical cross-sectional study
Ken Erbvin R. Sosa ; Carl Froilan D. Leochico ; Christian Rey D. Rimando
Acta Medica Philippina 2024;58(2):54-62
Background and Objective:
Pre-pandemic, various healthcare settings were not used to seeing patients virtually. The unprecedented need to adopt virtual care during the COVID-19 pandemic may have caught physical therapists (PTs) unready for it. This study aimed to determine the telerehabilitation knowledge, attitude, and practice of PTs in the Philippines during the COVID-19 pandemic and determine the association between demographic and study outcome variables.
Methods:
This is an analytical cross-sectional study among members of the Philippine Physical Therapy Association, Inc. (PPTA) practicing in the Philippines. Purposive sampling (total enumeration) was employed. All PPTA members were invited to the study through e-mail and official social media group chats. A self-administered questionnaire was used to obtain data on telerehabilitation knowledge (through test questions on various theoretical aspects), attitude, and practice.
Results:
The questionnaire items had a content validity index of >0.80. The study yielded a 40% response rate.
Most respondents were practicing clinicians in urban-based, private rehabilitation centers. Approximately half had average telerehabilitation knowledge, while the majority had agreeable telerehabilitation attitudes across different constructs. Among the respondents, 15.9% used telerehabilitation pre-pandemic, while 64.8% used it during the pandemic. Hybrid (synchronous and asynchronous) telerehabilitation sessions usually lasted one hour per patient, mostly using Facebook Messenger.
Conclusion
Telerehabilitation was not widely practiced locally pre-pandemic, which may explain their average
telerehabilitation knowledge. The positive telerehabilitation attitudes may represent a small group of PTs favoring telerehabilitation, while information from the larger population remains unknown. Early adopters of telerehabilitation may help introduce virtual care to colleagues and guide them in developing relevant knowledge and skills amid and beyond the enduring COVID-19 crisis.
COVID-19
;
Developing Countries
;
Physical Therapy Modalities
;
Telerehabilitation
;
Telemedicine
3.Caregivers’ perceptions and willingness to utilize telerehabilitation for outpatient consultation and therapy for pediatric patients in a COVID-referral center in a developing country: A cross-sectional study
Julie Ann T. Dulawan ; Sharon D. Ignacio ; Cynthia D. Ang-Muñ ; oz ; Frances Ann B. Carlos ; Carl Froilan D. Leochico
Acta Medica Philippina 2024;58(20):20-28
BACKGROUND
During the COVID-19 pandemic, social isolation and quarantine measures set to control the spread of the infection paved for the increased utilization of virtual methods of consultation and follow-up. Telerehabilitation allows access to rehabilitation services despite distance and makes possible the continuation of rehabilitation services despite the lack of face-to-face interaction. This is difficult for pediatric patients who are dependent on their caregivers for understanding and making decisions regarding their health. Loss of continuity of rehabilitation services led to poorer outcomes in children with disabilities. Although advantageous for them, pediatric patients may not benefit from telerehabilitation if caregivers have negative perceptions of the process and are unwilling to utilize the service.
OBJECTIVESThis study determined caregivers’ perceptions and willingness to participate in telerehabilitation as a method of outpatient follow-up for pediatric patients admitted to a COVID-referral center in a developing country.
METHODSThe study utilized a descriptive cross-sectional design. Respondents were adults (≥19 years old) caring for pediatric patients admitted at non-COVID wards of the Philippine General Hospital and who were referred for rehabilitation services. A survey tool adapted from a previous study on willingness to utilize telemedicine among caregivers of pediatric patients was translated into the Filipino language and used in the study. A dataset from Excel was imported in STATA 16 (StataCorp, Texas, USA) and was exhaustively checked for completeness, accuracy, and consistency before analysis. The association between patient characteristics and willingness to utilize telerehabilitation for any app was determined using Pearson’s chi-squared test or Fisher’s exact test, as appropriate. The latter was used when more than 20% of the cells had an expected value of less than or equal to five. A P value of less than 0.05 was considered significant for all tests.
RESULTSOf 123 respondents, 92 (75%) reported willingness to utilize telerehabilitation for outpatient consultation and therapy using video calls or a customized telerehabilitation app when available. Among 31 (25%) respondents who were not willing or unsure of participation, the main reasons identified were preference for face-to-face, lack of financial resources/load, poor connectivity, and doubt about the effectiveness of telerehabilitation.Patients with younger age (Fisher’s exact test, P=0.023), low usage of video call service (Fisher’s exact test, P=0.020), and lack of available devices (Fisher’s exact test, P=0.015) significantly reduced willingness to utilize telerehabilitation. Caregiver age, sex, educational attainment, estimated monthly income, number of devices used, speed of internet connectivity, and technological behaviors did not show statistical significance in association with willingness to participate in telerehabilitation.Most caregivers recognized the usefulness of a service allowing transmission of health data to and from the hospital, consultation with a doctor in case of an emergency, sending of reminders for medical visits and therapy, and provision of a list of home exercises and nutritional recommendations. Telerehabilitation was perceived advantageous, but concerns regarding privacy, trust, lack of human contact, and technological difficulty were also present.
