Comparative analysis of efficacy and complications of ventriculo-peritoneal shunt and endoscopic third ventriculostomy in the treatment of pediatric hydrocephalus
10.3760/cma.j.cn101721-20241216-00435
- VernacularTitle:VPS与ETV治疗小儿脑积水的效果观察
- Author:
Gang ZHANG
1
;
Bin JIANG
1
;
Xiangkai ZHANG
1
;
Hangyu SHI
1
;
Weiyang MI
1
Author Information
1. 西安市儿童医院神经外科，西安 710003
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Hydrocephalus;
Children;
Ventriculo-peritoneal shunt;
Endoscopic third ventriculostomy;
Complications
- From:
Clinical Medicine of China
2025;41(6):423-428
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To investigate the efficacy and complications of ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) and endoscopic third ventriculostomy (ETV) in the treatment of hydrocephalus in children.Methods:This study was a retrospective analysis. A total of 120 children with hydrocephalus admitted to Xi'an Children's Hospital from January 2021 to March 2024 were selected. Among them, 49 children who underwent VPS treatment were included in the VPS group, and 71 children who underwent ETV treatment were included in the ETV group. Perioperative indicators, complication rates, postoperative recovery outcomes, levels of neurological injury markers, and developmental status at 6 months postoperatively were compared between the two groups. Measurement data with normal distribution were expressed as Mean ± SD, and intergroup comparisons was performed by independent samples t-test; counting data were expressed as case (%), and intergroup comparisons were performed by χ2 test. Results:The operation time [(83.26±10.67) min], time to first flatus [(2.58±0.44) days], and total complication rate [24.49% (12/49)] in the VPS group were all higher than those in the ETV group [(74.68±8.64) min, (2.21±0.42) days, and 9.86% (7/71)], while the one-time success rate [81.63% (40/49)] was lower than that in the ETV group [95.77% (68/71)]. The differences between the groups were statistically significant ( t=4.85, P<0.001; t=4.65, P<0.001; χ2=4.66, P=0.031; χ2=4.97, P=0.026, respectively). On postoperative day 3, the Glasgow Coma Scale score in the VPS group [(12.46±0.72) points] was lower than that in the ETV group [(12.89±0.67) points], and on postoperative day 7, the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale score in the VPS group [(8.96±1.09) points] was higher than that in the ETV group [(8.54±1.02) points], with statistically significant differences ( t=3.35, P=0.001; t=2.16, P=0.033, respectively). On postoperative day 3, the levels of central nervous system-specific protein [(12.57±2.51) mg/L], high mobility group box 1 protein [(28.83±3.77) μg/L], and neuron-specific enolase [(21.47±2.56) μg/L] in the VPS group were all higher than those in the ETV group [(10.54±2.11) mg/L, (25.63±3.26) μg/L, (19.27±2.31) μg/L], and the differences were statistically significant ( t=5.04, P<0.001; t=4.96, P<0.001; t=4.91, P<0.001, respectively). At 6 months postoperatively, the developmental quotient score in the VPS group [(84.15±3.14) points] was lower than that in the ETV group [(86.51±3.27) points], and the difference was statistically significant ( t=3.93, P<0.001). Conclusion:Both VPS and ETV can be used for the treatment of hydrocephalus in children. However, ETV has a higher one-time success rate, better perioperative indicators, fewer complications, and superior postoperative neurological recovery compared to VPS.
