1.Changes experienced by physicians and nurses after a region-based palliative care intervention trial: the OPTIM-study
Tatsuya Morita ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Yoko Hanada ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Satoshi Suzuki ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Kenji Eguchi
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(1):121-135
The primary aim of this study was to collect the views of physicians and nurses in the regions where community-based palliative care intervention trial, the OPTIM-study, was performed. A content analysis of free comments of the questionnaire survey was conducted. Questionnaires were mailed to 1,763 physicians and 3,156 nurses after the intervention, and 706 and 2,236 responses were obtained, respectively. A content analysis identified 327 free comments from physicians and 737 from nurses. As favorable effects, the categories [Multidisciplinary teams and community networks were established] [Home-based care is widespread] [Medical knowledge and skills are acquired just as those involved in palliative care] emerged. The main effects of the community palliative care program included the establishment of multidisciplinary teams and community networks, development of home-based care, and increasing knowledge, skills, and awareness about palliative care.
2.Are specialized home care clinics and the Doctor net exclusive to each other?
Tatsuya Morita ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Hiroshi Ono ; Yuriko Fujishima ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Shohei Kawagoe
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(1):317-322
The purpose of the present study was to obtain the insights about the roles of specialized home care clinics and the “Doctor net” in community palliative care by investigating changes in the home death rates of cancer patients in a city where both specialized home care clinics and the Doctor net are available. A region palliative care intervention study was conducted, and data on the rate of cancer patients who died at home between 2007 and 2010 in the region were collected. The rate of cancer patients who died at home increased from 7.0% in 2007 to 13.0% in 2010. In 2007, 49% of the total number of people who died at home were patients of specialized home care clinics, and the rate increased to 13.0% in 2010. However, the number of cancer patients of other clinics who died at home did not decrease, from 63 in 2007 to 98 in 2009 and 77 in 2010. The functions of specialized home care clinics and the Doctor net adopted in general clinics were not exclusive to each other, and specialized home care clinics may improve palliative care implemented for cancer patients at home by participating in the Doctor net to provide general clinics with support.
3.Counting the use of specialized palliative care services
Tatsuya Morita ; Nobuya Akizuki ; Satoshi Suzuki ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Mitsunori Miyashita
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(2):374-381
The primary aim of this study was to compare the ratios of specialized palliative care use to all cancer death using 2 methods: 1) total number of patients who received either of specialized palliative care services (unadjusted), and 2) number of patients after adjustment of potentially duplicated counts (adjusted). The research team obtained patient list from all specialized palliative care services, and counted the number of the patients who received any specialized palliative care services. The ratio of adjusted value to unadjusted value was 0.59, and had large region differences.Unadjusted values had, although overestimated, essentially similar trends in changes by year and differences in the regions. In conclusion, total number of patients who received either of specialized palliative care services could be simple and feasible indicator to roughly determine the activity of specialized palliative care services, but exact number of the patients who received specialized palliative care services should be determined on the basis of the patient lists without duplicated counts.
4.Suggestions and recommendations from health care professionals involved in regional palliative care program
Tatsuya Morita ; Chizuru Imura ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Satoshi Suzuki ; Mie Shibuya ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Kumiko Harada ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Mika Hirayama ; Kenji Eguchi
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(1):163-171
The aim of this study is to collect the suggestions and recommendations of health care professionals involved in the regional palliative care program (OPTIM-study). A total of 101 multidisciplinary health care professionals who participated in the intervention program were interviewed, and 107 meaningful units were obtained from 89 valid interviews. The responses were categorized into “suggestions regardless of profession” (n=59), including “Participate in a multi-disciplinary conference to expand the network of people”, “Try to understand the situation of others”, “Seek support from others when you cannot solve the problem by yourself”, “Pursue all possibilities before giving up”, and “Do not try too hard”. As suggestions to those engaged in each profession, “Suggestions to community pharmacies” and “Suggestions to care managers” are frequently described. An examination of suggestions by the participants in the regional palliative care program could provide some insights to improve community palliative care.
5.How work community-standard palliative care manuals, patient education tools, and assessment tools? : OPTIM-study
Yoshiyuki Kizwa ; Megumi Umeda ; Takuya Shinjo ; Kazue Ishigamori ; Shinichiro Okuyama ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Chizuru Imura ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Tatsuya Morita
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(2):172-184
The aim of the present study was to examine the current use of a palliative care manual, brochures for patients, and assessment tools designed for the regional intervention study. A questionnaire survey (706 physicians and 2,236 nurses) and interviews (80 health care professionals) were conducted. The tools health care professionals most frequently used were the manual and brochures for families of imminently dying patients. Health care professionals experienced [shared understanding as a region level despite the clinical experience and specialty] and [increased confidence in palliative care they had practiced without clear evidence]. The manual were positively evaluated because they “cover all necessary information”, “come in an easy-to-carry-around size”, and “provide specific and practical advice”. Health care professionals valued the brochures for families of imminently dying patients, because illustrations were very helpful as oral explanation was difficult. This study suggests that the manual and brochures for families of imminently dying patients could serve to improve region-based palliative care.
