1.The logic of change and high-quality development pathways for family doctor contract service policies in China:An analytical framework based on policy integration
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):9-17
Objective:To investigate the multi-level logic of change in China's family doctor contract service policies and propose pathways for their high-quality development.Methods:An analytical framework grounded in policy integration theory was developed.Through content analysis and policy network analysis,346 policy documents on family doctor contract services were analyzed using Nvivo and Gephi software,with cross-text and cross-stage thematic coding to identify patterns of policy change.Results:The policy change process can be categorized into three phases:pilot exploration,nationwide implementation,enhance quality and efficiency.Key trends include:Policy frameworks transitioned from instrumental issue to comprehensive agendas;Policy subsystem participation shifted from unilateral leadership by health departments to multi-stakeholder collaboration;Objectives expanded from healthcare capacity-building to systemic integration across domains;Policy instruments evolved from fragmented trials to structured systems.Conclusion and Recommendations:To advance high-quality development,policymakers should:Strengthen value integration through strategic governance frameworks;Enhance coordination between central and local governments to drive iterative innovation in contract-based service models;Implement feedback integration with multidimensional evaluation mechanisms;Accelerate technical integration via digital transformation.
2.Analysis of research hotspots and development directions in health management and policy disciplines during the 14th Five-Year period
Lin-bin LUO ; Yi-qing XING ; Liang ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):1-8
Health management and policy is an essential supporting discipline for the realization of"Healthy China"and"Health Priority Development"strategies.This paper,guided by the strategic health demands of China,offers a comprehensive examination of the health management and policy discipline(G0405).The analysis draws on funding project data of the National Natural Science Foundation of China and related academic literature.The study highlights six key research themes within the G0405:health policy innovation and collaborative governance,medical insurance payment mechanisms and strategic purchasing,digital health and precision medicine,intelligent health interventions and behavioral medicine,community health governance,and socially driven dynamic research topics.However,challenges remain in macro-system research,theoretical development,and the creation of original theoretical contributions.To address China's modernization-driven health strategies,future disciplinary development needs to align with national priorities.In the context of the discipline's transformation,it is essential to prioritize problem-solving,shape macro-system perspectives,and foster a stronger connection between practices and scientific research.Additionally,it should establish a health management theoretical framework that reflects Chinese characteristics,and consistently drive the creative and innovative evolution of theoretical studies.
3.Policy analysis on general outpatient fund pooling of employee basic medical insurance from the perspective of coordinated development of Yangtze River Delta Region
Yi-jia FENG ; Lu-ying ZHANG ; Jiao-yang LI ; Sen-wei ZHANG ; Wen CHEN
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):18-24
Objective:To analyze policy differences in general outpatient fund pooling of employee basic medical insurance in Yangtze River Delta Region and raise suggestions from the perspective of coordinated development.Methods:The study analyzed policy documents on general outpatients financing,outpatient chronic and special diseases,and inclusion of retail pharmacies into risk pooling at provincial level and in some economically developed cities before August,2024.Typical cases were selected for detailed introduction.Results:General outpatient coverage of employee medical insurance in Yangtze River Delta Region is high,with individual account payment scenarios expanding to commercial health insurance,Long Term Care Insurance and family physician contracted service fees.Number of outpatient chronic and special diseases ranges from 3 to 83.Retail pharmacy policies differ less in access conditions and treatment and e-prescription is advancing rapidly.Suzhou is actively exploring total budget management of retail pharmacies.Conclusions:Outpatient fund pooling policies should be gradually promoted under the principle of"differentiated coordination".It is necessary to transform outpatient chronic and special diseases from"disease coverage"to"cost coverage";strengthen the management of retail pharmacies under the outpatient fund pooling scheme,and improve the coordinated regulatory mechanism for direct settlement of outpatient and medication expenses incurred in other places in the Yangtze River Delta.
