1.Could the Doctors Have Their Own Language? : Doctoring through Doctor's Essay, Narrative Medicine
Korean Medical Education Review 2017;19(2):111-113
No abstract available.
Narration
2.Comparative Evaluation of Completeness of Traditional Narrative versus Electronic Synoptic Operative Reports for Ovarian, Peritoneal and Fallopian Tube Cancer Surgery in a Tertiary Government Hospital
Aubrey Y. Señ ; eris ; Jean Anne B. Toral
Acta Medica Philippina 2021;55(1):23-34
Objective. This study aimed to compare the completeness and ease of use of narrative reports (NR) submitted by residents compared to electronic synoptic reports (SR) by gynecologic oncology fellows for patients who underwent ovarian, fallopian, and peritoneal cancer surgery.
Methods. We conducted a cross-sectional study in the Department of Obstetrics-Gynecology of the Philippine General Hospital from August to November 2019. We assessed the NRs and electronic SRs for completeness of data using quality indicators.
Results. The average percentage of completeness of quality indicators is 77.1% (35.7/65). Eight indicators were absent in all NRs. Reporting of residual lesions was low (29.1%). The mean time to accomplish SRs (10.4 minutes) was significantly shorter than the mean time to accomplish NRs (21.9 minutes) (p value = 0.0001). SRs were assessed to be superior to NRs in several areas of surgery for quality, completeness and timeliness.
Conclusion. This study showed that the NRs should be improved and periodic audit must be done to maintain quality assurance. The use of SR appears to be favorable and superior in terms of time required to accomplish.
narration
3.Narrative evidence-based medicine:a strategy for evaluation of clinical efficacy of Chinese medicine.
Qiu-Ping CHEN ; Ming-Yi SHAO ; Qian BI ; Rui-Xia ZHAO ; Lan-Qing LYU ; Hong-Yan CUI
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2022;47(2):557-561
Rich experience of clinical diagnosis and treatment has been accumulated in the developmental history of Chinese medicine, and the efficacy has been increasingly accepted by the public. However, the evaluation of clinical efficacy is currently based more on scientific evidence instead of merely the changes of patient symptoms. In Chinese medicine, the changes of major disease indicators, patient symptoms, and pathogenesis are the major criteria for the evaluation of clinical efficacy. The lack of well-accepted and uniform criteria and the uncertainty of subjective evaluation limit the development of clinical Chinese medicine. Evidence-based medicine combines clinical skills with the current best evidence. Narrative medicine, utilizing people's narratives in clinical practice, emphasizes patient feelings, willingness, and value orientation. The introduction of both evidence-based medicine and narrative medicine into the evaluation of clinical efficacy refers to the construction of the clinical efficacy evaluation system in a paradigm of participatory diagnosis and treatment. It can fully reflect the characteristics of Chinese medicine, respect the values of patients, and achieve universal clinical evidence. Therefore, it helps to improve the diagnosis and treatment, the relationship between doctors and patients, patients' life quality and decision-making awareness, and finally the new evaluation model of clinical efficacy of Chinese medicine.
Evidence-Based Medicine
;
Humans
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Narrative Medicine
;
Physicians
;
Treatment Outcome
4.Application and significance of mixed methods research in traditional Chinese medicine and narrative medicine.
Yi-Fan SHI ; Guo-Zhen ZHAO ; Yu-Chen WANG ; Tian-Yuan WANG ; Bo LI ; Qing-Quan LIU
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2022;47(1):259-264
Since narrative medicine was introduced in China, it has been widely used in medical education and clinical practice. The research on narrative medicine in China is especially characterized by its combination with traditional Chinese medicine(TCM). At present, the research on narrative medicine in China is still in the stage of small-scale practicing and theory advocating. Besides, there is also a lack of guidance on experimental design methodology for clinical application, which leads to few high-quality studies in this field. The present study reviewed the current high-quality research on narrative medicine to discuss the value and prospects of mixed methods research in narrative medicine. In addition, the common design, application procedures, and notes of mixed methods research were explained to provide references for the extensive applications of narrative medicine in the medical field, especially TCM clinical practice, education, and scientific research.
China
;
Drugs, Chinese Herbal
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Narrative Medicine
;
Research Design
5.Evaluation methods of clinical efficacy of traditional Chinese medicine.
