1.Biomechanical analysis of three kinds of rigid internal fixation methods for condylar head fractures.
Junhui SUN ; Duoduo LAN ; Dong WANG ; Yao XU ; Zeyu WANG ; Chenchen ZHANG ; Kai ZHANG ; Tao XU
West China Journal of Stomatology 2025;43(1):126-132
OBJECTIVES:
This study aims to analyze the biomechanics of three kinds of rigid internal fixation methods for condylar head fractures.
METHODS:
A three dimensional finite element model of the normal mandible was constructed. It was then used to prepare condylar head fracture finite element model and three kinds of rigid internal fixation finite element model (unilateral tension screw, bilateral tension screw, tension screw+titanium plate). The mechanical characteristics and changes of the mandible condyle under the same mechanical conditions were compared among the three different rigid internal fixation methods.
RESULTS:
The maximum equivalent stress and displacement of the non-free end of condyle under the rigid internal fixation method of unilateral tension screw were 71.03 MPa and 4.72 mm, respectively. The maximum equivalent stress and displacement of the free end of condyle were 78.45 MPa and 4.50 mm, respectively. The maximum stress of fracture suture was 3.27 MPa. The maximum equivalent stress and displacement of the non-free end of condyle under the rigid internal fixation method of bilateral tension screw were 70.52 MPa and 4.00 mm, respectively. The maximum equivalent stress and displacement of the free end of condyle were 72.49 MPa and 3.85 mm, respectively. The maximum stress of fracture suture was 2.33 MPa. The maximum equivalent stress and maximum displacement of the non-free end of condyle under the rigid internal fixation method of tension screw+titanium plate were 67.26 MPa and 2.66 mm, respectively. The maximum equivalent stress and maximum displacement of the free end of condyle were 69.66 MPa and 2.50 mm, respectively. The maximum stress of fracture suture was 2.18 MPa.
CONCLUSIONS
The tension screw+titanium plate rigid internal fixation method is the most conducive to biomechanical distribution for condylar head fractures.
Fracture Fixation, Internal/instrumentation*
;
Mandibular Condyle/surgery*
;
Biomechanical Phenomena
;
Bone Screws
;
Finite Element Analysis
;
Humans
;
Mandibular Fractures/surgery*
;
Bone Plates
;
Titanium
;
Stress, Mechanical
2.Research on prediction of fracture reduction fixator therapy based on multimodal multi-label method.
Hai-Yu LIU ; De-Long WANG ; Xing-Ping ZHANG ; Hong-de LI ; Yan SUN ; Xiao-Ping ZHANG
China Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology 2025;38(11):1164-1169
OBJECTIVE:
To construct a prediction model for fracture reduction fixator therapy using the multi-modal multi-label classification (MMC) method.
METHODS:
Medical record data of 818 orthopedic patients from 2019 to 2023 were collected. Medical image features were extracted using the VGG19 network, text features of TCM four diagnostic methods (Inspection, Auscultation & Olfaction, Inquiry, Palpation) were extracted via the MiniLM model, and clinical case features were extracted through a fully connected neural network. After fusing the multi-modal information, multi-label therapy prediction was achieved using a linear layer.
RESULTS:
Experimental results on the clinical multi-modal dataset showed that the MMC method performed excellently in terms of subset accuracy(SA), accuracy(Acc), precision, and F1-score, reaching 0.661, 0.856, 0.897, and 0.899 respectively. When the image modality and text modality were removed, the model performance decreased by an average of 8.1% and 2.4% respectively, while the hamming loss(HL) increased by 21.1% and 5.6% respectively.
CONCLUSION
The fracture reduction fixator therapy prediction model constructed in this study can effectively fuse multi-modal data, accurately predict personalized treatment plans for patients, and significantly improve the accuracy and reliability of treatment decisions. It provides a new solution for the digitalization and intellectualization of Traditional Chinese Medicine(TCM) in fracture treatment and has important clinical application prospects.
