The accuracy of virtual surgical planning assisted management for L-shaped reduction malarplasty
10.3760/cma.j.cn114453-20240702-00172
- VernacularTitle:虚拟手术设计应用于L形颧骨颧弓缩窄术中的精确性研究
- Author:
Xiaoshuang SUN
1
;
Han GE
1
;
Qing ZHAO
1
;
Heyou GAO
1
;
Zihang ZHOU
1
;
Bin YE
1
;
Jihua LI
1
Author Information
1. 口腔疾病研究国家重点实验室 国家口腔疾病临床医学研究中心 四川大学华西口腔医院正颌及关节外科，成都 610041
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Orthognathic surgery;
Reduction malarplasty;
L-shaped osteotomy;
Virtual surgical planning;
Three-dimensional printing;
Three-dimensional analysis;
Accuracy
- From:
Chinese Journal of Plastic Surgery
2025;41(1):38-46
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
Objective:To evaluate the accuracy of L-shaped reduction malarplasty under the guidance of virtual surgical planning (VSP).Methods:The data of adult female patients who were diagnosed with zygomatic protrusion or hypertrophy at Department of Orthognathic and Temporo-mandibular Joint Surgery, West China Hospital of Stomatology, Sichuan University, from January 2018 to December 2020 were analyzed retrospectively. L-shaped reduction malarplasty with or without bone resection and with the mortice and tenon joint structure on the zygomatic arch was conducted either by digital procedures comprising VSP and three-dimensional printing titanium templates (digtal surgery group) or by conventional method (control group). The incidence of postoperative complications and the patient postoperative satisfaction [using a Likert scale with a score ranging from 1 to 5, representing very dissatisfied, dissatisfied, average, satisfied and very satisfied, satisfaction rate = (very satisfied + satisfied)/ total number of patients × 100%] were statistically analyzed in the two groups. The differences in the postoperative symmetry of the zygomatic complex between the digital group and the control group were analyzed by three-dimensional cephalometry. The accuracy of VSP in L-shaped reduction malarplasty was evaluated by comparing the preoperative design model with the actual postoperative model in the digital group. The statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS 24.0 software. The chi-square test was used in the comparison of surgical complications and patient satisfaction rates. The symmetry of bilateral landmarks in the three-dimensional direction between the two groups was evaluated using the independent t-test, and the pre- and post-operative measurements in the digital group were compared using paired t-test. Results:A total of 78 patients were included, with 36 in the digital group, aged (25.2±3.6) years, and 42 in the control group, aged (24.3±2.8) years. Satisfactory reduction of zygomatic protrusion or hypertrophy was recognized among all patients. Compared with the control group, the digital group had lower percentage of complications [25% (9/36) vs. 55% (23/42)] and higher postoperative satisfaction [78% (28/36) vs. 48% (20/42)], both of which were statistically significant (all P<0.01). Regarding the symmetry of bilateral zygomatic complexes, the average deviations of ΔZb (bottom point of zygoma) in the digital group in the horizontal, vertical, and sagittal directions [(1.05±0.24), (1.05±0.24), (1.00±0.88) mm] were significantly smaller than those in the control group [(2.03±0.58), (1.32±0.68), (1.47±0.47) mm], with statistically significant differences (all P<0.05). The bone segment movements of virtual plans and actual result in the digital surgery group were measured and showed no obvious difference for the inward movement [(5.42±0.98) mm vs. (5.33±0.93) mm] and the sagittal overlap [(4.87±1.21) mm vs. (4.77±1.32) mm] at the zygoma roots, along with the step length at the long-arm of the L-shaped osteotomy line [(2.43±1.11) mm vs. (2.39±0.89) mm] (all P>0.05). The mean differences of facial width and protrusion measurements between virtual simulations and actual result in the digital group ranged from (1.13±0.47) mm to (2.07±0.88) mm, with no significant differences( P>0.05). Meanwhile, the high resemblance between virtual plans and actual result was depicted via superimposition models, with a deviation controlled within ±0.5 mm. Conclusion:The application of VSP in reduction malarplasty significantly improved surgical accuracy and reduced difficulties in the operation, which would improve patients’ postoperative satisfaction.
