2.Diagnostic accuracy of the optical coherence tomography in assessing glaucoma among Filipinos. Part 1: Categorical outcomes based on a normative database
Noel de Jesus Atienza ; Joseph Anthony Tumbocon
Philippine Journal of Ophthalmology 2012;37(1):3-10
Objective:
To determine the accuracy of the optic nerve head (ONH) and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL)
parameters using the Stratus OCT in diagnosing glaucoma among Filipino patients and to determine the validity of
the OCT measurements compared with a reference standard.
Methods:
Glaucoma suspects were recruited consecutively from patients undergoing diagnostic tests. The results
of the Stratus OCT fast RNFL protocol were analyzed against the independent assessment by glaucoma experts
who were blinded. Outcomes included RNFL thickness values of ≤5 percentile and ≤1 percentile of the normative
database for each RNFL sector, quadrant, and for the average RNFL thickness. Estimates of diagnostic accuracy
with 95% confidence intervals were calculated.
Results:
A total of 119 subjects assessed as glaucoma and 397 subjects assessed as normal were included in the
analysis. Using the best categorical criterion for abnormality (average RNFL thickness of ≤1 percentile of the
normative database), the OCT had a specificity of 98% (95% CI 96 - 99) and a sensitivity of 37% (95% CI 28 - 46).
The criterion with the highest sensitivity was the presence of at least one sector with thickness at ≤5 percentile.
Conclusion
The Stratus OCT demonstrated a specificity of 98% and a sensitivity of 37% for the diagnosis of
glaucoma using as a criterion an average RNFL thickness of ≤1 percentile of the normative database. It was a poor
screening test for glaucoma suspects, although it showed some promise as a confirmatory test.
Glaucoma
;
Tomography, Optical Coherence
3.Diagnostic accuracy of the optical coherence tomography in assessing glaucoma among Filipinos. Part 2: Optic nerve head and retinal nerve fiber layer parameters
Noel de Jesus Atienza ; Joseph Anthony Tumbocon
Philippine Journal of Ophthalmology 2012;37(1):11-18
Objective:
To determine the accuracy of the optic nerve head (ONH) and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) parameters
using the Stratus OCT in the diagnosis of glaucoma and to determine the validity of these measurements.
Methods:
Glaucoma suspects undergoing glaucoma diagnostic tests were recruited consecutively. The numerical
results of the Stratus OCT fast optic disc and fast RNFL protocols were analyzed against an independent assessment
by glaucoma experts who were blinded as to the results of the OCT. An ROC curve analysis was applied to derive
estimates of diagnostic accuracy and multi-level likelihood ratios.
Results:
A total of 119 subjects assessed as glaucoma and 397 subjects assessed as normal were included. All ONH
and RNFL OCT parameters showed statistically significant differences in mean values between the 2 groups. The
ROC curve identified the vertical integrated rim area (AUC: 0.822), the cup-disc area ratio (AUC: 0.816), and the
horizontal integrated rim width (AUC: 0.794) as the best optic disc parameters; and the RNFL average thickness
(AUC: 0.827), the superior quadrant (AUC: 0.807), and the inferior quadrant (AUC: 0.804) as the best RNFL
parameters. Multi-level likelihood ratios for ONH and RNFL parameters were calibrated using a projected posttest
probability of 70% for a positive test result (therapeutic threshold) and a 10% posttest probability for a negative
result (diagnostic threshold).
Conclusion
The results showed that statistically significant mean differences in ONH and RNFL parameters
did not translate into a high predictive ability for each individual parameter. Single cut-off value for each OCT
parameter based on the best sensitivity and specificity combination did not result in high predictive values for any
single parameter. Multi-level likelihood ratios for the best ONH and RNFL parameters were derived to increase the
diagnostic capability of the Stratus OCT.
Tomography, Optical Coherence
;
Glaucoma
;
Optic Disk
4.Correlation of average RNFL thickness using the STRATUS OCT with the perimetric staging of glaucoma
Sharah Mae G. Kaw ; Jose Ma. Martinez ; Joseph Anthony Tumbocon ; Noel de Jesus Atienza
Philippine Journal of Ophthalmology 2012;37(1):19-23
Objective:
To determine the correlation between average peripapillary retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness
measured with time domain optical coherence tomography (TD-OCT) in normal and glaucoma eyes.
Methods:
This was a cross-sectional study of 281 eyes randomly selected from a previous study. Assessment of
glaucomatous damage was done by glaucoma specialists who based their diagnosis on the visual field tests and optic
disc photos, independent of OCT results. Eyes were classified into the following groups: normal, mild, moderate,
or severe glaucoma. Severity of glaucoma was based on visual field abnormalities following a modified HodappAnderson-Parish criteria for staging. Average RNFL thickness of normal and glaucoma subgroups, as measured
with STRATUS–OCT, were analyzed using single ANOVA test. Association between average RNFL thickness and
severity of glaucomatous visual field loss was evaluated using the Pearson’s correlation coefficient analysis.
Results:
183 eyes had no glaucoma; 27 had mild, 32 had moderate, and 39 had severe glaucoma. Mean average
peripapillary RNFL thickness (μm) in the normal, mild, moderate, and severe glaucoma groups were 98.05(±13.46),
76.27(±11.79), 76.42(±16.01), and 56.17(±14.92) respectively. Significant differences were seen in the average
RNFL thickness among the groups (P<0.05), except in eyes with mild to moderate glaucoma. A moderately strong
correlation of -0.57 (P<0.05) was observed between average RNFL thickness and the stage of glaucoma.
Conclusion
TD-OCT showed moderately strong correlation between the average RNFL thickness and perimetric
stages of glaucoma. Average RNFL thickness is a good parameter to discriminate normal from glaucoma eyes.
Tomography, Optical Coherence
;
Glaucoma
;
Visual Field Tests