Humans
;
Female
;
Male
;
Middle Aged
;
Fracture Fixation/methods*
;
Adult
;
Fractures, Bone/surgery*
;
Neural Networks, Computer
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Aged
3.Intramedullary administration of tranexamic acid reduces bleeding in proximal femoral nail antirotation surgery for intertrochanteric fractures in elderly individuals: A randomized controlled trial.
Xiang-Ping LUO ; Jian PENG ; Ling ZHOU ; Hao LIAO ; Xiao-Chun JIANG ; Xiong TANG ; Dun TANG ; Chao LIU ; Jian-Hui LIU
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(3):201-207
PURPOSE:
Intertrochanteric fractures undergoing proximal femoral nail antirotation (PFNA) surgery are associated with significant hidden blood loss. This study aimed to explore whether intramedullary administration of tranexamic acid (TXA) can reduce bleeding in PFNA surgery for intertrochanteric fractures in elderly individuals.
METHODS:
A randomized controlled trial was conducted from January 2019 to December 2022. Patients aged over 60 years with intertrochanteric fractures who underwent intramedullary fixation surgery with PFNA were eligible for inclusion and grouped according to random numbers. A total of 249 patients were initially enrolled, of which 83 were randomly allocated to the TXA group and 82 were allocated to the saline group. The TXA group received intramedullary perfusion of TXA after the bone marrow was reamed. The primary outcomes were total peri-operative blood loss and post-operative transfusion rate. The occurrence of adverse events was also recorded. Continuous data was analyzed by unpaired t-test or Mann-Whitney U test, and categorical data was analyzed by Pearson Chi-square test.
RESULTS:
The total peri-operative blood loss (mL) in the TXA group was significantly lower than that in the saline group (577.23 ± 358.02 vs. 716.89 ± 420.30, p = 0.031). The post-operative transfusion rate was 30.67% in the TXA group and 47.95% in the saline group (p = 0.031). The extent of post-operative deep venous thrombosis and the 3-month mortality rate were similar between the 2 groups.
CONCLUSION
We observed that intramedullary administration of TXA in PFNA surgery for intertrochanteric fractures in elderly individuals resulted in less peri-operative blood loss and decreased transfusion rate, without any adverse effects, and is, thus, recommended.
Humans
;
Tranexamic Acid/administration & dosage*
;
Hip Fractures/surgery*
;
Male
;
Aged
;
Female
;
Fracture Fixation, Intramedullary/adverse effects*
;
Blood Loss, Surgical/prevention & control*
;
Antifibrinolytic Agents/administration & dosage*
;
Aged, 80 and over
;
Bone Nails
;
Middle Aged
;
Blood Transfusion/statistics & numerical data*
4.Novel approach of plate assisted buttressing in Hoffa fracture.
Amit SINGH ; Nirottam SINGH ; Gaurav SIWACH ; Mohit BANSAL ; Hemant JAIN ; Kishore RAICHANDANI
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(3):175-180
PURPOSE:
Hoffa fracture is a femoral condyle fracture in the coronal plane. The lateral condyle is more commonly involved. The diagnosis is often difficult to detect with routine radiographs. Conservative management in this type of fracture resulted in nonunion, malunion, and other complications, such as stiff knee. Therefore, surgical management is mandatory in displaced fractures. Previous studies suggest only application of cancellous screw fixation, but these are not enough to counter vertical shear stress. Therefore, this study will evaluate the clinical outcomes of open reduction and internal fixation of Letenneur type I Hoffa fracture using cancellous screws with posterior buttressing plate.
METHOD:
This was a prospective cohort study conducted from March 2017 to July 2022 in orthopaedics department of tertiary care center after approval of institutional ethical committee. The study included 36 patients with Letenneur type I fractures treated by open reduction and internal fixation using posterior buttress plate and cancellous screws. Radiographs and clinical outcomes, range of movement (ROM), bone union, and knee society score (KSS) of patients were assessed at the end of 4 and 12 months in the follow-ups. All statistical analysis was done using Epi info version 7.2.1.0.
