1.Comparison of domestic laws and regulations related to experimental animals and international terrestrial animal health codes
Kangning XUE ; Xiaoyu LIU ; Chihong ZHAO
Chinese Journal of Comparative Medicine 2016;26(2):7-11
The concept of “experimental animals” has been raised up, while we still need relevant laws and regulations on experimental animals.Accordingly, a potential safety hazard may occur when using these animals.Here we compare the content of the“Animal Epidemic Prevention Law of the People’ s Republic of China” and “Regulations for Experimental Animal Management”, with the “Terrestrial Animal Health Code” issued by International Organisation for Animal Health ( Office International des Epizooties,OIE) , in order to provide some advice to completing the relevant laws in China.
2.Difference between the cognitive and control ability and the responsibility in forensic psychiatry evaluation.
Xue-Wu LI ; Bei-Ling GAO ; Feng HU ; Chao WU ; Hua ZHANG ; Ya-Jun GUAN ; Wu LAI ; Yi LI ; Yi WANG ; Dong-Ling WU ; Xiao-Lan CAO
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2013;29(4):263-267
OBJECTIVE:
To analyze the difference between the cognitive and control ability and the responsibility in forensic psychiatry evaluation.
METHODS:
To compare the results of the responsibility evaluation from 2001.1 to 2006.10 (the first period) with that of the cognitive and control ability evaluation from 2006.11 to 2010.10 (the second period). The admissibility opinions on court judgment and evaluation were investigated by return visit. The legal professions' opinions on forensic psychiatric issues from the police office, the procuratorate, the court, and the judiciary were investigated.
RESULTS:
There was no significant difference of the criminal types between two periods (P > 0.05). There was significant difference of the diagnostic types between two periods (P < 0.05). The proportion of normal range and part loss of the cognitive and control ability in the second period were higher than that in the first period, but the proportion of complete loss of the cognitive and control ability in the second period was lower than that in the first period (P < 0.05). Among the legal professions, 70.5% of them thought that "the evaluation of cognitive and control ability" was different from "the evaluation of criminal responsibility" and 94.9% of them thought that "to confirm the influence of the forensic psychiatric evaluation of mental disorder on the crime behavior" or "to assess of cognitive and control ability" met requirements of normative judicial expertise.
CONCLUSION
The evaluation of cognitive and control ability is more aligned with legal requirements and behavioral norms of own subject than the evaluation of responsibility.
Crime/psychology*
;
Expert Testimony
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Insanity Defense
;
Mental Competency
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
3.An examination of the self-reported scale of brief psychopathological symptoms to detect malingering in forensic psychiatric subjects.
Bei-ling GAO ; Zhi-biao HUANG ; Dong-ling WU ; Shu-ming DING ; Wei-de LIANG ; Xue-wu LI
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2008;24(4):256-258
OBJECTIVE:
To examine the self-reported scale of brief psychopathological symptoms (SBPS) to detect malingering in forensic psychiatric cases.
METHODS:
Two hundred and six cases with different types of psychiatric problems were tested by SBPS. All cases were separately evaluated by two experts.
RESULTS:
About 34.5% cases (71/206) were classified as malingering by the cut-off 13 scores of SBPS. Compared with expert's evaluation, SBPS showed a false negative rate of 19.8% and a false positive rate of 1.7%, respectively, with a total accuracy rate of 90.8%. Cases involved in compensations including working injury and traffic accidence showed the highest rate of malingering (51%).
CONCLUSION
SBPS is useful for detecting malingering psychopathological symptoms.
Adult
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Lie Detection
;
Male
;
Malingering/psychology*
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Psychological Tests
;
Reproducibility of Results
;
Volition
;
Young Adult