Neoplasms of the urachus are uncommon, consisting of only 0.17% of all bladder malignancy. Mucinous cystic tumor of low malignant potential (MCLTMP) is a rare subtype with only 26 cases reported in the literature as of 2023. These tumors may present in a variety of ways such as hematuria, mucusuria, lower abdominal pain and irritative lower urinary tract symptoms. This is a case of 43-year-old female presenting at the emergency room for abdominal pain initially managed as a case of ovarian new growth in complication who underwent exploratory laparotomy, adhesiolysis, bilateral salpingectomy, partial cystectomy enbloc removal of urachal with anterior peritonectomy and excision of umbilicus. Histopathologic examination revealed mucinous cystic tumor of low malignant potential (MCLTMP) of the urachus. It is important to consider the possibility of a ruptured urachal cyst in a female patient who presents with hypogastric abdominal pain. A transabdominal and transvaginal ultrasound may lead to an incorrect diagnosis. In such cases where the patient presented with an acute abdomen, knowledge that a ruptured urachal cyst maybe a differential for such masses would lead to a strategic laparotomy incision aimed at a possible en-bloc removal of the umbilicus while maintaining the connections of the possible urachal mass to the urinary bladder.