4.Research on the impact of physician's compensation payment methods on medical service behavior:A scoping review
Qiang YAO ; Yue-fang JIAO ; Xiao-dan ZHANG ; Ya-qi RAO ; Hui-ling ZHENG ; Mian XIA
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):25-35
Objective:To systematically analyze the impact of various physician payment methods on medical service delivery behavior and outcomes.Methods:Based on the scoping review method,2 255 documents related to"physician","compensation","payment method",and"physician behavior"were retrieved from Web of Science,CNKI,VIP,and WanFang databases,and finally 70 studies were included based on scientific screening standards and process.Results:Fee-for-service encourages physicians to deliver an adequate volume of services but is susceptible to overtreatment;salary and capitation assist in controlling costs but can lead to insufficient service provision;the advantages of DRG/DIP in the quantity and quality of medical services weaken as the patient's condition worsens.Mixed payment methods can effectively balance the quantity and cost of medical services,while pay-for-performance is generally outstanding in improving quality.Conclusions:It is difficult for a single payment method to achieve the optimization of medical service delivery behavior and outcomes.A mixed payment system that integrates multiple payment methods with quality incentives must be established urgently.At the same time,it is recommended to deepen the reform of the mechanism for converting medical insurance balance into physician compensation,fully implement the allocation autonomy of public hospitals,and accelerate the establishment of a mixed physician payment method that is coordinated with medical insurance payment and performance appraisal.
5.Changes and urban-rural disparities in the physical health of children and adolescents:Influencing factors and policy implications
Yue-hui YU ; Jing-xia QIN ; Ya-xuan MAO ; Zhen LI
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):36-44
Objectives:To analyze factors associated with physical fitness and health in children and adolescents from the perspective of cohort and urban-rural differences in order to provide evidence for optimizing health intervention policies.Methods:Using data from the China Family Panel Studies(CFPS)from 2012 to 2020,this study examined trends in the health of children and adolescents in terms of height and weight.A hierarchical mixed-effects model was used to examine the impact of socioeconomic factors such as household income,health insurance and regional public health expenditure on physical fitness and health.Interaction models were also used to assess heterogeneous effects across birth cohorts and urban-rural contexts.Results:The physical fitness and health of children and adolescents in China have improved significantly,but urban-rural disparities persist.Household income,parental education and health insurance have protective effects on health,but the strength of these effects varies by cohort and between urban and rural areas.Height and weight outcomes for rural children were more closely associated with economic development and health insurance coverage.Conclusions:The factors associated with physical fitness and health in children and adolescents are dynamic.It is necessary to establish a tiered and targeted health promotion system,strengthening health insurance coverage and interventions in rural areas,while prioritizing family-based healthy lifestyle counselling in urban areas.
6.The development status of chaperone service industry and the countermeasures of strengthening supervision:A qualitative study
Rui DING ; Rui-ming DAI ; Biao WANG ; Li LUO ; Tian-tian ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):45-50
Objective:With the aging of the population and the increase of medical treatment in different places,chaperone services are gradually emerging,but there are problems such as insufficient training of patient navigators and lack of rules and regulations in the industry.It is necessary to strengthen supervision and standardized management to improve service quality.To explore the current situation and risks of the chaperone service industry from the perspective of patient navigators and doctors,and to provide suggestions for policy formulation.Methods:The Theory of Planned Behavior(TPB)and Knowledge-Attitude-Practice(KAP)models were developed to outline the interview.A total of 22 doctors and patient navigators were selected from 5 large Grade Three hospitals and 20 online consultation platforms in Shanghai for semi-structured interviews.The data were analyzed using"7 Steps of Data Analysis in Colaizzi Phenomenology Research".Results:The chaperone service industry faces risks such as lack of professional norms,vague definition of legal responsibilities,insufficient professional competence among practitioners,and regulatory gaps.Conclusions:We should further establish a unified industry standard and certification system,strengthen the training of patient navigators,improve the supervision of online platforms,and effectively protect the rights and interests of doctors,so as to better promote the development of the industry and provide quality services for patients and doctors.
