Comprehensive evaluation of columns in Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine
10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-4912.2021.08.014
- VernacularTitle:《中国小儿急救医学》栏目设置综合评价研究
- Author:
Qiang LIN
1
;
Wei LI
;
Xin XU
;
Wei ZHANG
;
Nan LIN
;
Chunfeng LIU
Author Information
1. 中国医科大学附属盛京医院《中国小儿急救医学》编辑部，沈阳 110004
- Keywords:
Column;
Comment column;
Guidance column;
Treatise column;
Communication index;
Citation index
- From:
Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine
2021;28(8):707-711
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:This paper makes a comprehensive evaluation on the columns of Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine from communication effect and citation effect, and analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of each column setting, so as to provide evidence-based basis for journal soliciting contributions, and guide column selection planning.Methods:The communication index (website browsing frequency, website download frequency, Wanfang download frequency) and citation index (citation frequency, zero citation rate, high citation rate, high citation rate ratio) of columns in Chinese Pediatric Emergency Medicine from 2016 to 2018 were counted, and whether there were statistical differences among the evaluation indexes of columns was analyzed.Results:In terms of communication index: among the top 20 column communication indicators, comments and guidance columns account for a very high proportion; The communication index of comment column and guidance column was significantly higher than that of other columns, and the differences were statistically significant; There was no significant difference between Article column and Clinical application research column.In terms of citation index: the citation frequency and high citation rate of the Article column are the highest, while the zero citation rate is the lowest, and there was no significant difference among the four columns of Expert forum, Clinical application research, Review and Guideline·consensus·interpretation; The high citation rate ratio of the Guideline·consensus·interpretation column is the highest, followed by the Article column, and the two columns are significantly higher than the Expert forum column; Among the top 20 papers with the highest citation frequency, the column of treatise accounts for 65%.Conclusion:Expert forum column and Guidelin·consensus·interpretation column are the key to influence the communication effect of journals.Article column and Guidelin·consensus·interpretation column are the key to influence the citation effect of journals.The absolute value of evaluation index can not scientifically evaluate the academic quality of journals.
