1.Survey on training needs for key general practice trainers in Shanghai
Minghui PENG ; Shanzhu ZHU ; Sunfang JIANG
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2016;15(4):258-263
Objective To survey the training needs for key general practice (GP) trainers.Methods The survey was conducted among participants of the first training course for national key GP trainers hold on March 2014 in Shanghai.The contents of questionnaire used for the survey included training needs of GP relevant knowledge,teaching ability and modes of assessment.The differences in training needs between GP trainers from community teaching bases and hospital teaching bases were analyzed.Results Total 151 key trainers completed the questionnaire (male/female:48/103) with average age of (38 ± 6)years.Among them 67.5% (102/151) were from community teaching bases and 29.8% (45/151) from hospital teaching bases;60.9% (92/151) participated in the General Practitioner Structured Vocational Training Program (GPSVTP).According to the survey,general practice clinical kills (72.2%,106/151) and general practice clinical thinking (70.2 %,106/151) were most required relevant knowledge;while general practice basic concept was least required (25.8%,39/151).The rate with need of policy system related GP training in hospital trainers was higher than that in community teaching base trainers(66.7% vs.44.1%,P < 0.05).For teaching ability needs,85.4% (129/151) selected teaching methods,75.5% (114/151) chose teaching assessment and evaluation methods.The participants showed more interesting in new-type teaching and evaluation methods,such as PBL,OSCE,mini-CEX and DOPS,and would use them in future teaching work (P < 0.01).Workshop (58.3%,88/151),demonstration(57.0%,86/151) and experience exchange (50.3%,76/151) were three most interested modes in current training;meanwhile theoretic teaching was lease interested (38.4%,58/151).Study tour was most interested training models for the future (71.5%,108/151),followed by short-term courses (49.0%,74/151),overseas study (39.1%,59/151) and distance learning (27.8%,42/151).Conclusion There are different needs for GP trainers from hospital and community teaching bases.To meet the different requirements,the focused training course and training method should be adapted.
2.An investigation and analysis on current status of general practice service teams in urban Sbanghai
Hua YANG ; Sunfang JIANG ; Shanzhu ZHU
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2010;9(1):15-18
Objective To investigate current status of general practice service teams in urban Shanghai to provide practical evidence and lay theoretical basis for sustainable development of general practice service teams in the future. Methods A cross-sectional study was carried out for 40 staff members of eight general practice service teams in eight urban districts of Shanghai, as well as 110 local residents, by observation, interview and questionnaire methods during March to April 2008. Results Among 21 general practitioners, 86 percent of them ( 18/21 ) were graduated from medical colleges or universities with three-year curriculum or at levels above it and 52 percent ( 11/21 ) had intermediate professional titles or above.Among the eight general practice service teams, five had full coverage of supervision and management for tuberculosis therapy, six had full coverage of management for tumor patients, four had full coverage of management for cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases and four had full coverage of management for patients with mental disorders. In all staff members of eight general practice service teams, 38 percent of them (15/40) were satisfactory with their working environment, 40 percent (16/40) with their work activities, five percent (2/40) with their incomes, and 28 percent (11/40) with their professional future.In 110 local residents, 77 percent (85/110) were satisfactory with service environment, 85 percent (93/110) with quality of health-care service and 89 percent (98/110) with the attitude of service teams.Conclusions Implementation of management for chronic diseases and two-way referral, as well as satisfaction of staff members in general practice service teams should be improved further.
3.Development of evaluation index system for community general practice teaching base
Huiling XIA ; Sunfang JIANG ; Juan SHOU ; Shanzhu ZHU ; Yao LIU
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2017;16(2):94-99
Objective To develop an index system for evaluation index system for community general practice teaching base.Methods A draft of evaluation index system for community general practice teaching base was preliminarily developed on the basis of literature research.Two rounds Delphi consultations with 32 experts of general practice were conducted between July 2014 and May 2015.The results of consultation were analyzed and the evaluation index system for community teaching base was established.Results In two rounds of Delphi consultation,the positive coefficients were both 100%,the authority coefficient of experts were 0.879 and 0.897,respectively,and the coordination coefficient were 0.165 and 0.204 (P <0.01).The established evaluation index system consisted of 4 first-class indexes,8 second-class indexes and 27 third-class indexes.Four first-class indexes were basic conditions,teaching conditions,teaching staff and teaching practice.Conclusion The established evaluation index system may be used to accredit community general practice teaching base and to improve the quality of general practitioner training.
