Objective: To develop a low-cost 3D-printed Laryngeal Injection Task Trainer (LITT) for simulation of transcutaneous injection laryngoplasty and evaluate its effectiveness among trainees. Methods: Design: Cross-Sectional Time-Motion Study and Post-Training Evaluation Survey Setting: Tertiary University College of Medicine Anatomy Laboratory Participants: Five residents and 2 consultants in Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery were trained using a LITT fabricated through three-dimensional printing of cartilage models and silicone molds through the UP SIBOL Greenhouse and the Philippine General Hospital Craniomaxillofacial Prosthesis Unit. Participants were asked to perform transcutaneous laryngeal injection on the LITT. The duration in performing the procedure from palpation of landmarks to injection of material was measured in seconds and recorded. After the simulation workshop, participants were asked to evaluate the subjective experience with surgical simulation using the modified Michigan Standard Simulation Experience Scale (MiSSES). Results: The mean time in performing transcutaneous laryngeal injection across different training levels for either trans-cricothyroid or trans-thyrohyoid approach was not statistically significant. Mean time in performing transcutaneous laryngeal injection between 2 approaches, the trans-cricothyroid approach (79.32 seconds with SD 34.89) and the trans-thyrohyoid approach (35.16 seconds with SD of 10.88), was statistically significant. Using the MiSSES tool for evaluation of the simulation training, majority of the participants agreed that the LITT allowed self-efficacy in performing the procedure, had adequate fidelity in terms of its characteristics and components, had high educational value in training participants for knowledge and skills on transcutaneous laryngeal injection and that the simulation provided good teaching quality. For the overall rating, all participants concurred, with 83.3% of participants answering strongly agree and 16.7% of participants responding somewhat agree, that the simulation experience was helpful in knowledge and skills development on transcutaneous laryngeal injection. On final evaluation of the LITT, 75% of the participants responded that it can be used in training but should be improved slightly. Conclusion The laryngeal injection task trainer (LITT) had an acceptable fidelity, educational value, teaching quality to improve self-efficacy in performing transcutaneous injection laryngoplasty - with points for improvement in terms of model and set-up stability, color accuracy and consistency of the visual indicator. It is recommended that the LITT be also used for future workshops and possibly further validation studies after applying the points for improvement gathered from this simulation study.

Background and Objective: The COVID 19 pandemic has changed the way the human anatomy is taught. A necessary shift towards online instruction, combined with a decrease in cadaver donation has resulted in the need for maximizing formalinized, soft-embalmed, computerized, and plastinated cadaver specimens. Task-oriented activities allow students to demonstrate acquired knowledge and skills. It is the aim of this study to get the perspective of students in the utilization of available laboratory materials. Methods: One hundred forty-three students participated in task-oriented activities. Students demonstrated anatomy of the facial nerve, recurrent laryngeal nerve, and phrenic nerve by parotidectomy, thyroidectomy, and posterior neck dissection using formalinized cadaver and VH dissector™. Deep neck and sagittal structures in the plastinated specimen were identified using laser pointers. Ossicular mobility of the middle ear, and endoscopy of the nose and larynx were demonstrated using the soft embalmed cadaver. Students were surveyed on their perceptions on the utility of each cadaver specimen. Results: Formalinized and soft-embalmed cadaver were observed to present the most accurate anatomy, while the virtual dissector and plastinated specimens were seen to be the most sustainable and reusable. Conclusion Task-oriented learning in head and neck anatomy may use different cadaveric materials with varied accuracy and utility.
Anatomy ; Cadaver ; Education, Medical

Background and Objective: The pandemic acted as an accelerator for the development of online teaching formats in anatomy and histology worldwide. The authors introduce a bridging program that reinforces the knowledge and understanding of gross and correlative anatomy and histology acquired in a virtual environment in preparation for its future clinical application. The study aims to evaluate the Learning Enhancement in Anatomy Program (LEAP) conducted among first-year medical students at the College of Medicine, University of the Philippines Manila. Methods: This descriptive cross-sectional study aims to determine the initial experience of implementing a learning enhancement program and assess areas for its improvement. An internally validated questionnaire was given to students after the program to gauge students’ reactions (Kirkpatrick Level 1 evaluation). Pre- and post-tests were administered to evaluate knowledge acquisition (Kirkpatrick Level 2 evaluation). Short-term behavioral peer evaluation (Kirkpatrick Level 3 evaluation) was also instituted. Results: One hundred fifty-two (152) students participated in the study. General reactions from students to the LEAP were consistently positive, with a steady majority of the students rating ‘5’ or a ‘Strongly Agree’ to positive statements regarding the program. Higher ratings for more traditional teaching methods, such as cadavers, formalinized specimens, and bones, compared to virtual systems were apparent. However, inter-student variation in preference for teaching modalities was observed. All stations of the LEAP were evaluated satisfactorily, with most gross anatomy stations rated higher than histology stations. A significant increase was noted in the total post-test scores compared to pre-test scores. This improvement in test scores was observed in the anatomy and histology subcategories and in six of the seven organ system modules. Perceived behavioral outcomes were also generally positive. Conclusion The LEAP is a worthwhile endeavor, garnering overwhelmingly positive reactions and a significant improvement in test scores. Future studies are necessary to fine-tune teaching and training in a blended learning environment.
Anatomy ; COVID-19 ; Education, Medical ; Program Evaluation

