Three-dimensional classification and clinical treatment of posterior cruciate ligament tibial avulsion fracture based on CT.
10.12200/j.issn.1003-0034.20240639
- Author:
Guang-Kai REN
1
;
Yu-Hang TIAN
1
;
Ming-Yu CUI
1
;
Bao-Ming YUAN
1
;
Yan-Bing WANG
1
;
Chuan-Gang PENG
1
;
Ming LI
2
;
Dan-Kai WU
1
Author Information
1. Orthopedic Medical Center, the Second Hospital of Jilin University, Changchun 130041, Jilin, China.
2. Traumatic Orthopedics Center, Ningbo No.6 Hospital, Ningbo 315040, Zhejiang, China.
- Publication Type:Journal Article
- Keywords:
Clinical treatment;
Computed tomography;
Posterior cruciate ligament;
Three-dimensional classification;
Tibial avulsion fracture
- MeSH:
Humans;
Male;
Female;
Posterior Cruciate Ligament/surgery*;
Adult;
Tibial Fractures/classification*;
Tomography, X-Ray Computed;
Middle Aged;
Retrospective Studies;
Fractures, Avulsion/classification*;
Imaging, Three-Dimensional;
Young Adult
- From:
China Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
2025;38(4):389-395
- CountryChina
- Language:Chinese
-
Abstract:
OBJECTIVE:A new three-dimensional(3D) classification of posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) tibial avulsion fracture based on computed tomography(CT) features was established and the significance in clinical treatment was explored in this study.
METHODS:From May 2013 to November 2023, 43 cases of PCL tibial avulsion fracture in the Second Hospital of Jilin University were analyzed retrospectively, including 29 males and 14 females, aged (34.3±8.5) years. According to traditional Meyers and McKeever classification, 3 cases were typeⅠ;2 cases of typeⅡ;38 cases were type Ⅲ. Based on the characteristics of CT images, 43 patients were given specific treatment strategies and followed up to evaluate the curative effect. According to the degree of fracture displacement, involved range and the integrity of fracture block demonstrated by CT images, the new three-dimensional classification of PCL avulsion fracture was established. Kappa coefficient was used for consistency test.
RESULTS:A new 3D classification of PCL tibial avulsion fracture was established. TypeⅠwas the non-displaced fracture (displacement degree ≤3 mm), in which typeⅠa was the avulsion range limited in the posterior intercondylar fossa, and Ib was the avulsion range beyond the posterior intercondylar fossa. TypeⅡrepresented the displaced fracture in the posterior intercondylar fossa (avulsion limited to the posterior intercondylar fossa and fracture displacement>3 mm), in which typeⅡa represented a slight displacement with a intact broken block and the posterior elevation of the avulsion (hinge mechanism), typeⅡb represented the complete separation of fracture ends with a intact fracture block, and typeⅡc was the comminuted fracture. Type Ⅲ was the displaced fracture beyond the posterior intercondylar fossa (avulsion involving the articular surface of the tibial plateau or the intercondylar ridge and the degree of displacement > 3 mm), among which type Ⅲa was the simple fracture with intact broken block, type Ⅲb represented the comminuted fracture, and type Ⅲc was the complex fracture with tibial plateau fracture. According to this new 3D classification, 43 patients were classified as type Ia in 2 cases and typeⅠb in 1 case;typeⅡa in 2 cases, typeⅡb in 15 cases and typeⅡc in 7 cases;type Ⅲa in 2 cases, type Ⅲb in 5 cases and type Ⅲc in 9 cases. All the 43 cases in this study achieved bone union. At the last follow-up, according to the hospital for special surgery knee score(HSS)evaluation system for the knee joint function, 27 cases were excellent, 11 cases were good, 5 cases were fair. The average Kappa value of inter-observer reliability in the first stage was 0.793, and the second stage was 0.855. The average Kappa value of the whole stage was 0.839, indicating high level of consistency. The average Kappa value of intra-observer reliability was 0.893, indicating high level of consistency.
CONCLUSION:The 3D classification of PCL tibial avulsion fracture is intuitive, demonstrating a high level of reliability. It has a certain guiding significance for the selection of clinical treatment methods, and it is suggested to be promoted and applied as a new classification system in clinical practice.
