1.Progress and prospects of moral injury research in China:a qualitative research based on NVivo12
Chinese Medical Ethics 2024;37(2):239-247
Objective:Papers related to moral injury on platforms such as CNKI,Wanfang,and VIP were retrieved and analyzed to understand the current status of moral injury research in China,provide a reference for future related content research,as well as lay the foundation for subsequent in-depth research on moral injury.Methods:Quantitative and qualitative analyses were conducted on literature related to moral injury from 2012 to 2023.Using the NVivo12 analysis tool,based on the content analysis method,the current status of research on moral injury in China was reviewed from the three dimensions of moral trauma,including research topics,research objects,and research perspectives.Results:The research themes of moral injury in China were mainly summarized in five aspects:concept,mechanism,measurement and assessment,symptoms and manifestations,as well as prevention and treatment.The research subjects were mainly high-risk occupational groups such as war-related personnel,medical staff,and teachers.The research was mainly conducted from the perspectives of ethics,medicine,cultural studies,and psychology.Conclusion:In the future,research on moral injury in China needs to deepen its theoretical system and promote empirical research.Expand research horizons,as well as enrich the research in the field of interdisciplinary and cross-disciplinary.Raise the level of attention,and pay attention to the physical and mental well-being of special employment groups.
2.Enlightenment on the Construction of Medical Professionalism from the Perspective of Moral Injury
Yu WANG ; Rongqing SHAO ; Mei YIN ; Xuesong WU
Chinese Medical Ethics 2023;36(8):933-940
The purpose of medicine is to preserve and develop the treatment in the process of saving lives and helping injuries. Medical professionalism is a comprehensive expression of physician’s clinical abilities, relationships and values between different subjects. In practice, white robed doctors utilize high standards of professionalism to practice the medical purpose and goals of "always centering on the interests of the patient" in specific diagnosis and treatment behaviors. At the same time, fulfilling the promises and expectations of medicine to the public. For these reasons, selfless dedication, self-sacrifice, and one-way pure altruism are all internalized into the basic requirements of medical professionalism: doctors should not only have the skill to revive the dead, but also have the benevolence of evangelists; they not only need to achieve maximum efficiency in technology, but also achieve the highest truth, goodness, and beauty in virtue. When these qualities are exaggerated or unattainable due to uncontrollable reasons, there will be a rift between the entrenched value systems and practical needs. In recent years, the global epidemic has had a huge impact on the medical system and medical staff, and the moral beliefs, role expectations, and value systems of doctors have also been impacted unprecedentedly, resulting in moral injury. The international research on moral injury in medical field has also received attention. China is currently in the adjustment period of epidemic related policies, with medical personnel bearing the brunt. Therefore, referring to relevant international research on moral injury to re-examine the relationship between the medical professionalism, which emphasizes one-way pure altruism, dedication and weakening or even neglecting personal well-being, and current medical practices. And constructing a moral injury early warning-repair system that focuses on doctors, patients, medical teams, medical institutions, medical environments, health systems, and other stakeholders, and ensuring its healthy operation. Not only in extreme periods, but also in ordinary daily diagnosis and treatment, it can support doctors to actively, safely, and healthily fulfill their mission of saving lives and helping injuries.