Comparative study on the efficacy of Zero-PVA versus titanium plate in single-level ACDF treatment and analysis of radiographic influencing factors
10.3760/cma.j.cn121113-20240828-00476
- VernacularTitle:颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术中可变角度零切迹椎间融合器与钛板椎间融合器固定的疗效比较
- Author:
Jing HUANG
1
;
Yunyu XIONG
;
Ziran ZHOU
;
Hengtao HE
;
Bing WANG
Author Information
1. 昆明医科大学第一附属医院骨科，昆明 650034
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Cervical spondylosis;
Spinal fusion;
Treatment outcome;
Risk factors
- From:
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics
2025;45(4):205-214
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To investigate the clinical and radiological differences in treating single-level cervical spondylosis using the Zero-profile interbody fusion cage (Zero-PVA) versus the titanium plate interbody fusion cage in anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) and to analyze the correlation between clinical outcomes and radiological parameters.Methods:this retrospective study collected data from patients with cervical spondylosis who underwent single-level ACDF surgery at the First Affiliated Hospital of Kunming Medical University between January 2019 and June 2022. A total of 70 patients (32 males and 38 females) with an average age of 51.34 ± 8.62 years (range: 29 to 77 years) were included. Based on the type of interbody fusion device used, patients were divided into two groups: the cage-plate construct (CP) group (35 patients; average age: 51.51 ± 10.02 years, range: 29 to 77 years) and the zero-profile interbody fusion device with variable angle (ZP) group (35 patients; average age: 51.17±7.11 years, range: 38 to 68 years). Preoperative, one-week postoperative, and final follow-up (≥6 months postoperative) data were collected for visual analogue scale (VAS) scores, neck disability index (NDI) scores, and Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) scores. Radiological parameters assessed included surgical segment intervertebral disc height, cervical lordosis angle, surgical segment Cobb angle, T 1 slope (T 1S), and C 2-C 7 sagittal vertical axis (C 2-C 7 SVA). Additional evaluations included Bazaz dysphagia ratings at one week and final follow-up, Odom surgical outcome ratings at final follow-up, fusion grades, adjacent vertebral ectopic ossification grades, and adjacent segment degeneration. Patients were further classified into a symptom relief group and an incomplete symptom relief group based on Odom ratings. Logistic regression analysis was performed to examine the correlation between radiological parameters and postoperative outcomes. Statistical methods such as ROC curves, Youden index, product index, and Euclidean index were used to determine optimal cut-off values for radiological parameters affecting postoperative outcomes. Results:There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups in terms of gender, age, follow-up duration, surgical segment, or classification ( P>0.05), confirming comparability. At both one-week post-operation and final follow-up, VAS, NDI, and JOA scores showed no significant differences between the groups ( P>0.05). However, the incidence of dysphagia in the CP group was 49% at one week post-operation and 20% at final follow-up, significantly higher than that in the ZP group (14% at one week and 0 at final follow-up; P<0.05). The intervertebral space height in the CP group was 9.16±0.84 mm at one week post-operation and 8.19±1.11 mm at final follow-up, which was significantly higher than in the ZP group (8.22±1.23 mm at one week and 7.57±1.14 mm at final follow-up; P<0.05). The surgical segment Cobb angle in the CP group at final follow-up (7.34°±4.21°) was significantly greater than in the ZP group (4.63°±4.32°; t=2.661, P=0.010). Regarding heterotopic ossification (HO) of the superior vertebral body, in the CP group, 27 cases were grade 0, 7 cases were grade 1, and 1 case was grade 2. In the ZP group, 34 cases were grade 0 and 1 case was grade 1, with a statistically significant difference between the groups (χ 2=6.128, P=0.028). Binary logistic regression analysis revealed that a reduction in intervertebral space height of ≥0.63 mm at one week post-operation and final follow-up ( OR=2.913, P=0.021) and a heterotopic ossification grade of ≥1 ( OR=5.178, P=0.042) were correlated with incomplete symptom relief after single-level ACDF surgery. Conclusions:Both Zero-PVA and titanium plate interbody fusion devices demonstrated favorable clinical outcomes in single-level ACDF surgery. However, a reduction in intervertebral space height and heterotopic ossification of the superior vertebral body may be risk factors for incomplete symptom relief following single-level ACDF.
