Abstract In low-resource settings such as Melanesia, gestational diabetes often goes undiagnosed due to many factors, including the unsuitability of current tests. Ideally a gestational diabetes test for low-resource settings should meet criteria related to acceptability, test performance and operational characteristics, with minimal impositions on individual patients or the wider health system. None of the six tests recommended in country-specific gestational diabetes guidelines in Melanesia (2-hour oral glucose tolerance test, glucose challenge test, fasting plasma glucose, random plasma glucose, 2-hour postprandial glucose and glycated haemoglobin) meet criteria related to these attributes. Additionally, each Melanesian country has different, complex algorithms that use multiple tests in different combinations. With a high and increasing burden of diabetes mellitus (and therefore assumed gestational diabetes), Melanesian health practitioners and policymakers should be aware of the limitations of recommended tests for gestational diabetes and be open to alternative technologies that may be more appropriate.