2.Effects of cognitively stimulating activities on the cognitive functioning of older people with mild cognitive impairment: A meta-analysis
Raymund F. Mamayson ; Mary Grace C. Lacanaria
Acta Medica Philippina 2024;58(6):14-23
Background:
The number of individuals with mild cognitive impairment (MCI), or those people without dementia who are experiencing age-related cognitive decline, has increased in recent years. Conveniently, several interventions to delay cognitive decline exist, where cognitively stimulating activities (CSA) have been receiving too much attention. However, its beneficial effects have not been well established among older people with MCI due to conflicting findings.
Objectives:
This study aimed to assess and summarize the available evidence on the effects of CSA on the overall cognitive functioning of older people with MCI. Specifically, it sought to answer the PICO question, “In older people with MCI, does engagement in cognitively stimulating activities improve cognitive function?”
Methods:
A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials examining the effects of CSA on
older people with MCI were conducted. Three studies met the inclusion criteria from the 1,328 records from BioMed Central, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, Health Source: Nursing/Academic Edition, MEDLINE, and PubMed databases and 156 articles from WorldCat, DSpace Saint Louis University, and Google Scholar databases and catalogs. Effect size values were inspected using the random-effects model. Data were summarized as standardized mean difference (SMD) with corresponding 95% confidence intervals in the forest plot.
Results:
This meta-analysis which compared studies that employed similar methodologies, found that CSA has a significant, large effect in improving cognitive functioning among older people with MCI, evidenced by an SMD of 0.798 (95% CI = 0.510-1.085, p = 0.001). While its superiority over other interventions that improve cognitive function was not observed in this study, it was still found that using CSA was helpful in terms of its cost-effectiveness. Also, heterogeneity across studies was non-significant (Cochran’s Q = 0.151, df = 2, p = 0.927, I2 = 0.00%). These results mean that clinical heterogeneity was absent even though a diverse range of CSA was employed. Additionally, methodological diversity was not present since there were no variations in the study design and minimal variability in the risk of bias assessment.
Conclusion
Overall, it is acknowledged that CSA are effective and practical, inexpensive, non-pharmacologic cognitive training approaches to delay cognitive decline among older people with MCI. However, interpreting this study’s significant, large effect, and non-significant heterogeneity warrants caution.
Cognition
;
Cognitive Dysfunction
;
Meta-Analysis
3.End-of-Life planning among older Filipinos
Erryne Noelle C. Aguilar ; Mariah Stephanie L. Cardinal ; Jennifer D. Doria ; Casserine P. Dumpilo ; Christian Anthony C. Fabros ; Charlie Magne S. Flores ; Angelika Marie R. Milo ; Samantha Faye Q. Natino ; Angelo L. Ortiz ; Joyce Ann P. Pastor ; Vicente B. Turas III ; Raymund F. Mamayson ; Mary Rose D. Valenzuela
Philippine Journal of Nursing 2017;87(2):55-59
Purpose:
The number of older Filipinos continues to rise resulting in increasing
numbers of people who live in a modernized world which offers numerous options to
prepare for the End-of-Life (EoL). Henceforth, EoLplanning among older Filipinos and
the factors which could potentially influence the propensity to plan ahead needs further
investigation. This study ascertained the level of health, relationship, funerary, legal
and financial-related EoL planning among older Filipinos, and established the
association between EoL planning and sex, chronologic age, religious affiliation,
ethnicity, health and financial status.
Methods:
The study utilized a descriptive survey design, including 400 respondents,
chosen through purposive sampling and met the inclusion of Filipino, Baguio
residents, aged 60 and above, able to read and understand English, Filipino or Ilokano,
and without psychological disturbances or cognitive deficits. The researchers used a
self-made questionnaire after establishing validity (0.96) and reliability (0.82). The
Saint Louis University Research Ethics Committee ensured the ethical conduct of this
research. Data were treated with statistics using frequency, mean and Chi-square
test.
Findings:
The responses indicated moderate levels of EoL planning overall.
Moreover, statistical tests revealed that only health status has a significant association
with EoLplanning.
Conclusions
Based on the findings, the researchers conclude that EoL planning
remains not widely used in the Philippines, thus, intensifying the call for more
aggressive interventions to make EoL planning salient and acceptable to older people.
In addition, health status affects EoL planning considerably, and that knowing the sex,
chronologic age, religious affiliation, ethnicity and financial status did not help predict
EoLplanning.