RESULTS:
In the 36 patients with Letenneur type I fracture, the majority belong to younger age group between 25 and 54 years with 22 males and 14 females. The modes of injury were road traffic accidents in 25 patients and fall from height in 11 patients. The right knee was involved in 21 cases and left was involved in 15 cases. Lateral condyle involvement was seen in 27 cases and medial condyle in 9 cases. All 36 patients with Letenneur type I Hoffa fracture were evaluated 4 months after surgical intervention. The notable improvements were observed in terms of ROM 120.4° ± 5.0° and KSS 85.0 ± 4.2. At the 12-month follow-up, considerably better outcomes were maintained regarding ROM 128.1° ± 5.2° and KSS 89.3 ± 4.8 with p < 0.05 which was statistically significant. At the final follow-up, all patients had routine fracture healing with a union time of (3.2 ± 3.4) months.
CONCLUSIONS
Fixation of Letenneur type I Hoffa fracture with cancellous screws and posterior buttress plate is effective, reliable and capable of providing adequate stability. Buttress plate assisted fixation is a valuable enhancement of the conventional technique of lag screw fixation of Hoffa fractures.
Humans
;
Bone Plates
;
Male
;
Female
;
Fracture Fixation, Internal/instrumentation*
;
Adult
;
Prospective Studies
;
Middle Aged
;
Femoral Fractures/surgery*
;
Bone Screws
;
Range of Motion, Articular
;
Young Adult
;
Aged
;
Hoffa Fracture
5.Effectiveness and safety of augmentative plating technique in managing nonunion following intramedullary nailing of long bones in the lower extremity: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Cong-Xiao FU ; Hao GAO ; Jun REN ; Hu WANG ; Shuai-Kun LU ; Guo-Liang WANG ; Zhen-Feng ZHU ; Yun-Yan LIU ; Wen LUO ; Yong ZHANG ; Yun-Fei ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(3):164-174
PURPOSE:
To methodically assess the effectiveness of augmentative plating (AP) and exchange nailing (EN) in managing nonunion following intramedullary nailing for long bone fractures of the lower extremity.
METHODS:
PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Library were searched to gather clinical studies regarding the use of AP and EN techniques in the treatment of nonunion following intramedullary nailing of lower extremity long bones. The search was conducted up until May 2023. The original studies underwent an independent assessment of their quality, a process conducted utilizing the Newcastle-Ottawa scale. Data were retrieved from these studies, and meta-analysis was executed utilizing Review Manager 5.3.
RESULTS:
This meta-analysis included 8 studies involving 661 participants, with 305 in the AP group and 356 in the EN group. The results of the meta-analysis demonstrated that the AP group exhibited a higher rate of union (odds ratio: 8.61, 95% confidence intervals (CI): 4.12 - 17.99, p < 0.001), shorter union time (standardized mean difference (SMD): -1.08, 95% CI: -1.79 - -0.37, p = 0.003), reduced duration of the surgical procedure (SMD: -0.56, 95% CI: -0.93 - -0.19, p = 0.003), less bleeding (SMD: -1.5, 95% CI: -2.81 - -0.18, p = 0.03), and a lower incidence of complications (relative risk: -0.17, 95% CI: -0.27 - -0.06, p = 0.001). In the subgroup analysis, the time for union in the AP group in nonisthmal and isthmal nonunion of lower extremity long bones was shorter compared to the EN group (nonisthmal SMD: -1.94, 95% CI: -3.28 - -0.61, p < 0.001; isthmal SMD: -1.08, 95% CI: -1.64 - -0.52, p = 0.002).
CONCLUSION
In the treatment of nonunion in diaphyseal fractures of the long bones in the lower extremity, the AP approach is superior to EN, both intraoperatively (with reduced duration of the surgical procedure and diminished blood loss) and postoperatively (with an elevated union rate, shorter union time, and lower incidence of complications). Specifically, in the management of nonunion of lower extremity long bones with non-isthmal and isthmal intramedullary nails, AP demonstrated shorter union time in comparison to EN.