Objective: We aim to determine the association between preoperative CT scan findings of thyroid cartilage invasion, cricoid cartilage invasion, and paraglottic space involvement with tumor extension to the thyroid gland on final histopathology among patients with laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) in a tertiary hospital in the Philippines. Methods: Patients with histopathologically-confirmed laryngeal SCC who underwent total laryngectomy with thyroidectomy while admitted at the public ward of the Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Philippine General Hospital, from January 2013 to December 2019 were included. CT scans were reviewed by 2 blinded independent radiologists. CT scan data including subsite/s involved, thyroid cartilage/cricoid cartilage erosion, paraglottic space involvement, thyroid gland involvement, and thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology were gathered. Clinicopathologic data such as age, T Stage, early tracheostomy, and time between CT scan and surgery were also collected and analyzed. Fisher’s exact test was computed for both clinicopathologic and CT scan data with a significant value having p<0.05. Cramer’s V and phi coefficient were computed for nondichotomous and dichotomous variables, respectively. Odds ratio was also computed for dichotomous variables with p<0.05 on Fisher’s exact test. Results: Fifty-nine (59) men and 4 women were included, aged 43 to 81 years old. Most patients were classified as T3 (n=18) and T4 (n=41) (total=93.7%), with most having transglottic primary tumors (n=29, 46%), and only 8 (12.7%) patients having subglottic tumor involvement on final histopathology. Thyroid cartilage erosion or invasion were noted in 63.4% (n=40) of patients’ CT scans and 58.7% (n=37) of patients’ final histopathology reports. Cricoid cartilage and paraglottic space involvement were often not reported on final histopathology results. Thyroid gland involvement was only noted in the final histopathology reports of 5 patients (7.9%). Significant association between cricoid cartilage findings (p=0.032, Cramer’s V=0.318) or thyroid gland involvement on CT scan (p=0.018, Phi=0.384; OR 13 95% CI 1.797, 94.035) with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology was noted. The rest of the variables had no significant association with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology. Conclusion Cricoid cartilage involvement (erosion or invasion) and thyroid gland involvement on CT scan are associated with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology in patients with laryngeal SCC. Patients with these CT scan findings may stand to benefit more from thyroidectomy to ensure good margins of resection.
Laryngeal Neoplasms ; Thyroidectomy ; Carcinoma ; Epithelial Cells

Background. Simulators in laryngology are an essential part of training. They provide an avenue for medical students and resident trainees to practice valuable psychomotor skills outside the realm of an actual patient encounter - thereby decreasing the risk of possible patient morbidity. Herein we present three locally manufactured simulation devices that can be used to train residents in laryngology procedures.

Objective. To present three simulation platform devices (Laser Box, Flexible Endoscopy Simulation, Thiel Cadaver Chair) and their applications in simulation-based learning

Methods. The Laser Box, Flexible Endoscopy Simulation, and Thiel Cadaver Chair were manufactured by outside parties designated as 'Laser Machinists'.

Results. Ten (10) units of the Laser Box, two (2) units of the Thiel Cadaver Chair, and two (2) units of the Flexible Endoscopy Simulation were constructed. They were used in a laryngology postgraduate course in our institution to teach the participants on endoscopies and laser phonosurgery.

Conclusion. Simulation for otolaryngologic procedures should be an essential part of training. The learning curve for procedures such as laryngoscopy and laser phonosurgery can be addressed with the production of simulation platforms. Most institutions in the Philippines still adopt the "see one, do one, teach one" approach, which lacks standardization and puts patients at risk. Various task trainers for laser phonosurgery and flexible endoscopy have been reported in the literature, but there seems to be no published data on the use of a cadaver chair for simulation. In the COVID-19 era, aside from being excellent teaching tools, simulation platforms derive their importance in helping train residents, educate medical students, and review consultants - maximizing skill development - and thereby decreasing repeated attempts, and indirectly, exposure to the SARS-CoV-2. Future validation studies are required for the models, with the eventual long-term goals to further standardize training, increase patient safety and incorporate a simulation-based curriculum for the specialty locally.