Ethics Committees, Research
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
4.Effects of brain games on global cognition among older Filipinos
Raymund F. Mamayson ; Lilia G. Caballes ; Kyle Nathaniel B. Asiatico ; Rose Angela R. Acosta ; Sheantelle Dominique S. Chavez ; Lauderdale B. Deocares ; Alessandra P. Gayagay ; Abigail Ruth K. Lonogan ; Vince Rafael B. Nuega ; Arianne Joy B. Salvador ; Gail Lian B. Santos ; June Virlin A. Wooden
Acta Medica Philippina 2020;54(2):109-116
Objective:
This study ascertained the effects of brain games on global cognition among older Filipinos.
Methods:
A quasi-experimental design was used. The participants were 60 elderly Filipinos, aged 60 to 93 years, residing in Baguio City, and were not engaging in any physical or nutritional interventions to improve cognitive function. None have subclinical cognitive impairments as screened using the Mini-Cognitive Examination. The Addenbrooke's Cognitive Examination-III (ACE-III) tool which correlated significantly with standard neuropsychological tests, and provided a high internal reliability score of 0.88, was used. Data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics.
Results:
Pretest mean scores of both active control and experimental groups increased in the posttest. Additionally, both coloring and brain games had extremely significant effects on global cognition (p=0.0001). Lastly, the unrelated t-test revealed extremely significant difference between the effects of brain games and coloring on global cognition (p=0.0001).
conclusions
Based on the results, brain games showed evidence of effectiveness in improving global cognition, and that compared to coloring, it is more effective in improving global cognition among older Filipinos. Variables like motivation and expectancy effects influence the improvement in global cognition among older Filipinos. Lastly, cognitive training using brain games show promise as a non-pharmacologic intervention to address cognitive decline.
5.Effects of e-learning materials on caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry
Raymund F. Mamayson ; Wyn P. Cawalo ; Elliz John P. Morales ; Rhomayne Xyla D. Morla ; Kayla Louise M. Nebrida ; Zia Marizz P. Orca ; Leigh Shamaine R. Pacolor ; Diana P. Paran ; Alexandra Ysabelle P. Ramos ; Ezra Nicole S. Razon ; Ma. Marie Antonette C. Sales ; Sir Josh Marlowe G. Soriano ; Alexandra Krisha Danielle I. Tagorda ; Rex Daniel B. Tingson
Acta Medica Philippina 2024;58(19):18-28
BACKGROUND
E-learning has emerged as a crucial technique that educators embrace and apply. Two effective e-learning materials are video-based learning (VBL) and e-book-based remote learning (EBRL). While several studies have proven their effectiveness, none have compared these e-learning materials, especially regarding caregivers’ knowledge of delirium, dementia, and depression (3Ds). Based on the extant literature, many caregivers are untrained and often lack the knowledge and skills to lessen the burden on delirious, demented, and depressed older adults. Hence, there is a growing need to explore how e-learning materials will address caregivers’ lack of knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry.
OBJECTIVESThis study ascertained the effects of e-learning materials on caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry and determined significant differences within and between groups.
METHODSA three-arm, quasi-experimental study, which included 63 informal caregivers in Baguio City who met the inclusion criteria and were chosen through purposive sampling, was conducted. Data were gathered using the Delirium-related knowledge tool, the Bangladesh version of the Depression Literacy Questionnaire, and the Dementia Knowledge Assessment Tool version 2. Data collection was done face-to-face and was conducted from March to April 2023. Data were treated with descriptive and inferential statistics using means, paired t-test, one-way omnibus ANOVA, and the post hoc Scheffé’s test. Ethics approval was provided by the Saint Louis University Research Ethics Committee (SLU-REC-UG 2023-004).
RESULTSAll the pretest mean scores of respondents in the VBL, EBRL, and control groups increased in the posttest. Additionally, the paired t-test revealed that the VBL and EBRL materials significantly affected the caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry, evidenced by a t-statistic of -5.80 (p=0.00001) and -4.48 (p= 0.00023), respectively. Lastly, one-way ANOVA revealed that there was a statistically significant difference in mean scores between at least two groups (F(2,60) = [7.060], p=0.002). Post hoc analysis using Scheffé’s test for multiple comparisons found that the mean values significantly differed between the VBL and the waitlist control group (Scheffé=10.589), and between the EBRL and the waitlist control group (Scheffé=10.589). There was no statistically significant difference between the VBL and the EBRL groups (Scheffé=0).
CONCLUSIONSThis study suggests that informal caregivers in Baguio City are moderately knowledgeable about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry. Moreover, both VBL and EBRL materials showed effectiveness in improving caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry, highlighting the substantial equivalence of both materials. Lastly, caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry increases as they engage in e-learning materials. Thus, it is acknowledged that VBL and EBRL materials are valuable, cost-effective, and practical interventions in improving caregivers’ knowledge about the 3Ds of geriatric psychiatry.
Human ; Geriatric Psychiatry ; Delirium ; Dementia ; Depression