Humans
;
Bone Nails/adverse effects*
;
Bone Plates/adverse effects*
;
Femoral Fractures/surgery*
;
Fracture Fixation, Intramedullary/methods*
;
Fractures, Ununited/surgery*
;
Lower Extremity/injuries*
6.Analysis of risk factors, pathogenic bacteria characteristics, and drug resistance of postoperative surgical site infection in adults with limb fractures.
Yan-Jun WANG ; Zi-Hou ZHAO ; Shuai-Kun LU ; Guo-Liang WANG ; Shan-Jin MA ; Lin-Hu WANG ; Hao GAO ; Jun REN ; Zhong-Wei AN ; Cong-Xiao FU ; Yong ZHANG ; Wen LUO ; Yun-Fei ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(4):241-251
PURPOSE:
We carried out the study aiming to explore and analyze the risk factors, the distribution of pathogenic bacteria, and their antibiotic-resistance characteristics influencing the occurrence of surgical site infection (SSI), to provide valuable assistance for reducing the incidence of SSI after traumatic fracture surgery.
METHODS:
A retrospective case-control study enrolling 3978 participants from January 2015 to December 2019 receiving surgical treatment for traumatic fractures was conducted at Tangdu Hospital of Air Force Medical University. Baseline data, demographic characteristics, lifestyles, variables related to surgical treatment, and pathogen culture were harvested and analyzed. Univariate analyses and multivariate logistic regression analyses were used to reveal the independent risk factors of SSI. A bacterial distribution histogram and drug-sensitive heat map were drawn to describe the pathogenic characteristics.
RESULTS:
Included 3978 patients 138 of them developed SSI with an incidence rate of 3.47% postoperatively. By logistic regression analysis, we found that variables such as gender (males) (odds ratio (OR) = 2.012, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.235 - 3.278, p = 0.005), diabetes mellitus (OR = 5.848, 95% CI: 3.513 - 9.736, p < 0.001), hypoproteinemia (OR = 3.400, 95% CI: 1.280 - 9.031, p = 0.014), underlying disease (OR = 5.398, 95% CI: 2.343 - 12.438, p < 0.001), hormonotherapy (OR = 11.718, 95% CI: 6.269 - 21.903, p < 0.001), open fracture (OR = 29.377, 95% CI: 9.944 - 86.784, p < 0.001), and intraoperative transfusion (OR = 2.664, 95% CI: 1.572 - 4.515, p < 0.001) were independent risk factors for SSI, while, aged over 59 years (OR = 0.132, 95% CI: 0.059 - 0.296, p < 0.001), prophylactic antibiotics use (OR = 0.082, 95% CI: 0.042 - 0.164, p < 0.001) and vacuum sealing drainage use (OR = 0.036, 95% CI: 0.010 - 0.129, p < 0.001) were protective factors. Pathogens results showed that 301 strains of 38 species of bacteria were harvested, among which 178 (59.1%) strains were Gram-positive bacteria, and 123 (40.9%) strains were Gram-negative bacteria. Staphylococcus aureus (108, 60.7%) and Enterobacter cloacae (38, 30.9%) accounted for the largest proportion. The susceptibility of Gram-positive bacteria to Vancomycin and Linezolid was almost 100%. The susceptibility of Gram-negative bacteria to Imipenem, Amikacin, and Meropenem exceeded 73%.
CONCLUSION
Orthopedic surgeons need to develop appropriate surgical plans based on the risk factors and protective factors associated with postoperative SSI to reduce its occurrence. Meanwhile, it is recommended to strengthen blood glucose control in the early stage of admission and for surgeons to be cautious and scientific when choosing antibiotic therapy in clinical practice.
