1.Evaluation of the First Trial of a White Coat Ceremony as a Ceremony of Passage: A Method for Teaching Professionalism in Undergraduate Medical Education.
Toshi ABE ; Yoshio OGOH ; Takato UENO ; Mariko HOTTA ; Akihiro HAYASHI ; Ichiro YOSHIDA ; Naofumi HAYABUCHI ; Michio SATA
Medical Education 2002;33(3):193-199
Purposes: We performed a white coat ceremony for medical students, because there had not been a definite passage ceremony to create the desire to serve and the awareness of being physician. Opinions about the ceremony were with a questionnaire survey. Methods: The ceremony of white coat conferment was performed for the first time for 112 fourth-year medical students on January 11, 2001, just before the start of clinical training. A white coat and an identification badge with photograph were presented to the medical students, who were taking the first step to becoming a physician. A questionnaire survey was performed the next day to evaluate students' feelings. The questionnaire asked about student's 1) sense of responsibility to be engaged in medical practice, 2) feelings of kindness to patient, 3) love for of their school, 4) attachment to the white robe, 5) consciousness of being a professional, 6) sense of mission as a physician, 7) motivation to learn, 8) feelings of seriousness, and 9) desire to live ethically. A listening survey for the school staff and students was also included. Results: Clear improvements in consciousness were recognized in all items of the questionnaire (P>.0001). Approximately 80% of students approved of the ceremony being performed annually from the following year. The ceremony had had no established form, but many people acknowledged its significance. However, some students who did not realize the significance of the ceremony because it was performed in the middle of the semester. Conclusions: Although this was the first experience for us, many students and teaching staff were understanding and responded favorably to this passage ceremony. The ceremony to instill medical professionalism in student doctors will be improved with further efforts and experiences.
2.Curriculum of Medical Schools in North America Offering Various Education Programs: A Report of the Inspection Tour Organized by Dr. Hinohara in July, 2005
Takao MORITA ; Mariko TANAKA ; Tooru WAKUI ; Toshimasa YOSHIOKA ; Eiji GOTOH ; Tomomitsu HOTTA ; Tadao BAMBA ; Tsuguya FUKUI ; Shigeaki HINOHARA
Medical Education 2005;36(6):391-397
1) The study tour was organized by Dr. Hinohara to learn about the medical education in North America and its philosophy to support the method.
2) The McMaster University, which started PBL curriculum in 1969, began COMPASS curriculum which focuses on conceptual thinking and e-learning in which tutorial groups still remain as the key to the learning process.
3) The Duke University, which values the researcher promotion, began a new curriculum including at further integration of basic and clinical medicine and structural clinical training (Intersession).
4) The Washington University, which constructed WWAMI Program that cooperated with the medical institutions in four states surrounding Washington, started College System to support the students and to strengthen their clinical competencies.
5) Common aspects of the innovation of medical education in North America are (1) further integration of the basic and clinical medicine, (2) early exposure to the principle of clinical medicine and (3) promotion of professionalism by Clinical Preceptorship.
3.Evaluation of Individual Care of Patients by Medical Students for Attitude Education.
Takato UENO ; Ichiro YOSHIDA ; Mariko HOTTA ; Toushi ABE ; Makoto TURUTA ; Syuhei KOUNO ; Yoshio OGOU ; Akihiro HAYASHI ; Haruhiko EGUCHI ; Ichiro MIYAJIMA ; Seiji WATANABE ; Seiya OKUDA ; Michio SATA
Medical Education 2001;32(2):117-122
The usefulness of individual care of patients in the attitude education of undergraduates was evaluated with questionnaires completed by 4th-year medical students and patients. Ninety-eight percent of students finished performing patient care during a 2-week period. Seventy percent of patients completed questionnaires. The appearance, manner of greeting, and language of the students were considered good by 87% or more of the patients, and the students' consideration for the patients' safety, privacy, and communication was considered good by 86% or more of the patients. The practice was approved by 77% of the patients and was objected to by none. Ninety-nine percent of students completed questionnaires, and 79% of the respondents approved of the practice. Fourteen percent of the student respondents, many of whom had been treated as outpatients, objected to the practice. These results suggest that individual care of patients by medical students is useful for both patients and students.
4.Analyses of Scores of Examinations for Practical Training in Clinical Skills and for Clinical Training and Scores of Graduation Examinations in Undergraduate Medical Students
Takato UENO ; Ichiro YOSHIDA ; Hiroki INUTSUKA ; Mariko HOTTA ; Takuji TORIMURA ; Hitoshi ABE ; Syuhei KOUNO ; Akihiro HAYASHI ; Masayuki WATANABE ; Teiji AKAGI ; Kazuhiko MATUO ; Yoshio OGO ; Yoshinori TAKAJYO ; Hiroshi MIYAZAKI ; Michio SATA
Medical Education 2004;35(5):303-308
We analyzed the scores of objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) and written examinations administered to fourth-year medical students after practical training in clinical skills and to fifth-year medical students after clinical training and scores of graduation examinations taken by sixth-year medical students. Correlations were analyzed among the scores of 96 students who had taken all 3 examinations during a 3-year period. Mean scores on examinations in the fourth, fifth, and sixth years were compared between sixth-year students who did or did not graduate and between graduating students who did or did not pass the national examination for medical practitioners in Japan. Significant correlations in the scores were found between 1) OSCEs and written examinations for fourth-year students versus those for the fifth-year students; 2) OSCE and written examinations for fourth-year students versus graduation examination scores for the sixth-year students; and 3) OSCE and written examinations for fifth-year students versus graduation examination scores for sixth-year students. In addition, the mean scores in the fourth and fifth years were significantly higher for sixth-year students who graduated and passed the national examination than for students who did not graduate or who graduated but failed the national examination. These results suggest that the practical training in clinical skills given to fourth-year students and the clinical training given to fifth-year students strongly affect the overall evaluation of the ability of sixth-year students and success on the national examination.