Objective. To determine the diagnostic accuracy of self-collected snorted and spit saliva in detecting COVID-19 using RT-PCR (ssRT-PCR) and lateral flow antigen test (ssLFA) versus nasopharyngeal swab RT-PCR (npRT-PCR). Methods. One hundred ninety-seven symptomatic subjects for COVID-19 testing in a tertiary hospital underwent snort-spit saliva self-collection for RT-PCR and antigen testing and nasopharyngeal swab for RT-PCR as reference. Positivity rates, agreement, sensitivity, specificity, and likelihood ratios were estimated. Results. Estimated prevalence of COVID-19 using npRT-PCR was 9% (exact 95% CI of 5.5% - 14.1%). A higher positivity rate of 13% in the ssRT-PCR assay suggested possible higher viral RNA in the snort-spit samples. There was 92.9% agreement between ssRT-PCR and npRT-PCR (exact 95% CI of 88.4% to 96.1%; Cohen’s Kappa of 0.6435). If npRT-PCR will be assumed as reference standard, the estimated Sensitivity was 83.3% (exact 95% CI of 60.8% to 94.2%), Specificity 93.9% (exact 95% CI of 89.3% to 96.5%), Positive predictive value of 57.7% (exact 95% CI of 38.9% to 74.5%), Negative predictive value of 98.2% (exact 95% CI of 95% to 99.4%), positive likelihood ratio of 3.65 (95% CI of 7.37 to 24.9), negative likelihood ratio of 0.178 (95% CI of 0.063 to 0.499). There was 84.84% agreement (95% exact CI of 79.1% to 89.5%; Cohen’s Kappa of 0.2356) between ssLFAvs npRT-PCR, sensitivity of 38.9% (exact 95% CI of 20.3% to 61.4%), specificity of 89.4% (exact 95% CI of 84.1% to 93.1%), PPV of 26.9% (95% CI of 13.7% to 46.1%), NPV of 93.6% (exact 95% CI of 88.8% to 96.4%), LR+ of 3.67 (95% CI of 1.79 - 7.51), LR – of 0.68 (95% CI of 0.47 - 0.99). Conclusion. Our data showed that snort-spit saliva RT-PCR testing had acceptable diagnostic performance characteristics and can potentially be used as an alternative to the standard nasopharyngeal/oropharyngeal swab RT-PCR test for COVID-19 in certain situations. However, our data also showed that snort-spit saliva antigen testing using lateral flow assay did not offer acceptable performance.
Saliva ; SARS-CoV-2 ; Reverse Transcription ; Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction

Objective: This study aims to investigate which, if any head and neck symptoms (trismus, dysphagia, alterations in speech or facial movements, and dyspnea) might be good predictors of outcomes (mortality, tracheostomy, discharged, decannulated) and prognosis of tetanus patients. Methods: Design: Retrospective Cohort Study Setting: Tertiary National University Hospital Patients: Seventy-three (73) pediatric and adult patients diagnosed with tetanus and admitted at the emergency room of the Philippine General Hospital between January 1, 2013 and December 31, 2017. Demographic characteristics, incubation periods, periods of onset, routes of entry, head and neck symptoms, stage, and outcomes were retrieved from medical records and analyzed. Results: Of the 73 patients included, 53 (73%) were adults, while the remaining 20 (27%) were pediatric. The three most common head and neck symptoms were trismus (48; 66%), neck pain/ rigidity (35; 48%), and dysphagia to solids (31; 42%). Results of multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that only trismus (OR = 3.742, p = .015) and neck pain/ rigidity (OR = 4.135, p = .015) were significant predictors of decannulation. No dependent variable/symptoms had a significant effect in predicting discharge and mortality. Conclusion: Clinically diagnosed tetanus can be easily recognized and immediately treated. Most of the early complaints are head and neck symptoms that can help in early diagnosis and treatment resulting in better prognosis. In particular, trismus and neck pain/rigidity may predict the outcome of decannulation after early tracheotomy, but not of discharge and mortality.
tracheotomy ; tetanus ; trismus ; Neck Pain ; Muscle Rigidity

