1.Dosimetry study on conformal radiation therapy, intensity modulated radiation therapy and intensity modulated arc radiotherapy in middle thoracic esophageal cancer
Yao SUN ; Xijun LIU ; Tonghai LIU ; Yonghua YU ; Yong YIN
Cancer Research and Clinic 2013;(1):15-18
Objective To compare the dosimetry of three different radiation therapy plans [threedimensional conformal radiation therapy (3DCRT),intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT),intensity modulated arc radiotherapy (IMAT)].Methods Selected 15 cases with middle thoracic esophageal cancer,Varian Eclipse 8.6 planning systems were designed with 3DCRT,IMRT,IMAT,3DCRT using 5-8 coplanar radiation fields,IMRT using 7 coplanar radiation fields,IMAT using 2 radians.Three planned dose difference were compared.Results Compared with 3DCRT,IMRT and IMAT were better with heterogeneity index (HI),conformality index (CI),VPTV 95 %,V5,V20,V35 of total lung,and V30 of heart (t =2.531,P< 0.05).There was no statistically significant difference for the V10,V15,V25,V30 mean dose of total lung,the mean dose of heart,the maximum dose of spinal cord,and the minimum dose of PTV among the three plans (t =1.325,P >0.05).Conclusion IMAT and IMRT are similar in the middle thoracic esophageal cancer radiotherapy target volume dose coverage and organs at risk protection,they are better than 3DCRT.IMAT in the monitor units and delivery time are less than IMRT.
2.Two radiotherapy treatment planning systems in comparison of dose calculating results for simulation phantom,patients and homogeneous organization phantom
Zengjun ZHAO ; Jie LU ; Yong YIN ; Baosheng LI ; Tonghai LIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2008;17(4):308-311
Objective Using Eclipse and Pinnacle3 V 7.4f treatment planning sytems (TPS) for dose calculation of the CT images of simulation phantom,patients and homogeneous organization phantom,to compare the differences between the two TPS for the calculation of non-uniform organizations.Methods For the CT images of simulation phantom,patients and homogeneous organization phantom,the calculating results between the two TPS were compared,including the common used clinical indexes of V20 and V30 of the lung,D95 of the planning target volume,the doses of the ISO and eight points of interest inside ISO slice.Resuits For simulation phantom and patients,although the calculating differences of the isocenter doses between the two TPS were small,the differences of other indicators were large.For example,when using secondary collimator irradiation,the maximal D95 difference of planning target volume reached 10.17%for patients and 4.64%for simulation phantom.When using muhileaf collimator irradiation,the maximal D95 difference reached 10.74%for patients and 5.66%for simulation phantom.Sometimes the dose differences of points 1-4 at the edge of planning target volume were more than 10%.In addition,the V30 differences of the lung were large too.But for the homogeneous organization phantom,the calculating differences were small.Conclusions The calculating differences between the two TPS are less for simulation phantom than for patients,and more for simulation phantom and patients than for homogeneous organization phantom.
3.Application of liner-accelerator two-degrade collimator in the treatment of nasopharyngeal carcinom with intensity-modulated radiotherapy
Tong BAI ; Jinhu CHEN ; Yong YIN ; Jie LU ; Tonghai LIU
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2010;19(4):355-357
ObjectiveTo study the efficacy of using multileaf collimators with different position and different degree in the treatment of nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) using intensity-modulated radiotherapy techniques.Methods Ten patients withNPC were administered andanalyzed.Thepenumbra characteristics, dose of target, and radiation conformal indexes (CI) of mode T1 and mode T2 were measured and compared using dose volume histogram generated by Varian Eclipse three-dimensional planning computer system. Mode T1 :The angles of seven coplanar beams were 0°, 52°, 106°, 160°, 212°, 258°and 308°,respectively. There were no restriction on the position and degree of multileaf collimators. Parameters were set and optimized. Mode T2 :The beam angles and the parameters were as same as mode T1. According to the actual situations, the position and the degree of the multileaf collimators were changed. Then thedose optimization was performed. Results Target dose coverage in both mode T1 and T2 could be clinically accepted, and the CI were 0. 82 and 0. 83(t = -0. 25, P =0. 815). The maximum dose reductions in the lens, eyes, optic nerves and corneas were 28. 7% (t = 4. 80, P = 0. 000), 2. 7% (t = 2. 99, P = 0. 021),1.4%(t= 1.05,P=0.032), and 30.5% (t=2.99,P=0. 020), respectively. However, the mean dose and V35 of the parotid were increased by 0. 6% (t = - 2. 82, P = 0. 043) and 9.9% (t = - 2. 05, P =0. 038). ConclusionsOpimization of multileaf collimators can reduce the scattering and leaking rays. Compared with mode T1 ,controlling the position and degree of multileaf collimators could reduce the radiation dose to the eyes and optic-nerves, especially to the lens.
4.NBI system versus conventional endoscopy in diagnosis of colorectal adenomas: a systematic review
Xifeng JIN ; Tonghai CHAI ; Chunan LIU ; Huanming ZHOU ; Juan FANG
Chinese Journal of General Practitioners 2009;8(10):710-713
Objective To evaluate the validity of narrow-band imaging (NBI) system in detection of colorectal adenoma, as compared to that of endoscopy of the colon and rectum, in a systematic review. Methods Relevant literatures were retrieved from Medline (January 1966 to October 2008), OVID (January 1996 to October 2008), EMBASE (January 1980 to October 2008), Coehrane Library (Issue 3, 2008) and Chinese Biological Medicine Disk (CBM disk, January 1997 to October 2008). Quality of the literatures retrieved was assessed based on the Cochrane Reviewers' Handbook and Jadad's score. RevMan version 4. 2 software was used for meta-analysis. Results Seven randomized clinical trials (2838 patients) were included in the study. Compared with white-light colonoscopy, no significant difference was observed in terms of adenoma detection rate (OR 1.18, 95% CI 1.00-1.39, P=0.06) by NBI system, which could significantly improve total number of detection for fiat lesions of the colon and rectum (pooled WMD 0.14, 95% CI 0.02-0.26, P=0.02), but with a longer withdrawn time (pooled WMD 1.05, 95% CI 0.08-1.22, P<0.01). Conclusions Detection rate for flat lesions of the colon and rectum, not for adenoma, can be improved by NBI system and meanwhile its withdrawn time is prolonged, indicating that routine use of NBI system for detecting colorectal adenomas may be recommended only with its further refined technique.
5.A comparative study of percutaneous transhepatic variceal embolization with cyanoacrylate and ethanol,gelfoam or metal coils
Chun-Qing ZHANG ; Fu-Li LIU ; Hong-Wei XU ; Tonghai CHAI ; Lin XU ; Chunan LIU ;
Chinese Journal of Digestion 2001;0(10):-
0.05).The variced recurrence rate in 1- and 2-year were 12% (3/25) and 20% (5/25) in TH glue group,and 39.1% (9/23) and 86.9%(20/23) in control group (P
6.Application of deformable registration and empirical calculation method to calculate the accumulated dose for normal tissues and organs at risks in lung cancer radiotherapy plans
Changsheng MA ; Jie LU ; Tonghai LIU ; Guifang ZHANG ; Jinhu CHEN ; Yong YIN
Chinese Journal of Radiological Medicine and Protection 2012;32(1):70-73
Objective To evaluate the accumulated doses to normal tissues and organs at risks (OARs) of patients with lung cancer in radiotherapy plans by using the deformable registration method,and make comparison with the empirical calculation method.Methods Ten patients with lung cancer were analyzed retrospectively.3D-CRT or IMRT plans were designed before treatment. CT to simulator was rescanned and the same treatment plan was redesigned during radiotherapy. Based on the deformable registration method,the Mimvista software was used to calculate the accumulated doses to normal tissues and OARs in two CT images respectively.The empirical estimation algorithm was calculated by the linear relationship between the fractions and the total prescribed dose.Results The target coverage of patients had no significant difference in two plans.There were no significant differences in all the dose volume parameters for normal tissues and OARs,except the mean dose to right lung( t =2.98,P < 0.05 ) when the the same plan was conducted in position-setting and reposition CT images.Conclusions The empirical estimation for the accumulated dose could be used to evaluate the dose and volume parameters for normal tissues and OARs in lung cancer by the same plan.
7.Dosimetric comparison of three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy,intensity-modulated radiotherapy and volumetric modulated arc radiotherapy in partial breast irradiation
Tao SUN ; Jianbin LI ; Min XU ; Tonghai LIU ; Xiutong LIN ; Guifang ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Radiological Medicine and Protection 2012;32(1):74-79
Objective To compare the dosimetric differences of three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3D-CRT), intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) and volumetric modulated arc radiotherapy(V-MAT) for external beam partial breast irradiation.Methods Twelve patients with breast cancer receiving breast-conserving surgery and external beam partial breast irradiation were enrolled.Three different techniques including 3D-CRT,IMRT and V-MAT were designed for each patient.The dosimetry in the target,the dose to the organs at risk(OAR),the MU and delivery time were compared.Results All three plans met the clinical requirement. 3D-CRT showed the worst conformity in target. V-MAT provided the lowest target coverage and homogeneity in target.3D-CRT plans showed the lowest values for the V5,V10,mean dose and the highest values for V30 in the ipsilateral lung.No statistically significant differences were observed in V20 of the ipsilateral lung among three plans.V-MAT showed the lowest values in ipsilateral normal breast volume 15,20 and 25 Gy post-irradiation.For V5,the mean and max dose in heart,the mean dose in contralateral lung and the mean,max dose in thyroid,IMRT and 3D-CRT showed the highest and lowest value respectively(z =-2.94 - -2.09,P < 0.05 ).The MUs in 3D-CRT,IMRT and V-MAT were 417.6 ± 34.4,772.8 ± 54.4 and 631.0 ± 109.0,respectively (z =- 2.93, - 2.76,-2.93,P < 0.05 ). V-MAT significantly reduced the delivery time. Conclusions V-MAT shows significant advantages in reducing the dose in the ipsilateral normal breast and the delivery time compared with 3D-CRT and IMRT.
8.Dosimetric difference in RapidArc planning for radiotherapy of multiple hepatic malignancy using different photon energy
Guanzhong GONG ; Yong YIN ; Deyin ZHAI ; Tonghai LIU ; Jinlong SONG ; Jie LU ; Jinhu CHEN ; Ruozheng WANG
Journal of International Oncology 2012;39(5):391-395
ObjectiveTo investigate the dosimetric difference in the application of RapidArc using 6 and 15 MV X-rays for radiotherapy of multiple hepatic malignancy.MethodsA total of 12 cases with multiple hepatic tumors ( primary 5 cases and secondary 7 cases) were selected.All patients underwent the three dimensional CT simulation in free breathing.For each patient,RapidArc plans with single or two 358° arcs using 6 or 15 MV X-rays were designed respectively,the prescription dose was 2Gy per fraction × 25 fractions.The dosimetric differences were compared among RapidArc plans.ResultsAll of RapidArc plans could meet the clinicalrequirement.There were no significant differences in the conformity index ( CI ),homogeneity index ( HI),the maximum dose and the minimum dose of PTV among RapidArc plans ( P > 0.05).All the CI could get to 0.91 and HI could get to 0.88.In the RapidArc plans with two 358° arcs,the Vs,V10,V15 of normal liver were higher than with single arc,while V20,V25,V30,V35,V40 were lower than with single arc.There were no significant differences in the different radiation dose of normal liver,stomach,duodenum and spinal cord among different plans ( P >0.05 ).The monitor units of RapidArc plans using 6 MV X-rays increased 12% compared to 15 MV averagely.CondusionThe 6 MV X-ray would be selected chiefly in the radiotherapy of multiple haptic tumor using RapidArc with whole arc(s).
