1.A prospective, randomized, controlled study on anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with or without remnant preservation
Lei HONG ; Guanyang SONG ; Xu LI ; Hui ZHANG ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2015;35(4):387-393
Objective To compare the clinical outcomes of patients who underwent remnant-preserved anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with those who underwent conventional ACL reconstruction (ACLR).Methods From January 2010 to October 2012,93 eligible patients suffered from ACL injuries were randomly allocated into remnant-preserved group (ACLR with remnant preservation;n=48;Male/Female=34/14;Left/Right=25/23) and conventional group (ACLR without remnant preservation;n=45;Male/Female=33/12;Left/Right=22/23).The mean age of patients,time from injury to surgery,rates of combined meniscal injuries,and medial collateral ligament injury all showed no significant difference between the two groups preoperatively.All the patients underwent ACL reconstruction using 4-strand hamstring autografts.The postoperative assessments included knee functional scales (IKDC grade classification and Lysholm score),stability examinations (Lachman,pivot-shift,and KT-1000 arthometer),proprioceptive evaluations,and second-look arthroscopy.Results The average follow-up time was 25.4 months for the remnant-preserved group and 25.2 months for the conventional group.For IKDC grade classification,there were 32 patients with grade A,9 with grade B,1 with grade C in remnant-preserved group,whereas 30 with grade A,8 with grade B,2 with grade C in conventional group,which showed no significant difference between the two groups.Moreover,the Lysholm score (95.9±5.2 vs.95.4±1.7),Lachman test,pivot-shift test,KT-1000 arthometer (1.1±1.2 mm vs.1.2±0.9 mm),proprioceptive evaluations (joint position sense:3.6°± 1.8° vs.3.9°±2.2°) all showed no significant differences between the two groups.Additionally,the synovial coverage of grafted tendon under second-look arthroscopy was categorized as grade A in 11,grade B in 6,grade C in 2,grade D in 2 in remnant-preserved group,whereas grade A in 10,grade B in 5,grade C in 2,and grade D in 2 in conventional group,which still showed no significant difference.Conclusion In terms of the knee functional scales,stability examinations,joint position sense and graft synovial coverage,remnant-preserved ACLR group showed no superiority to the conventional ACLR group.
2.Dual-plane high tibial osteotomy to treat posterolateral corner injuries combined with varus deformity of knee joint
Hui ZHANG ; Hua FENG ; Lei HONG ; Xuesong WANG ; Jin ZHANG ; Xin LIU ; Guanyang SONG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2016;36(7):392-398
Objective To investigate the clinical outcome of dual?plane high tibial osteotomy to treat posterolateral corner injuries combined with varus and/or hyperextension deformity. Methods From October 2008 to March 2014, there were 12 patients (13 knees) undergoing high tibial osteotomy. All the patients were double or triple varus knee combined with posterior cruciate ligament and posterolateral corner (PLC) injuries. During the surgery, the weight bearing line of lower extremity was set to 62%position of the tibial plateau on the coronal plane. The tibial slope was increased to diminish the hyperextension on the sagit?tal plane. Full?length weight bearing X?ray was used to evaluate the position of weight bearing line, femoral?tibial angle and tibial slope pre? and post?operatively. The stress radiograph was used to evaluate the posterior and posterolateral stability. The Op?ti_knee gait analysis system was used to evaluate the varus of angle during weight bearing stage. Results The weight bearing line was corrected from 19.6%±19.1% preoperatively to 42.6%±17.9% postoperatively (t=-4.178, P=0.002). The femoral?tibial angle was 172.8°±4.2° preoperatively and improved to 178.1°±4.2° postoperatively (t=-4.520, P=0.001). The tibial slope was increased from 10.2° ± 5.3° preoperatively to 18.4° ± 6.3° postoperatively (t=-5.735, P=0.000). The tibial posterior translation was decreased from 11.4±5.3 mm preoperatively to 8.1±6.9 mm postoperatively (t=2.415, P=0.042) in 9 patients. The separa?tion of lateral compartment was decreased from 16.3 ± 6.5 mm preoperatively to 14.2 ± 4.9 mm postoperatively (t=3.194, P=0.019). Gait analysis was performed in 7 patients and showed that the varus was improved from 3.0° ± 2.6° preoperatively to-2.7°±2.5° postoperatively during weight bearing stage (t=-8.500,P=0.014). Eight patients had sufficient improvement in knee function so that a subsequent posterolateral corner reconstruction was not necessary. Conclusion The dual?plane medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy can improve the alignment of lower extremity and the stability of knee joint, and 67%patients do not need a staged PLC and posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.
3.The effects of excessive pre?operative anterior tibial translation on post?operative knee stability after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction
Guanyang SONG ; Hui ZHANG ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2019;39(7):392-397
Objective To investigate the effects of excessive pre?operative anterior tibial translation (ATT) on post?opera?tive knee stability after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Methods From January 2016 to December 2016, a total of 348 patients with noncontact ACL injuries who underwent primary anatomic single?bundle ACL reconstruction were retrospec?tively analyzed. The hamstring autograft was used as the grafted tendon. The ATT relative to the lateral femoral condyle was mea?sured on pre?operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans. Among them, twenty patients (ATT positive group) who demon?strated>10 mm ATT distance were matched in a 1∶2 fashion to 40 control participants (ATT negative group) with<3 mm ATT dis?tance. All patients were followed for at least 2 years. The post?operative clinical outcomes, including the ATT distance, the KT?1000 side?to?side difference, and the pivot?shift tests were compared between the two groups. Results The ATT distance of the ATT positive group was 13.5±1.3 mm, which was significantly larger than that of the ATT negative group (2.5±1.4 mm) (t=45.435, P=0.013) pre?operatively. At 2?year follow?up, the ATT distance of the ATT positive group was 9.7±1.8 mm, which was significant?ly larger than that of the ATT negative group (0.9±1.6 mm) (t=49.655, P=0.011). Moreover, the KT?1000 side?to?side difference of the ATT positive group was 4.4±1.5 mm, which was also significantly larger than that of the ATT negative group (0.8±1.1 mm) (t=38.945, P=0.014). There was significantly difference in the pivot?shift test between the two groups (ATT positive group: 1 grade 0, 18 grade I, 1 grade II vs. ATT negative group: 39 grade 0, 1 grade I) (χ2=40.521, P=0.012). Conclusion Excessive ATT could not be completely restored to normal after isolated anatomic single?bundle ACL reconstruction. Compared to the ATT negative group, the ATT positive group has inferior knee stability at 2?year follow?up.
4.Combined anterior closing-wedge high tibial osteotomy and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction for treating chronic anterior cruciate ligament injury with increased posterior tibial slope
Guanyang SONG ; Qiankun NI ; Tong ZHENG ; Hui ZHANG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2021;41(14):977-984
Objective:To investigate the short-term clinical outcomes of patients who received combined anterior closing-wedge high tibial osteotomy (ACW-HTO) and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction in treating chronic ACL injury with increased posterior tibial slope (PTS).Methods:From January 2017 to June 2018, a total of 54 patients (46 males and 8 females, mean age 30.8±3.9 years, range from 20 to 42 years) with chronic (time from injury to surgery was more than 6 months) ACL injury and increased PTS (>17°) were retrospectively analyzed. Eighteen of them received combined ACW-HTO and ACL reconstruction (ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group), while the remaining 36 received isolated ACL reconstruction (ACL reconstruction group). The demographic data, pre-operative and post-operative anterior tibial translation, pivot-shift result, KT-1000 side-to-side difference, subjective Lysholm score, Tegner activity score, and International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) objective grading system were collected and compared between the two groups.Results:There were no significant differences between the two groups in terms of age, sex, body mass index, time from injury to surgery and proportion of patients with concomitant medial or lateral meniscus tear ( P>0.05). At 2-year's follow-up, the anterior tibial translation in the ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group was 0.9±0.4 mm, which was significantly smaller than that in the ACL reconstruction group 7.3±1.5 mm ( t=10.049, P<0.001). Moreover, there was significant difference in the pivot-shift result between the two groups (ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group: 18 low-grade vs. ACL reconstruction group: 31 low-grade, 5 high-grade) (χ 2=16.071, P<0.001). The KT-1000 side-to-side difference in the ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group was 1.5±0.6 mm, which was significantly smaller than that in the ACL reconstruction group 4.4±1.2 mm ( t=13.858, P<0.001). In addition, the subjective Lysholm score in the ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group was 93.3±4.3, which was significantly higher than that in the ACL reconstruction group 80.3±6.3 ( t=12.176, P<0.001). The Tegner activity score in the ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group was 7.3±0.9, which was significantly higher than that in the ACL reconstruction group 6.8±0.6 ( t=6.356, P=0.043). There was significant difference in terms of the IKDC objective grading system between the two groups (ACW-HTO+ACL reconstruction group: 17 grade A, 1 grade B vs. ACL reconstruction group: 29 grade A, 5 grade B, 2 grade C) (χ 2=12.351, P<0.001). Conclusion:The combined ACW-HTO and ACL reconstruction showed superior short-term knee stability and functional scores compared with the isolated ACL reconstruction in treating chronic ACL injury with increased PTS.