Humans
;
Surgical Wound Infection/epidemiology*
;
Male
;
Female
;
Risk Factors
;
Retrospective Studies
;
Middle Aged
;
Adult
;
Case-Control Studies
;
Fractures, Bone/surgery*
;
Aged
;
Drug Resistance, Bacterial
;
Logistic Models
;
Anti-Bacterial Agents/therapeutic use*
;
Incidence
;
Bacteria/drug effects*
7.Posterior-only fixation in pelvic fractures: Is it sufficient in lateral compression injuries?
Sameer AGGARWAL ; Sandeep PATEL ; Lav MEHTA ; Mohak KATARIA ; Vishal KUMAR ; Prasoon KUMAR
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(3):226-230
PURPOSE:
Lateral compression (LC) injuries account for more than two-thirds of all pelvic fractures. The goal of surgical treatment is to provide adequate stability and early mobilization. The consensus on posterior fixation of such injuries is strong in the literature; however, the necessity of anterior ring fixation is not clear. Therefore, this study was formulated to determine the practicability of posterior-only fixation in LC injuries.
METHODS:
Between March 2015 and May 2020, all patients with LC type pelvic ring fractures who were admitted and operated upon in a single level 1 trauma center were included in this cross-sectional observational study. Demographic data, co-morbidities, treatment, types of surgical fixation, concomitant injuries and surgeries, surgical complications, length of hospital stay, injury to weight bearing duration, and follow-up period were documented. Functional outcome and quality of life were assessed using Majeed score and SF-36 questionnaire. Non-normally distributed data were presented as median (Q1, Q3) and normally distributed data were presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD). Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was used for correlation analysis.
RESULTS:
A total of 25 patients were included, with a mean age of 29.8 years. All patients were managed operatively with posterior-only fixation. The median Majeed score was 90 (76, 95). The median physical component summary score was 69.37 (38.75, 85.62). The median mental component summary score was 63.95 (39.25, 87.87). There was no significant difference compared to population norms of both physical component summary and mental component summary. Injury to weight bearing time correlated significantly (p = 0.002) with Majeed score as well as SF-36 score (p = 0.044). No other variable had a significant association with outcomes.
CONCLUSION
Posterior-only fixation is sufficient for fixing LC injuries with up to 80% of cases having good to excellent functional outcomes. However, comparative studies with larger sample sizes are needed for further validation.
Humans
;
Male
;
Female
;
Adult
;
Cross-Sectional Studies
;
Pelvic Bones/surgery*
;
Fractures, Bone/surgery*
;
Fracture Fixation, Internal/methods*
;
Middle Aged
;
Young Adult
;
Quality of Life
;
Adolescent
;
Length of Stay
8.Comparative analysis of the safety and efficacy of fenestrated pedicle screw with cement and conventional pedicle screw with cement in the treatment of osteoporotic vertebral fractures: A meta-analysis.
Li CAO ; Hong-Jie XU ; Yi-Kang YU ; Huan-Huan TANG ; Bo-Hao FANG ; Ke CHEN
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(2):101-112
PURPOSE:
Bone cement-reinforced fenestrated pedicle screws (FPSs) have been widely used in the internal fixation and repair of the spine with osteoporosis in recent years and show significant improvement in fixation strength and stability. However, compared with conventional reinforcement methods, the advantages of bone cement-reinforced FPSs remain undetermined. This article compares the effects of fenestrated and conventional pedicle screws (CPSs) combined with bone cement in the treatment of osteoporosis.
METHODS:
A clinical control study of FPSs and CPSs combined with bone cement reinforcement in osteoporotic vertebral internal fixation was performed using the database PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, CNKI, the Wanfang, and the China Biomedical Literature Service System. Two evaluators screened the relevant literature in strict accordance with the inclusion criteria (diagnosis of participants, type of clinical study, treatment with FPS and CPS, and outcome indicators) and exclusion criteria (duplicate literature and missing or incorrect data) and independently conducted data extraction and quality evaluation. Clinical control studies of direct comparison between FPS and CPS combined with bone cement reinforcement in patients who were definitively diagnosed with thoracolumbar fractures or spinal degenerative diseases were included. Quality evaluation was conducted using the Cochrane risk bias evaluation tool for randomized controlled studies and using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for retrospective case-control studies. RevMan software (version 5.3) was used for the meta-analysis to compare the clinical efficacy, radiological results, and related complications of the 2 methods.