7.Study on the co-evolution of China's health workforce policies and the objectives of the new healthcare reform:Based on cross-referencing and content analysis of 196 policy documents
Jing-yu WANG ; Ren LONG ; Xiao-yun LIU
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):51-58
Objective:To analyze the evolutionary patterns of China's health workforce policies following China's healthcare system reform and assess their alignment with reform objectives.Methods:This study examined health workforce-related policies implemented during China's healthcare system reform.Cross-referencing analysis and content evaluation were conducted within Health Worker-Centered Framework.Results:A total of 196 policies were analyzed,revealing two evolution patterns:(1)alignment with systemic reform goals,ensuring integration with broader healthcare transformation;(2)incremental optimization within the health workforce domain,emphasizing continuity and phased development.Thematic priorities included education/training,performance incentives,and human resource mobility,which closely coordinate with key reform targets such as strengthening primary care,reforming public hospitals,and establishing hierarchical diagnosis and treatment system.Conclusions:Since the healthcare system reform,China's health workforce policies reveals their dynamic alignment with reform goals.Policy evolution closely synergizes with reform objectives,providing institutional support for health talent development.However,Sectoral synergy dilemmas remain in health workforce policies,future efforts should strengthen policy integration and dynamic adjustment mechanisms to achieve high-quality development of health human resources.
8.Research on theequity of primary healthcare human resources allocation and its driving path:A qualitative comparative analysis based on Fuzzy Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis
Xiao-chen FENG ; Yong-qiang WANG ; Ran WANG ; Xin WANG ; Sheng LUO ; Yu-qing MI
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):59-65
Objective:To explore the equity and driving path of primary healthcare human resource allocation across 31 provinces in China,providing references for optimizing such allocations.Methods:Using data from the 2022 primary healthcare human resources in 31 provinces in China,the Health Resource Density Index(HRDI)was used to measure the equity of primary healthcare human resource allocation.The fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis(fsQCA)was applied to construct configurational pathways influencing on allocation patterns.Results:In 2022,the HRDI for primary healthcare human resources in China was 2.349 0 in the East,1.198 6 in the Central region,and 0.775 2 in the West.Configurational analysis revealed three paths that promote high equity:the internal-external balance-driven model(H1),the government-led model(H2),and the economic-demand combined model(H3),with overall consistency and coverage of 0.955 and 0.794,respectively.Seven paths lead to low equity:internal-external constraint models(L1,L2),economic constraint models(L3),and demand constraint models(L4,L5,L6,L7),with overall consistency and coverage of 0.967 and 0.795,respectively.Conclusions:Significant regional disparities exist in the equity of primary healthcare human resource allocation in China.Population density is a critical factor influencing allocation equity.The collaboration of various factors contributes to enhancing the equity of primary healthcare human resources distribution.Therefore,future efforts to enhance equity should focus on promoting inter-regional mobility and resource sharing,while precisely addressing regional shortcomings to achieve high equity in primary healthcare human resource allocation.
9.Research on practice guideline of health conversational artificial intelligence
Cheng-yu MA ; Hai-feng WU ; Yu-hui ZHANG ; Xue-fei GU ; You-li HAN
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):66-73
The development of artificial intelligence(AI)technology has provided new avenues for the public to access health information.While both domestic and international research and practical applications of health conversational AI have emerged,there remains a lack of consensus on the key issues surrounding their development.Based on a comprehensive review of domestic and international literature and multiple rounds of expert consultations,the study focuses on six issues:the definition,characteristics,application scenarios,evaluation elements,evaluation methods,as well as prospects and challenges of AI-driven health consultation systems,and develops the practice guideline for health conversational artificial intelligence.The findings aim to provide scientific reference for promoting the innovative application of AI technology in the healthcare field.
10.China's proposal of global public health cooperation in the context of reverse globalization
Rui-juan WANG ; Bang-dong WU ; Lu-zhuo-er PENG ; Yi SONG ; Ru-xin BAO ; Hao LI ; Ran REN ; Feng CHENG ; Xiao-hui LIANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2025;18(4):74-81
This paper uses literature and network data to systematically sort out the theoretical and practical foundations of global public health cooperation,combines expert interviews to conduct empirical analyses,and further explores China's strategies for participating in global public health cooperation through quantitative statistics and text mining of interview data,and proposes a plan for China's participation in global public health cooperation under the current international situation.Under the countercurrents to globalization,China should take its own public health capacity building as the foundation,put global security and health equity at the core,with a philosophy of open cooperation and sustainable development,actively promote bilateral and multilateral cooperation,focus on cultivating global health talents,and enhance the effectiveness of disease prevention and control by making use of existing platforms,international mechanisms and digital health technologies,so as to help build a Global Community of Health for All.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail