Assessment of post-traumatic stress disorder is a frequently encountered problem in forensic practices. Detection of malingering has become a focus in these assessments. While it is a difficult task due to kinds of traumatic events, complex clinical symptoms, subjective medical information, and presence of diverse psychotic disorders. The clinical traits, detecting methods and testing instruments of PTSD malingering were reviewed so as to help practical management and assessment.
Forensic Psychiatry ; Humans ; Lie Detection ; Malingering/diagnosis* ; Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic/diagnosis*

OBJECTIVE: The diagnosis of myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is commonly made by Simons' clinical diagnostic criteria which is mainly based on patients' complaints, so it is difficult to distinguish from malingering. The purpose of this study is to evaluate local twitch response by needling (LTR) as an objective diagnostic criterion of MPS. METHOD: Forty four industrial designers complaining of regional pain in neck, shoulder, or upper arm were examined by a physiatrist. If trigger point was detected, local twitch response by needling was confirmed and than severity was measured by 4 grades. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value of local twitch response was calculated with diagnosis made by Simons' clinical diagnostic criteria. Correlation between grade of local twitch response and sum of clinical features in Simons' criteria was also evaluated. RESULTS: Local twitch response by needling was corresponding with the diagnosis of MPS by Simons' criteria (sensitivity 100%, specificity 96.7%, positive predictive value 93.3%), and the severity of local twitch response was significantly associated with sum of clinical features in Simons' criteria (Spearman correlation 0.950; p=0.048) CONCLUSION: Local twitch response by needling is an important and objective diagnostic criterion of MPS.
Arm ; Diagnosis ; Malingering ; Myofascial Pain Syndromes* ; Neck ; Sensitivity and Specificity ; Shoulder ; Trigger Points

The objective is to review a case of pneumoparotitis and to discuss how knowledge of this unique presentation is important when making differential diagnoses in emergency medicine. A patient with recurrent subcutaneous emphysema of the head and neck is reviewed. Stenson's duct demonstrated purulent discharge. Physical examination revealed palpable crepitance of the head and neck. Fiberoptic laryngoscopy and barium esophagram were normal. Computed tomography demonstrated left pneumoparotitis and subcutaneous emphysema from the scalp to the clavicles. This is an unusual presentation of pneumoparotitis and malingering. Emergency physicians should be aware of pneumoparotitis and its presentation when creating a differential diagnosis for pneumomediastinum, which includes more life-threatening diagnoses such as airway or esophageal injuries.
Barium ; Clavicle ; Diagnosis ; Diagnosis, Differential ; Emergencies ; Emergency Medicine ; Head ; Humans ; Laryngoscopy ; Malingering ; Mediastinal Emphysema ; Neck ; Physical Examination ; Scalp ; Subcutaneous Emphysema

The authors reported a case and its diagnostic process of post-traumatic narcolepsy which had developed after a head trauma. The 51-years-old patient showed frequent generalized paralytic attack, which was aggravated during stressful situation, diet time, and in front of hospital staffs. During the paralytic attack, consciousness was alert, and he never collapsed to hurt. All laboratory findings including serum potassium level were within normal limit, and also brain imaging studies and electroencephalography revealed no specific abnormal findings. Our clinical impression was a conversion disorder or a malingering at first, but after the detailed history taking and the careful observation, daytime sleep attack and some sleep problems were revealed. Thus nocturnal polysomnography and multiple sleep latency test(MSLT) were performed, and then the authors could diagnose as "narcolepsy". HLA-DR2 typing was negative. After imipramine trial, the frequency and the intensity of attack was dramatically reduced. The authors concluded that narcolepsy should be considered in the differential diagnosis of sleepiness or transient loss of muscle tone after traumatic brain injury.
Brain Injuries* ; Cataplexy ; Consciousness ; Conversion Disorder ; Craniocerebral Trauma ; Diagnosis, Differential ; Diet ; Electroencephalography ; HLA-DR2 Antigen ; Humans ; Imipramine ; Malingering ; Narcolepsy* ; Neuroimaging ; Polysomnography ; Potassium

OBJECTIVE: To develop an objective criteria with computerized dynamic posturography (CDP) for identification of non-organic or malingering symptoms of balance disorders. METHODS: One hundred and four normal subjects were instructed to feign balance disturbance after naturally performing on CDP. Paired t-test was used to determine if there was significant difference of CDP equilibrium scores between normal and malingering performance. The CDP records including raw curve of 50 subjects were critically evaluated by previously published seven criteria in indicating malingering performance. If the sensitivity of a criterion was greater than 90%, it would be accepted as our laboratory's identifying criterion. The CDP records of remaining 54 subjects were used to test the sensitivity and specificity of the accepted criteria. RESULTS: There were statistically significant differences of CDP equilibrium scores between normal and malingering performance (P < 0.01). The mean equilibrium scores of malingering performance were lower than that of normal performance. The sensitivity and specificity of our criteria for identifying malingerers were 92.5% and 98.2%, respectively. CONCLUSION It is necessary to identify malingering performance before analyzing the CDP equilibrium scores. Our identifying criteria of malingerers seems to be quite useful and accurate.
Adult ; Diagnosis, Computer-Assisted/methods* ; Diagnosis, Differential ; Female ; Forensic Medicine ; Humans ; Image Processing, Computer-Assisted ; Male ; Malingering/diagnosis* ; Neuropsychological Tests ; Postural Balance/physiology* ; Posture/physiology* ; Sensitivity and Specificity ; Vestibular Diseases/diagnosis*

OBJECTIVE: To study the application value of contrast vision in identifying the malingering decreased vision in the practice of clinical forensic medicine. METHODS: Thirty-one young and middle aged volunteers were selected and divided randomly into group 1 (16 persons with 32 eyes) and group 2 (15 persons with 30 eyes). The optotype contrast was 100%, 25%, 10% and 5%, respectively. The contrast vision of group 1 was tested. The contrast vision of group 2 was tested as follows: (1) the volunteers cooperated without inspector's interference; (2) the volunteers cooperated under inspector's interference; (3) the volunteers disguised decreased vision without inspector's interference; (4) the volunteers disguised decreased vision under inspector's interference. The data was then analyzed by statistics. RESULTS: There was a close correlation between contrast vision and contrast. As the contrast decreased, the vision acuity also decreased. The contrast vision curve of former two methods showed a good reproducibility while the contrast vision curve of latter two methods had a bad reproducibility. CONCLUSION The repetition of contrast curve with or without inspector's interference can be used to discriminate malingering vision. The acquired contrast curves can be provided to the court as direct evidence and can help enhance the verification conclusion.
Adult ; Contrast Sensitivity/physiology* ; Diagnosis, Differential ; Female ; Humans ; Male ; Malingering/psychology* ; Reproducibility of Results ; Sensitivity and Specificity ; Severity of Illness Index ; Vision Tests/statistics & numerical data* ; Vision, Binocular ; Vision, Low/psychology* ; Visual Acuity ; Young Adult