4.The ratio of urine albumin to creatinine used in screening for albuminuria among the middle-aged and elderly at high-risk for diabetes in an urban community with casual and morning urine specimens
Sunfang JIANG ; Xin GAO ; Limin REN ; Xusheng CHEN ; Naiqing ZHAO
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2009;8(1):22-26
Objective To compare the value of clinical application of the ratio of urine albumin to creatinine (ACR) in the community-dwelled middle-aged and elderly at high-risk for diabetes in screening for albuminuria with casual and morning urine specimens. Methods Totally, 443 middle-aged and elderly people (234 men and 209 women) at high-risk for diabetes, with an average age of (59±8) years, were recruited from Changfeng Community of Shanghai in screening for albuminuria with casual and morning urine specimens collected on the same day, as well as another two morning urine specimens collected at an interval of two weeks, for determination of urine ACR. Albuminuria was defined as ACR equal to or more than 30 mg (albumin)/g (creatinnine) in two or more of the three urine specimens collected. Results Overall prevalence of albuminuria was 6. 3% ( 28/443 ) in the middle-aged and elderly according to diagnostic standard mentioned above, significantly higher in casual urine specimens than in morning urine specimens (14. 9% vs. 5.9%, P <0. 05). Urine ACR of casual urine specimens was significantly higher than that of morning urine (7. 1 mg/g vs. 3. 2 mg/g, P<0. 001 ). There was no significant difference in sensitivity and positive predictive value (PPV) between casual and morning urine specimens in screening for albuminuria (96. 4% vs. 92. 9%, and 99.7% vs. 99. 5%, respectively, P >0. 05). Specificity and negative predictive value (NPV) of casual urine specimens was significantly lower than those of morning urine specimens (90.6% vs. 100.0%, and 40.9% vs. 100.0%, respectively, P<0.05). The optimal cut-off value of ACR by casual urine specimens was 40. 0 mg/g in screening for albuminuria, based on receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve, with sensitivity of 96. 4%, specificity 95.2%, PPV 57.5% and NPV 99. 8%. The middle-aged and elderly with negative albuminuria in morning urine but positive in casual urine had more risk factors for cardiovascular and chronic kidney diseases than those with negative albuminuria in both morning and casual urine specimens. Conclusions Morning urine specimen is better than casual urine for albuminuria screening in the middle-aged and elderly people with risk factors for diabetes in urban community, but casual urine used in screening for albuminuria is very convenient for collection. It is suggested that urine ACR of 40. 0 mg/g be used as an optimal cut-off value for casual urine in albuminuria screening among them.
5.Cut-off value of waist circumference for identifying metabolic syndrome in middle-aged and elder residents in Changfeng community of Shanghai
Sunfang JIANG ; Xin GAO ; Limin REN ; Xusheng CHEN ; Naiqing ZHAO
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2008;7(12):818-821
Objective To explore an optimal cut-off value of waist circumference(WC)for identifying metabolic syndrome(MS)in middle-aged and elder residents in an urban community.Methods Database of 1558 residents aged 40-79 years at high-risk in screening for diabetes from Changfeng community,Putuo District,Shanghai during 2005 to 2007 was used to analyze sensitivity and specificity of varied cut-off values of WC for identifying two or more components of MS in men and women,respectively.Receiver operating characteristics(ROC)curve was used to explore the optimal value.Results Optimal cut-off value of WC was 85.0 cm for men and 80.0 cm for women,respectively,for identifying two or more components of MS bv ROC curve,with sensitivity of 72.3%and 74.9%,and specificity of 50.2%and 62.2%,respectively.Based on that optimal cut-off value of WC and definition of International Diabetes Federation(IOF),prevalence of MS was 38.8%in this population,40.7%in men and 37.8%in women,respectively.Conclusion The optimal cut-off value of WC was 85.0 cm in men and 80.0 cm in women,respectively,for identifying MS in the middle-aged and eldedy in an urban community of Shanghai.
