Interobserver variability in chronic atrophic gastritis diagnosis using endoscopic Kimura-Takemoto classification
10.3760/cma.j.cn321463-20250114-00499
- VernacularTitle:慢性萎缩性胃炎内镜下木村-竹本分型诊断异质性研究
- Author:
Hengyu WANG
1
;
Wen CHEN
;
Mingkai CHEN
;
Yufeng LEI
;
Lei CHEN
Author Information
1. 陆军军医大学第一附属医院消化内科，重庆 400038
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Gastroscopy;
Chronic atrophic gastritis;
Diagnostic accuracy;
Variability
- From:
Chinese Journal of Digestive Endoscopy
2025;42(4):307-313
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To analyze interobserver variability in endoscopic diagnostic accuracy of chronic atrophic gastritis (CAG) among endoscopists with varying levels of experience.Methods:Endoscopic examination data from 247 patients who underwent endoscopy from January 2021 to June 2024 at Department of Gastroenterology, the First Affiliated Hospital of Army Medical University ( n=154), Renmin Hospital of Wuhan University ( n=35) and Shanxi Provincial Coal Central Hospital ( n=58) were retrospectively collected. The collected images were reviewed by an expert panel of three individuals with the title of deputy chief physician or above. The final endoscopic Kimura-Takemoto classification diagnosis of the expert panel was regarded as the golden standard. Fourteen endoscopists from the above three centers provided their Kimura-Takemoto classification diagnosis. These endoscopists were divided into the junior group ( n=7, with experience of <2 000 procedures) and the senior group ( n=7, with experience of >10 000 procedures). The difference in the accuracy of endoscopic Kimura-Takemoto classification diagnosis between the groups were analyzed. Results:Diagnostic accuracy for Kimura-Takemoto classification ranged from 65.99% (163/247) to 86.64% (214/247) in the senior group with the overall accuracy of 77.27% (1 336/1 729). The junior group exhibited diagnostic accuracy ranging from 36.44% (90/247) to 72.47% (179/247) with the overall accuracy of 62.12% (1 074/1 729). The senior group demonstrated higher overall diagnostic accuracy than that of the junior group ( χ 2=93.27, P<0.001). The diagnostic accuracy of non-CAG in the senior group was higher than that in the junior group [83.73% (463/553) VS 72.33% (400/553), χ 2=20.27, P<0.001]. The diagnostic accuracy of C-type atrophy in the senior group was higher than that in the junior group [90.10% (801/889) VS 82.79% (736/889), χ 2=19.66, P<0.001] .The diagnostic accuracy of O-type atrophy in the senior group was higher than that in the junior group [83.97% (241/287) VS 68.29% (196/287), χ 2=18.56, P<0.001]. Conclusion:Interobserver variability is observed in the diagnostic accuracy of endoscopic Kimura-Takemoto classification for CAG among endoscopists with different experience levels. Experienced endoscopists exhibit higher diagnostic accuracy for CAG compared with their less experienced counterparts.
