1. Meta analysis on effectiveness of epidermal growth factor in treating patients with inhalation injury
Xiaoqing LI ; Wenjun LIU ; Jianxing DUAN ; Wuquan LI ; Xin WANG ; Yating WEI
Chinese Journal of Burns 2018;34(7):459-465
Objective:
To systematically evaluate the effectiveness of epidermal growth factor (EGF) in treating patients with inhalation injury by meta analysis.
Methods:
Databases including PubMed, Cochrance Library, and Embase were searched using key words " inhalation injury, smoke inhalation injury, epidermal growth factor, and EGF" , and Chinese Journals Full-text Database, China Biology Medicine disc, VIP Database, and Wanfang Database were searched using key words in Chinese version "吸入性损伤,表皮生长因子" to obtain the randomized controlled trails about EGF published publicly in the treatment of patients with inhalation injury from the establishment of each database to December 2017. The measurement indexes included content of total protein and albumin, colloid osmotic pressure (COP), the number of total cells, percentages of neutrophils, lymphocytes, and fibroblasts in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), the time of disappearance of pulmonary symptoms, the time of exfoliation of necrotic mucous membrane, the time of removal of tracheal tube, the amount of respiratory secretions, and the incidence of lung infection. Meta-analysis was conducted by RevMan 5.3 statistical software.
Results:
A total of 6 trials involving 375 patients were included, with 182 patients in group EGF who received EGF treatment and 173 patients in conventional treatment group who received conventional treatment. All of the 6 trails had unclear risk of bias. The content of total protein and albumin and COP in BALF of patients in group EGF were lower than those in conventional treatment group, with standardized mean differences (SMDs) respectively -9.37, -26.77 , and -8.13 [with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) respectively -14.11--4.63, -41.85--11.69, -9.54--6.73,
2. Network meta analysis of the effectiveness of surgery combined with multiple interventions in treating patients with ear keloids
Xiaoqing LI ; Wenjun LIU ; Jianxing DUAN ; Xin WANG ; Di WANG ; Gaofei ZHANG ; Yating WEI
Chinese Journal of Plastic Surgery 2018;34(12):1010-1019
Objective:
To evaluate the effectiveness of surgery combined with multiple interventions in treating patients with ear keloid by network meta-analysis.
Methods:
Databases including " PubMed" , " Cochrane Library" were searched using key words " (((((((((((Ear, External[MeSH Terms]]] OR (Ears, Exernal]] OR (Outer Ear]] OR (Ear, Outer]] OR (Ears, Outer]] OR (External Ear]]] AND (((keloid[Mesh Terms]]] OR (keloids]]] AND ((((((surgery[MeSH Terms]]] OR (operative therapy]] OR (operative procedures]] OR (invasive procedures]] OR (operations]]]] AND (randomized controlled trial[pt]]" , database " Embase" was searched using key words ((′external ear′/exp] OR(′auricle′/exp] OR (′ear lobe′/exp]] AND ((′surgery′/exp] OR (′ear surgery′/exp]] AND (′keloid′/exp] AND (′randomized controlled trial′/exp] and Chineses journals full-text database, China biology medicine disc, VIP database, and Wanfang database were searched using key words in chinese version "耳瘢痕疙瘩,手术" to obtain the randomized controlled trails about surgery combined with multiple interventions in the treatment of ear keloid from the establishment of each database to June 2018. EndNote X7, Revman 5.3, STATA 14.0, GeMTC 14.3 statistical software were used to extract data from studies, study quality assessment, drawing network figure, publication bias analysis, traditional meta-analysis, heterogeneity test, consistency test, similarity test, network meta-analysis.
Results:
A total of 18 trails involving 8 therapeutic measures were included, and 1 425 patients with ear keloid were included. All of the 18 trails had high risk of bias. The network figure shows that there are 28 different pairwise comparisons among the eight treatments. Of the 18 studies included, 10 were directly compared, and the remaining 18 were not directly evidenced, those comparisons will be made indirectly by the network meta-analysis. The basic symmetry of each point in the funnel plot and the
3.Meta-analysis of clinical effects of microskin grafting and Meek microskin grafting in repairing extensively deep burn wounds
Gaofei ZHANG ; Wenjun LIU ; Di WANG ; Jianxing DUAN ; Xiaoqing LI
Chinese Journal of Burns 2020;36(7):560-567
Objective:To systematically evaluate the clinical effects of microskin grafting and Meek microskin grafting in repairing extensively deep burn wounds using meta-analysis.Methods:Foreign language databases including PubMed and Cochrane Library were searched with the terms of " Meek micrografting, burn" , and Chinese databases including Chinese Journal Full- Text Database, Chinese Biomedical Database, VIP database, and Wanfang Data were searched with the terms in Chinese version of "微粒皮, Meek植皮,烧伤" to retrieve the publicly published randomized controlled trials on the microskin grafting and Meek microskin grafting in repairing extensively deep burn wounds from the establishment of each database to March 20, 2019. The outcome indexes included the survival rate of skin graft, primary healing rate, operation time, and surgical treatment cost after the first operation, as well as the wound healing time and length of hospital stay. RevMan 5.3 and Stata 14.0 statistical software were used to conduct a meta-analysis of eligible studies. Results:A total of 821 patients with extensively deep burns were included in 15 studies, including 410 patients in microskin group who received microskin grafting and 411 patients in Meek microskin group who received Meek microskin grafting. The bias risks of the 15 studies included were uncertain. Compared with those of microskin group, the survival rate of skin graft and primary healing rate of patients in Meek microskin group were significantly increased, with relative risks of 0.76 and 0.66 (95% confidence interval=0.66-0.88, 0.50-0.88, P<0.01), the surgical treatment cost was significantly reduced, with a standardized mean difference of 3.19 (95% confidence interval=1.36-5.01, P<0.01), and the operation time, wound healing time, and length of hospital stay were significantly shortened, with standardized mean differences of 6.05, 2.39, and 2.35 (95% confidence interval=3.66-8.44, 1.43-3.35, 2.03-2.68, P<0.01). Subgroup analysis showed that microskin grafting combined with allogenic skin graft might be a heterogeneous source of operation time. Sensitivity analysis showed that the combined effect size was stable in the operation time, surgical treatment cost, and wound healing time. There was no publication bias in the survival rate of skin graft, operation time, wound healing time, and length of hospital stay ( P>0.05), while the primary healing rate and surgical treatment cost had publication bias ( P<0.01). Conclusions:Compared with microskin grafting, Meek microskin grafting improves the rates of skin graft survival and primary healing, shortens operation time, wound healing time, and length of hospital stay, and reduces the treatment cost in treating extensively deep burn wounds.
4. Effects of anteriolateral thigh perforator flap and fascia lata transplantation in combination with computed tomography angiography on repair of electrical burn wounds of head with skull exposure and necrosis
Xiaoqing LI ; Xin WANG ; Yalong HAN ; Gang JI ; Zonghua CHEN ; Jia ZHANG ; Jianping ZHU ; Jianxing DUAN ; Yongjing HE ; Xiaomin YANG ; Wenjun LIU
Chinese Journal of Burns 2018;34(5):283-287
Objective:
To explore the effects of anteriolateral thigh perforator flap and fascia lata transplantation in combination with computed tomography angiography (CTA) on repair of electrical burn wounds of head with skull exposure and necrosis.
Methods:
Seven patients with head electrical burns accompanied by skull exposure and necrosis were admitted to our burn center from March 2016 to December 2017. Head CTA was performed before the operation. The diameters of the facial artery and vein or the superficial temporal artery and vein were measured, and their locations were marked on the body surface. Preoperative CTA for flap donor sites in lower extremities were also performed to track the descending branch of the lateral circumflex femoral artery with the similar diameter as the recipient vessels on the head, and their locations were marked on the body surface. Routine wound debridement and skull drilling were performed successively. The size of the wounds after debridement ranged from 12 cm×8 cm to 20 cm×12 cm, and the areas of skull exposure ranged from 8 cm×6 cm to 15 cm×10 cm. Anteriolateral thigh perforator flaps with areas from 13 cm×9 cm to 21 cm×13 cm containing 5-10 cm long vascular pedicles were designed and dissected accordingly. The fascia lata under the flap with area from 5 cm×2 cm to 10 cm×3 cm was dissected according to the length of vascular pedicle. The fascia lata was transplanted to cover the exposed skull, and the anteriolateral thigh perforator flap was transplanted afterwards. The descending branch of the lateral circumflex femoral artery and its accompanying vein of the flap were anastomosed with superficial temporal artery and vein or facial artery and vein before the suture of flap. The flap donor sites were covered by intermediate split-thickness skin graft collected from contralateral thigh or abdomen.
Results:
The descending branch of the lateral circumflex femoral artery and its accompanying vein were anastomosed with superficial temporal artery and vein in six patients, while those with facial artery and vein in one patient. All the flaps survived after the operation, and no vascular crisis was observed. Wound healing was satisfactory. One patient was lost to follow up. Six patients were followed up for 6 to 10 months. The patients were bald in the head operation area with acceptable appearance. No psychiatric symptom such as headache or epileptic seizure was reported. The flap donor sites were normal in appearance. The muscle strength of the lower extremities all reached grade V. The sensation and movement of the lower extremities were normal.
Conclusions
Anterolateral thigh perforator flap with fascia lata transplantation can effectively repair electrical burn wounds of head with skull exposure and necrosis. The fascia lata can be used to protect the vascular pedicle of flaps, which is beneficial to the survival of the flap. Preoperative head and lower extremities CTA can provide reference for intraoperative vascular exploration in donor site and recipient area, so as to shorten operation time.