Ming ZHUANG ; Jia-Li AN ; Meng-Yuan ZHONG ; Chun-Yang WANG ; Xue-Chen DU ; Jia-Ni ZHAI ; Wen-Ke ZHENG
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2023;48(12):3263-3268
Clinical efficacy is the basis for the development of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM), and the evaluation of clinical efficacy of TCM has always been the focus of attention. The technical and methodological difficulties in the evaluation process often restrict the generation of high-level evidence. Therefore, methodological research should be deepened and innovative practice should be carried out to study the application of scientific research methods in the evaluation of the advantages of TCM. After more than ten years of development, the clinical efficacy evaluation of TCM, on the basis of the initially classic placebo randomized controlled trials, has successively carried out a series of meaningful attempts and explorations in N-of-1 trials, cohort studies, case-control studies, cross-sectional studies, real world studies, narrative medicine studies, systematic evaluation, and other aspects, laying the foundation for the transformation of TCM from "experience" to "evidence". This paper focused on the clinical efficacy evaluation of TCM, summarized the main connotation and development status of efficacy evaluation indicators, standards, and methods, and put forward corresponding countermeasures and suggestions for the problems of indicator selection, standard formulation, and methodology optimization in the research process. It is clear that scientific and objective evaluation of the efficacy of TCM is an urgent problem to be solved at present.
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Cross-Sectional Studies
;
Treatment Outcome
;
Case-Control Studies
;
Narrative Medicine
6.Discussion on design of clinical trial scheme for doctor-patient co-construction of traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine under concept of narrative medicine.
Yu XIN ; Hao-Xin YANG ; Xiu-Wen ZHANG ; Guo-Zhen ZHAO ; Yan-Yan DAI ; Bo LI
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2020;45(5):1202-1208
With the continuous improvement of modern medical technology, medical practice has become more and more procedural. The medical process is often dominated by doctors, while the value orientation of patients is often ignored, lacking effective communication between doctors and patients. In response to this phenomenon, Charon R proposed the concept of narrative medicine, which has been recognized by all walks of life. In recent years, the value of medical humanism has attracted more attention, and the research on narrative medicine at home and abroad is increasing gradually. But at present, most of the research on narrative medicine is in terms of theory, lacking clinical research. How to make narrative medicine applied in the real world is the focus of current research. Following the concept of narrative medicine, and taking the study on doctor-patient parallel medical record to evaluate the real clinical efficacy of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) and Western medicine(WM) in the treatment of digestive diseases as an example, this study is to explore the design contents and key points of the clinical trial scheme of doctor-patient co-construction of TCM and WM under narrative medicine, and discuss the activity form and clinical efficacy evaluation method under narrative medicine. Clinical trial design includes four aspects: medicine, ethics, statistics and trial management. This study explored the design of the doctor-patient co-construction clinical trial scheme under narrative medicine from both theoretical and practical aspects, providing reference for the design and research of future doctor-patient co-construction scheme, and expecting to establish a better efficacy evaluation method of TCM and WM.
Clinical Trials as Topic
;
Humans
;
Medical Records
;
Medicine, Chinese Traditional
;
Narrative Medicine
;
Patient Participation
;
Research Design
7.What is narrative medicine?
Journal of Zhejiang University. Medical sciences 2019;48(5):467-473
Narrative medicine first entered China in 2011 and has developed rapidly since then. The patient-centered care, shared decision making and relational medicine in the medical sphere, together with patients narrating their illness and narratology contributed to the rise of narrative medicine. Through listening to patients' narratives, paying attention to their emotions, and representing their stories in various ways, clinicians can connect with patients and empathize with them. In this way, affiliation and mutual trust with patients can be established. Patients will feel good in the doctor-patient encounter because of such humane care, and clinicians may get satisfaction from their work. Narrative medicine courses characterized by close reading of literature and writing should be added to the curriculum of medical education as the major content of medical humanities, so as to train narrative competence for the future doctors.
