1.The dynamic transformation logic of ambiguous policy implementation mode:A case of the immediate settlement of trans-regional treatment policy
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):1-7
Objective:Under the highly complex and uncertain social conditions,ambiguity has increasingly become an important attribute of public policy.The implementation process of ambiguous policy is often accompanied by the dynamic transformation of the implementation mode.However,the transformation process and specific mechanism are still lack of in-depth discussion.Methods:Based on the modified Ambiguous-Conflict Model and Multiple Streams Framework,this paper constructs an analytical framework to explain the dynamic transformation of ambiguous policy implementation mode in the context of China,and takes the immediate settlement of trans-regional treatment policy as an example to explore the mechanism of the transformation.Results:It is found that the implementation mode of an ambiguous policy will undergo a dynamic transformation path from experimental implementation to symbolic implementation,then to political implementation,and finally towards administrative implementation.Conclusions and Suggestions:Multiple measures such as refined means of implementation,clear relationship between powers and responsibilities,top-down high-level driving,sufficient resources and digital technology,can help reduce the ambiguity and conflict of the policy and improve the effect of policy implementation.
2.Policy research on equalization of basic public health services from the perspective of policy tools
Hong HE ; Jun JIAO ; Wei-Wei YU ; Che DENG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):8-15
Objective:Quantitative analysis of policies on equalization of basic public health services was used,to comprehensive understanding of characteristics and the use of combinations of policy tools,and to provide recommendations for promoting equalization of basic public health services in China.Methods:The research object was policies on equalization of basic public health services by the central government from 2009 to 2022,and a three-dimensional policy analysis framework of"Policy tools(dimension X)-Stakeholders(dimension Y)-Policy process(dimension Z)"was constructed to carry out the content analysis of policies.Results:The proportion of supply-oriented policy tools was reasonable,and policy focus on government departments and policy implementation stage;Public health programs have been mainly used,and capacity enhancement of primary health care institutions has been valued and given financial and human resources support.However,there were structural dysfunction,imbalance in policy patterns of interest subjects,and uneven attention at policy stages.Suggestions:Promote the optimization of internal structure of policy tools,diversify policy attention to stakeholders,and rationalize distribute policy phases.
3.A quantitative research on China's basic medical insurance policy text for Traditional Chinese Medicine from the perspective of policy instrument
Sheng-Hui SHI ; Mao YOU ; Rui-Feng LI ; Xue-Qing TIAN ; Ping REN ; Lan-Tao WU ; Qiu-Ying ZHENG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):16-22
Objective:To summarize and analyze the composition characteristics and problems of basic medical insurance policies for traditional Chinese medicine in various provinces of China,providing reference for optimizing and improving subsequent basic medical insurance policies for traditional Chinese medicine.Methods:Based on the perspective of policy instrument,combined with two dimensions of policy instrument types and policy development process,the content analysis method is used to quantitatively analyze the content of the basic medical insurance policies for traditional Chinese medicine released at the provincial level from 2011 to 2023.Results:The 93 included policy documents were coded and sorted,with a cumulative total of 487 codes.From the perspective of policy instrument dimensions,subcategories of policy instruments involve diverse themes,but there are differences in the level of attention paid to each policy tool.From the perspective of policy development process,each link also presents a discrete trend,indicating a dominant feature of policy planning and implementation.Conclusion:To improve the basic medical insurance policy system of traditional Chinese medicine in China,it is necessary to optimize the combination of policy instrument and construct a coordinated and balanced policy instrument framework;Overall planning of the development process of traditional Chinese medicine medical insurance policies,highlighting the unique advantages of traditional Chinese medicine;Emphasize policy synergy between dimensions and strengthen the implementation of traditional Chinese medicine medical insurance policies.