CONCLUSIONWith high levels of willingness among caregivers, telerehabilitation is a viable method of providing rehabilitation services for the continuation of management after inpatient admission among pediatric patients. Limitations in its utilization include technological issues including the lack of devices, low level of service use, and slow internet connectivity. Although well perceived as advantageous, there are concerns regarding loss of human contact, difficulty in using technological devices, and trust and privacy issues that may affect utilization.
Human ; Telerehabilitation ; Caregivers ; Pediatrics ; Children With Disability ; Disabled Children ; Covid-19 ; Developing Countries
4.Socioeconomic disparities in hypertension medication adherence in Quezon City: A cross-sectional study
Jamee G. Lanag ; Carolyn A. Lavadia ; Daniel Royce Lee ; Richelle Anne L. Matias ; Johanna Arndriella M. Mendoza ; Marianne Claire M. Morales ; Ina Mulingbayan ; Jose Ronilo Juangco ; Norbert Lingling D. Uy
Health Sciences Journal 2024;13(2):63-68
INTRODUCTION:
Hypertension is a major risk factor for cardiovascular diseases, with adherence to treatment often influenced by socioeconomic status. This study assessed adherence to hypertension medication among patients in Quezon City across economic classes from August to October 2023.
METHODS:
An analytical cross-sectional design was employed, surveying 116 hypertensive Filipinos aged 18-64 years using the Brief Medication Questionnaire-1 (BMQ-1) and socioeconomic classifications based on multiples of the poverty line.
RESULTS:
Findings revealed that 50.9% of respondents were adherent or probably adherent to treatment, while 49.1% exhibited low or probable low adherence. Those who are low adherent and probable low adherent are 1.399 times more likely to belong to the “Low Income and Below.”, though this association was not statistically significant.
CONCLUSION
Adherence to hypertension treatment among the respondents was suboptimal, particularly among the lower-income groups. While the association between socioeconomic status and adherence was not statistically significant, the findings underscore the need for interventions targeting financial barriers and improving healthcare accessibility. Addressing these challenges can enhance adherence levels and reduce the burden of hypertension and cardiovascular risks across socioeconomic strata.
Cardiovascular diseases
;
hypertension
;
prescription drugs
;
medication adherence
;
developing countries
5.Countermeasures for the construction of occupational health information standard system.
Na CHEN ; Jing Yun LI ; Maimaiti NAZHAKAITI ; Le Le JIA ; Zhong Bin ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Occupational Diseases 2023;41(2):145-148
As an important part of health information standard system, occupational health information standard system is the foundation and guarantee of promoting the construction of occupational health information. This article is based on the literature research about current situation of domestic and foreign health information standards and occupational health information standard system, thus take "the National Health Information Standardization System" and "the National Public Health Information Construction Standards and Norms" into account, focus on the requirements of occupational health information construction and related work. Thus, put forward suggestions on the construction of occupational health information standard system, to accelerate the occupational health information construction, data collection, transmission and application.
Occupational Health
;
Data Collection
;
Internationality
;
Public Health
6.The implementation and management of disease risk reduction claims in the European Union and the United States.
Xue Tong YUAN ; Song Hao KANG ; Qi WANG ; Yun Sheng BAI ; Hui Lian CHE
Chinese Journal of Preventive Medicine 2023;57(10):1674-1681
The improvement of food labeling can improve consumers' health awareness, reduce the burden of chronic diseases on the health and economy, and promote the development of the healthy food industry. Disease Risk Reduction Claim has been developed in European Union and the U.S. for over 20 years, with mature management methods and experience, but it is still lacking in China. Learning and drawing on the international management experience of food disease risk reduction claims can assist China to establish food disease risk reduction claims and improve the food health claims and labeling system.
Humans
;
United States
;
European Union
;
Food Labeling
;
Food Industry
;
China/epidemiology*
7.Discovery and distribution of and response to arbovirus in China over the past seven decades.
Chinese Journal of Schistosomiasis Control 2023;35(5):427-436
Arbovirus is a group of virus transmitted by blood-sucking arthropod bites, which infects both arthropods and vertebrates. More than 600 arboviruses have been characterized worldwide until now, including 65 highly pathogenic viruses, which pose a high threat to public health. The risk of arbovirus transmission is increasing due to climate change, international trade and urbanization. The review summarizes the discovery and distribution of emerging and reemerging arboviruses and novel arboviruses with potential pathogenic risks, and proposes responses to the arbovirus transmission risk, so as to provide insights into the research and management of arboviruses and arthropod-borne infectious diseases in China.
Animals
;
Humans
;
Arboviruses/physiology*
;
Commerce
;
Internationality
;
Arbovirus Infections/prevention & control*
;
Vertebrates
8.Characterization and Comparison Analysis of WHO Monographs on Selected Medicinal Plants and ISO Standards of Chinese Materia Medica.
Jing-Yi YANG ; Zhen SANG ; Rui WANG ; Yan-Hong SHI ; Yi-Ran HUANG
Chinese journal of integrative medicine 2023;29(6):540-548
Medicinal plants or Chinese materia medica (CMM) are now attracting worldwide attention as they have increasingly prominent advantages over chemical drugs in disease treatment and healthcare. Since the 1990s, World Health Organization (WHO) and International Organization for Standardization established the Technical Committee of Traditional Chinese Medicine (ISO/TC 249) have carried out the development of quality standards on medicinal plants or CMMs respectively, and a considerable number of monographs and international standards have been published. Since the two international organizations adhere to different principles, the standards they develop naturally have different emphasis. Driven by market demand and international trade, ISO mainly takes quality, efficacy and safety into consideration when developing standards, while WHO pays more attention to clinical practice, quality control and medication guidance. Up to now, there is a lack of comparative analysis on the records, background, principles, basic content, and main requirements of quality standards on medicinal plants or CMMs respectively published by WHO and ISO. Therefore, based on international standards of CMM developed by ISO/TC 249 platform and WHO Monographs on Selected Medicinal Plants, this paper systematically compares the purposes, selected principles, standard-developing process, basic content, and main quality requirements to summarize their similarities and differences, and find their merits, aiming to serve as a reference to the development of international standards for CMMs that helps them go global.
Materia Medica/therapeutic use*
;
Plants, Medicinal
;
Commerce
;
Internationality
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Reference Standards
;
Drugs, Chinese Herbal/therapeutic use*
;
China
9.Analysis of healthy life expectancy and related socioeconomic influencing factors among the middle-aged and elderly in China, the United States, and the European Union.
Xing Duo HOU ; Ya Nan LUO ; Yin Zi JIN ; Zhi Jie ZHENG
Chinese Journal of Epidemiology 2023;44(6):1006-1012
Objective: To calculate and compare the healthy life expectancy (HLE) of the middle-aged and elderly in China, the United States, and developing and developed countries in the European Union(EU) and analyze the impact of socioeconomic factors on HLE in different countries or regions. Methods: Four surveys from 2010 to 2019 were brought into the research. The data were collected from the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study, Health and Retirement Study, and the Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe. Developed and developing countries in the EU were divided into two groups for calculation. Education level, total family wealth, and work retirement status were selected to measure socioeconomic status, and activities of daily living were used as health status indicators. We used the multi-state life cycle table method to calculate the transition probability between different health states and estimate life expectancy and HLE. Results: A total of 69 544 samples were included in the study. In terms of age, the middle-aged and elderly in the United States and developed countries of the EU have higher HLE in all age groups. In terms of gender, only Chinese women have lower HLE than men. Regarding socioeconomic factors, the middle-aged and elderly with higher education levels and total family wealth level have higher HLE. In China, working seniors have higher HLE, while for USA women and developed countries of the EU, retired or unemployed seniors have higher HLE. Conclusions: Demographic and socioeconomic factors impact HLE in different countries or regions. China should pay more attention to the health of women and the middle-aged and elderly retired with lower education and less total family wealth.
Aged
;
Male
;
Middle Aged
;
United States
;
Female
;
Humans
;
Healthy Life Expectancy
;
European Union
;
Activities of Daily Living
;
Longitudinal Studies
;
Socioeconomic Factors
;
China/epidemiology*
10.New outlook on safety of traditional Chinese medicine: concept and practice.
Xiao-He XIAO ; Xu ZHAO ; Zhao-Fang BAI ; Jia-Bo WANG ; Hai-Bo SONG
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2023;48(10):2557-2564
Profound changes have taken place in human disease spectrum, constitution spectrum, and drug use behavior, and the safety of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) faces new trends and problems. In particular, serious adverse reactions/events such as liver injury and kidney injury caused by non-toxic TCM have been frequently reported, overturning people's understanding of TCM safety, and even shaking the public's confidence in the development of TCM. In the new era of globalization, correctly understanding the situation and problems of TCM safety and addressing the dilemmas in safety evaluation and risk prevention of TCM are the key missions to be undertaken by TCM practitioners. This paper suggests that the situation and problems of TCM safety should be viewed objectively and dialectically, and the use standard of TCM should be advanced with the times. Furthermore, this paper puts forward the new conception and methodology of TCM safety(including one innovative understanding, two types of evaluation modes, tri-elements injury hypothesis; four-quadrant risk decision processes, and five-grade safety evidence body) for the first time, hoping to provide new theories, new strategies, new methods and successful examples for solving the safety problems of TCM.
Humans
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional/adverse effects*
;
Internationality
;
Drugs, Chinese Herbal/adverse effects*


Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail