1.Correlation between insomnia and job performance in shift nurses
Khulan D ; Basbish Ts ; Bulgantsetseg B
Mongolian Medical Sciences 2023;204(2):67-75
Sleep and wakefulness are physiological processes in our lives that are regulated by circadian
rhythms. The level of melatonin, the "sleep hormone", increases with the onset of darkness, and
its production slows down in the morning. Exposure to artificial light at night disrupts our circadian
rhythm and the processes it controls. Shift work is when an individual works from 9 am to 5 pm.
But the night shift refers to the time when a group of workers who work at night in factories and
enterprises work in the evening or at night, especially from 4 p.m. to 8 a.m. according to a regular
schedule. One in five people in industrialized countries work night shifts, and studies in America and
Europe show that between 15 and 30% of adult workers have some form of shift work. Between 10%
and 30% of shift workers meet the diagnosis of shift work disorder (SWD). 5-10% of shift workers experience severe shift insomnia and sleepiness. At least ¾ of shift workers suffer from insomnia.
Excessive sleepiness usually occurs during shifts (mainly at night) and is associated with impaired
cognitive ability due to the need for sleep and reduced alertness, and decreased alertness reduces
performance. Job performance is influenced by many workplace environmental factors, including
workload, coworker relationships, stress levels, and extended hours. A nurse specialist provides
nursing care by monitoring and evaluating 24 hours a day, and by working night shifts, the circadian
system of sleep is disturbed, causing sleep problems and insomnia. When examining how night shift
work affects nurses' ability to concentrate, the decline in concentration (33.3%) was twice as high as
that of day shift nurses (16.7%). found that shift nurses who worked the night shift had higher rates of insomnia and chronic fatigue compared to nurses who stopped working the night shift. Lack of sleep
manifests as a decline in cognitive functions such as attention, decision making, and reaction time.
These cognitive and functional declines can negatively affect quality of life and lead to impaired job
performance. An Australian study by Winwood et al found that fatigue associated with night shifts
increases the risk of human error and injury, and negatively affects the quality of patient care. Lack of sleep significantly affects nurses' alertness, concentration, and job performance. This review article
discusses the relation between shift work-related sleep and job performance based on international
research findings.
2.Some aspects of chronotype and sleep quality in shift nurses
Khulan D ; Basbish Ts ; Duuriimaa S
Mongolian Medical Sciences 2024;208(2):21-29
Introduction:
5-10% of shift workers experience severe shift insomnia and sleepiness. A nurse specialist stays by
the client's side 24 hours a day, assesses and monitors their physical condition, and provides nursing
care. In a comparative study on the work activity among shift nurses, night shift nurses were less
active (40%) and more fatigued (53.3%) than day shift nurses.
An aspects of chronotype and sleep quality in shift nurses does not established in Mongolia and the
data is very rare, and we aimed to conduct this study.
Goal:
To study shift schedule, sleep quality and individual chronotype of shift nurses.
Materials and Methods:
This study is a cross-sectional study. The survey was completed between July 1, 2023 and December
31, 2023, and included a total of 117 nurses who met the inclusion and exclusion criteria of the BZDGH,
SKDGH, and KUDGH research. In collecting research data, the questionnaires "Insomnia Severity
Index", which is a commonly used international standard questionnaire for assessing insomnia, The
Munich Chrono Type Questionnaire for assessing individual chronotype, and "Karolinska Sleepiness
Scale" were used.
The ethical approval:
The ethical approval for the study was obtained by a decision of the Ach Medical University-Ethical
Committee on Research on June 30, 2023 (2023/02/05).
Statistical analysis :
Results were calculated using SPSS - 21.0 v program by a descriptive statistic, and the Pearson
correlation analysis.
Results :
The average score of the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI) was 12.60±6.38, which is the sub threshold
for clinical insomnia. But the average Karolinska Sleepiness Scale (KSS) score for sleepiness is
4.41±2.50, or moderate alertness during the shift. Workday sleep-wake pattern and non-workday
sleep-wake pattern are correlated (r=0.44, p=0.001). Also, individual chronotype is correlated with
chronotype of non-working days (r=0.23, p=0.02).
Conclusions
Nurses' sleep quality levels were pre-clinical insomnia and moderate alertness during shifts for sleepiness.
Working and non-working day sleep-wake patterns are different, chronotype is medium early type. The
sleep-wake pattern of weekdays and the sleep-wake pattern of non-workdays are related to each other.
The chronotype of the individual is related to the chronotype of non-working days.