1.Compassion fatigue among nurses assigned to COVID-19 facilities: A constructivist grounded theory
Aldren R. Remon ; Mary Grace C. Lacanaria
Acta Medica Philippina 2020;54(Online):1-15
Background:
The Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) pandemic significantly disrupted regular health care services, mainly in the hospitals. Nurses soldiering on the battlefront of care of disaster response in the Philippines during the disease outbreak are at high risk of developing rapid-onset compassion fatigue. Notably, research is still needed to investigate the impact of compassion fatigue on various clinical areas and further develop a theory of compassion fatigue within the nursing context.
Objectives:
The study explored the concept of compassion as experienced by nurses directly caring for COVID-19 patients. The study further explored the experiences of nurses on compassion fatigue.
Methods:
This study employed qualitative methodology, specifically the constructivist grounded theory.
Results:
Thirty-four participants were included in the study. The narratives and voices of the nurses unfolded the following themes: (1) Acts of Compassion, (2) COVID-19 Pandemic: Nursing Challenges and Detours, (3) Nurses’ Compassion Fatigue, (4) Narratives of Opportunities: Thriving at the outset of COVID-19. All four concepts are linked to the multidimensional concept of compassion fatigue. A substantive theory, “Remon’s CF Theory in Nursing," is proposed based on the grounded experiences of nurses caring for COVID-19 patients related to compassion fatigue.
Conclusion:
Compassion Fatigue (CF) is a psycho-social phenomenon and occupational hazard affecting nurses
directly caring for or in contact with COVID-19 patients. CF is a process that develops over time brought by prolonged enactment of compassion, the experience of empathic distress, and concurrence of organizational, contextual, and psychosocial factors. Nurses' CF can potentially affect safety and lead to poor nursing care, compromised work relations, and burnout. Nurse leaders' organizational and leadership commitment and support through up-to-date policies and continuous research on the topic are necessary to regain compassion among nurses. Likewise, reframing nurse compassion fatigue as an organizational and collective problem provides the larger perspective to further improve clinical practice and nurses’ welfare.
Recommendations
Nurse leaders, hospital and COVID-19 facility administrators must ensure specific policies
and priorities that address issues causing and fueling nurse compassion fatigue, including frequency of exposure to traumatic events, lack of resources, and inadequate support system. The study further suggests conducting quantitative research to test the proposed theory and explore the relationship between organizational, psychosocial, and environmental context, compassion fatigue, and compassion-driven factors.
Compassion Fatigue
;
Nurses
;
Grounded Theory
2.Intimate partner violence from the perspective of Caviteñas: Its implications to the nursing profession
Philippine Journal of Nursing 2016;86(1):39-47
This study used a grounded theory approach to primarily understand the processes
Caviteña participants go through in order to arrive at a decision about how to optimize
intimate relationships in the presence of abuse and also on how to generate a conceptual
framework out of the interconnections of the concepts identified. Eleven participants
were interviewed. Five core categories emerged namely: intimate partner violence (IPV),
gender differences, processes, consequences and interventions. IPV from the
perspective of Caviteñas can be constructed as an inner experience that affects many
dimensions of a woman as a person. It causes pain that goes beyond what is physical and
deeply penetrates an affected person's inner emotional core. It is a product of interplay
among a multitude of factors and is a culprit of many physical and psychological health
problems. It affects not just the woman and the perpetrator but also the children, the rest
of the family's members, and the community as well. The conceptual framework
challenges nurses to address the phenomenon through a holistic, integrated,
multidisciplinary approach by taking into account the many layers of the victim's persona -
physically, psychologically, emotionally and even economically.
Intimate Partner Violence
;
Grounded Theory
3.Compassion fatigue among nurses assigned to COVID-19 facilities: A constructivist grounded theory
Aldren R. Remon ; Mary Grace C. Lacanaria
Acta Medica Philippina 2023;57(11):51-65
Background:
The Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) pandemic significantly disrupted regular health care services,
mainly in the hospitals. Nurses soldiering on the battlefront of care of disaster response in the Philippines during the disease outbreak are at high risk of developing rapid-onset compassion fatigue. Notably, research is still needed to investigate the impact of compassion fatigue on various clinical areas and further develop a theory of compassion fatigue within the nursing context.
Objectives:
The study explored the concept of compassion as experienced by nurses directly caring for COVID-19 patients. The study further explored the experiences of nurses on compassion fatigue.
Methods:
This study employed qualitative methodology, specifically the constructivist grounded theory.
Results:
Thirty-four participants were included in the study. The narratives and voices of the nurses unfolded the following themes: (1) Acts of Compassion, (2) COVID-19 Pandemic: Nursing Challenges and Detours, (3) Nurses’ Compassion Fatigue, (4) Narratives of Opportunities: Thriving at the outset of COVID-19. All four concepts are linked to the multidimensional concept of compassion fatigue. A substantive theory, “Remon’s CF Theory in Nursing," is proposed based on the grounded experiences of nurses caring for COVID-19 patients related to compassion fatigue.