9.Dosimetric study of thoracic esophageal carcinoma radiotherapy using RapidArc combined with active breathing coordinator
Deyin ZHAI ; Yong YIN ; Jinhu CHEN ; Tonghai LIU ; Dongping SHANG ; Changsheng MA ; Jie LU
Chinese Journal of Radiological Medicine and Protection 2012;32(4):364-368
Objective To compare and analyze the dosimetric characteristics of the intensity-modulated arc therapy (RapidArc) combined with active breathing coordinator (ABC) in the thoracic esophageal carcinoma radiation therapy. Methods Ten thoracic esophageal carcinoma patients undergoing radiotherapy were selected for this study.The CT simulations were performed under three breath patterns respectively:moderate deep inspiration breath-hold (mDIBH) with ABC aid; Set the trigger threshold to 80% of the peak of the respiration curve; and free breathing (FB).Based on the corresponding CT image sets,three treatment plans were generated for each patient respectively:Arc-ABC( three small arcs),ArcFB (consisted of two coplanar full arcs) and IMRT-FB plan.The following dosimetric parameters were compared among different plans:D2%,D98%,V95,homogeneity index ( HI),conformal index ( CI ) the percentage of volume receiving dose of over x Gy (Vx),monitor unit (MU),control points and treatment time.Results The planning target volume ( PTV ) of FB was 376 cm3 which decreased to 260 cm3 after using ABC.For mDIBH and FB patients,the total lung volumes were 5964.6 cm3(35% more than FB) and 3838.8 cm3 respectively; the heart volumes were 524.4 cm3 and 642.7 cm3 respectively. No significant difference was observed among Arc-ABC,IMRT-FB and Arc-FB in terms of D2,D98,V95,CI and HI.For Arc-ABC plans,there were significant decreases of radiation dose in total-lung's V10,V20,V30,V40 and mean lung dose ( F =4.38,5.34,4.07,3.89,4.28,P <0.05).Various dose decreases of heart V20,V3,V40,Dmean and spinal cord Dmax were observed,yet no statistically significant difference existed.The MUs and total control points of Arc-ABC plans were significantly lower than other plans ( F =26.86,12.56,P < 0.05 ).Conclusions When thoracic esophageal carcinoma patients were treated with radiotherapy,the combined utilization of RapidArc and ABC can potentially decrease the volume of irradiated lung yet escalate the dose in target.
10.The dosimetric study of the targets and organs at risk in whole breast forward intensity-modulated radiotherapy during free breathing based on 4DCT
Wei WANG ; Jianbin LI ; Hongguang HU ; Tonghai LIU ; Fengxiang LI ; Min XU ; Tao SUN
Chinese Journal of Radiation Oncology 2012;21(4):357-360
ObjectiveTo explore the correlation between the respiration-induced clinical target volume (CTV) motion and volume variation and the dosimetric variation of planning target volume (PTV) and organs at risk (OAR) during free-breathing (FB) with whole breast intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT).MethodsSeventeen patients with breast conserving surgery underwent respiration-synchronized four-dimentional computed tomography (4DCT) simulation scans on the state of FB.The treatment plan was constructed using the end-inspiration phase scan,then copied and applied to the other respiratory phases.The dose distribution was calculated separately to evaluate the dose-volume histograms parameters for the PTV,ipsilateral lung and heart.ResultsDuring FB,the CTV motion vector was (2.09 ±0.74) mm,and the volume variation was (3.05 ± 0.94) %.There was no correlation between the volume variation of CTV and dosimetric variation of PTV/OAR ( r =-0.390 -0.480,P =0.182 -0.775 ).In anteroposterior (AP),superoinferior (SI) and vector directions,the CTV movement correlated well with the PTV mean dose,conformal index,and the lung volume receiving high dose (V20,V30,V40,and V50;r=-0.975-0.791,P =0.000 -0.041 ).In SI and vector directions,the CTV displacement only correlated with the heart volume receiving > 5 Gy ( V5 ) ( r =-0.795,0.687,P =0.006,0.028 ).The lung volume variation and the lung volume receiving high dose correlated reasonably well (r=0.655 -0.882,P=0.001-0.04 0).The heart volume variation only correlated with the V5 of heart (r =-0.701,P =0.024).ConclusionsDuring free-breathing,the effect of breast volume variation can be ignored for whole breast IMRT,and whole breast IMRT assisted with breath-hold may improve the accuracy of dose delivery during radiotherapy.