Comparison of erector spinae plane block at T 2 and nerve root block at C 5 in patients undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery with general anesthesia
10.3760/cma.j.cn131073-20240613-00611
- VernacularTitle:T 2竖脊肌平面阻滞和C 5脊神经根阻滞用于全身麻醉肩关节镜手术效果的比较
- Author:
Kun WANG
1
;
Xiangang KONG
;
Chengjun SONG
;
Chengwei SONG
;
Chengwen LI
Author Information
1. 济宁市第一人民医院麻醉科，济宁 272011
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Nerve Block;
Erector spinae;
Spinal nerve roots;
Anesthesia, general;
Arthroscopy;
Shoulder joint
- From:
Chinese Journal of Anesthesiology
2025;45(6):726-731
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To compare the effects of erector spinae plane block at T 2 (T 2-ESPB) and nerve root block at C 5 (C 5-NRB) in patients undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery with general anesthesia. Methods:This was a randomized, controlled, non-inferiority study. Sixty American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status classification I or Ⅱ patients, aged 45-75 yr, with body mass index ≤35 kg/m 2, scheduled for elective arthroscopic shoulder surgery at Jining No. 1 People′s Hospital from April 2023 to February 2024, were included and divided into 2 groups ( n=30 each) using a random number table method: C 5-NRB group (group C) and T 2-ESPB group (group T). In group C, C 5-NRB was carried out by injecting 0.5% ropivacaine 5 ml. In group T, T 2-ESPB was performed by injecting 0.25% ropivacaine 30 ml. The efficacy of nerve block was assessed using a prick test at 30 min after administration, and then total intravenous anesthesia was performed in both groups. The time to first rescue analgesia (the non-inferiority boundary Δ =2 h), requirement for rescue analgesia within 24 h after operation and intraoperative consumption of anesthetics were recorded. The motor function of the affected limb during shoulder abduction, elbow flexion and elbow extension was assessed and scored using the modified Bromage scale (MBS) at 30 min and 4 and 12 h after nerve block. The diaphragmatic excursion was measured and recorded using M-mode ultrasound before nerve block and at 30 min after nerve block to evaluate the occurrence of diaphragmatic paralysis. Complications such as local anesthetic toxicity, recurrent laryngeal nerve block and pneumothorax were also recorded. Results:The mean difference (95% confidence interval) for the time to first rescue analgesia between the two groups was 5.551 (1.875-9.148) h, with the upper limit exceeding the non-inferiority boundary. Compared with group T, the intraoperative consumption of remifentanil was significantly reduced, the time to first rescue analgesia was prolonged, the consumption of morphine for rescue analgesia was decreased, MBS scores during shoulder abduction, elbow flexion and elbow extension were decreased at 30 min after block, and MBS scores during shoulder abduction and elbow flexion were decreased at 4 and 12 h after block in group C ( P<0.05). There was no significant difference in the diaphragmatic excursion, incidence of diaphragm paralysis and incidence of complications before and after block in the two groups ( P>0.05). Conclusions:C 5-NRB provides superior efficacy compared to T 2-ESPB when used for arthroscopic shoulder surgery under general anesthesia.