Conclusion:
Compassion Fatigue (CF) is a psycho-social phenomenon and occupational hazard affecting nurses
directly caring for or in contact with COVID-19 patients. CF is a process that develops over time brought by prolonged enactment of compassion, the experience of empathic distress, and concurrence of organizational, contextual, and psychosocial factors. Nurses' CF can potentially affect safety and lead to poor nursing care, compromised work relations, and burnout. Nurse leaders' organizational and leadership commitment and support through up-to-date policies and continuous research on the topic are necessary to regain compassion among nurses. Likewise, reframing nurse compassion fatigue as an organizational and collective problem provides the larger perspective to further improve clinical practice and nurses’ welfare.
Recommendations
Nurse leaders, hospital and COVID-19 facility administrators must ensure specific policies and priorities that address issues causing and fueling nurse compassion fatigue, including frequency of exposure to traumatic events, lack of resources, and inadequate support system. The study further suggests conducting quantitative research to test the proposed theory and explore the relationship between organizational, psychosocial, and environmental context, compassion fatigue, and compassion-driven factors.
Compassion Fatigue
;
Nurses
;
Grounded Theory
4.Uncovering the transformational experience of cancer victors
Renante Dante Tan ; Gloria G. Yang
Philippine Journal of Nursing 2017;87(2):60-72
Introduction:
Incidence of cancer morbidity and mortality in the Philippines
continues to escalate despite the survival rate that much still need to be desired.
Few were able to cross the bridge. Still the social processes surrounding cancer
survivors’experiences has not been given much attention.
Methods:
A Grounded Theory was the design selected using in-depth, unstructured
interview among ten (10) participants who were considered as cancer survivors.
Purposive, snowball and theoretical sampling were used to recruit participants.
Interviews were audiotaped or recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data analysis
was guided by Creswell’s four major phases; open coding, axial coding, selective
coding and visual portraying. Memoing, field notes, member checking, audit trail
and validation were all integrated with the study to enhance trustworthiness of
study findings.
Results:
Based from the participants’ story, the primary psychosocial process that
emerged can be described as “transformational journey”. This core variable
explains the complexity of the journey in the life of a cancer survivor. The
researchers identified six (6) iterative phases namely: (1) seeking answers; (2)
encountering burden; (3) will to survive; (4) exhausting measures to live; (5)
becoming a victor and (6) transitioning.
Conclusion
The findings from this study elucidates that cancer patients who
become victorious after battling the disease traverses a transformational journey
that defies and changes their perspective at what life is. Healthcare provider
should develop protocol on how to support and to assist patient as they battle
through the challenges in the different stages of their journey.
Cancer Survivors
;
Neoplasms
;
Grounded Theory
;
Data Analysis
5.The Coping Experience of Nursing Students in Clinical Practice: Trying to be a Meaningful Presence.
Doo Nam OH ; Young Rhan UM ; Chunmi KIM ; Sejin JU ; Jung Hyun CHOI ; Myung Sook PARK
Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education 2016;22(4):430-440
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to understand the coping experience of nursing students in clinical practice. METHODS: In-depth interview was done with semi-structured questionnaire on 32 nursing students taking clinical practice. Data was analyzed through the grounded theory. RESULTS: Core category of coping experience of nursing students was ‘trying to be a meaningful presence’ while clinical practice. Students' coping strategies were ‘overcoming inexperience’, ‘receiving the recognition from the clinical instructors’, and ‘governing mind and body’. Helping components for their coping behaviors were ‘support from people’, ‘personal experience before clinical practice’, ‘dynamics with partners’. Through the coping experience during clinical practice, nursing students became mature and confirmed their identities as student nurses. CONCLUSION: Nursing students taking clinical practice tried to be a meaningful presence.
Adaptation, Psychological
;
Grounded Theory
;
Humans
;
Nursing*
;
Students, Nursing*
6.A Study on the Experience of Depression in Elderly Women Living Alone.
Journal of Korean Academy of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 2016;25(3):195-206
PURPOSE: This study was done to explore the experience process for depression in elderly women living alone. METHODS: Data was analyzed using Strauss and Corbin's Grounded theory. The twelve participants were elderly women living alone, aged 65 to 80 years. RESULTS: From the participants' statements, 116 concepts, 43 sub-categories and 16 categories were extracted by an open coding process. Core category was 'wandering in a waste land'. The experience process leading to depression in elderly women living alone had 4 phases: loss, emptiness, struggle and response. CONCLUSION: The findings in this study on the experience of depression in elderly women living alone can be used for evidence in a detailed assessment, early detection and prevention of depression in elderly women living alone.
Aged*
;
Clinical Coding
;
Depression*
;
Female
;
Grounded Theory
;
Humans
7.Preceptees' Experiences of Nursing Students in the Clinical Practice with Preceptorship: “Being refined while taking a firm stand with lack”.
Jeong Sook PARK ; Young Suk PARK
Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education 2018;24(2):168-180
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to explore preceptees' experience among nursing students in the Clinical Nursing Practice program as integral practice. Specific aims were to identify problems students face as preceptees at a clinical practice and how they interact with preceptors and others. METHODS: Grounded theory methodology was utilized. Data were collected from interactive field notes and transcribed notes with individual in-depth interview from 12 senior nursing students who had experiences as a preceptee in the Clinical Nursing Practice. RESULTS: Through constant comparative analysis, a core category emerged as “Being refined while taking a firm stand with lack.” The process of “Being refined while taking a firm stand with lack” consisted of four phases: sailing phase, adaptation phase, achievement phase and wistful returning phase. CONCLUSION: The findings of the study indicate that there is a need for nursing students to understand the limitations and strengths to learning experiences in preceptorship. In addition, the Clinical Nursing Practice as an integral practice program is needed to improve nursing capacity and for proper adaptation to real clinical environment among graduating students.
Grounded Theory
;
Humans
;
Learning
;
Nursing*
;
Preceptorship*
;
Qualitative Research
;
Students, Nursing*
8.Changes in Strauss & Corbin's Grounded Theory
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing 2019;49(5):505-514
PURPOSE: This study aimed to introduce and elucidate changes in Strauss and Corbin's grounded theory and discuss its application to the field of nursing in South Korea. METHODS: The changes in grounded theory by Strauss and Corbin were examined through a literature review of grounded theory from its inception. RESULTS: Strauss and Corbin acknowledged their philosophical backgrounds of symbolic interactionism and pragmatism; however, their methodology based on positivism overwhelmed their epistemology and ontology. This inconsistency has been represented by the coding paradigm and the premise of “emergent from the data.” In the revised version of Basics, Strauss and Corbin modified their theory to weaken the coding paradigm and strengthen the strategies for the development of substantive theory. CONCLUSION: Strauss and Corbin's revised grounded theory did not fully address the inconsistency of their epistemology and ontology between their acknowledgement and methodology. However, these changes constitute a meaningful step toward resolving inconsistencies and highlight the development of substantive theory. This has implications for Korean nursing researchers who have utilized methodologies in grounded theory with dogmatic approaches; grounded theory, with its evolving nature, is not a finalized method and calls for open approaches for the development of a grounded theory that fits Korean nursing.
Clinical Coding
;
Grounded Theory
;
Korea
;
Methods
;
Nursing
;
Nursing Research
9.Experiences of the Development of Parent-Child Relations among Korean College Students.
Child Health Nursing Research 2018;24(4):420-433
PURPOSE: This study was conducted to explore experiences of the development of parent-child relations among Korean college students. METHODS: The participants were 18 Korean college students. Data were collected through in-depth interviews, and the main question was, “Could you tell me about how your relationship with your parents has developed?”. Data were analyzed using Strauss and Corbin's grounded theory methodology. RESULTS: The central phenomena of the experiences of parent-child relations among Korean college students were ‘new realizations about parent-child relations’ and ‘competing against parents’. The major action/interaction strategies were ‘having an equal status to one's parents’ and ‘keeping parents at a distance’. Consequences included 'going beyond the bounds of parental guidance’. CONCLUSION: These findings indicate that students tried to give back to their parents, and also endeavored to stand apart from their parents in order to obtain independence. Their efforts were influenced by their parents' efforts to be tolerant towards their children. The findings emphasize that Korean college students experienced the process of building new, interdependent relations with their parents.
Child
;
Grounded Theory
;
Humans
;
Parent-Child Relations*
;
Parents
;
Qualitative Research
10.Turnover Experience of Male Nurses.
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing 2017;47(1):25-38
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to identify turnover experiences of men in nursing and to derive a substantive theory on the turnover experience of men who are nurses. METHODS: Data were collected through in-depth interviews with 13 men who had worked as a nurse for 1 year or more, and had a turnover experience during that period. Collected data were analyzed on the basis of Strauss and Corbin's grounded theory. RESULTS: The core category in the turnover experiences of the respondents was ‘seeking a stable place for me’. In the analysis of the core category, types of ‘contentment’, ‘seeking’, ‘survival’ and ‘confusion’ were identified. The sequential stages of these nurses’ turnover experience were ‘confrontation’, ‘incertitude’, ‘retrying’ and ‘realization’. However, when a problem arose in the process, they returned to the stage of confusion. Thus, these stages could occur in a circular fashion. CONCLUSION: These findings provide a deep understanding of the turnover experience of men in nursing and offers new information about how they adapt to nursing practice. The findings should be useful as foundational data for men who hope to become nurses and also for managers responsible for nurses who are men.
Grounded Theory
;
Hope
;
Humans
;
Life Change Events
;
Male*
;
Nurses, Male*
;
Nursing
;
Personnel Turnover
;
Surveys and Questionnaires