1.Application of multiple exposure assessment methods in occupational health risk assessment of trichloroethylene in electroplating enterprises
Zhuandi ZHAO ; Sheng ZHANG ; Jinru CHEN ; Xiongxia FU ; Lihua ZHU ; Shibiao SU
Chinese Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Occupational Diseases 2020;38(10):782-786
Objective:To explore the applicability of different exposure assessment methods in occupational health risk assessment of trichloroethylene (TCE) occupation posts in electroplating enterprise.Methods:In November 2018, the occupational health risk assessments are conducted in trichloroethylene (TCE) occupation posts of 6 metal plating enterprises in a street in Shenzhen by using the qualitative risk assessment, semi-quantitative risk assessment (including contact ratio method, contact index method and synthesis index method) and quantitative risk assessment method (including non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risk assessment methods) , and the results of different methods are compared.Results:The results of qualitative assessment method are all level 4 (high risk) ; the results of contact ratio method show that the risk level is level 5 (very high risk) ; the results of contact index method and Synthesis index method show that the risk level is level 3 and level 4, 66.7% and 33.3% respectively; Non-carcinogenic risk assessment results show that TCE jobs are "unacceptable"; carcinogenic risk assessment results in carcinogenic inhalation excess risk of 50% each being "unacceptable" and "acceptable". The results of the six risk assessment methods showed that there were 3 "substantially consistent", 1 "partially consistent", and 2 "inconsistent" among the 6 companies.Conclusion:Synthesis index method and the carcinogenic risk assessment method are more suitable for occupational health risks of TCE occupation posts.
2.Application of multiple exposure assessment methods in occupational health risk assessment of trichloroethylene in electroplating enterprises
Zhuandi ZHAO ; Sheng ZHANG ; Jinru CHEN ; Xiongxia FU ; Lihua ZHU ; Shibiao SU
Chinese Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Occupational Diseases 2020;38(10):782-786
Objective:To explore the applicability of different exposure assessment methods in occupational health risk assessment of trichloroethylene (TCE) occupation posts in electroplating enterprise.Methods:In November 2018, the occupational health risk assessments are conducted in trichloroethylene (TCE) occupation posts of 6 metal plating enterprises in a street in Shenzhen by using the qualitative risk assessment, semi-quantitative risk assessment (including contact ratio method, contact index method and synthesis index method) and quantitative risk assessment method (including non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risk assessment methods) , and the results of different methods are compared.Results:The results of qualitative assessment method are all level 4 (high risk) ; the results of contact ratio method show that the risk level is level 5 (very high risk) ; the results of contact index method and Synthesis index method show that the risk level is level 3 and level 4, 66.7% and 33.3% respectively; Non-carcinogenic risk assessment results show that TCE jobs are "unacceptable"; carcinogenic risk assessment results in carcinogenic inhalation excess risk of 50% each being "unacceptable" and "acceptable". The results of the six risk assessment methods showed that there were 3 "substantially consistent", 1 "partially consistent", and 2 "inconsistent" among the 6 companies.Conclusion:Synthesis index method and the carcinogenic risk assessment method are more suitable for occupational health risks of TCE occupation posts.