5.Anterolateral ligament reconstruction in treating anterior cruciate ligament injury with grade 2 pivot-shift
Guan WU ; Hui ZHANG ; Xu LI ; Guanyang SONG ; Lei HONG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2022;42(9):555-562
Objective:To evaluate the clinical outcomes in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) patients undergoing ACL reconstruction combined with anterolateral ligament (ALL) reconstruction in treating patients with Grade 2 pivot-shift.Methods:From October 2015 to August 2018, a total of 59 patients with Grade 2 pivot shift were allocated into ALL reconstruction group underwent combined ACL and ALL reconstruction ( n=29) and control group underwent isolated ACL reconstruction ( n=30). Lachman, pivot-shift and KT-1000 side-to-side difference test were used to determine the knee laxity. International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) subjective score and Lysholm score were used to assess the knee function. The results of Lachman test and pivot-shift test were classified into -, 1+, 2+, 3+. Results:All patients were followed up for 1 year. The average age was 30.5±8.3 years (range, 15-48 years) in ALL reconstruction group with 5 months duration from injury. The left knee was involved in 11 cases, while 18 cases in right knee in ALL reconstruction group. There were 15 cases with injury in medial meniscus and 8 cases in lateral meniscus. In control group, the average age was 32.2±9.7 years (range 17-51 years) with 14 cases in left knees and 16 in right knees. In these patients, 18 of them had medial meniscus injury, while other 11 patients had lateral meniscus injury. The average duration from injury to surgery was 7 months. The Lachman test (-: 25, 1+: 4 vs. -: 25, 1+: 4, Z=-0.91, P=0.361), KT-1000 arthrometer (1.9±1.3 mm vs. 2.2±1.3 mm, t=0.66, P=0.513), IKDC subjective score (92.4±5.6 vs. 90.2±6.7, t=1.37, P=0.176) and Lysholm score (91.0±6.2 vs. 89.1±5.0, t=1.29, P=0.201) did not show significant difference between the two groups. Pivot-shift test (-:27, 1+: 2 vs. -: 20, 1+: 8, 2+: 2, Z=-0.66, P=0.507). Pivot-shift test was significantly superior in ALL reconstruction group compared with that in control group (6.5% vs.33.3%, χ 2=21.70, P<0.001). Conclusion:Patients with preoperative Grade 2 pivot shift had significant improvement in rotatory knee laxity after ACL reconstruction combined with ALL reconstruction compared with isolated ACL reconstruction. However, there was no significant difference in anterior laxity and knee function scores between the two groups.
6.Relationship between anterior tibial translation and bony morphology around the knee after anterior cruciate ligament injury
Tong ZHENG ; Hui ZHANG ; Guanyang SONG ; Yue LI ; Zhijun ZHANG ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2022;42(9):594-602
Objective:To investigate the relationship between anterior tibial translation (ATT) and bony morphology around the knee after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury.Methods:A total of 67 patients diagnosed with acute ACL injury without any meniscal lesions were enrolled in this study between September 2019 and August 2020. Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans were used to measure the ATT of the lateral compartment, and bony morphology was assessed by measuring lateral femoral condyle (LFC) length, LFC height, lateral tibial plateau (LTP) length, LTP slope and by calculating the following ratios: LFC ratio (LFC length/LFC height), knee extension ratio (LFC length/LTP length), and knee flexion ratio (LFC height/LTP length). The status of the anterolateral ligament (ALL) was assessed by preoperative MRI scans and classified as completely injured (44 patients), partially injured (19 patients), or intact (4 patients). The ATT was compared between patients with completely injured ALL and those with partially injured or intact ALL. Pearson correlation analysis between the ATT and each bony variable was performed in ALL-completely-injured patients and ALL-partially-injured or intact patients.Results:Of the 67 patients, 33 were male and 34 were female, with a mean of age 31.7±9.7 years (range 15-47 years). The average of time interval between ACL injury and MRI examination was 26.0±22.0 days (95% CI: 20.7, 31.4 d). The ATT of the lateral compartment was 5.6±4.0 mm (range, -4.9-16.2 mm), the average of LFC length was 37.3±2.5 mm (range, 30.5-43.2 mm), the average of LFC height was 37.4±3.6 mm (range, 30.6-46.3 mm), the average of LTP length was 46.9±4.1 mm (range, 39.0-56.8 mm), the average of LTP slope was 6.3°±3.1° (range, -3.7°-11.6°), LFC ratio was 100.4%±8.1% (range, 84.1%-119.0%), knee extension ratio was 80.0%±5.8% (range, 66.1%-96.3%), and knee flexion ratio was 80.0%±6.0% (range, 66.4%-93.8%). The ATT was greater in patients with completely injured ALL than in patients with partially injured or intact ALL (6.4±4.3 mm vs. 3.9±2.8 mm, t=2.52, P=0.014). The ATT was negatively correlated with LFC height ( r=-0.43, P<0.001) and LTP length ( r=-0.35, P=0.004) and was positively correlated with LFC ratio ( r=0.48, P<0.001), knee extension ratio ( r=0.36, P=0.003), and LTP slope ( r=0.29, P=0.018). All these correlations were still statistically significant in patients with complete ALL injury ( P<0.05), but were no significant in patients with partial ALL injury or intact ALL ( P>0.05). Conclusion:Bony morphology of the distal femur and proximal tibia was associated with ATT after ACL injury. Such an association was more dramatic in patients with a complete ALL injury.
7.The Impact of the Anteromedial Impingement Fracture of Tibial Plateau in Posterolateral Corner Injuries
Xu LI ; Guanyang SONG ; Xin LIU ; Hui ZHANG ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Sports Medicine 2017;36(11):950-955
Objective To identify the incidence of the anteromedial impingement fracture of tibial plateau in the posterolateral corner injuries,and to confirm the relationship between the extent of the anteromedial tibial impingement fracture and the severity of the posterolateral instability of the knee joint.Methods The radiographic images of the posterolateral corner injuries were reviewed retrospectively to identify the incidence of the anteromedial impingement fracture of the tibial plateau.A matched group of the posterolateral corner injury patients without the anteromedial impingement fracture was compared with the anteromedial impingement fracture group for the posterior instability and varus instability.And the anteromedial impingement fracture group was subdivided into a marginal fracture group and a compression fracture group based on the size of the fracture,and the posterior instability and medial instability were compared between the two groups.Results From January 2007 to January 2017,there were 266 patients with posterolateral corner injuries admitted,with 19 (7.1%) combined with the anteromedial impingement fractures of the tibial plateau.The posterior instability was significantly severer in the fracture group than the control group (P=0.030),while there were no significant differences in the varus instability between them (P=0.800).Similarly,the posterior instability was significantly severer in the marginal group compared to the compression group (P=0.026),but without significant differences in the varus instability (P=0.397).However,the compression fracture group had a higher risk to have neurovascular injuries (of the popliteal artery and the common peroneal nerve) compared with the marginal fracture group.Conclusion The incidence of the anteromedial impingement fracture of the tibial plateau in posterolateral corner injuries was 7.1%.The anteromedial impingement fracture of the tibial plateau may indicate more severe posterior instability,and a compression fracture may suggest more severe posterior instability compared with the marginal fracture.If there is a compression type fracture,the neurovascular status must be carefully evaluated in addition to the examination of the posterolateral and posterior instability.
8.Tibial Tubercle Proximalization for the Treatment of Severe Habitual Dislocation of Patella: A Retrospective Study
Yue LI ; Hui ZHANG ; Guanyang SONG ; Zhe XUE ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Sports Medicine 2017;36(11):945-949,955
Objective To evaluate the clinical outcome of tibial tubercle proximalization in the treatment of patients with severe habitual dislocation of patella (HDP).Methods Among 51 HDP patients treated surgically in our hospital between April 2010 and 2014,28 were eligible for retrospective evaluation.All patients underwent tibial tubercle proximalization and lateral structure release.Additional surgeries included medial patellofemoral ligament (MPFL)reconstruction and tibial tubercle medialization.Radiological and subjective evaluations were performed at 4th and 8th weeks after the operation,as well as 1 year and every year afterwards.Results Twenty-eight patients,with an average age of (27.2 ± 9.4)(ranging from 18 to 39)were followed up for a minimum of 2 years,the mean follow-up period being (26.4 ± 5.8)months (ranging from 24 to 36).It was found 17.2% (5/29) patients of quadriceps weakness,6.9% (2/29)of patellofemoral pain and 6.9% (2/29)of stiffness.No redislocation was reported.Significant improvement was observed in all subjective evaluation scores.Conclusions For patients with severe HDP,tibial tubercle proximalization can achieve satisfactory results.
9.Incidence of concomitant anterolateral ligament MRI abnormality on patients with high-grade pivot-shift phenomenon
Guanyang SONG ; Hui ZHANG ; Xin LIU ; Guan WU ; Zhe XUE ; Hua FENG
Chinese Journal of Orthopaedics 2018;38(7):385-389
Objective To investigate the incidence of concomitant anterolateral ligament (ALL) abnormality by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on patients with high-grade pivot-shift after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries.Methods From January 2016 to June 2016,one hundred and sixty-four consecutive patients with acute ACL injury were retrospectively reviewed.All patients underwent comprehensive pre-operative physical examinations and MRI scans.Sixty-eight patients with acute ACL injury who showed high-grade (grade Ⅱ and Ⅲ) pivot-shift phenomenon were enrolled in the high-grade pivot-shift group.They were matched in a 1:1 fashion to another 68 ACL-injured participants who showed low-grade (grade 0 and Ⅰ) pivot-shift phenomenon during the same study period.The grade of ALL injury was divided into grade Ⅰ (sprain),grade Ⅱ (partial tear) and grade Ⅲ (complete tear),and they were further compared between the high-grade pivot-shift group and the low-grade pivot-shift group on the coronal view of their T2WI MRI scans.Results The mean age of the patients in all groups was 29.3 years old.There were 43 male and 25 female patients in each group.There were no significant differences in terms of the time from injury to surgery,the body mass index and the KT-1000 side-to-side difference.Overall,there were 105 patients (77.2%,105/136) showed abnormal signal of the anterolateral ligament on MRI scans.The incidence of concomitant ALL injury in the high-grade pivot-shift group (94.1%,64/68) was significantly higher than that in the low-grade pivot-shift group (60.3%,41/68,x2=10.786,P=0.013).Specifically,there were 15,19 and 30 patients who showed grade Ⅰ,Ⅱ and Ⅲ ALL abnormality in high-grade pivot-shift group.However,there were only 29,8 and 4 patients who showed grade Ⅰ,Ⅱ and Ⅲ ALL abnormality in low-grade pivot-shift group.The incidence of patients who showed grade Ⅱ/Ⅲ MRI evidence of concomitant ALL injury was 76.6% (49/64) in the high-grade pivot-shift group,which was also significantly higher than that in the low-grade pivot-shift group (29.3%,12/41,x2=18.452,P=0.009).Conclusion In the present study,77.2% of the patients who showed high-grade pivot-shift demonstrated combined ALL injury on the MRI scan.In addition,patients in the high-grade pivot-shift group showed significantly higher incidence of combined ALL MRI abnormality compared with those in the low-grade pivot-shift group.The high-grade pivot-shift phenomenon might be caused by combined ACL and ALL injury.
10.Static Anterior Tibial Translation after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injury: Incidence and Clinical Characteristics
Guanyang SONG ; Hua FENG ; Hui ZHANG ; Xin LIU ; Zhe XUE
Chinese Journal of Sports Medicine 2017;36(12):1033-1037
Objective To explore the incidence and clinical characteristics of the anterior tibial translation(ATT) after anterior cruciate ligament injury.Methods One hundred and fifty-three patients with the anterior cruciate ligament injury underwent standard magnetic resonance imaging scans with full knee extension.Based on the relative location between the lateral tibial plateau and the lateral femoral condyle,all the patients were divided into an ATT positive group and an ATT negative group.Moreover,the posterior tibial slope angle(PTSA),the continuity of anterolateral ligament(ALL),and the integrity of posterior horn of the lateral meniscus of all the patients were detected so as to find the risking factors for ATT.Results Among the 153 patients,46 patients were finally confirmed to have ATT.Moreover,the average PTSA of the ATT positive group was significantly larger than that of the ATT negative group.However,there were no significant differences between the two groups in the continuity of ALL and the integrity of posterior horn of lateral meniscus.Conclusion In this study,the incidence of ATT was 30.1%,which may be correlated to the increased PTSA.