1.Concerns, perceived impact and preparedness in an avian influenza pandemic--a comparative study between healthcare workers in primary and tertiary care.
Teck Yee WONG ; Gerald Ch KOH ; Seng Kwing CHEONG ; Heow Yong LEE ; Yuke Tien FONG ; Meena SUNDRAM ; Kelvin KOH ; Sin Eng CHIA ; David KOH
Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore 2008;37(2):96-102
INTRODUCTIONWith the potential threat of an avian influenza (AI) pandemic, healthcare workers (HCWs) are expected to play important roles, and they encounter significant stress levels from an expected increase in workload. We compared the concerns, perceived impact and preparedness for an AI pandemic between HCWs working in public primary care clinics and a tertiary healthcare setting.
MATERIALS AND METHODSAn anonymous, self-administered questionnaire was given to 2459 HCWs working at 18 public polyclinics (PCs) and a tertiary hospital (TH) in Singapore from March to June 2006. The questionnaire assessed work-related and non-work-related concerns, perceived impact on personal life and work as well as workplace preparedness.
RESULTSWe obtained responses from 986 PC and 873 TH HCWs (response rate: 74.6% and 76.7%). The majority in both groups were concerned about the high AI risk from their occupation (82.7%) and falling ill with AI (75.9%). 71.9% accepted the risk but 25.5% felt that they should not be looking after AI patients with 15.0% consider resigning. HCWs also felt that people would avoid them (63.5%) and their families (54.1%) during a pandemic. The majority expected an increased workload and to feel more stressed at work. For preparedness, 74.2% felt personally prepared and 83.7% felt that their workplaces were prepared for an outbreak. TH HCWs were more likely to be involved in infection-control activities but the perception of infection-control preparedness in both groups was high (>80.0%).
CONCLUSIONSHCWs in both public primary and tertiary healthcare settings felt prepared, personally and in their workplaces, for a pandemic. Their main concerns were risks of falling ill from exposure and the possibility of social ostracism of themselves and their families. Preparedness levels appeared high in the majority of HCWs. However, concerns of HCWs could affect their overall effectiveness in a pandemic and should be addressed by incorporating strategies to manage them in pandemic planning.
Adolescent ; Adult ; Aged ; Animals ; Attitude of Health Personnel ; Birds ; Disaster Planning ; Disease Outbreaks ; Female ; Humans ; Infectious Disease Transmission, Patient-to-Professional ; prevention & control ; Influenza A Virus, H5N1 Subtype ; pathogenicity ; Influenza in Birds ; transmission ; Influenza, Human ; epidemiology ; prevention & control ; transmission ; virology ; Male ; Middle Aged ; Primary Health Care ; Singapore
2.A cross-sectional study of primary-care physicians in Singapore on their concerns and preparedness for an avian influenza outbreak.
Teck Yee WONG ; Gerald C H KOH ; Seng Kwing CHEONG ; Meena SUNDRAM ; Kelvin KOH ; Sin Eng CHIA ; David KOH
Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore 2008;37(6):458-464
INTRODUCTIONDuring an avian influenza (AI) pandemic, primary-care physicians (PCPs) are expected to play key roles in the prevention and control of the disease. Different groups of PCPs could have different concerns and preparedness level. We assessed the concerns, perceived impact and preparedness for an outbreak among PCPs in Singapore.
MATERIALS AND METHODSA cross-sectional survey of PCPs working in private practice (n=200) and public clinics (n=205) from March to June 2006 with an anonymous self-administered questionnaire on concerns (12- items), perceived impact (10 items) and preparedness (10 items) for an outbreak.
RESULTSTwo hundred and eighty-five PCPs responded - 149 (response rate: 72.7%) public and 136 (response rate: 67.3%) private. The majority were concerned about risk to their health from their occupation (95.0%) and falling ill with AI (89.7%). Most (82.5%) accepted the risk and only 33 (11.8%) would consider stopping work. For perceived impact, most felt that people would avoid them (69.6%) and their families (54.1%). The majority (81.3%) expected an increased workload and feeling more stressed at work (86.9%). For preparedness, 78.7% felt personally prepared for an outbreak. Public PCPs were more likely to be involved in infection-control activities and felt that their workplaces were prepared.
CONCLUSIONSMost PCPs felt personally prepared for an outbreak but were concerned about their exposure to AI and falling ill. Other concerns included social ostracism for themselves and their families. Public PCPs appeared to have a higher level of preparation. Addressing concerns and improving level of preparedness are crucial to strengthen the primary-care response for any AI outbreak.
Adult ; Animals ; Birds ; Communicable Disease Control ; methods ; Cross-Sectional Studies ; Disease Outbreaks ; prevention & control ; statistics & numerical data ; Female ; Health Care Surveys ; Humans ; Influenza A Virus, H5N1 Subtype ; isolation & purification ; Influenza in Birds ; epidemiology ; Male ; Middle Aged ; Odds Ratio ; Physicians, Family ; statistics & numerical data ; Risk Factors ; Singapore ; epidemiology ; Surveys and Questionnaires