4.Impacts of DRG/DIP payment reform on physicians' welfare and its mechanism research
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):23-29
Objective:To evaluate the effects of DRG/DIP payment reform and to study the impact of DRG/DIP payment reform on physicians'welfare.Methods:Based on the job demand-resource model,data from 251 samples collected using the questionnaire method were analyzed by multiple regression with city fixed effects.Results:The DRG/DIP payment reform reduced physicians'salary levels,and the impact on physicians'welfare differed significantly across departments.However,the negative effect of DRG/DIP payment reform on physicians'salary levels weakened as the standardization of the reform improved.Conclusions:Medical institutions should adjust the performance appraisal methods of physicians in a timely manner according to the structural impact of DRG/DIP payment reform and the actual situation of different departments,and continuously improve the standardization of DRG/DIP payment reform,so that the value of physicians'labor can be reflected and returned.
5.Research on the participation mechanism of basic medical insurance for platform workers:International experiences and implications for China
Xiao-Dou YU ; Kai-Ran ZHANG ; Hong-Bo WANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):30-37
The digital economy promotes economic growth and changes in employment patterns,but it also exposes platform workers to the risk of losing their basic medical insurance rights and interests.Based on the theory of inclusive governance,this paper constructs a three-dimensional analysis framework of opportunity-process-result for the participation mechanism,analyzes the international experiences of basic medical insurance participation mechanism for platform workers,and puts forward suggestions for optimizing the basic medical insurance participation mechanism in light of China's actual situation.The finding shows that the value orientation of realizing the universal health of medical insurance,the inclusive and coordinated participation mechanism,and the fair treatment of sharing and unification are the main strategies to deal with the issue of medical insurance participation of platform workers in the international arena.Therefore,it is recommended to firstly,expand and improve the basic medical insurance system covering the whole population with the concept of the supremacy of the right to health;secondly,promote the synergistic development among the stakeholders to enhance the systemic resilience of the basic medical insurance;and lastly,strengthen the function of mutual assistance and mutual aid of the basic medical insurance to promote the common prosperity effect of the basic medical insurance.
6.Comparison of patient trust patterns between tertiary hospitals and primary healthcare institutions:A mixed research based on interviews and survey experiment
Xi-Yang TONG ; Hong-Yu LI ; Jun SU ; Jin-Xin ZHANG ; Shi-Chao ZHAO ; Xiao-Jie SUN
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):38-44
Objective:This study utilizes a hybrid research design,integrating interviews with experimental surveys,to investigate the variances in patient trust models between tertiary hospitals and primary healthcare institutions.Methods:Thirty-eight residents participated in semi-structured interviews,which were then analyzed using content analysis.The experimental survey segment divided participants into two groups:"Tertiary Hospitals"and"Primary Healthcare Institutions,"resulting in 648 valid questionnaires.These questionnaires were subjected to variance analysis to assess differences.Results:Patients exhibit greater systemic trust in tertiary hospitals than in primary healthcare facilities,while interpersonal trust is stronger in primary healthcare settings.Suggestions:Therefore,strategies should be developed to bolster systemic trust at the primary level and emphasize the advantages of interpersonal trust.Moreover,specific measures are required to reshape patients'interpersonal trust in tertiary hospitals.
7.Life expectancy gap in provincial level district in China and its socio-economic determinants between 2000 and 2020
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):45-51
Objective:To estimate the life expectancy gap and trends in China's provincial regions from 2000 to 2020,and to examine the socioeconomic factors contributing to the life expectancy gaps.Methods:The log-quadratic model was used to estimate life expectancy,and influencing factors were analyzed based on principal components analysis and regression analysis.Results:The findings of the study indicate a significant reduction in the gap of life expectancy at birth among China's provincial regions from 2000 to 2020.However,the gap in life expectancy for the elderly population is widening.Socioeconomic status factors,risk factors,and health service factors account for 71%,60%,and 43%of the gap in life expectancy among provinces,respectively,collectively explaining 74%.Conclusions and Suggestions:The current life expectancy gap between provincial regions in China remains substantial,determined by socioeconomic status factors,risk factors,and health service factors.However,it is worth noting that the impact of a healthy lifestyle as a mediating factor is not as significant as anticipated,suggesting that cultural and environmental factors also play a role in the regional health gap.It is recommended that,effective interventions such as healthy lifestyles should be implemented,and secondly,focus on the impact of cultural and health service factors.