RESULTS:
A total of 13 articles were included, including 7 randomized controlled studies and 6 retrospective case-control studies. There were 909 patients in these studies, 451 in the FPS and polymethyl methacrylate (FPS & PMMA) group and 458 in the CPS and polymethyl methacrylate (CPS & PMMA) group. The results of the meta-analysis showed that there was no significant difference between the 2 groups in operation time, hospital stay, visual analogue score, Japanese orthopaedic association score, Oswestry disability index score, Cobb angle, vertebral body deformation index and fusion rate (p > 0.05). The mean difference of intraoperative bleeding volume was -10.45, (95% confidence intervals (CI) (-16.92, -3.98), p = 0.002), the mean difference of loss height of the anterior edge of the vertebral body after surgery was -0.69 (95% CI (-0.93, -0.44), p < 0.001), and the relative risk (RR) of overall complication rate was 0.43 (95% CI (0.27, 0.68), p < 0.001), including the RR of bone cement leakage rate was 0.57 (95% CI (0.39, 0.85), p = 0.005). The screw loosening rate (RR = 0.26, 95% CI (0.13, 0.54), p < 0.001) of the FPS group was significantly lower than that of the CPS group.
CONCLUSION
The existing clinical evidence shows that compared with the CPS combined with bone cement, the use of FPS repair in the internal fixation of an osteoporotic vertebral body can reduce the amount of intraoperative bleeding, be more conducive to maintaining the height of the vertebral body, and significantly reduce the incidence of postoperative complications such as bone cement leakage and screw loosening.
Humans
;
Pedicle Screws
;
Bone Cements
;
Spinal Fractures/surgery*
;
Osteoporotic Fractures/surgery*
;
Fracture Fixation, Internal/instrumentation*
9.Efficacy and safety of conventional biplanar and triangulation method for sacroiliac screw placement in the treatment of unstable posterior pelvic ring fractures: A real-world retrospective cohort study.
Yu-Bo ZHENG ; Xing HAN ; Xin ZHAO ; Xi-Guang SANG
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(5):336-341
PURPOSE:
The fixation method commonly employed worldwide for treating unstable fractures of the posterior pelvic ring is the percutaneous iliosacral screw technique. However, prolonged operation time and frequent fluoroscopies result in surgical risks. This study aimed to investigate whether a new triangulation method could reduce operative and fluoroscopy times and increase the accuracy of screw placement.
METHODS:
This study is a real-world retrospective cohort analysis that examined a patient cohort who underwent percutaneous iliosacral screw fixation between January 1, 2019 and December 31, 2022. Inclusion criteria were patients (1) diagnosed with posterior pelvic ring instability who underwent pelvic fracture closed reduction and percutaneous S1 transverse-penetrating iliosacral screw placement and (2) aged >18 years. Exclusion criteria were: (1) combined proximal femoral fractures, (2) severe soft tissue injury in the surgical area, (3) incomplete imaging data, and (4) declining to provide written informed consent by the patient. The patients were divided into 2 groups according to the screw insertion method: conventional and triangulation methods. Screw placement and fluoroscopy times recorded by the C-arm were compared between the 2 methods. The accuracy of screw placement was evaluated by Smith grading on postoperative CT. Normality tests were conducted to assess the distribution of the quantitative variables and the Chi-square test was used to compare the qualitative variables.
RESULTS:
The study included a total of 94 patients diagnosed with posterior pelvic ring instability, who underwent percutaneous iliosacral screw placement. The patients were divided into 2 groups: 46 patients treated with the conventional surgical method and 48 patients received the triangulation method. The operation time (61.13±9.69 vs. 35.77±6.27) min and fluoroscopy frequency times (52.15±9.29 vs. 24.40±4.04) of the triangulation method were significantly reduced (p<0.001).
CONCLUSIONS
The use of a triangular positioning technique for the surface positioning of percutaneous iliosacral screws could reduce the operative time and fluoroscopy frequency. And the screw placement accuracy using this new method was comparable to that using other conventional methods.
Humans
;
Retrospective Studies
;
Bone Screws
;
Pelvic Bones/surgery*
;
Male
;
Female
;
Fracture Fixation, Internal/methods*
;
Fractures, Bone/surgery*
;
Adult
;
Middle Aged
;
Fluoroscopy
;
Aged
;
Sacrum/surgery*
;
Operative Time
10.Comparison of hook plates vs. locking plates for Neer type IIB fractures of lateral end clavicle: A systematic review.
Ravi PATEL ; Muhammad Murtaza KHAN ; William GIBSON ; Robin BANERJEE ; Asif PARDIWALA
Chinese Journal of Traumatology 2025;28(4):269-275
PURPOSE:
Surgical management of the lateral end of clavicle fractures has been a challenge for orthopedic surgeons considering the high rate of non-union. There has been no right and wrong answer to these types of fractures and many methods discussed in the literature, but the 2 most used bony procedures are hook plate and locking plate with or without the use of supplementary soft tissue procedures. The available evidence, in this case, is scarce with questionable reliability. The idea of this systemic review is to promote evidence-based practice when choosing between the 2 implants for this fracture. This study aims to review the results by performing a systemic review of the literature comparing the results of locking plate vs. hook plate for the lateral end of clavicle fracture fixation with an emphasis on outcome and associated complications.
METHODS:
A search of the literature was made with the keyword "clavicle" in PubMed/Ovid Medline/Embase and University of Edinburgh online library "discover Ed". A total of 4063 articles were identified including case series (with at least 3 cases) and review articles focusing on locking plate alone, comparisons of locking plate and hook plate, or hook plate alone. Articles were excluded if they were not published in English, focused on pediatric studies, or consisted only of book chapters. Studies examining tension band wiring, soft tissue procedures for fracture fixation, arthroscopic-assisted procedures, additional soft tissue procedures along with plate fixation, and fracture dislocation of the lateral end of the clavicle were also excluded. The search was then narrowed down to 21 articles after consideration of inclusion and exclusion criteria. A detailed review of the surgical methodology further excluded additional soft tissue procedures, resulting in a final selection of 15 studies. The quality of the studies was assessed using the Modified Coleman Score by the authors.
RESULTS:
A total of 15 studies related to Neer type II fracture met the inclusion criteria. However, 2 other studies also included type V fracture as well. The mean age of patients in these studies was 32 years. The mean follow-up period was 24.3 months (ranging from 6 to 65 months). The time of radiological union was documented from 2 to 4.5 months. Constant and disabilities of arm, shoulder, and hand scores were most used as the criteria for patient outcomes. The size of the lateral fragment that can accommodate/provide bicortical fracture was documented in only 3 studies. The mean incidence of removal of hook plate was 86.9%. In contrast, the mean incidence of removal of locking plate was 27.0%. Superficial wound infection was documented in 5 studies and deep wound infection was seen in 1 study. The mean union rate for hook plate was 97.0% compared to 100% for locking plate. Complications associated with hook plate have been documented in 11 studies. The most commonly reported incidence of complication was acromial osteolysis. The quality of studies was assessed using modified Coleman score. Other than 2 studies that were considered for the study that met the "fair" standard all of them were considered "poor" based on the modified Coleman score.
CONCLUSION
Both hook plate and locking plate provide acceptable operative treatment options for the lateral end of clavicle fracture. However, a consideration of surgeons' experience, the likelihood of a second operation, and the size of the lateral fragment should be considered when choosing between the 2 types of implants.
Humans
;
Clavicle/surgery*
;
Bone Plates
;
Fractures, Bone/surgery*
;
Fracture Fixation, Internal/instrumentation*

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail