1.Application of discrete event simulation model in analysis on cost-effectiveness of epidemiology screening.
Jia Min WANG ; Qiu Ping LIU ; Chao GONG ; Ming Lu ZHANG ; Pei GAO ; Xun TANG ; Yong Hua HU
Chinese Journal of Epidemiology 2023;44(3):463-469
Discrete event simulation (DES) model is based on individual data, by which discrete events over time are simulated to reflect disease progression. The effects of individual characteristics on disease progression could be considered in the DES model. Moreover, unlike state-transition models, DES model without setting of fixed cycle can contribute to more accurate estimation of event time, especially in the evaluation of the long-term effectiveness of screening strategies for complex diseases in which time dimension needs to be considered. This article introduces the general principles, construction steps, analytic methods and other relevant issues of the DES model. Based on a research case of estimating the cost-effectiveness of screening for abdominal aortic aneurysms in women aged 65 years and above in the United Kingdom, key points in applications of the DES model in analysis on effectiveness of complex disease screening are discussed in detail, including model construction and analysis and interpretation of the results. DES model can predict occurring time of discrete events accurately by establishing the distribution function of their occurring time and is increasingly used to evaluate the screening strategies for complex diseases in which time dimension needs to be considered. In the construction of DES model, it is necessary to pay close attention to the clear presentation of model structure and simulation process and follow the relevant reporting specification to conduct cost-effectiveness analysis to ensure the transparency and repeatability of the research.
Humans
;
Female
;
Cost-Benefit Analysis
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Disease Progression
3.Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Combined Chemotherapy Regimen Containing Bedaquiline in the Treatment of Multidrug-Resistant Tuberculosis in China.
Cai Hong XU ; Ying Peng QIU ; Zi Long HE ; Dong Mei HU ; Xiao YUE ; Zhong Dan CHEN ; Yuan Yuan XU ; Yan Lin ZHAO
Biomedical and Environmental Sciences 2023;36(6):501-509
OBJECTIVE:
This study aims to estimate the cost-effectiveness of the combined chemotherapy regimen containing Bedaquiline (BR) and the conventional treatment regimen (CR, not containing Bedaquiline) for the treatment of adults with multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) in China.
METHODS:
A combination of a decision tree and a Markov model was developed to estimate the cost and effects of MDR patients in BR and CR within ten years. The model parameter data were synthesized from the literature, the national TB surveillance information system, and consultation with experts. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) of BR vs. CR was determined.
RESULTS:
BR ( vs. CR) had a higher sputum culture conversion rate and cure rate and prevented many premature deaths (decreased by 12.8%), thereby obtaining more quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) (increased by 2.31 years). The per capita cost in BR was as high as 138,000 yuan, roughly double that of CR. The ICER for BR was 33,700 yuan/QALY, which was lower than China's 1× per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2020 (72,400 yuan).
CONCLUSION
BR is shown to be cost effective. When the unit price of Bedaquiline reaches or falls below 57.21 yuan per unit, BR is expected to be the dominant strategy in China over CR.
Adult
;
Humans
;
Antitubercular Agents/therapeutic use*
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Cost-Benefit Analysis
;
Tuberculosis, Multidrug-Resistant/drug therapy*
;
China/epidemiology*
4.Cost-effectiveness of pharmaceutical smoking cessation intervention in China primary cancer prevention.
Pei Yuan SUN ; Yu Ting XIE ; Ran Ran QIE ; Huang HUANG ; Zhuo Lun HU ; Meng Yao WU ; Qi YAN ; Cai Rong ZHU ; Ju Fang SHI ; Kai Yong ZOU ; Ya Wei ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Oncology 2024;46(1):66-75
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of typical pharmaceutical smoking cessation intervention strategies in China in the context of primary cancer prevention. Methods: Markov cohort simulation models were established to simulate the burden of 12 smoking caused cancer, including lung cancer, oral cancer, nasopharyngeal cancer, laryngeal cancer, esophageal cancer, gastric cancer, pancreatic cancer, liver cancer, kidney cancer, bladder cancer, cervical cancer, and acute myeloid leukemia. Taking incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) as the main indicator, the model sets one year as the cycling period for 50 periods and simulates the cohort of 10 000 thirty-five-year-old current smokers with various smoking cessation strategies. To ensure the robustness of conclusion, univariate sensitivity analysis, probability sensitivity analysis, and age-group sensitivity analysis were conducted. Results: The results showed that varenicline intervention was the most cost-effective intervention. Compared to the next most effective option, incremental cost of each additional quality-adjusted life year is 11 140.28 yuan, which is below the threshold of willingness to pay (1 year GDP per capita). The value of ICER increased as the increasing age group of adopting intervention, but neither exceeded the threshold of willingness to pay. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that the value of discount rate, the hazard ratio and cost of intervention strategy had a greater impact on the result of ICER. Conclusion: In China, the use of varenicline to quit smoking is highly cost effective in the context of cancer primary prevention, especially for younger smokers.
