1.Schizophrenia and jurisdictional identifications of mental diseases.
Ya-hui WANG ; Ke QIAO ; Guang-you ZHU
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2007;23(1):57-59
Schizophrenia is the most common in forensic psychiatry. The motive, the style and the consequence of any schizophrene's misdeed have its own particularity. So schizophrenia is significant in the forensic practice. The characteristics of schizophrene's misdeed and the peace breaker's responsibility, competence to stand trial and to serve a sentence werereviewed.
Crime/psychology*
;
Expert Testimony/standards*
;
Forensic Psychiatry/standards*
;
Humans
;
Liability, Legal
;
Mental Competency/legislation & jurisprudence*
;
Schizophrenia
2.The creation of an instrument to determine competency to stand trial.
Qin-ting ZHANG ; Wei ZHANG ; Ke-jun HUO
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2004;20(3):150-154
OBJECTIVE:
To create an instrument to determine the mental disorder offenders' competency to stand trial, which is according with the Chinese legal system.
METHODS:
Integrating the foreign instruments and the Chinese criminal jurisprudence, and combing the authors' forensic psychiatric experience, the research team created an instrument which was called Competency to stand trial Determining Instrument firstly, then used the instrument in practice, in the end the validity and reliability of the instrument were inspected, and through an diagnostic test, the feasibility of the instrument was evaluated.
RESULTS:
Split-half and homogeneity reliability of the instrument is 0.9366 and 0.9213 respectively, the correspondence of the conclusion between the instrument and the expertise is 0.704. Except the sensitivity is 0.6097, all the other diagnostic index are over 0.80.
CONCLUSION
The Competency to stand trial Determining Instrument is feasible.
Expert Testimony
;
Forensic Psychiatry/methods*
;
Humans
;
Mental Competency/standards*
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Psychiatric Status Rating Scales
;
Reproducibility of Results
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
3.Physical injury and mental injury.
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2004;20(4):256-252
Physical and mental injury exist as relative aspect of human injury. They have different medicine and legal feature, as well as mutual dependence and conversion. Physical and mental injury not only present respective character in the classification, but also have difference in specific basis of rating.
Depression/psychology*
;
Expert Testimony/standards*
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Severity of Illness Index
;
Wounds and Injuries/psychology*
4.Advanced investigation of testamentary capacity of the mentally disordered.
Yan-Xia PANG ; Wei-Xiong CAI ; Qin-Ting ZHANG ; Fu-Yin HUANG ; Tao TANG ; Jia-Sheng WU ; Jian-Jun WANG ; Ri-Xia DONG
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2009;25(3):208-211
Testamentary capacity is one of the civil competences, it means that a natural person enjoys the capacity or qualification to establish testament and deal with his property. Recently, the cases of testamentary capacity assessment of the mentally disordered are increasing. This article firstly introduces the concepts of the testament as well as the testamentary capacity, and then summarizes the assessment standard of the testamentary capacity, by using the Banks v. Goodfellow case as a basis to make the standard criteria including: the understanding of the nature of a will and codicil, the knowledge of the general extent of one's assets, the knowledge of the natural object of one's bounty, the understanding of the impact of the distribution of the assets of the estate, and the absence of a delusion specifically affecting the distribution of the estate. The impact factors of the testamentary capacity, including dementia, mood disorder, schizophrenia, alcohol, drug, and undue influence, etc., are summarized. Lastly, the related assessment tools such as the Mini-Mental State Examination, the Clock-Drawing Test, and the Testament Definition Scale are introduced briefly.
Alcoholism/psychology*
;
Dementia/psychology*
;
Expert Testimony/standards*
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Mental Competency/standards*
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Mental Status Schedule
;
Wills/legislation & jurisprudence*
5.Study of affecting factors of mentally prisoner's competency to serve a sentence.
Fu-yin HUANG ; Cheng-rong LU ; Qin-ting ZHANG ; Weixiong CAI ; Wei GUAN ; Jiasheng WU ; Jianjun WANG
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2004;20(4):218-220
OBJECTIVE:
Explore the affecting factors of mentally prisoner's competency to serve a sentence (CSS), establish the base of quantitative study of CSS.
METHODS:
Firstly, the researchers compile a questionnaire named legal-psycho ability of competency to serve a sentence questionnaire, then the researchers scaling the object with RTHD, and ask all object complete the questionnaire. there a hypothesis, that the object who are cured in cured ward is incompetent to serve a sentence (ISS), and the other who are stay in rehabilitated ward is competent to serve a sentence (CSS).
RESULTS:
There are 185 object admitted the study, the ISS group the CSS group have significance between psychiatric and legal aspects.
CONCLUSION
At the influence of psychiatric symptoms, the mentally prisoner's competency to serve a sentence had been impaired, and they should been transferred from prison to hospital.
Adult
;
Expert Testimony/standards*
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry
;
Humans
;
Male
;
Mental Competency
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Mentally Ill Persons/psychology*
;
Middle Aged
;
Prisoners/psychology*
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
6.A debate about mental disability expertise of the disability evaluation criteria of traffic accident injurious.
Wei HAN ; Shan-Zhi GU ; Teng CHEN ; Xiao-Di JIA
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2006;22(2):144-146
In recent years, mental disability estimation are more than ever in the practice of forensic psychiatric expertise. The standards about mental disability estimation in the Disability Evaluation Criteria of Traffic Accident Injury are ambiguous and difficult to operate, it cause to different understanding in one case. This article discuss some common questions through 3 aspects in mental disability expertise according to some typical cases, there are the first, we should compare the IQ score before and after injurious in intelligence estimate. The second, the mental disability estimation should be done at least one year after the end of medicine treatment. The third, mental estimate scale should be used in mental disability estimation.
Accidents, Traffic
;
Adolescent
;
Craniocerebral Trauma/psychology*
;
Disability Evaluation
;
Expert Testimony/standards*
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry/legislation & jurisprudence*
;
Humans
;
Intelligence
;
Male
;
Persons with Mental Disabilities
;
Wechsler Scales
;
Young Adult
7.Reliability of the Violence Risk Scale of Chinese version.
Xue-Li ZHANG ; Xia-Can CHEN ; Wei-Xiong CAI ; Jun-Mei HU
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2012;28(1):32-35
OBJECTIVE:
To introduce and revise the Violence Risk Scale (VRS) for assessing violence risk and risk change, and to examine the reliability of Violence Risk Scale of Chinese version(VRS-C).
METHODS:
The original English version of the VRS was translated into Chinese according to established translation procedures. To examine the scorer reliability the 14 cases assessed by 3 assessors separately. One hundred and twenty-five patients with mental disorders from 3 different institutions in Sichuan province (Refined Control Ward in Ankang Hospital, Department of Forensic Psychiatry, Institute of Forensic Science and Mental Health Center of West China Hospital) were collected to examine the reliability of VRS-C.
RESULTS:
The results showed moderately good scale reliability of the VRS-C, with 0.80 of ICC for scorer reliability. All items have significant consistence with Cronbach's alpha coefficient as 0.921, split-half reliability as 0.906 and item total correlation as 0.246-0.849.
CONCLUSION
The reliability of the VRS-C version is acceptable.
Adolescent
;
Adult
;
Age Factors
;
China/epidemiology*
;
Educational Status
;
Female
;
Forensic Psychiatry/methods*
;
Humans
;
Language
;
Male
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Middle Aged
;
Psychological Tests/standards*
;
Psychometrics
;
Reproducibility of Results
;
Risk Assessment/standards*
;
Surveys and Questionnaires
;
Violence/statistics & numerical data*
;
Young Adult
8.Progress in standard assessment on competency to stand trial of mentally disordered offenders.
Xiao-Bing CHEN ; Wei-Xiong CAI
Journal of Forensic Medicine 2012;28(4):293-298
Competency to stand trial relates directly to legal rights of the appraised individual as well as whether criminal procedure can be carried out smoothly. Foreign scholars have conducted a large number of theoretical researches, and developed a series of standardized evaluation tools. However, the assessment on competency to stand trial has mainly focused on medical criteria in China for a long time, and most cases were judged by forensic psychiatrists' experience. Recently, Chinese scholars have started the initial research on standardized evaluation. This paper reviews the notion of competency to stand trial, the evaluation criteria, and the assessment tools domestically and abroad. The main focus is on foreign assessment tools, which included three categories. First category includes checklist, self-report questionnaires and sentence-completion tasks. Second category is the interview-based instruments without criterion-based scoring. Last category is the interview-based instruments with criterion-based scoring. This literature may be helpful for further research and standardization on assessment tools of competency to stand trial of mentally disordered offenders.
Crime/psychology*
;
Criminal Law/legislation & jurisprudence*
;
Criminals/psychology*
;
Forensic Psychiatry/standards*
;
Humans
;
Insanity Defense
;
Mental Competency/psychology*
;
Mental Disorders/psychology*
;
Psychiatric Status Rating Scales
;
Psychological Tests
;
Reference Standards
;
Reproducibility of Results
;
Surveys and Questionnaires