8.Weight analysis of the health performance evaluation index system for county health alliance based on entropy weight method
Yue-Ying CUI ; Chi ZHOU ; Rui-Hua FENG ; Lei YANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):52-57
Objective:After initially establishing a health performance evaluation index system for county health alliance,this study aimed to calculate the weight coefficients of various indicators and dimensions through the entropy weight method,which provided an evaluation orientation for county health alliance to achieve health-centered sustainable development.Methods:Based on existing research,the entropy weight method was used to standardize and calculate the weights of 27 indicators from five sample regions.Results:The weight coefficients for the three dimensions of construction structure,organizational process,and health outcomes are 0.261,0.301,and 0.439,respectively.In the construction structure dimension,the weight coefficients for inside-county medical utilization rate(0.105)and the proportion of outpatient and emergency visits in primary healthcare institutions inside-county(0.048)are relatively high.In the organizational process dimension,the weight coefficients for standardized management service rates for hypertension at the primary health care(0.062)and diabetes control rates(0.050)are relatively high.In the health outcome dimension,the weight coefficients for the low birth weight rate(0.072)and life expectancy(0.051)are relatively high.Conclusions:The weight coefficients of the health performance evaluation indicators for county health alliance calculated based on the entropy weight method highlighted the important role of health outcomes,as well as objectively reflect the contribution of each evaluation index to the health performance of the county health alliance.
9.Study on the strategy of the U.S.bilateral anti-malaria development assistance for health to Africa and implications
Jun-Yi SHI ; Yi-Kai FENG ; Yin-Zi JIN ; Ming-Hui REN
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):58-64
Objective:To analyze the characteristics of the U.S.bilateral anti-malaria development assistance for health(DAH)to Africa,and to provide suggestions for the future strategy of China's anti-malaria DAH.Methods:Policy analysis and descriptive statistical analysis were used to summarize the characteristics of the U.S.President's Malaria Initiative(PMI)in terms of funding input,program design,and monitoring and evaluation.Results:PMI had provided $8.62 billion to 24 African countries up to fiscal year 2022.Its assistance followed the framework of"prevention-case management-surveillance-behavioral interventions-health system capacity building",with more than 80%of total funding flowing to prevention and case management.In recent years,there has been increased support for surveillance and health system capacity building.The monitoring and evaluation included performance management and implement research.Conclusions and Suggestions:Characteristics of the U.S.bilateral anti-malaria DAH to Africa include:strong political commitment and high investment;program design that is consistent with international guidelines and integrated with its own advantages,and an emphasis on results-oriented evaluation and feedback learning.In the future,China should increase resource input to implement the political commitments,develop strategies for anti-malaria DAH based on national guidelines and domestic experience,and conduct project surveillance and evaluation.
10.The international pharmaceutical trade policies of the BRICS countries and its implications for China
Zuo-Kun LIU ; Wang-Yao MA ; Yi-Wu GU ; Yu-Yang ZHANG ; Ji-Yan MA ; Ming-Fan PANG ; Yi-Nuo SUN ; Yang-Mu HUANG
Chinese Journal of Health Policy 2024;17(4):65-71
This study adopted the policy text analysis method,review the historical background of the enactment,aimed to comparatively analyze the international pharmaceutical trade policies of the BRICS countries.The main objectives of the BRICS countries'international pharmaceutical trade policies included ensuring stable and accessible drug supply,expanding exports of domestic products and creating a favorable political environment.For these purposes,Brazil,Russia,and South Africa all ensure drug supply through substantial imports.However,they have also taken measures such as compulsory patent licensing and promoting localization of production by foreign companies to reduce import dependence.India,on the other hand,protects its domestic industry by resisting drug imports to ensure drug supply while simultaneously promoting the export of pharmaceutical products.China continually optimizes approval and data monitoring procedures to align with international standards,creating a favorable trade environment and expanding exports.China should further refine its international pharmaceutical trade policies while ensuring the autonomy of domestic drug research and supply,fostering stronger collaboration within BRICS nations and promoting global access to public healthcare products.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail