1.Healthcare Practitioners’ Views of Postnatal Depression: A Qualitative Synthesis
SITI ROSHAIDAI BINTI MOHD ARIFIN
Malaysian Journal of Health Sciences 2019;17(1):73-82
The World Health Organisation recommends healthcare practitioners to equip themselves with appropriate skills to assess the psychological distress in women attending the antenatal and postnatal healthcare. Nevertheless, little is known about the healthcare practitioners’ perceptions of postnatal depression and its management. The aims of this review were: (i) to explore the experiences of healthcare practitioners in caring for women with postnatal depression in different countries and (ii) to identify any qualitative study conducted in Malaysia regarding the healthcare practitioners’ perceptions of postnatal depression. To achieve these objectives, a qualitative synthesis of studies reporting the healthcare practitioners’ experience of managing women with postnatal depression was conducted. A search in CINAHL, PubMed, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and ASSIA databases was performed using specific keywords and published peer-reviewed articles from 2006 to 2016 were screened for inclusion criteria. A total of 15 relevant studies were identified and reviewed. The studies included were conducted in eight different countries: America, Australia, United Kingdom, Brazil, Canada, Greek, Mexico, and Slovenia. No study conducted in Malaysia was found. This review suggested that the experiences of managing women with postnatal depression were relatively similar among the healthcare professionals in different countries. The main limitations reported by the healthcare practitioners were the lack of resources on maternal mental health and the absence of policy regarding the management of postnatal depression. Further research should investigate how Malaysian healthcare practitioners perceive postnatal depression and their roles in its management to provide more insights into the current clinical practice in Malaysia for postnatal depression.
2.Exploring women’s perceptions and experiences of menopause among East Coast Malaysian women
Nurjasmine Aida Jamani ; Nurul Najmi Mohamad Ishak ; Siti Roshaidai Mohd Arifin ; Azwanis Abdul Hadi ; Karimah Hanim Abd Aziz
Malaysian Family Physician 2021;16(1):84-92
Background: Menopause signifies the beginning of a non-reproductive phase from the reproductive
period. Although it is considered a natural life transition, recent studies have indicated that a
woman’s menopausal experience may impact her quality of life. While studies have examined
Malaysian women’s knowledge and awareness of menopause, they have focused on the prevalence
of menopausal symptoms and sociocultural aspects. These investigations also used a quantitative
design that may have limited the information regarding the nature and experience of menopause.
Objectives: This study explores women’s perceptions and understanding of their menopausal
experience.
Methods: A total of 20 menopausal women were recruited using purposive sampling through social
media in the state of Pahang, Malaysia. In-depth semi-structured interviews were used to explore
how they perceived their menopausal experience. The data were then analyzed using thematic
analysis.
Results: Three themes that emerged from the findings included perceptions of menopause,
biopsychosocial changes and help-seeking behavior. For many Muslim women, menopause was
perceived as a time for them to engage in religious commitment more than they had before.
Conclusion: The study findings uncovered a knowledge gap and a lack of support for women
impacted by menopause. Muslim women regarded their menopause phase as a time for them to
engage in religious duty fully. These results indicate the need for a psychosocial intervention and
educational program to ensure women a better transition throughout their menopausal phase
3.REVIEW - Assessment tools to measure postnatal mental illness: A 10-year scoping review
Siti Roshaidai Mohd Arifin ; Nur Liyana Shahmi Ruslan ; Khadijah Hasanah Abang Abdullah ; Nurul Ain Hidayah Abas ; Rohayah Husain ; Karimah Hanim Abd Aziz ; Ramli Musa ; Fathima Begum Syed Mohideen ; Asma Perveen ; Khairi Che Mat
Malaysian Family Physician 2022;17(2):10-21
Introduction:
The use of assessment tools to measure postnatal mental illness is essential in healthcare settings. However, variations in the types of tools and their reliability in a particular population lead to under-recognition of mental health status in postnatal mothers. The aim of this review is to evaluate the most recent 10 year of research on the validity and reliability of postnatal mental illness assessment tools.
Methods:
A literature search of studies from online databases PubMed, Scopus, and Science Direct was conducted.
Results:
A total of 59 studies were selected for this review. Several studies utilised multiple assessment tools, and a total of 96 assessment tools were identified and classified into six domains: postnatal blues, postnatal stress, postnatal anxiety, postnatal depression, postnatal psychosis, and postnatal psychological disorder. In this review, EPDS was the most common tool used to identify postnatal depression and anxiety while DASS 21 was the most common tool used to identify postnatal psychological disorder. There is a wide range in preponderance of evidence for the reliability of each assessment tool and there were inconsistencies in assessing the validity of the assessment tools.
Conclusion
This review provides information regarding some of the main assessment tools currently available to measure postnatal mental illnesses. There were no standardised tools that were used in a particular setting. The results may differ in different population because there are differences in not only languages and dialects, but also cultural and racial backgrounds, which greatly influences their perception and interpretation of postnatal mental illness.
Mental Disorders