VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY OF DIGITAL PHOTOS AS A DIAGNOSTIC TOOL FOR DETERMINATION OF CARIES
- Author:
Mohd Faiz Nasruddin
1
;
Noorharliana Mohamed Zohdi
1
;
Siti Aisyah Roslan
1
;
Nik Mohd Mazuan Nik Mohd Rosdy
2
Author Information
- Publication Type:Other Types
- Keywords: Diagnosis; Digital Images; International Caries Detection Assessment System (ICDAS); Reliability and Validity
- From: Journal of University of Malaya Medical Centre 2024;27(Special Issue):90-96
- CountryMalaysia
- Language:English
- Abstract: VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY OF DIGITAL PHOTOS AS A DIAGNOSTIC TOOL FOR DETERMINATION OF CARIES:Objectives: The impact of COVID-19 on dental care and the adoption of tele-dentistry for caries detection needs investigating. The pandemic led to the use of digital photography, including DSLR cameras and smartphones, for remote dental operations. Literature suggests that use of digital images was found to enhance caries detection sensitivity compared to visual examination. The study aims were 1) to compare the reliability of visual inspection and digital photographs for caries diagnosis among dental clinicians and 2) to compare diagnostic tools of determination of caries between full ICDAS codes and modified ICDAS codes utilization. Methods: The research involved 45 postgraduate dental students examining 45 extracted permanent teeth using full ICDAS scores and modified ICDAS scores in three phases (Full Visual ICDAS, Digital ICDAS and Combination of Visual and Digital ICDAS). Kappa scores, sensitivity, specificity and Area Under the Curve (AUC) readings between participants answers and benchmark answers were determined. Results: Statistical analysis revealed that introducing digital images reduced inter-rater agreement, however modified ICDAS codes utilization showed comparable results between visual and digital methods. Intra-rater agreement for visual and modified ICDAS was high, while digital images showed moderate agreement. Sensitivity for caries detection was around 93% for visual and digital methods, and specificity ranged from 67% to 80%. The AUC values indicated good performance (0.89) for both full and modified ICDAS with visual examination and lower values for digital examination (0.81-0.82). Discussion: Results were consistent with prior studies however this research highlights video/image efficacy, emphasizing validity, reliability, and improved clinician planning using modified ICDAS. Conclusion: Use of digital photographs for caries diagnosis were promising and the use of modified ICDAS codes were comparable to conventional use of full ICDAS codes. Overall, the study demonstrated the potential benefits of digital methods in dental caries diagnosis and tele-dentistry practices.
- Full text:2026080219304440855VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY.pdf
