1.Factors that Influence the Decision Maker regarding End-of-life Care
Masahiro Iwabuchi ; Kazuki Sato ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Tatsuya Morita ; Hiroya Kinoshita
Palliative Care Research 2016;11(2):189-200
Objectives:To determine the factors that influence the decision maker regarding end-of-life (EOL) care and to disclose how aggressive care in the last week before death, place of death, and quality-of-life (QOL) affected the decisions made. Methods:The subjects were 409 bereaved family members (cause of death included cancer, stroke, heart disease, and pneumonia) that registered with an internet research agency. Decision-making was controlled either by the patient, family, or physician or shared by the patient, family, and physician. Results:The results of a multinomial logistic regression analysis demonstrated that when a family controlled decision-making, they were less likely to report patient-family EOL discussion [odds ratio (OR)=0.52], and that the patient had good communication with the physician (OR=0.77); they were also likely to report that the patient had dementia (OR=1.94). Families who reported physician-controlled decision-making (vs patient controlled) were less likely to report that the patient had good communication with the physician (OR=0.62). Cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the last week and place of death were not associated with the decision maker. EOL QOL was associated with EOL care of the decision maker. When a physician controlled decision-making, patient EOL QOL was at its lowest. Conclusion:To improve patient-controlled decision-making, it is critical that patients, families, and physicians have more communication regarding EOL care.
2.Caregiving Consequence for Dying Elderly Patients with and without Comorbid Dementia from the Perspective of Bereaved Family Members
Kazuki Sato ; Miyu Serizawa ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Hiroya Kinoshita
Palliative Care Research 2017;12(1):159-168
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate the consequences of caring for end-of-life elderly patients from the bereaved family’s perspective. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional, anonymous, self-report questionnaire survey for bereaved family members by web survey. Outcomes were caregiving consequences (Caregiving Consequences Inventory). We compared the outcomes between with and without dementia. Results: 163 and 224 dying elderly patients with and without comorbid dementia were analyzed from bereaved family members’ responses. The outcomes were not significantly different (burden, 5.24±1.12, 5.32±1.24, p=0.487; fulfillment, 4.53±1.06, 4.59±1.29, p=0.627; growth, 4.94±0.93, 5.00±1.04, p=0.523). Fulfillment was significantly associated with spouse, family visitation, and mental health. Growth was significantly associated with age, spouse, end-of-life discussion, and family preference of treatments. Conclusion: The evaluation of the consequences of caring for end-of-life elderly patients from the bereaved family’s perspective were not significantly between the informal caregivers of those with and without comorbid dementia.
3.Good Death of Dying Elderly Patients with and without Comorbid Dementia from the Perspective of Bereaved Family Members
Kazuki Sato ; Arisa Kikuchi ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Hiroya Kinoshita
Palliative Care Research 2017;12(1):149-158
Objectives: This study aimed to evaluate good death (end-of-life quality of life) from the perspective of bereaved family members. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional, anonymous, self-report questionnaire survey for bereaved family members by web survey. Outcomes were achievement of a good death (Good Death Inventory, GDI). We compared the outcomes between with and without dementia. Results: 163 and 224 dying elderly patients with and without comorbid dementia were analyzed from bereaved family members’ responses. The achievement of good death were significantly different (GDI scores, 4.2±1.0, 4.4±0.9, Adj P=0.053) as regards “maintaining hope and pleasure,” “good relationship with family,” and “independence.” Conclusion: The achievement of good death was not significantly different between the dying elderly patients with and without comorbid dementia. Psychosocial care for informal caregivers would be important for better quality of dying in the terminally ill elderly patients with dementia.
4.The Japanese perception of feasibility of end-of-life home care until death and related factors.
Kazuki Sato ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Tatsuya Morita ; Masao Suzuki
Palliative Care Research 2007;2(1):101-111
Purpose: To clarify factors associated with the Japanese perception of whether they can live at home until death with the inclusion of knowledge and beliefs about end-of-life. Methods: A questionnaire survey was conducted on the Japanese general population who participated in a lecture meeting about palliative home care (N=61, effective response rate, 100%). Results: Ten (16%) responded they could live at home until death. Barriers to end-of-life home care were "Home care would burden my family (80%)," " Family and I are anxious about emergency care when I get worse (59%)" and "Family and I are anxious about whether I can enter a hospital emergently when I get worse (52%)" in that order. From the multivariate logistic regression model, respondents who expressed "Opioids cause addiction (OR, 95% confidential interval (CI):0.29, 0.09-0.99)" and "Artificial hydration and nutrition should be continued as the minimum standard until death (OR, 95%CI:0.39, 0.16-0.95)" were more likely to perceive that they could live at home until death. Conclusion: The empowerment activity for the general population regarding correct knowledge about palliative care, benefit and disadvantage of life-sustaining treatment, and correct knowledge about home care is important for the end-of-life patients who want to live at home until death to achieve their wish.
5.Quality indicator in palliative care: A review
Mitsunori Miyashita ; Kazuki Sato ; Tatsuya Morita ; Chisato Hamashima ; Tomotaka Sobue
Palliative Care Research 2007;2(2):401-415
As measuring the quality of palliative care is considered to be important, quality indicators (QIs) that are able to extracted from medical database or from medical chart review have recently been developed in Western countries. In this paper, we reviewed the development of QIs and actual measurements collected in palliative care settings. The present results indicate that QIs based on data extracted from such sources as the cancer registry, medical claim, and palliative care databases, include items regarding aggressive treatment, hospice use, and intensive care units visits. Furthermore, QIs based on data extracted from medical chart reviews were developed for use with community-dwelling elderly patients. As with other QIs, QIs utilized at ICUs, QIs utilized at nursing homes, and evaluation of care from the perspective of bereaved families was conducted. In the future, QI items and methods appropriate for Japanese medical settings should be developed and their feasibility, reliability, and validity should be examined.
6.Simultaneous Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy and Cardiac Surgery in a Patient with Triple Coronary Vessel Disease, Mitral and Tricuspid Valve Insufficiency after Three-Area Old Myocardial Infarction
Takashi Miura ; Imun Tei ; Takashi Oshitomi ; Kazuki Sato ; Eiichi Tei
Japanese Journal of Cardiovascular Surgery 2005;34(3):220-224
We performed cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) in addition to coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG), mitral valve replacement (MVR) and tricuspid valve annuloplasty (TAP) in a 72-year-old patient with poor cardiac function (New York Heart Association functional class III, ejection fraction 38%), triple coronary vessel disease, and mitral and tricuspid valve insufficiency after three-area old myocardial infarction. Electrocardiography showed no change in the QRS interval after CRT. However, tissue Doppler echocardiography showed synchronicity of the septum and posterior segments in the left ventricle, and that contraction of the septum was in the systolic phase of the cardiac cycle after CRT. New York Heart Association functional class improved from III to I after the operation. CRT of the dyssynchronized myocardium in which ischemia and volume overload were improved by CABG, MVR and TAP may improve regional cardiac function and synchronicity.
7.Analysis of administrative data to investigate end-of-life cancer care in a Japanese university hospital: development of methodology
Yuko Sato ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Kenji Fujimori ; Jun Nakaya ; Yoko Fujimoto ; Makoto Kurihara ; Kazuki Sato ; Chikashi Ishioka
Palliative Care Research 2015;10(3):177-185
Purpose:To explore a methodology for evaluating end-of-life (EOL) cancer care using diagnosis procedure combination (DPC) administrative data. Methods: We investigated care provided to inpatients whose deaths were attributed to cancer and occurred between August 2010 and December 2012. We measured the quality of palliative care by dividing the decedents into two groups: those who died in the palliative care unit (PCU) and those who died in the general wards(GW). Results: A total of 311 inpatient deaths were identified as cancer deaths. Of these, 147 patients were included in the PCU group and 164 in the GW group. We calculated the DPC data as follows: the rates of chemotherapy administered within 30 days before death (PCU 0%, GW 27%) and within 14 days before death (PCU 0%, GW 10%), admission to the intensive care unit (PCU 0%, GW 2%), life-sustaining interventions (PCU 0%, GW 3%), rehabilitation sessions (PCU 10%, GW 26%), emergency admission (PCU 2%, GW 27%), and antibiotics (PCU 32%, GW 28%). In the PCU group, rates of chemotherapy and emergency admission were significantly lower(<0.0001;<0.0001, respectively), and rehabilitation sessions were significantly higher (p=0.0002) than in the GW group. Conclusion: EOL care in a university hospital can be easily investigated using DPC data. Some limitations are the single-site study design, the health insurance system, and secondary use of administrative data. However, this methodology may be adapted to investigate the entire Japanese claim database and to evaluate EOL cancer care.
8.A Preliminary Survey to Measure the Quality Indicators of End-of-life Cancer Care Using the Japanese National Database
Yuko Sato ; Kenji Fujimori ; Koichi Benjamin Ishikawa ; Kazuki Sato ; Chikashi Ishioka ; Mitsunori Miyashita
Palliative Care Research 2016;11(2):156-165
Purpose: This survey aimed to develop a methodology for measuring the quality indicators of end-of-life care for cancer patients using the Japanese National Database, which was comprised of the health insurance claim data of all Japanese people. Methods: Life-sustaining treatment (LST) and chemotherapy near the time of death are accepted as reliable indicators of poor quality end-of-life care. To measure these, the Sampling Data Set (SDS) from the National Database (NDB) was used. Results: 1,233 cancer patients were studied, who had died from 14th to 31st October, 2012. The rates of LST and chemotherapy in the final 14 days of life were 8.2% (95%CI 6.7-10.1), 3.5% (2.6-4.8) for inpatients (n=1,079) respectively. In the SDS, 27-70% of chemotherapy drugs were not named, in order to prevent identification of patients receiving rare treatment. Discussion: The figures for rates of chemotherapy might be underestimated in the sampling data set, because of the anonymization of rare treatment. And in-patient and out-patient data may in some cases have been duplicated when entries applied to the same person. In the future using the NDB, it might be possible overcome some of these limitations.
9.Preliminary study for the brief measure of quality of life and quality of care for the national random sampling hospital survey: content validity and interpretability
Megumi Shimizu ; Kazuki Sato ; Masashi Kato ; Daisuke Fujisawa ; Tatsuya Morita ; Mitsunori Miyashita
Palliative Care Research 2015;10(4):223-237
To monitor the quality of life (QOL)of cancer patients through the Patient Behavior Survey, a large population-based survey, we developed a short QOL and quality of care (QOC)questionnaire. In order to help evaluate QOL in cancer patients, we also conducted a web–based survey designed to evaluate the content validity and interpretability of the questionnaire. In total, 630 cancer patients completed the survey. For each item, the result that more than 90% responses determined the item was of importance indicated that the item was important for living with cancer. Regarding items related to QOC, satisfaction with care, we consolidated responses; for example, the answer of “neutral” could also be interpreted as “almost satisfied” and patients who answered “other” may also mean that the item does not apply to them. We found that this questionnaire accurately evaluated the QOL of cancer patients and the responses were interpretable and presentable.
10.Practical Use of Feedback Report of Nationwide Bereavement Survey in Participated Institutions
Naoko Igarashi ; Maho Aoyama ; Kazuki Sato ; Tatsuya Morita ; Yoshiyuki Kizawa ; Satoru Tsuneto ; Yasuo Shima ; Mitsunori Miyashita
Palliative Care Research 2017;12(1):131-139
Aims: The aim of this study was to clarify practical use of feedback report in each institution participated the nationwide bereavement survey (J-HOPE3). Methods: After a nationwide bereavement survey (J-HOPE3) conducted in 2014, we sent a feedback report to each participated institution (20 general wards, 133 inpatient palliative care units, and 22 home hospice services). The feedback report included the results from quality of care, bereaved family’s mental status, and free comments from the participant of their own institution. We sent a questionnaire 4 month following to the feedback report for all institutions regarding the practical use of results from the feedback report. Results: The analysis included 129 (response rate 74%) returned questionnaires. The institutions that they passed around the report was 90%, discussed about their results at a staff meeting was 54%, and reported the results to manager/chief of the institution was 65%. Around 80% of the institutions responded positively to receive the feedback report of their own institution such as “It was good that they could understand the strengths and weakness of their own institutions” which reported that they worked on to improve care were 48%. Conclusions: Current study had shown data about practical use of the feedback report of bereavement study. It is important to feedback the results and encourage the institution to make use of the results in their daily practice, especially to discuss the results in staff meetings.