1.Quality Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines and Expert Consensus Statements for Knee Osteoarthritis Based on AGREE Ⅱ (2019—2025)
Yifan LU ; Zhuo YANG ; Hui XIONG ; Gonghui JIAN ; Xiaolong LU ; Pei CHEN ; Wenjie SU ; Zebing MA ; Tianxiao CHEN ; Simin TANG ; Tao WANG
Chinese Journal of Experimental Traditional Medical Formulae 2026;32(23):186-195
ObjectiveTo evaluate the quality of clinical practice guidelines and expert consensus statements on knee osteoarthritis (KOA) based on the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation Ⅱ (AGREE Ⅱ), thus providing a new perspective for clinical selection as well as guideline development and updating. MethodsA systematic search was conducted for KOA-related guidelines and consensus statements published from November 1, 2019 to December 31, 2025. The databases and platforms searched included CNKI, VIP, Wanfang Data, PubMed, Web of Science, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), SinoMed, Yimaitong, and relevant official websites. Two researchers independently screened the literature, and four researchers used AGREE Ⅱ to score the included documents and completed the quality appraisal after reaching a unified understanding. Subgroup analyses were further performed according to developing organization, document type, medical approach, funding status, and region of development, and longitudinal comparisons were conducted by year of publication. ResultsA total of 23 guidelines and consensus statements were included. The standardized scores of the six AGREE Ⅱ domains, from the highest to the lowest, were clarity of presentation [(70.36±8.13)%], scope and purpose [(67.46 ± 11.44)%], editorial independence [(64.50±20.01)%], rigor of development [(62.24±15.26)%], stakeholder involvement [(55.73±10.29)%], and applicability [(53.89±13.17)%]. In terms of overall recommendation, 6 documents were rated as grade A and 17 as grade B. Stratified analyses showed that professional organizations scored higher than comprehensive organizations. The overall scores of traditional Chinese medicine/integrative medicine and Western medicine guidelines (or consensus statements) were similar. Guidelines scored higher than consensus statements. The overall scores were similar between documents with reported funding and those without reported funding. International guidelines scored higher than domestic guidelines. Longitudinal comparisons showed that the largest number of documents was published in 2021. The overall scores were higher in 2021—2022, and some domain scores declined in 2023—2024. Overall, the quality of recent guidelines and consensus statements for KOA showed slight fluctuations, without a clear linear trend. ConclusionThe included guidelines and consensus statements for KOA can generally serve as references for clinical practice. However, the quality across domains remains uneven, and stakeholder involvement and applicability are still weak domains. Future guideline development and updating should further improve methodological standardization and transparency in reporting.
2.Comparison of thoracoscopic 2 hole and 3 hole for congenital pulmonary bulla resection
Tianxiao TAO ; Huaishun XIN ; Changhai SUN ; Xinwei ZHANG ; Xiwu FENG
Chinese Journal of Primary Medicine and Pharmacy 2014;(24):3725-3726,3727
Objective To compare the effects of thoracoscopic 2 hole and 3 hole for congenital pulmonary bulla resection.Methods 38 cases of congenital pulmonary bulla patients,both in the VATS downlink congenital pulmonary bulla resection.According to the number of holes,thoracoscopic operation were divided into the two groups. To observe the use of group 19 cases of 2 holes,19 cases 3 holes were adopted in the control group.Pull the chest tube operation time,operation time of the two groups were compared after.and the average hospitalization time after opera-tion,postoperative analgesia drug application.Results The observation group operation time,operation time,pulling the chest tube after operation the average hospitalization time, analgesic drug application rate respectively were (46.89 ±9.11)min,(3.95 ±0.85) d,(7.37 ±1.34) d,21.1%,The control group were (66.05 ±12.09) min, (4.37 ±0.98)d,(7.32 ±1.57)d,52.6%.There were statistically significant differences in rate of the two groups in operation time,analgesic drug application.(t=-5.516,χ2 =4.071,P<0.05);38 cases were cured,followed up for 3-24 months,no recurrence occurred in 1 cases.Conclusion Video assisted thoracic descending congenital pulmona-ry bulla resection,the 2 hole 3 hole more than minimally invasive,short operation time,postoperative analgesic use rate is low.
3.Clinical analysis of surgical treatment for the aged patients with primary NSCLC: a report of 35 cases
Xiwu FENG ; Changhai SUN ; Jizhou ZHANG ; Huaishun XIE ; Xinwei ZHNAG ; Tianxiao TAO ; Shixue LIU
Chinese Journal of Primary Medicine and Pharmacy 2013;20(14):2139-2141
Objective To investigate the clinical feature of perioperative management of non-small cell lung cancer(NSCLC) in aged patients and improve the efficacy of surgical treatment.Methods The clinical data of 35 aged patients with NSCLC were retrospectively analyzed.The risk factors of postoperative complications were analyzed by single factor analysis,the factors had statistical significance were included in Logistic regression analysis.Results Postoperative complications occurred in 10 cases,accounting for 28.6%,and 1 case died,accounting for 2.9%.Logistic regression analysis showed that smoking,chronic bronchitis,coronary heart disease,pulmonary lobectomy were independent risk factors of postoperative complications.ConCLusion Correct staging before operation,strict surgical indication,choose the standard surgical method to reduce surgical trauma,strengthen the perioperative management can still achieve satisfactory therapeutic effect in surgical operation for aged patients with NSCLC.

Result Analysis
Print
Save
E-mail