Objective: To review available resources and provide evidence-based recommendations that may optimize otorhinolaryngologic out-patient health care delivery in the “post”-COVID-19 era while ensuring the safety of our patients, healthcare workers and staff. Data Sources: Relevant peer-reviewed journal articles; task force, organizational and institutional, government and non-government organization recommendations; published guidelines from medical, health-related, and scientific organizations. Methods: A comprehensive review of the literature on the COVID-19 pandemic as it pertained to “post”-COVID 19 out-patient otorhinolaryngologic practice was obtained from peer-reviewed articles, guidelines, recommendations, and statements that were identified through a structured search of the data sources for relevant literature utilizing MEDLINE (through PubMed and PubMed Central PMC), Google (and Google Scholar), HERDIN Plus, the World Health Organization (WHO) Global Health Library, and grey literature including social media (blogs, Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook). In-patient management (including ORL surgical procedures such as tracheostomy) were excluded. Retrieved material was critically appraised and organized according to five discussion themes: physical office set-up, patient processing, personal protection, procedures, and prevention and health-promotion. Conclusion These recommendations are consistent with the best available evidence to date, and are globally acceptable while being locally applicable. They address the concerns of otorhinolaryngologists and related specialists about resuming office practice during the “post”-COVID-19 period when strict quarantines are gradually lifted and a transition to the “new” normal is made despite the unavailability of a specific vaccine for SARS-CoV-2. While they target practice settings in the Philippines, they should be useful to ENT (ear, nose & throat) surgeons in other countries in ensuring a balance between service and safety as we continue to serve our patients during these challenging times.

Objective: We aim to determine the association between preoperative CT scan findings of thyroid cartilage invasion, cricoid cartilage invasion, and paraglottic space involvement with tumor extension to the thyroid gland on final histopathology among patients with laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) in a tertiary hospital in the Philippines. Methods: Patients with histopathologically-confirmed laryngeal SCC who underwent total laryngectomy with thyroidectomy while admitted at the public ward of the Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Philippine General Hospital, from January 2013 to December 2019 were included. CT scans were reviewed by 2 blinded independent radiologists. CT scan data including subsite/s involved, thyroid cartilage/cricoid cartilage erosion, paraglottic space involvement, thyroid gland involvement, and thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology were gathered. Clinicopathologic data such as age, T Stage, early tracheostomy, and time between CT scan and surgery were also collected and analyzed. Fisher’s exact test was computed for both clinicopathologic and CT scan data with a significant value having p<0.05. Cramer’s V and phi coefficient were computed for nondichotomous and dichotomous variables, respectively. Odds ratio was also computed for dichotomous variables with p<0.05 on Fisher’s exact test. Results: Fifty-nine (59) men and 4 women were included, aged 43 to 81 years old. Most patients were classified as T3 (n=18) and T4 (n=41) (total=93.7%), with most having transglottic primary tumors (n=29, 46%), and only 8 (12.7%) patients having subglottic tumor involvement on final histopathology. Thyroid cartilage erosion or invasion were noted in 63.4% (n=40) of patients’ CT scans and 58.7% (n=37) of patients’ final histopathology reports. Cricoid cartilage and paraglottic space involvement were often not reported on final histopathology results. Thyroid gland involvement was only noted in the final histopathology reports of 5 patients (7.9%). Significant association between cricoid cartilage findings (p=0.032, Cramer’s V=0.318) or thyroid gland involvement on CT scan (p=0.018, Phi=0.384; OR 13 95% CI 1.797, 94.035) with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology was noted. The rest of the variables had no significant association with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology. Conclusion Cricoid cartilage involvement (erosion or invasion) and thyroid gland involvement on CT scan are associated with thyroid gland involvement on final histopathology in patients with laryngeal SCC. Patients with these CT scan findings may stand to benefit more from thyroidectomy to ensure good margins of resection.
Laryngeal Neoplasms ; Thyroidectomy ; Carcinoma ; Epithelial Cells

Objective: To report a case of thyroglossal duct carcinoma with concurrent papillary thyroid carcinoma Methods: Design: Case Report. Setting: Tertiary National University Hospital. Patient: One. Results: A 46-year-old woman was diagnosed with thyroglossal duct carcinoma after undergoing a Sistrunk procedure. Due to presence of thyroid nodules, the patient underwent second stage thyroidectomy with central neck dissection which revealed papillary thyroid carcinoma. Conclusion Thyroglossal duct carcinomas are rare entities and there is no current consensus regarding their management. Difficulties arise in the diagnosis of these tumors as they present similarly to benign thyroglossal duct cysts. Most cases are diagnosed postoperatively. Proper preoperative assessment including head and neck examination, biopsy, and radiologic imaging is necessary to recognize patients who could benefit from more aggressive management.
Thyroglossal Cyst ; Thyroid Cancer, Papillary