Videotape feedback reportedly improves communication skills in students learning to conduct medical interviews. We carried out a study of videotape feedback in the undergraduate training program of the department of neuropsychiatry. To evaluate the interviews, we used objective structured clinical examinations and feedback from interviewed patients. The students showed several shortcomings, such as passive investigation into symptoms, past history, family history and explanatory models; poorly expressed empathy; unclear summation; poor explanation about what interviewees should do after the interview; and infrequent use of specific probes and silence skills. Feedback from patients was more favorable than that from instructors. Because our program asking psychiatric patients to participate as interviewees seems to have both advantages and disadvantages, using simulated patients would be helpful for examining the validity of our program.