1.Compensation for Occupational Diseases by Chemical Agents in Korea.
Soon Chan KWON ; Soo Yong ROH ; Ji Hoon LEE ; Eun A KIM
Journal of Korean Medical Science 2014;29(Suppl):S78-S84
Investigation into the frequency of compensation for occupational diseases (ODs) caused by hazardous chemicals revealed an important opportunity for the improvement and further development of occupational health and safety systems in Korea. In response to concerns after outbreaks of disease due to chemical exposure, specific criteria for recognition of ODs were established and included in the Enforcement Decree of the Labor Standard Act (LSA) and the Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act (IACIA) on June 28, 2013. However, the original versions of the LSA and IACIA contain several limitations. First, the criteria was listed inconsistently according to the symptoms or signs of acute poisoning. Second, all newly recognized hazardous chemicals and chemicals recognized as hazardous by the International Labor Organization (ILO) were not included in the LSA and IACIA. Although recent amendments have addressed these shortcomings, future amendments should strive to include all chemicals listed by the ILO and continuously add newly discovered hazardous chemicals as they are introduced into the workplace.
Adolescent
;
Burns, Chemical/economics
;
Female
;
Humans
;
Metals, Heavy/economics/poisoning
;
Occupational Diseases/*chemically induced/*economics
;
Occupational Exposure/*adverse effects
;
Poisoning/economics
;
Republic of Korea
;
Workers' Compensation/*economics
2.Compensation for Occupational Neurological and Mental Disorders.
Journal of Korean Medical Science 2014;29(Suppl):S59-S65
Standards for the recognition of occupational diseases (ODs) in Korea were established in 1954 and have been amended several times. In 2013, there was a significant change in these standards. On the basis of scientific evidence and causality, the International Labour Organization list, European Commission schedule, and compensated cases in Korea were reviewed to revise the previous standards for the recognition of ODs in Korea. A disease-based approach using the International Classification of Diseases (10th version) was added on the previous standards, which were agent-specific approaches. The amended compensable occupational neurological disorders and occupational mental disorders (OMDs) in Korea are acute and chronic central nervous system (CNS) disorders, toxic neuropathy, peripheral neuropathy, manganese-related disorders, and post-traumatic stress disorder. Several agents including trichloroethylene (TCE), benzene, vinyl chloride, organotin, methyl bromide, and carbon monoxide (CO) were newly included as acute CNS disorders. TCE, lead, and mercury were newly included as chronic CNS disorders. Mercury, TCE, methyl n-butyl ketone, acrylamide, and arsenic were newly included in peripheral neuropathy. Post-traumatic stress disorders were newly included as the first OMD. This amendment makes the standard more comprehensive and practical. However, this amendment does not perfectly reflect the recent scientific progress and social concerns. Ongoing effort, research, and expert consensus are needed to improve the standard.
Female
;
Humans
;
Mental Disorders/chemically induced/*economics/pathology
;
Nervous System Diseases/chemically induced/*economics/pathology
;
Occupational Diseases/*economics
;
Occupational Exposure
;
Republic of Korea
;
Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic/diagnosis/*economics
;
Workers' Compensation/*economics
3.The Scope and Specific Criteria of Compensation for Occupational Diseases in Korea.
Jaechul SONG ; Inah KIM ; Byung Soon CHOI
Journal of Korean Medical Science 2014;29(Suppl):S32-S39
The range of diseases covered by workers' compensation is constantly expanding. However, new regulations are required for the recognition of occupational diseases (ODs) because OD types evolve with changes in industrial structures and working conditions. OD criteria are usually based on medical relevance, but they vary depending on the social security system and laws of each country. In addition, the proposed range and extent of work-relatedness vary depending on the socio-economic conditions of each country. The Labor Standards Act (LSA) and the Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act (IACIA) of Korea employ lists based on their requirements without listing causes and diseases separately. Despite a considerable reshuffle in 2003, the basic framework has been maintained for 50 yr, and many cases do not fit into the international disease classification system. Since July 1, 2013, Korea has expanded the range of occupational accidents to include occupational cancers and has implemented revised LSA and IACIA enforcement decrees. There have been improvements to OD recognition standards with the inclusion of additional or modified criteria, a revised and improved classification scheme for risk factors and ODs, and so on.