6.Analysis for the needs in general practice training
Zhigang PAN ; Yongming DING ; Sunfang JIANG ; Lilan CUI ; Shanzhu ZHU
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2008;7(3):154-156
Objective To study the changes in needs of standard training for general practice during the period of 2000 to 2006.Methods Sixty-two trainees participated in a municipal training program for general practitioners(GPs)in Zhongshan Hospital,Shanghai were interviewed by questionnaire to understand their recognition of general practice and needs in training for general practice,and compared to other 53 trainees who entered an another training program in 2000.Results Nineteen of 53 trainees(36percent)trained in 2000 could understand all the six aspects of general practice,including medical and health care,preventive care,rehabilitative care,health education and family planning techniques service,51(94 percent)were willing to accept such training,and 30(57 percent)did not satisfy with current conditions in community health care service.As compared,their recognition for general practice,acceptance of training,and satisfaction with their working condition improved obviously in trainees trained in 2006,with proportions of 100 percent,100 percent and 98 percent,respectively.But,main reason for dissatisfaction with community health care service could still attribute to less attention paid to general practice by relevant leadership.Conclusions Nowadays.the needs in general practice training by health care workers in communities increased greatly,but which still should be supported by governmental policies.
7.Follow-up survey on general practitioners after residency training in Shanghai
Minghui PENG ; Xiangjie ZHANG ; Yao LIU ; Hui LI ; Sunfang JIANG
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2016;15(6):430-433
Objective To survey the current working status of general practitioners (GPs) who received residency training in Shanghai.Methods The current status of general practitioners,who completed residency training in Shanghai from 2013 to 2014,was surveyed with self-designed questionnaire by e-mail.The survey items included current employers,job specification,clinical practice,teaching,scientific research and so on.Results Three hundred and thirteen out of 377 GPs,who completed residency training from 2007 to 2012,participated in the survey (83.0%),including 85 males and 228 females with a mean age of (31.2 ± 2.6) years.Among all participants,298 (95.2%) worked in community health service centers,12.8% (40/313) of them were involved in general practice teaching,9.9% (31/313) undertook management,9.3% (29/313) did academic research in community,and 7.7% (24/313) had chance for overseas study.The survey also showed that 134 person/times received various commendations and awards.Conclusion Most GPs who completed residency training are undertaking clinical practice in community health service centers,and they are also well involved in management,teaching,and research.
8.Survey on the capacity and training needs of community mentors of general practice in different areas of Shanghai
Huiling XIA ; Sunfang JIANG ; Juan SHOU ; Shanzhu ZHU ; Yao LIU
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2015;14(12):928-933
Objective To investigate the capacity and training needs of the community general practice mentors in different areas of Shanghai.Methods General practice mentors from community health centers,who attended a municipal training program in Shanghai during July 2012 to October 2012,were participated in the survey with a self-designed questionnaire.The general condition,basic ability (clinical skill,teaching ability and professional development),motivation and needs of training were investigated.The factors affecting the willingness of training were analyzed.Results Among 742 mentors receiving the survey,259 were from the urban area,174 from rural-urban continuum and 309 from rural area.The academic degree in urban group was relatively higher:17 out of 257 (6.6%) holding master degree.The ratio of participants who had received standardized training in urban,rural-urban and rural areas was 33.2%,25.3%,37.4%,respectively.The personal quality and communication skills in urban group were significantly higher than those in rural-urban continuum and rural group (18.58 ± 2.49,17.89 ± 2.69,17.85 ±2.34,P <0.05).The clinical skill (12.31 ± 1.98,11.95 ±2.02,11.52 ± 1.81),teaching ability (11.99 ± 2.62,11.63 ± 2.86,11.12 ± 2.77) and professional development (6.42 ± 1.61,6.36 ± 1.55,5.61 ± 1.38) in urban group were all significantly poorer than those in other two groups.The main purpose of participation in training was to improve medical knowledge and clinical skills in three groups (70.8%,74.0%,80.4%,respectively),followed by the need for community teaching.The rural group has higher training requirements in improving clinical diagnosis and treatment ability (75.3%,80.1%,85.5%,respectively in three groups),doctor-patient communication ability (38.0%,44.0%,50.7%,respectively) and community preventive care ability (29.4%,30.7%,42.8%,respectively).The urban group had much more requirements in scientific research training (38.8%,34.9%,14.1%,respectively).Logistic regression analysis showed that doctors with supports from the leadership (OR =2.688,P < 0.05) and with less working stress (OR =2.241,P < 0.05) were more willing to participate in mentor training.Conclusion There are discrepancies in basic ability and training needs of community general practice mentors in different areas of Shanghai,so we should develop specific or targeted training program in the future.
9.Follow-up of graduates of general practice residency training working in community health service centers in Shanghai
Jian WANG ; Zhigang PAN ; Sunfang JIANG ; Shanzhu ZHU
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2015;14(11):874-876
Telephone interview was conducted to follow up the 151 graduates of general practice residency training in Zhongshan Hospital who are working in community health service centers in Shanghai up to June 2014;the results were compared with those of 130 graduates in 2011.Based on investigation of 2014,94 out of 151 graduates worked in downtown and 57 worked in suburbs of Shanghai,while in interview of 2011,72 out of 130 in downtown and 58 in suburbs.Among 151 participants in 2014 interview 13 had senior professional tide,138 (91.39%) had intermediate or primary professional titles,while 4 in 2011 interview had senior professional title,126 (96.92%) had intermediate or primary professional title.Among 151 participants in 2014 interview,40 (26.49%) were heads of GP teams and 45 (29.80%) held administrative positions,while in 2011 interview 33 (25.83%) were heads of GP teams and 30 (23.08%) held administrative positions.2014 interview showed that 211 first-author papers were published,59 research projects were obtained with 4.34 million Yuan funds,303 prizes was awarded in 151graduates,all of which were increased compared to those of 2011 group.The resign rates in 2011 and 2014 groups were 6.43% (9/140)and 10.06% (17/169),respectively;the job-moving rates in 2011 and 2014 groups were 5.00% (7/140) and 11.95% (19/159),respectively.The resign rate of 2011-2014 was 5.03% (8/159) and the job-moving rate of 2011-2014 was 11.95% (19/159).Conclusion The follow-up study shows that the graduates of general practice residency training of Zhongshan Hospital perform well in community health service centers in Shanghai.
10.Application of standardized patients in intensive training of clinical skills for general practice trainees and its effectiveness
Juan SHOU ; Shanzhu ZHU ; Sunfang JIANG ; Xiangjie ZHANG ; Minghui PENG
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2011;10(1):17-20
Objective To explore application of standardized patients (SPs) in intensive training of clinical competency for general practice trainees. Methods Fifty-three general practice trainees in Shanghai Zhongshan Hospital were enrolled in the study, randomly assigned to intervention and control groups. Control group proceeded in routine clinical rotation, while intervention group accepted intensive training course with SPs as trainers. Three months after intervention, clinical skills of the two groups were compared in a simulated medical environment. Results There was no statistically significant difference in their baseline characteristics between the two groups (P >0.05). Competency in history taking, physical examinations,communication with patients, comprehensive consultation, medical record writing as well as case-analysis,improved significantly in intervention group after intervention, as compared to those before it ( P < 0. 01 ),with the highest score of communication skill of 82 ± 10. Although competency of history taking, physical examinations, comprehensive consultation, medical record writing also improved significantly three months later in control group as compared to their baselines (P < 0. 01 ), while no statistically significant difference in their communication skills was found ( P > 0. 05 ). Scores of skills in physician-patient communication,comprehensive consultation as well as medical record analysis were significantly higher in intervention group than those in control one after intervention ( P < 0. 01 ), but no significant difference in physical examinations was found between the two groups ( P > 0. 05 ). Conclusions Application of SP in intensive training course for clinical competency can remarkably improve their competency in interpersonal communication and comprehensive consultation for general practice trainees.