6.Usefulness and perceived-barriers of patient-held-records in palliative care settings: the OPTIM-study
Tatsuya Morita ; Kazue Komura ; Yumi Sakuma ; Chizuru Imura ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Akemi Yamagishi ; Satoshi Suzuki
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(2):382-388
The primary aim of this study was to describe how patient-held-records was used in the regional palliative care program (OPTIM-study). The number of patient-held-records disseminated was 1,131 per region per year. A total of 15% and 16% of 706 physicians and 2,236 nurses in the region reported that they used patient-held-records disseminated during the study periods, respectively. In-depth interview identified themes [difficulty in dissemination], potential benefits of patient-held-records ([improved sense-of-control of patients], [improved information sharing among health care professionals]), and barriers ([lack of patient-perceived benefits and patient burden], [necessity that all health care professionals involved should be aware the value of patient-held-records and understand how to use it]). Of 11 hospitals who introduced patient-held-records, only 2 hospitals continued to use it during 3-year study periods. In conclusion, region-wide dissemination of patient-held-records seems to be unfeasible in many regions in Japan.
7.What is the greatest impact of the regional palliative care program?: the OPTIM-study
Tatsuya Morita ; Chizuru Imura ; Yoshiko Nozue ; Satoshi Suzuki ; Mie Shibuya ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Kumiko Harada ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Mika Hirayama ; Kenji Eguchi
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(2):209-217
The purpose of this study was to identify the greatest impact of the regional palliative care program on community health care professionals. Interviews were conducted involving 101 people who became involved in the intervention program implemented in 4 areas across Japan, and 96 valid responses were collected. The following were cited as the greatest impact: [I developed a network of people, and realized the importance of collaboration] (n=61; “I was able to develop an interpersonal relationship” and “Now I understand the significance of collaboration”), [My knowledge and skills regarding palliative care were improved] (n=18; “Knowledge and support helped me respond to patients with confidence” and “I have come to think that there is more to palliative care than terminal care”), [I rediscovered my role through a wide variety of experiences] (n=10), [Both collaboration and palliative knowledge/skills meant a lot to me] (n=4), [What I experienced in this program will help me play my role] (n=2), and [Patients and their families became satisfied] (n=1). The community palliative care program was most effective in facilitating collaboration, and helped participants develop knowledge and skills concerning palliative care.
8.Requests for cancer treatment and palliative care: suggestions from 821 advanced cancer patients and bereaved families
Kazue Komura ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Yoshiyuki Kizawa ; Shohei Kawagoe ; Nobuya Akizuki ; Akemi Yamagishi ; Motohiro Matoba ; Satoshi Suzuki ; Hiroya Kinoshita ; Yutaka Shirahige ; Tatsuya Morita ; Kenji Eguchi
Palliative Care Research 2011;6(2):237-245
It is important to collect patients' and their families' opinions to provide good palliative care. This study aims to analyze the contents of free description provided by the survey for cancer patients and bereaved families, which was performed before the intervention of The Outreach Palliative Care Trial of Integrated Regional Model (OPTIM) study. Requests for and good points of cancer treatment and palliative care were collected and classified. 1,493 advanced cancer patients and 1,658 bereaved families in four areas received the questionnaire, and 271 patients and 550 families filled in the free description. Cancer patients and bereaved families had demands for improved communication with medical staff, improved quality of pain relief, financial support of treatment, more educational activities on palliative care, and improved cooperation within and outside hospitals. Palliat Care Res 2011; 6(2): 237-245
9.The effect of an intervention of a regional palliative care intervention program on home hospice utilization and hospital staff’s perceptions about home care: an observation from the OPTIM-study
Yutaka Shirahige ; Takatoshi Noda ; Minoru Hojo ; Shinichi Goto ; Shiro Tomiyasu ; Masahiro Deguchi ; Sadayuki Okudaira ; Masakazu Yasunaka ; Mika Hirayama ; Ritsuko Yoshihara ; Taeko Funamoto ; Ayumi Igarashi ; Mitsunori Miyashita ; Tatsuya Morita
Palliative Care Research 2012;7(2):389-394
This study aimed to clarify whether a regional palliative care intervention program, the OPTIM project, increased home hospice utilization, and explore the potential association between the home hospice utilization and the hospital staff's perceptions on home care. A questionnaire survey was conducted involving 154 physicians and 469 nurses. The rate of patients who made the transition to home-based care increased 967% in A Hospital, 295% in B Hospital, and 221% in C Hospital in 2010 compared to 2007, which was assumed to be 100. Staff of a hospital where many patients made the transition to home-based care were more likely to agree with the following statements concerning home care perspectives: “I started to consider that even cancer patients can be treated at home until the last moment of their life”, “I usually ask patients whether they wish to receive home-based care”, “We decided on coping strategies for sudden changes in the course of disease and a place to contact in advance”, and “I started to simplify treatment procedures, such as prescriptions during hospitalization for patients and their families to prepare for home-based care“.