1.Socio-Economic Impact of HIV/AIDs and Mental Health
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2012;12(Supplement 1):12-12
HIV/AIDS and Mental Health are two chronic diseases with huge economic burden in developing countries. For HIV/AIDS, this year marked three decades since HIV/AIDs first identified with more than 34 million people in the world are living with this chronic condition with 2.6 million new cases.
More than 90% of cases are adult in their economically productive life and nearly half are women. Even though HIV/AIDs incidence fell by more than 25% in 33 countries for the last ten years, the existing burden is still huge. Africa, the least resource continent in the world bears most of the brunt of this chronic condition housing nearly two thirds of global HIV positive cases. It is estimated that the available resources for HIV/AIDs in 2009 is USD 15.9 billion, there is a shortage of nearly USD10 billion. Only one third of these countries make HIV/AIDs a high budgetary priority. Mental illness is a chronic non-communicable disease responsible for 37% of global healthy life years lost. It was also estimated that in 25% of the patients visiting any health facilities, at least one suffer from undiagnosed mental health, neurological or behavioural disorder. The current global cost of mental health is estimated at USD 2.5 trillion. This will increase to USD 6.1 trillion in 2030. More than two thirds of this cost is indirect cost mostly due to loss in productivity. Managing these two conditions posed great challenges to low and middle income countries. Huge economic burden means that additional source of funding should be sought with full participation of all stakeholders. Mobilizing resources at the community level should be seriously considered. Support for community to provide long term care for HIV/Aids and mental health patients should be adequately supported by governments through properly targeted and well organized programme. Incentives and disincentives to influence efficient and effective performance should be put in place with innovative financing approach.
Vertical programme should be avoided while more integrated approach with significant task shifting should be given a priority to ensure success and sustainability. In conclusion, policy makers in low and middle income countries should take positive measures to ensure that HIV/Aids and mental health is properly addressed by mobilising efforts from all stakeholders.
2.Systematic Review Of Factors Associated With Willingness To Pay For Health Financing Scheme
A Azimatun Noor ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2017;17(2):103-112
Health care has emerged as one of the fastest growing industry worldwide. This induced health care costto rise tramendously. However, it is important to preserve high quality health care services that are equitable and affordable. In many countries, people are expected to contribute to the cost of the health care. Are populations ready to accept the concept and willing to pay for health financing scheme? What possible factors that may associate with their decision? This is the objective of the study, to examine the relevance evidence for this through a systematic review of literatures.We systematically searched Ovid MEDLINE and Google Schoolar databases until April 2016. We assessed the study population willingness to pay for health financing scheme and determine the significant variables that associate with WTP. 19 full-text articles were included in the review. Factors that were found significantly associated with WTP for health financing scheme by many studies were age, education, income and residential locality. Other factors that also found associated with WTP were health care services utilization and expenditure. The review findings showed that WTP for health financing scheme is beyond the households’ financial capacity and has multifactorial influences.
Willingness to pay, health financial scheme, health insurance, social health insurance
3.The Gap Between Knowledge And Perception On Education In Traditional And Complementary Medicine Among Medical Staff In Malaysia
Maihebureti Abuduli ; Zaleha Md Isa ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2015;15(1):77-82
Although the Ministry of Health Malaysia has been encouraging the practice of Traditional and Complementary Medicine (T&CM)1, 2, 3, 4 but patients/clients has not been able to apply it for their need of medical treatments and sometimes it leads to negative outcomes due to lack of knowledge on T&CM and its safe applications5,6’7,8 Most of the western-trained physicians are ignorant of risk and benefits of T&CM9,10,11. This study was aimed to determine the gap between knowledge regarding T&CM and perception on education in T&CM among the medical staffs in five selected hospitals in Malaysia. A cross-sectional survey was done at five public hospitals among medical staff in Malaysia by using quantitative methods. A total of 477 medical staffs were involved in this study. The study showed that the overall knowledge of T&CM among the medical staffs were poor (61.2%). Having good knowledge regarding T&CM were significantly higher in Hospital Duchess of Kent (52%, p=0.001), among the non-Malays (44%, p=0.047) and pharmacists (47.2%, p=0.030). Positive perception on health education in T&CM among medical staffs were high (85.3%) especially among females (88.1%, p=0.002) and pharmacists (93.7%, p<0.001). The use of T&CM among the general population is relatively high in Malaysia and many patients increasingly seek the information on T&CM therapies from medical staffs. Knowledge regarding T&CM was poor in this study because most of the medical staffs have not been exposed to T&CM education. This interesting scenario between poor knowledge and high positive perception on health education in T&CM shows the demand of urgent intervention in educating the medical staffs. We recommend that medical staffs must have some basic education and knowledge about T&CM before they could offer advice to their patients. Doctors are of the utmost important in this regard because they play a very important role in patient care. Providing T&CM education to medical staff may help to integrate T&CM into the mainstream medicine.
Medicine, Traditional
;
Complementary Therapies
4.The Introduction Of Subsidised Health Insurance For The Poor In The City Of Padang, Indonesia: Does The Gap On Health Payment And Health Service Utilisation Still Exist?
Ade Suzana Eka Putri ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Amrizal Muhammad Nur
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2015;15(3):132-138
Indonesian government secures the access of the poor towards health services through subsidised schemes. This study is aimed to describe the pattern of health expenditure by households and to describe the pattern of health service utilisation across household’s socioeconomic level in the city of Padang after seven years of the introduction of subsidised schemes. A household survey was conducted involving 918 households, with multistage random sampling method. The proportion of out-of-pocket (OOP) health spending as a share of household’s capacity to pay was regressive across consumption quintiles. The proportion of households with catastrophic health expenditure was 1.6% while 1.1% faced impoverished health expenses. Among those who need health care, the utilisation among the rich was higher than the poor. Health insurance schemes in Padang provides financial protection, however with regards to household’s capacity to pay, the poor has the higher burden of health payment. The gap on health service utilisation between the poor and the better-offs was still apparent for outpatient services and it has been narrowed for inpatient care. This study suggests that the subsidised schemes for the poor are highly needed and the possibility of the leakage of subsidies to the rich should be considered by the government.
5.Global Economic Burden Of Asbestos Related Diseases In Comparison With The Costs Of Production And Consumption
Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Ahmad Munir Qureshi ; David Baguma
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2017;17(1):111-125
Occupational cancers, including mesothelioma and lung cancer are linked to the use of asbestos. Annually, at least
100,000 global deaths are attributed to asbestos exposure putting a heavy burden on national budgets. Expenses
incurred on treatment of asbestos related diseases (ARDs) reduce households and national resource savings, while ARDs
culminate in terminal burdens. The objective of this study is to measure the economic burden of ARDs and to assess the
economic impact of asbestos consumption. The health and economic burden of asbestos was estimated in macro-global
consumption-production model using production function frontier-based and generalized least squared approach for
asbestos products and cost tabulation. Production, in metric tons (Mt) was adopted as a dependent variable among
explanatory variables, including consumption. Information on treatment cost of asbestos related diseases (mesothelioma,
asbestosis and lung cancer) was obtained from costing information and published literatures. Annual total economic
burden of asbestos is at USD 11.92 billion. Out of this cost, USD 4.34 billion per annum is the economic burden of
managing three common ARDs. The cost of compensation for patients suffering ARDs is USD 4.28 billion. From the
remaining USD 3.3 billion, USD 2.93 billion is the value of asbestos consumed in 2003 and USD372.15 million is the loss of
earning due to hospital visits and admissions. For every USD 1 spent on consumption of asbestos, global economy has to
absorb almost USD 4 due to health consequences of ARDs. Banning of asbestos production and usage in production of
goods has far-reaching impacts on household welfare, health and economic development. The insights revealed are
expected to inform decision makers the need to ban all forms of asbestos, especially in developing countries where usage
is increasing.
6.Leadership Styles Of Military Hospital Managers In Malaysia And Its Influencing Factors
Junaidah Kamarruddin ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Adlina Suleiman ; Mohd Nor Yahaya
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2020;20(2):171-177
A good quality leader is vital in ensuring effective and efficient services rendered to patients. However, as to date, little is known on the leadership styles of managers in Military Hospitals in Malaysia and the region. The aim of this cross-sectional study was to determine the leadership styles and identify the influencing factors, among Military and Non-Military managers in five Military Hospitals in Malaysia. A pre-tested 20-item questionnaire was distributed to eligible managers in the hospitals. Based on the total score, the leadership style of managers was classified into Transformational (TS) and Non-Transformational style (N-TS). Among the 501 respondents, 375 (74.9%) of them were Non-military managers and 126 (25.1%) of them were Military managers. 46.8% (n=59) of the managers with military background practiced TS while only 27.7% (n=104) of Non-military managers have TS (X2 =15.662; p <0.001). Managers aged 40 years and above, male, with higher educational level, served longer in the service, attended in-service training and participated in other capacity building activities were more likely to practice TS. Analysis using stepwise multiple logistic regressions proved that predictors of TS style are educational level (AOR=2.319; 95% CI=1.300,4.134), working experience (AOR=1.075; 95% CI=1.049,1.102), Military managers (AOR=1.759; 95% CI=1.104,2.802) and attended in-service training (AOR=2.070; 95% CI=1.369,3.129). In conclusion, the Military Hospitals have the benefit of being managed by Military managers that practice TS. Educational level and in-service training are two most important elements that influence the practice TS among the managers in these Military Hospitals.
7.The Economic Burden Of Frailty Among Elderly People: A Review Of The Current Literature
Alkhodary A. A. ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Aniza Ismail ; Nur A. M. ; Shahar S.
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2020;20(2):224-232
Life expectancy from birth is increasing dramatically. Due to this increase, the population of elderly people will increase. Consequently, geriatric related illnesses will increase leading to increased necessity to build up comprehensive and coordinated cost effective health care services appropriate for elderly people. Frailty is not a disease, but rather considered as a syndrome requiring comprehensive and multidisciplinary care approach. It is a prevalent reversible pathological transitional stage between healthy aging and disability. Frailty is associated significantly with increased health care utilization, mortality, and comorbidities such falls, hospitalizations, physical dependence, and poor perception of health. The aim of this review is to compile existing literature on the economic cost of frailty syndrome among elderly people in the recent years. Search queries were constructed to look for articles related to the economic cost of frailty in the electronic databases available at the National University of Malaysia library for articles published between the years 2011 and 2019. The accessed electronic database included New England journal of medicine, Science Direct, SCOPUS, BMJ, Cochrane, and Wiley Online Library. Articles included in this review when they were original research, participants were defined as frail elderly, manuscripts written in English language, and involved clearly described measures of frailty cost. Among the literature, twenty one articles were found to satisfy the inclusion criteria of the review process. The cost of care for frail elderly was ranging from US $ 8,620 to 29,910 per patient per year. The cost of health care was ranging from US $ 2,540 to 221,400. The health care cost was accounting for 40% to 76% of the total care cost. Hospitalization cost was the highest, it was ranging from US $ 806 to 152,726. Outpatient cost was ranging from US $ 200 to 18,000. Medications cost was ranging from US $ 7 to 3,434 per frail elderly patient per year. Home help cost was ranging from US $ 804 to 19,728 per frail elderly patient per year. In conclusion, frailty is a costly syndrome. It can be considered as a cost effective target for health promoting interventions to contain future elderly cost.
8.Quality of Life Among Preinvasive & Invasive Cervical Cancer In Malaysia
Sharifa Ezat Wan Puteh ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Paul Ng ; Rushdan Mohd Nor
ASEAN Journal of Psychiatry 2009;10(2):115-126
Objective: This study aims to determine the quality of life (QOL) of Malaysian women based on their physical and mental scores and correlates with age and cervical disease severity.
Methods: This is a cross-sectional study from Nov 2006 till Dec 2007 from participating
Gynecology-Oncology outpatient and in patient’s wards. QOL interviews used the SF-36 questionnaires. Main domains were the Physical Composite Scores (PCS) and the Mental Composite Scores (MCS).
Results: A total of 396 participated in the study. Mean respondents age were 53.31 ± 11.21 years, educated till secondary level (39.4%), Malays (44.2%) with mean marriage duration of 27.73 ± 12.12 years. Among pre-invasive diseases, the cervical intra epithelial neoplasia (CIN) 1 was the highest in percentage of cases
(8.1%). Among invasive cancer, stage 1 cancer was highest (31.1%), followed with stage 2 (28.3%), stage 3 (7.3%) and stage 4 cancers (5.8%). PCS scores are highest among the pre-invasive and stage 1 cancer (F=4.357; p<0.0001) and influenced by age and income. MCS were not significantly influenced by age or stage of cervical diseases (F= 1.393; p=0.206) but the regression model showed that amount
spent on health care was a significant factor. Conclusion: Cervical diseases posed a substantial cause in reducing QOL with increasing age and disease severity. This disability can be reduced with early screening and intervention to prevent disease progression. Reducing disease burden play a role to improve QOL among at risk women before developing late stages of disease.
9.Estimation Of Cost Of Diagnostic Laboratory Services Using Activity Based Costing (ABC) For Implementation Of Malaysia Diagnosis Related Group (My-Drg®) In A Teaching Hospital
Ibrahim Roszita ; Amrizal Muhd Nur ; SA Zafirah AR ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid
Malaysian Journal of Public Health Medicine 2017;17(2):1-8
The Malaysia Diagnosis Related Group (MY-DRG®), established since 2002, is a patient classification system that stratifies disease severity and categories patients into iso-resource groups. Casemix can be used to estimate costs per episode of care and as a provider payment tool in health services. Casemix has also been used to enhance quality and improve the efficiency of health services. Hence, estimation cost per DRG is important especially in developing countries where costing data are still scarce. We embarked on a study to determine the costs of the diagnostics laboratory services for each MY-DRG® based on the severity of illnesses. Most costing studies for diagnostic laboratory services usually focus on the cost of consumables and equipment alone and employed the step-down costing method. Very few studies applied Activity-Based Costing (ABC) method to estimate the costs for diagnostic laboratory services. This study was done with the purpose of developing the diagnostics laboratory cost using the ABC method. All medical cases discharged from UKM Medical Centre (UKMMC) in 2011 grouped into MY-DRG® were included in this study. In 2011, a total of 2.7 million diagnostic laboratory investigations were carried out in the Department of Diagnostic Laboratory Services in UKMMC. ABC was conducted from January to December 2013 in all units of the department. Cost of 242 types of diagnostic laboratory services were collected using a costing format. Out of 25,754 cases, 16,173 (62.8%) cases were from the medical discipline. After trimming using L3H3 method, 15,387 cases were included in the study. Most of the cases were on severity level one (44.6%), followed by severity level two (32.3%) and severity level three (23.1%). The highest diagnostic laboratory service weight was for Lymphoma & Chronic Leukemia, severity level III (C-4-11-III) with the value of 5.9609. Information on seven cost components was collected form each procedure: human resources, consumables, equipment, reagents, administration, maintenance and utilities. The results revealed that, the biggest cost component for human resources was in Molecular Genetic Unit (89.6%), consumables (34.8%) from Tissue Culture Unit, equipment (11.2%) and reagents (68.1%) from Specialized Haemostasis Unit. In conclusion, the accurate and reliable cost of the diagnostic laboratory services can be determined using ABC. Top management of the department should be able to use the output of the study to take appropriate steps to reduce unnecessary wastages of resources in the various units of the services.
10.Direct Medical Cost of Stroke: Findings from a Tertiary Hospital in Malaysia
Nor Azlin Mohd Nordin ; Syed Mohamed Aljunid ; Noor Azah Aziz ; Amrizal Muhammad Nur ; Saperi Sulong
The Medical Journal of Malaysia 2012;67(5):473-477
This study aimed to estimate cost of in-patient medical care due to stroke in a tertiary hospital in Malaysia. A
retrospective analysis of stroke patients admitted to
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia Medical Centre (UKMMC)
between January 2005 and December 2008 were conducted.
Cost evaluation was undertaken from the health provider’s
perspective using a top-down costing approach. Mean
length of stay (LOS) was 6.4 ± 3.1 days and mean cost of
care per patient per admission was MYR 3,696.40 ± 1,842.17
or 16% of per capita GDP of the country. Human resources
made up the highest cost component (MYR 1,343.90, SD:
669.8 or 36% of the total cost), followed by medications
(MYR 867.30, SD:432.40) and laboratory services (MYR
337.90, SD:168.40). LOS and cost of care varied across
different stroke severity levels (p<0.01). A regression
analysis shown significant influence of stroke severity on
cost of care, with the most severe stroke consumed MYR
1,598.10 higher cost than the mild stroke (p<0.001). Cost of medical care during hospital admission due to stroke is
substantial. Health promotion and primary prevention
activities need to take priority to minimise stroke admission in future.