China
;
Curriculum
;
Education, Medical
;
Humans
;
Narrative Medicine
;
trends
;
Physician-Patient Relations
8.A narrative analysis on stories of underage smoking initiation among public school children
Christa R. Baniqued ; Stephanie I. Barbers ; Daniel K. Bañ ; as ; Marianne G. Bangloy ; Noel B. Bautista ; Katrina M. Barretto ; Kevin R. Base ; Jeremae D. Bassig ; Krisha F. Batalla ; Alyssa F. Bautista ; Trizia E. Bautista ; Joseph C. Beloso ; Sean C. Belo ; Kristian M. Bercero ; Franciosa Gavino-Collins
Health Sciences Journal 2020;9(2):38-45
INTRODUCTION:
Smoking is one of the most common preventable risk factors for disease and continues
to be a burden on public health, especially in developing countries like the Philippines. This study aims
to provide an understanding of underage Filipino smokers that is sensitive to the context within which
they are found.
METHODS:
The narrative approach was used to understand events across time and in a way that gave
meaning to the storied experience of the participants. Core story creation and emplotment were used to
flesh out the narratives of smoking initiation. The stories of six residents of Barangay Doña Imelda were
analyzed to understand the significance of smoking initiation in their context.
RESULTS:
The overarching narrative found was “putting meaning into time” and from this, three themes
emerged: 1) time is meaningful when shared, 2) finding solace from the struggles of daily living, and
3) resisting oppressive structures. Using these insights, the discussion was grounded on anti-smoking campaigns such as the DOH Annual No Smoking Month, the Sin Tax Law, and the Nationwide Smoking Ban.
CONCLUSION
This paper concludes that a more proactive approach to smoking initiation is warranted by
making meaningful alternative activities available to public school children.
Narration
;
Smoking
;
9.An Intervention Model to Help Clients to Seek Their Own Hope Experiences: The Narrative Communication Model of Hope Seeking Intervention.
Dal Sook KIM ; Hesook Suzie KIM ; Sally THORNE
Korean Journal of Hospice and Palliative Care 2017;20(1):1-7
The paper describes The Narrative Communication Model of Hope Seeking Intervention developed by the authors as an approach to help clients to have individually specific hope experiences. The Model is founded upon the existential conceptualization of hope that views hope as subjective, unique experiences of meaning and processes. The Model has been developed based on the findings both in the literature and the authors' work on the nature of hope and hope experiences and integrating the concept of hope as subjective meanings and experiences, the processes of story-telling and the concept of narrative configuration as a way to engage in person-specific experiences, and person-centered communication. The results of the experiences with the application of the model in a study are used to clarify the model further. The Model incorporating story-telling and narrative construction through person-centered communication is identified in three components–the story-telling, the narrative intervention, and the communication components. These components are processed as an intervention to culminate into person-specific hope experiences in which active participation of clients as the story-teller and of interventionist as the communicative facilitator is required to produce narratives of hope with individual specific thematic plots that become the basis for hope experiences. The application of the Model has shown positive outcomes in clients with successful seeking of own hope experiences. The success of the Model application seems to depend upon interventionists' understanding of the model and the competency with the application of person-centered communication strategies.
Hope*
;
Individuality
;
Models, Theoretical
;
Narration
;
Patient-Centered Care
10.Hansen's Oral Life Histories and Healing.
Korean Journal of Medical History 2013;22(2):389-420
The individual oral statement is human story based on experience. The personal experience forms unconsciousness which appears in a form of oral statement by ego that doesn't want to lose existence. Thus, the process which exposes a tormented hearts is the objectification of oneself. Through this step, oral person attains a healing. If this sort of individual oral is accrued, the undeserved personal affairs could be a history. In case of Hansen's disease patient, She could escape from negative understanding about herself and the world. Furthermore, She kept formating her values about meaningful life and future oriented value. Also, She wants to keep a record of her life. She comes to know that what she denied is actually what she should surmount over oral statement. As a result, She could attains a healing for oneself through oral statement. The oral statement made her look into she's problems. Therefore, oral statement is a self-realization. Through this, person could know what the problem is and solution. This research is about only one person, so there is need for more cases and studies. If this sort of individual oral statement is accrued, there could be a curative narration. This can suggest an curative alternative when we suffer from problem of life. The merit of this research is rendering this possibility.
Ego
;
Heart
;
Humans
;
Leprosy
;
Narration
;
Unconsciousness
;
United Nations