1.A literature review of instruments measuring communication skills in medical education
Aiko Tsunezumi ; Hirono Ishikawa ; Takahiro Kiuchi
Medical Education 2013;44(5):335-344
Objectives: This study reviewed the literature on instruments measuring physician-patient communication skills in medical interviews. Our goal was to clarify the features of current instruments and problems in assessing physician-patient communication with them.
Methods: In 2012, we searched for published articles about instruments assessing physician-patient communication skills in the bibliographic databases PubMed, PsycINFO, and the Education Resources Information Center using the combination of search terms (“consultation skills” OR “doctor-patient communication” OR “physician-patient relations”) AND “medical education” AND (instruments OR measurement OR assessment). Instruments designed for faculty observers and to be used in medical education were included in the study. To compare the instruments, we classified the items of each instrument on the basis of the framework of the Kalamazoo Consensus Statement (KCS), an experts’ consensus statement on 7 essential elements of physician-patient communication.
Results: Ten instruments were included in the study. Eighty-three percent of all 277 items of the instruments were classified to any of the 7 elements identified in the KCS. Most of the instruments included more than 6 elements identified in the KCS, and some of the instruments had been constructed on the basis of the KCS. However, the instruments varied considerably in essential communication skills to understand the patient’s perspective, to share information, and to reach agreement on problems and plans.
Conclusions: Further study is needed to provide evidence for essential communication skills in physician-patient consultation. Because essential communication skills depend on the educational goals, culture, language, and other factors, ensuring the reliability and validity of tools administered to evaluate communication must be required.
2.Usefulness of stepwise opioid switching to methadone: a case report
Katsuya Abe ; Takayuki Hisanaga ; Takahiro Higashibata ; Wakako Inatsu ; Daisuke Kiuchi ; Shingo Hagiwara ; Miho Shimokawa ; Yasuo Shima
Palliative Care Research 2014;9(3):511-515
Introduction: The use of methadone in Japan is limited to cases being switched from the preceding use of strong opioids; the stop-and-go strategy is recommended in which the previously used opioid analgesic is discontinued and methadone is initiated at its full estimated dosage. Case: Refractory cancer pain due to an iliolumbar syndrome was temporarily exacerbated by the stop-and-go switching to methadone from morphine along with ketamine. Pain relief was achieved upon readministration and concomitant use of morphine with methadone after approximately two weeks. Discussion: Through examining this case, we believe that a stepwise switching strategy, rather than the stop-and-go strategy, could be more useful. Considering that overdosage may cause side effects, it is safer to initiate methadone with a small dose. However, more studies need to be conducted to decide whether the establishment of the initial dosage and dosage adjustment should be made more flexible to avoid pain intensification. Further investigation is required on whether the concomitant use of adjuvant analgesics such as ketamine, which similar to methadone is an NMDA receptor antagonist, should be continued when switching to methadone.
3.Frequency of Serious Adverse Skin Reactions Caused by Continuous Subcutaneous Administration of Psychotropic Drugs
Ritsuko Yabuki ; Takayuki Hisanaga ; Daisuke Kiuchi ; Miho Shimokawa ; Katsuya Abe ; Takahiro Otsuka ; Ayako Sakurai ; Satoko Suda ; Yasuo Shima
Palliative Care Research 2016;11(1):123-127
Continuous subcutaneous injections of medication are effective in controlling symptoms of the terminal stage of cancer. Chlorpromazine and levomepromazine occasionally cause skin irritation. We examined all patients who underwent continuous subcutaneous administration of psychotropic drugs (chlorpromazine, levomepromazine, midazolam) at the palliative care unit of our hospital from April 2010 to March 2013, the frequency of adverse skin reactions of Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events (CTCAE) v4.0 grade 3 or above. Of the 603 hospitalized patients, 389 (64.5%) underwent continuous subcutaneous administration of one of the three drugs. The frequency of grade 3 or above (ulceration or necrosis) adverse skin reactions was 4 out of 345 chlorpromazine cases (1.2%; 95% CI: 0.0-2.3%), 2 out of 90 levomepromazine cases (2.2%; 95% CI: −0.8-5.2%), and 0 out of 210 midazolam cases (0.0%; 95% CI: 0.0-0.0%). The frequency of serious adverse skin reactions caused by continuous subcutaneous administration of psychotropic drugs was low, suggesting that this treatment is relatively safe for the skin.
5.Effects of a Communication Program in Undergraduate Medical Education on Physician's Clinical Practice.
Tatsuro ISHIZAKI ; Yuichi IMANAKA ; Akihiro OKAMOTO ; Hisashi OKUYAMA ; Yasuaki KAMANO ; Takahiro KIUCHI ; Satoshi GOTO ; Takeshi TANIGAWA ; Takeo NAKAYAMA ; Satoshi HONJO ; Shunsaku MIZUSHIMA ; Noriko MURAKAMI
Medical Education 1998;29(6):399-406
This study examined the effectiveness of a communication program in undergraduate medical education in improving communication in physicians' clinical practice. The effectiveness of the program was assessed with a mail survey using self-rated questionnaires 9 years later. Ninety participants were follwed up in late 1994; 57.8% of them replied to the questionnaire. Of the respondents, 60% replied that programs concerned with active listening and role-playing had benefits on communicating with patients and families. In addition, 40% of respondents answered that case studies aimed at teaching comprehensive medicine with the team approach was effective in improving communication with co-medical staff. These results suggest that the communication program in undergraduate medical education is effective in improving clinical communication in clinical practice when students are highly motivated.
6.Clinical Trials Registry in the Field of Rehabilitation Medicine
Ryo MOMOSAKI ; Masafumi OKADA ; Tsuyoshi OKUHARA ; Takahiro KIUCHI ; Naoshi OGATA ; Masahiro ABO
The Japanese Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 2018;55(7):606-613
Objective:To investigate the characteristics of studies registered in the field of rehabilitation medicine.Methods:The university hospital medical information network clinical trials registry database was searched for domestic clinical trials associated with rehabilitation medicine that were registered after June 2005. We extracted information about studies and analyzed their registration trends and overall characteristics.Results:Among the 21,410 registered trials, we found 529 trials associated with rehabilitation. The purpose of this study was to investigate efficacy in 65% of the studies. Among these studies, 54% were parallel-group comparison studies, 50% were registered retrospectively, and 85% did not publish any results. In comparison studies, 86% were randomized controlled studies, and 47% were open-label trials.Conclusion:An increasing trend of registration was observed. However, we found several problems in registration. Prospective registration is important to decrease publication and outcome reporting biases. Education for the relevant study protocol and registration might improve the quality of clinical study in domestic rehabilitation medicine.