Exploration on statistics and method of the results of resolution parameters of quality control method of diagnostic equipment with ultrasound based on real world data
10.3969/j.issn.1672-8270.2025.06.007
- VernacularTitle:基于真实世界数据的超声诊断设备质量控制分辨力检测参数分析及性能检测方法探讨
- Author:
Zhipeng LIU
1
;
Mingming LI
;
Zhigang CUI
;
Chunhua YANG
;
Yang LI
Author Information
1. 江苏省人民医院(南京医科大学第一附属医院)临床医学工程处 南京 210000
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Ultrasound diagnostic equipment;
Performance testing;
Real world study;
Quality control;
Mutual recognition of results
- From:
China Medical Equipment
2025;22(6):35-38
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To explore more objective detection method for the performance of diagnostic equipment with ultrasound,so as to demonstrate that the subjectivity of the interpretation criteria will affect the results of resolution parameters of detection performance of ultrasonic equipment.Methods:A total of 77 conventional probes of 33 ultrasound equipment of Jiangsu Provincial Hospital were collected and sorted out.The resolution parameters of their performance were tested twice from 2022 to 2023 by the technical personnel of our institute and the tester of Jiangsu Institute of Metrology.The data was described by using the quartiles method.The resolution parameters of performances of ultrasound equipment and probes were paired to conduct Wilcoxon rank sum test,so as to compare the differences in same institute between different years,and in same year between different institute in testing the resolution parameters of performances of ultrasound equipment and probes.Results:For linear array probes,as long as the performance was tested in accordance with the standard method,there was no statistically significant difference in the resolution parameters measured between different institutes and between different times(P>0.05).For the convex array probe,in 2023,the lateral resolution[2(2,2)]of the 70mm target group,and the axial and lateral resolutions[1(1,1)and 3(3,3.25)]of the 120mm target group of our institute were different with the lateral resolution[2(1,2)]of the 70mm target group,and the axial and lateral resolutions[2(2,3)and 2(2,3)]of the 120mm target group of Jiangsu Institute of Metrology,and the differences of them between our institute and Jiangsu Institute of Metrology were significant(Z=-2.887,-2.53,-3.69,P<0.05),respectively.In our institute,the axial and lateral resolutions[1(1,2)and 2.5(2,3)]of the 70mm target group,and the axial resolution[1(1,2)]of the 120mm target group in 2022 were different with the axial and lateral resolutions[1(1,1)and 2(2,2)]of the 70mm target group,and the axial resolution[1(1,1)]of the 120mm target group in 2023,and the differences of them between two years were significant(Z=-3.317,-3.419,-2.982,P<0.05).In Jiangsu Institute of Metrology,the lateral resolutions of the 70mm target group,and the axial resolution[1(1,1)]of the 120mm target group in 2022 year were different with those in 2023 year,and the differences of them were significant(Z=-2.333,-3.051,P<0.05),respectively.Conclusion:The interpretation for lateral resolution of convex array probe in target group with high depth,the difference of subjective interpretation criteria will cause the essential difference of final results.This paper suggested that the key image should be retained when the resolution of the image of target group with high depth of the convex array probe is interpreted.At the later stage,artificial intelligence(AI)-assisted quality control can also be introduced to conduct objective interpretation by computers.
