Literature Study on the Evolution of TCM Syndrome Characteristics of Chronic Heart Failure From 1973 to 2023
- VernacularTitle:1973-2023年慢性心力衰竭中医证候特征演变规律文献研究
- Author:
Chidao ZHANG
1
;
Yongxia WANG
;
Mingjun ZHU
;
Zuoying XING
;
Boyong QIU
;
Xinlu WANG
;
Rui YU
Author Information
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords: Chronic heart failure; TCM syndrome; Symptom elements; Weakness retention; Law of evolution
- From: World Science and Technology-Modernization of Traditional Chinese Medicine 2025;27(1):121-131
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
- Abstract: Objective To excavate the TCM syndrome of chronic heart failure from 1973 to 2023 and summarize the evolution of the characteristics of medical syndrome.Methods The relevant literature on clinical research on TCM syndromes in three databases including CNKI from January 1,1973 to October 1,2023 was searched,and SPSS 21.0 and Rstudio software were used to conduct descriptive statistical analysis,association rule analysis,and cluster analysis on the distribution characteristics of TCM syndrome types and pattern elements in the final literature.Results A total of 218 literatures,including 41604 patients,covering 29 provinces,municipalities and autonomous regions across the country,were included,of which 179 articles explicitly reported the TCM composite syndrome type,including 31123 patients.A total of 71996 pattern elements were extracted,and the common elements included qi deficiency,blood stasis,phlegm turbidity,etc.The main location of the disease include heart,liver,spleen,etc.The characteristics of TCM syndromes in different regions and different periods show certain evolution rules,from 1973 to 2023,the proportion of qi deficiency and blood stasis pattern and phlegm and stasis mutual obstruction pattern showed an upward trend.The proportion of simple false evidence increased from 1994 to 2003 compared with 1973 to 1993,but decreased from 2004 to 2023,and was lower than that from 1973 to 1993.The proportion of yang deficiency water pan syndrome showed a downward trend;The evolution of syndromes in different regions has changed from deficiency to deficiency and real mixed syndrome,for example,North China,which has the highest proportion,has changed from cardiopulmonary qi deficiency to qi deficiency and blood stasis.In recent years,the proportion of heart,liver and spleen in the chronic heart failure syndrome pattern showed an overall upward trend,the proportion of the syndrome elements of the deficiency syndrome showed a downward trend,and the proportion of the syndrome elements of the standard disease syndrome showed an upward trend.Conclusion The characteristics of chronic heart failure syndrome are always the evidence of deficiency and reality,with"deficiency and qi retention"as the core pathogenesis,and the main disease sites are the heart,liver,and spleen,and the pattern elements composed of qi deficiency,phlegm turbidity,blood stasis,and water drinking gradually occupy a dominant position,and the TCM pattern type of chronic heart failure may show a trend of"deficiency of phlegm and stasis"in the future.