Accidents, Occupational/*classification/*economics
;
Humans
;
Insurance, Accident/economics
;
Insurance, Health/economics
;
Neoplasms/chemically induced
;
Occupational Diseases/*classification/*economics/mortality
;
Occupational Exposure/adverse effects
;
Occupational Health
;
Republic of Korea
;
Risk Factors
;
Workers' Compensation/*economics/legislation & jurisprudence/standards
4.Compensation for Occupational Cancer.
Inah KIM ; Eun A KIM ; Jae Young KIM
Journal of Korean Medical Science 2014;29(Suppl):S40-S46
The legal scope and criteria for occupational cancer in Korea was out of date. The aim of this study was to review the current criteria for occupational cancer and amend the existent criteria on the basis of recent scientific evidence. The scientific evidence and the legal list of occupational cancer were analyzed to identify the causes of occupational cancer on a global scale. The relationship between compensated occupational cancer cases and carcinogen exposure in Korea was examined. The factors associated with specific causes and target cancers were determined to produce additional criteria. Five-hundred and nineteen cases of 2,468 were awarded compensation for occupational cancer including lung, malignant mesothelioma, lymphohematopoietic, and liver cancers from January 2000 to October 2012. Between 1996 and 2005, benzene accounted for 84.4% of cases, and between 1999 and 2005, asbestos was associated with 62.3% of cases. Fourteen novel causative agents and 12 additional target cancers were identified and the final guidelines were amended to include 23 causative agents and 21 target cancers. This amendment of the criteria for occupational cancer represents the widest change in Korean history and is expected to improve the understanding of occupational cancer by providing an up-to-date and accurate reference guide.
Asbestos/toxicity
;
Benzene/toxicity
;
Carcinogens/toxicity
;
Female
;
Humans
;
Insurance, Health/*economics
;
Middle Aged
;
Neoplasms/chemically induced/*economics
;
Occupational Diseases/*economics/mortality
;
Occupational Exposure/*adverse effects
;
Republic of Korea
;
Workers' Compensation/*economics/legislation & jurisprudence/standards
5.Compensation for Work-Related Hematologic, Liver, and Infectious Diseases.
Journal of Korean Medical Science 2014;29(Suppl):S66-S71
Occupational diseases may be defined only medically or scientifically, and even then, their definition is not simple. However, compensable occupational diseases involve the additional layer of legal systems and social welfare policies as well. Their multifaceted nature makes determining the work-relatedness of these diseases more complex. Korea has established standards for the recognition of occupational diseases in Schedule 5 of the Enforcement Decree of the Labor Standards Act, and specific criteria for the recognition of occupational diseases are listed in Schedule 3 of the Enforcement Decree of the Industrial Accident Compensation Insurance Act. The new list of compensable occupational diseases comprises 13 articles as an open-ended system. The newly added articles pertain to lymphohematopoietic (Article 5) and infectious diseases (Article 9), as well as diseases of other target organs. Furthermore, the article on liver diseases (Article 8) has been partially revised. The new act has been changed to clarify the meaning as it has been presented in recent research. It is necessary to achieve agreement among concerned parties, including experts from the legal, medical, and social domains to resolve the issues of work-relatedness, causation, notion of aggravation, and so on for preparing a list and a process that are more reasonable.
Adult
;
Benzene/toxicity
;
Communicable Diseases/*economics
;
Dimethylformamide/toxicity
;
Drug-Induced Liver Injury/economics
;
Female
;
Hematologic Diseases/chemically induced/*economics
;
Humans
;
Lead/toxicity
;
Liver Diseases/*economics
;
Male
;
Middle Aged
;
Occupational Diseases/*economics
;
Republic of Korea
;
Trichloroethylene/toxicity
;
Vinyl Chloride/toxicity
;
Workers' Compensation/*economics