Humans
;
Cost-Benefit Analysis
;
Smoking Cessation
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Nasopharyngeal Neoplasms
;
Varenicline
;
China
;
Kidney Neoplasms
;
Pharmaceutical Preparations
5.Cost-effectiveness of pharmaceutical smoking cessation intervention in China primary cancer prevention.
Pei Yuan SUN ; Yu Ting XIE ; Ran Ran QIE ; Huang HUANG ; Zhuo Lun HU ; Meng Yao WU ; Qi YAN ; Cai Rong ZHU ; Ju Fang SHI ; Kai Yong ZOU ; Ya Wei ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Oncology 2024;46(1):66-75
Objectives: To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of typical pharmaceutical smoking cessation intervention strategies in China in the context of primary cancer prevention. Methods: Markov cohort simulation models were established to simulate the burden of 12 smoking caused cancer, including lung cancer, oral cancer, nasopharyngeal cancer, laryngeal cancer, esophageal cancer, gastric cancer, pancreatic cancer, liver cancer, kidney cancer, bladder cancer, cervical cancer, and acute myeloid leukemia. Taking incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) as the main indicator, the model sets one year as the cycling period for 50 periods and simulates the cohort of 10 000 thirty-five-year-old current smokers with various smoking cessation strategies. To ensure the robustness of conclusion, univariate sensitivity analysis, probability sensitivity analysis, and age-group sensitivity analysis were conducted. Results: The results showed that varenicline intervention was the most cost-effective intervention. Compared to the next most effective option, incremental cost of each additional quality-adjusted life year is 11 140.28 yuan, which is below the threshold of willingness to pay (1 year GDP per capita). The value of ICER increased as the increasing age group of adopting intervention, but neither exceeded the threshold of willingness to pay. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that the value of discount rate, the hazard ratio and cost of intervention strategy had a greater impact on the result of ICER. Conclusion: In China, the use of varenicline to quit smoking is highly cost effective in the context of cancer primary prevention, especially for younger smokers.
Humans
;
Cost-Benefit Analysis
;
Smoking Cessation
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Nasopharyngeal Neoplasms
;
Varenicline
;
China
;
Kidney Neoplasms
;
Pharmaceutical Preparations
6.Is non-contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging cost-effective for screening of hepatocellular carcinoma?
Genevieve Jingwen TAN ; Chau Hung LEE ; Yan SUN ; Cher Heng TAN
Singapore medical journal 2024;65(1):23-29
INTRODUCTION:
Ultrasonography (US) is the current standard of care for imaging surveillance in patients at risk of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been explored as an alternative, given the higher sensitivity of MRI, although this comes at a higher cost. We performed a cost-effective analysis comparing US and dual-sequence non-contrast-enhanced MRI (NCEMRI) for HCC surveillance in the local setting.
METHODS:
Cost-effectiveness analysis of no surveillance, US surveillance and NCEMRI surveillance was performed using Markov modelling and microsimulation. At-risk patient cohort was simulated and followed up for 40 years to estimate the patients' disease status, direct medical costs and effectiveness. Quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio were calculated.
RESULTS:
Exactly 482,000 patients with an average age of 40 years were simulated and followed up for 40 years. The average total costs and QALYs for the three scenarios - no surveillance, US surveillance and NCEMRI surveillance - were SGD 1,193/7.460 QALYs, SGD 8,099/11.195 QALYs and SGD 9,720/11.366 QALYs, respectively.
CONCLUSION
Despite NCEMRI having a superior diagnostic accuracy, it is a less cost-effective strategy than US for HCC surveillance in the general at-risk population. Future local cost-effectiveness analyses should include stratifying surveillance methods with a variety of imaging techniques (US, NCEMRI, contrast-enhanced MRI) based on patients' risk profiles.
Humans
;
Adult
;
Carcinoma, Hepatocellular/diagnostic imaging*
;
Liver Neoplasms/diagnostic imaging*
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Cost-Benefit Analysis
;
Quality-Adjusted Life Years
;
Magnetic Resonance Imaging/methods*
7.Cost-effectiveness analysis of well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma surveillance using nuclear medicine procedures
John Kenneth V. Gacula ; Jerry M. Obaldo ; Vio Jianu C. Mojica
The Philippine Journal of Nuclear Medicine 2022;17(2):8-20
Introduction:
Well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma (WDTC) is the most common type of thyroid cancer with a notable
increasing incidence worldwide. It is prevalent among Filipino descent as compared to other nationalities. Its
good prognosis and high survival rate predispose patients to lifetime surveillance with incomplete response,
instead of death, as outcome measure. This eventually leads to increase in cost of care, utilization, and
allocation of medical resources for the survivors of the disease. Thyroglobulin immunoradiometric assay
(Tg IRMA) and I-131 diagnostic whole-body scan (dWBS) are two nuclear medicine procedures that are part of
WDTC surveillance. Due to their varied availability in Asia-Pacific, most clinicians measure thyroglobulin (Tg)
alone due to perceived cost-effectiveness.
Objective:
This study aims to analyze the cost-effectiveness of two nuclear medicine procedures used in WDTC surveillance,
namely thyroglobulin immunoradiometric assay and I-131 diagnostic whole-body scan, in detecting incomplete
response.
Methodology:
Three clinical guidelines on WDTC management were reviewed to identify frequency, total number and
expenditure for surveillance, namely from the University of the Philippines-Philippine General Hospital in 2008
(PGH 2008), American Thyroid Association in 2015 (ATA 2015), and the Department of Health (DOH 2021). A
Markov model was constructed to simulate a 36-month surveillance with complete and incomplete response to
treatment as disease states. Parameter values like rate of incomplete response in WDTC patients, prognostic
values per each surveillance test, and other relevant data were collected from literature search and established
data. The cost of surveillance was based on the rates offered by Philippine General Hospital (PGH) Radioisotope
Laboratory as of November 2022. One-way sensitivity was done to check robustness of results.
Results:
ATA 2015 incurs the most expenses, amounting to PHP 14,600.00 to 20,450.00 ($ 254.19 – 356.04) for three
years of surveillance, followed by DOH 2021 (PHP 11,700.00 – 15,600.00 or $ 203.74 – 271.65), and PGH 2008
(PHP 3,900.00 – 6,825.00 or $ 67.91 – 118.85). The thyroglobulin IRMA arm costs lower (PHP 17,784.00 or
$ 309.74) than I-131 dWBS (PHP 271,875.00 or $ 4,735.13) in detecting incomplete response. I-131 dWBS
should cost around PHP 570.00 (or $ 9.92) to be as cost-effective as the thyroglobulin IRMA.
Conclusion
This study has identified that thyroglobulin IRMA is more cost-effective than I-131 diagnostic whole-body scan
in detecting incomplete response in WDTC patients. This supports the perceived cost-effectiveness of
thyroglobulin measurement in surveillance, even without diagnostic whole body-scans. This study also identified
that the new DOH 2021 guidelines will incur lesser expenditure in using nuclear medicine procedures for
surveillance as compared to ATA 2015 guidelines. Local clinicians may also find it easier to follow as it is more
suitable to the Philippine setting.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
8.Cost-effectiveness of treatment for moderate to severe psoriasis at the Rizal Medical Center
Journal of the Philippine Medical Association 2023;102(1):18-28
Background:
Cost-effectivenessstudiesareimportant for chronic diseases such as psoriasis, which may cause significant financial burden and negatively affect the patient's quality of life.
Objectives:
This study evaluated which among the treatment options, namely topicals phototherapy (TP), topicals + systemic (TS), and topicals + biologics (TB), is the most cost-effective for the management of moderate to severe psoriasis at the Rizal Medical Center's Psoriasis Center
Methods:
A total of 65 moderate to severe psoriasis patients seen at the Rizal Medical Center's Psoriasis Center in 2021 were included in this retrospective cross-sectional study. Chart review was conducted to account all direct costs of treatment. The effectiveness in relation to the overall cost was assessed using the psoriasis area severity index (PASI) and the dermatological life quality index (DLQI).
Results:
Our study showed that TS is the most cost-effective treatment for moderate to severe psoriasis with the lowest cost per PASI75 and DLQI<5 improvement valued at Php335.36, followed by TP valued at Php 762.87, and lastly by TB at Php 19,058.03. Despite TB incurring the highest cost, all patients in this treatment group showed the highest mean difference of PASI and DLQI.
Conclusions
Our findings suggest that topical with systemic medication is the most cost-effective treatment for moderate to severe psoriasis
Psoriasis
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
9.The cost-effectiveness and budget impact of a community-based universal newborn hearing screening program in the Philippines.
Adovich S. RIVERA ; Hilton Y. LAM ; Charlotte M. CHIONG ; Maria Rina T. REYES-QUINTOS ; Rosario R. RICALDE
Acta Medica Philippina 2017;51(1):28-35
BACKGROUND: In 2000, the World Health Organization recommended implementation of universal hearing screening. The Philippines enacted this policy into law in 2009 as it was found to be cost-effective for the Philippines. The model at the time used a hospital-based approached to screening. This paper examines the cost-effectiveness and budget impact of implementing a community-based universal hearing screening program.
METHODS: A model was developed following a community-based hearing screening program. Parameters were obtained through literature review, secondary data analysis, and consultation with experts. Cost-effectiveness was assessed for a single birth cohort from a public payer and societal perspective.
RESULTS: A community-based universal hearing screening program was found to be cost-saving. One-way sensitivity analysis showed that results were sensitive only to treatment rate and follow-up rate. The program is also a high budget impact program.
CONCLUSION: A community-based hearing screening program is cost-saving for the Philippines. Ensuring treatment and good follow-up in testing will ensure cost-effectiveness.
Hearing Loss ; Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
10.Cost-effectiveness analysis of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray in treatment of chronic rhinosinusitis.
Zhi-Yan HUANG ; Xu-Sheng ZHANG ; Wen-Qiao GONG ; Juan LIU ; Li-Juan LU
China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica 2023;48(15):4237-4242
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness and economic efficiency of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray in the treatment of chronic rhinosinusitis(CRS). The randomized controlled trial(RCT) of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray in the treatment of CRS was searched against EMbase, PubMed, Cochrane Library, CNKI, VIP, SinoMed, and Wanfang. The efficacy, nasal mucociliary transport time, and safety of the therapy above in the treatment of CRS were analyzed with single-group rate and Meta-analysis, and the economy and sensitivity were evaluated from the perspective of payer. A total of 9 RCTs were included, including 1 145 patients. Meta-analysis showed that compared with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray alone, Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray in the treatment of CRS patients increased the effective rate(RR=1.17, 95%CI[1.11, 1.24], P<0.000 01) and shortened the nasal mucociliary transport time(MD=-3.32, 95%CI[-5.86,-0.78], P=0.01), there was no significant difference in the incidence of adverse reactions between the two groups. The incremental cost-effectiveness analysis showed that the treatment costs of the control group and the observation group were 44.15 yuan and 1 044.96 yuan, respectively. In the Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray treatment group, 75.48 yuan was spent to improve the effective rate of CRS by 1%. The one-way sensitivity analysis indicated the days of treatment, the RR of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray, the price of unit preparation of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules, and the effective rate of Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray alone had great influence on the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio. In conclusion, Biyuan Tongqiao Granules combined with Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray improves the therapeutic effect on CRS. The probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed that when the willingness to pay was greater than 7 920 yuan(less than 0.1 of GDP per capita 8 098 yuan), the combined therapy was economically superior to the control. Due to the limited number of articles published, it is necessary to carry out a real-world clinical trial of Biyuan Tongqiao Gra-nules and Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray in the treatment of CRS, so as to compare the cost-effectiveness of Biyuan Tongqiao Granules and Triamcinolone Acetonide Nasal Spray.
Humans
;
Triamcinolone Acetonide/adverse effects*
;
Nasal Sprays
;
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
;
Sinusitis/drug therapy*
;
Chronic Disease